Laughing All the Way to the Bank

Money may not buy happiness, but can happiness buy money?

BY CHARLES KENNY | APRIL 11, 2011

By now, everyone knows the paradox of money and happiness, subject of a thousand articles written by penniless journalists. Rich people aren't much happier than the rest of us. But in fact there is a relationship between the two -- it is just the reverse of what most people think. Money may not be able to buy happiness, but happiness can apparently buy money -- happy people become richer than unhappy people over time. Which leads to an obvious policy conclusion: If you want a strong economy, make people smile.

In economics, there is a heated argument going on between supporters and opponents of the "Easterlin Paradox," named after Richard Easterlin, a professor at the University of Southern California. Easterlin studied the results of polls that asked questions along the lines of, "When you take your life as a whole, do you consider yourself very happy, somewhat happy, or not happy at all?" When he looked across the world, rich countries were also happier. But when Easterlin looked at changes in average income and happiness poll answers over time, he couldn't find any relationship between the two.

That result has been challenged recently, but even researchers who are more bullish about the impact of income on happiness find that survey evidence suggests it matters considerably less than friends, family, health, faith, or having a job. But perhaps the relationship looks weak because people are looking in the wrong place. Happy people have lots of features that make them a good bet as employees. So might being happy make you rich?

It is indeed productive to be content with life. According to a detailed analysis of research to date published in Psychological Bulletin, happy people have more friends -- not least because we all like happy people more than sad people. One sign: Unmarried men and women in Australia toward the top of the happiness curve are 50 percent more likely to get (and stay) married in a given period than the average person. Those who report themselves content are less prone to mental illness and suicide and are comparably rare substance abusers. The happy are more likely to be healthy, less likely to die in a car crash or get injured from any cause, and tend to live longer -- 70-year-olds who report themselves happy go on to live 20 months longer than average, all else being equal.

The same review of studies also points to a number of features that suggest happy people will be more financially successful. Students who say they are happy are more likely to graduate. Happy job-seekers are more likely to find employment; they also get better jobs. They go on to be more satisfied with their work -- indeed, as much as 25 percent of the variation in people's job satisfaction may be a result of their predisposition to be happy. Managers rate happy staff more productive, creative, and reliable. Happy staff are less likely to be absent from work or quit the job, and more likely to be part of strong social networks in the office. Happy cricket players even score more runs. The University of Warwick's Andrew Oswald suggests that workers in a happier state of mind have 12 percent higher productivity.

Given all that, it would be a surprise if happier people weren't better off. If labor markets are functioning as they should, more productive workers ought to be paid more. And using data from Russia, Carol Graham of the Brookings Institution and her colleagues found that people who were happier in 1995 did indeed go on to have higher incomes in 2000. (They argue that income also brought greater reported happiness, but Graham's work around the world suggests that people who have got richer can often be surprisingly unhappy about it -- a group she labels "frustrated achievers.")

Mark Wilson/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: ECONOMICS
 

Charles Kenny is a senior fellow at the Center for Global Development, a Schwartz fellow at the New America Foundation, and author, most recently, of Getting Better: Why Global Development Is Succeeding and How We Can Improve the World Even More. "The Optimist," his column for ForeignPolicy.com, runs weekly.

FELINE74

6:29 AM ET

April 12, 2011

A simpler, gloomier explanation for the correlation.

A happy person can take on a well-paying job that requires reducing or giving up activities (hobbies, time with friends or family) which makes him or her happy. In some cases, such as medicine or certain types of law, this job can also involve dealing with sad situations or challenges to his or her faith on a regular basis.

Over time, a person in this situation would become wealthier and less happy. Money is bought with happiness.

 

FP_READER

10:14 AM ET

April 12, 2011

Happiness is relative

Money, friends or stuff has nothing to do with it either way. Happiness flows from within. The possession of money, friends, or stuff is a byproduct of the LACK of happiness - a compensation mechanism.

 

LAKESHOST

12:43 PM ET

April 22, 2011

It Does't Matter

I've been there, done that and bought the T-shirt. In my experience there is no direct relationship between wealth and happiness.

During the prime of my working life I was what many would describe as very rich. At that time my happiness was most often determined by being challenged by my work, working with talented and interesting people and spending time with my friends and family.

Since my semi-retirement, I am significantly less well off and continue to enjoy a reasonable level of happiness.

Currently, my happiness is derived from being with friends and family, enjoying my favourite activites such as walking, fishing and photography.

In my opinion, happiness is derived from living a stimulating and interesting lifeand that can be achieved whether rich or poor.

John Taylor PhD
http://JohnTaylorsBlog.com