Thug Democracy

Nigeria is cheering its first legitimate and internationally praised election. But violent protests in the north make it clear just how divided the country still is.

BY MAGGIE FICK | APRIL 19, 2011

KANO, Nigeria—Brandishing wooden planks and lighter fuel, young men and boys -- some hardly taller than the makeshift clubs they were wielding -- took to the streets of several northern Nigerian cities Monday, April 18, to protest the emerging results of Saturday's presidential election. As they waved their clubs, they shouted "Only Buhari! We want change!" echoing the campaign slogans of their fallen candidate, the onetime military ruler of Nigeria, Muhammadu Buhari, who battled the incumbent President Goodluck Jonathan in the April 16 election. 

Saturday's vote marked a first for Africa's most populous country in its latest chapter of democratic rule. Nigerian and international observers praised it as the only election since 1999 -- when the country transitioned to civilian rule after decades of military dictatorship -- to break away from a history of chaotic, rigged, and violent polls. Unlike previous occasions, on Saturday there was no ballot stuffing, no "Elvis Presleys" or other fake names on the voters list, no hired thugs stealing ballot boxes from polling stations. Everything was on track -- right up to the moment when widespread, deadly violence broke out.

The first rioters flooded the streets Monday morning, as soon as word had spread that the results were expected to favor Jonathan. By the time the electoral commission certified his victory on Monday evening, the protests had calmed slightly, but by Tuesday morning, fighting had erupted once again in Kaduna and the Associated Press reported by midday that "charred bodies" lined the road on the southern outskirts of the city. Violence spread to some 13 northern states throughout the day Monday. The Nigerian Red Cross reported that 16,000 people had fled their homes, afraid that the violence would continue.

Quickly, what was meant to be Nigeria's first truly legitimate election has begun to look a lot like the clouded ones of the past, even if the votes themselves add up the way they're supposed to. And it's not at all clear that the protesters in the north who torched churches, looted vehicles, and smashed billboards are entirely to blame, given the behavior of their leaders in Abuja. More importantly, if Jonathan does not manage to address the broader issues raised by this violence -- notably the discontent among northerners with the status quo that includes a huge class of unemployed and marginalized youth -- he may find his term as president focused largely on putting out brush fires rather than initiating badly needed reforms.

Security forces in Kaduna, Kano, and smaller northern cities such as Sokoto and Zaria managed to restore calm on Monday by firing live rounds into the air to disperse angry crowds, but not before the youth rioters had torched the homes and vehicles of some actual or perceived supporters of Jonathan's People's Democratic Party -- including the emir's residence in Kano. In Kaduna, rioters set fire to the electoral commission's state offices. As the sun set on April 18 in Kano, an ancient Muslim trading center that's now Nigeria's second-largest city after Lagos, an eerie calm had settled, but heaps of burned tires and wood remained on the streets.

But it's far from clear that the police can keep the protesters quiet for long, and indeed protests picked up again on Tuesday. Nor, for that matter, will Nigeria's politicians be able to quell the discontent. In a country where political elites have so often run roughshod over elections by paying young, uneducated, and unemployed men to do their dirty work at the ballot box and in the streets, those same elites now have little credibility when appealing for calm.

SEYLLOU DIALLO/AFP/Getty Images

 

Maggie Fick is a freelance journalist.

JEAN KAPENDA

10:36 AM ET

April 20, 2011

Is the "Mobcracy" Taking Over Democracy in Africa?

The “mobcracy” (not democracy), is everywhere in Africa and has spread like a plague: Nigeria, Congo, Rwanda, Uganda, Angola, Equatorial Guinea, Gabon, Cameroon, Chad, etc. Elections are held over and over just to put those countries at the door of democracy, please foreign donors and investors, and give some form of legitimacy to despots, thieves, and even assassins. There is no major step towards democracy as the powerful Africa’s Cosa Nostra has virtually silenced its internal opponents: you speak against it and you’re dead on the streets the next day. It is the mobcracy that is fueling corruption across the continent, and elections are just a make-up for this Cosa Nostra- which makes Sicilian Mafiosi look like pygmies- to operate openly. Solution: strengthen the justice system as the # 1 priority. Just look at Egypt: by prosecuting Mubarak , his sons and other “big fishes”, Egypt is sending a clear message that this is the right way to end the mobcracy and initiate democracy.

 

OLEAFRICA

5:58 AM ET

April 23, 2011

Yes, "Mobcracy" is spreading in Africa

Hi Jean,

Indeed "Mobcracy" is spreading thick and fast. Some had predicted it years back just from the fact that people were to get tired one day from the kind of leadership most of our African leaders have chosen to follow. Most of the countries currently facing "mobcracy" revolution share two common things; leaders who have been in power for decades and government letting price inflation of basic common commodities while continuing to squander public funds. You can visit an analysis I did on current problems in Africa.

 

SHAKARA

4:22 PM ET

April 20, 2011

More Background required before coming to conclusions

Your statement that "Now that Jonathan has been elected for a four-year term, the north feels it has been dealt the bum lot once more."Is not entirely accurate without listing the heads of state of nigeria.
Please note that leaders of northern extraction have ruled nigeria far longer than southerners. In fact, this election can be characterised as a anti-north election given the fact that all the opposition candidates are northern.

 

ADORE

11:27 PM ET

April 25, 2011

Tension as Nigerians elect

Amid tension, Nigeria will again be shut down today to elect Governors and state lawmakers, the last leg of the ballot that began with that of the National Assembly (NASS) on April 9, and produced the President on April 16, with violent reaction from the North.

Only 23 states will vote for Governor and legislators. Kano and Bauchi will do so on April 28.

Lawmakers will be elected today in nine other states, but the contest for Governor will hold next year. A new Anambra Governor will not emerge until 2014, likewise in Ekiti.

Low turn out is expected in the North, especially in the flash points where Congress for Progressive Change (CPC) members wreaked havoc for days, and killed and maimed, in their agitation over the result of the Presidential vote.

Tough fights, particularly for Governor, are on the cards in Oyo, Ogun, Kwara, and Niger, among others.

In Kwara, it is a dead heat between Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) Governorship candidate, Abdulfatah Ahmed, and Action Congress of Nigeria (ACN) candidate, Dele Belgore.

Three parties have demanded a change in the elections in Niger, following the discovery that the logos of the African Democratic Congress (ADC) and Citizens Popular Party (CPP) are missing from the ballot paper.

In Borno, the All Nigeria Peoples Party (ANPP), CPC, and PDP are locked down in a do-or-die battle.

Down South, Accord Party (AP) Governorship candidate in Oyo, Rashidi Ladoja, warned the PDP against rigging, declaring that, “It is rig and roast.”

ACN Governorship candidate, Abiola Ajimobi, told Governor Adebayo Alao-Akala to begin writing his handover note.

The Peoples Party of Nigeria (PPN) and the PDP raised the tempo in Ogun, with the PPN accusing PDP Governorship candidate, Adetunji Olurin, of falsifying his age.

The PPN recalled that Olurin had told the then Television Service of Oyo State (TSOS), now Broadcasting Service of Oyo State (BCOS), in an interview that he was born in December 1944 – which makes him 66 years old.

“Whereas in a documentary on the same Olurin, regarding his Governorship ambition and broadcast on April 24 on Gateway Television (GTV), he claimed he joined the military in 1967 at the age of 21.

“By this, his claim was that he was born in 1946. With this clear lie, Olurin gives himself away as someone that should not be trusted by the people of Ogun State whose mandate to govern he seeks,” the PPN argued in a statement.

Governor Babatunde Fashola is in pole position for re-election in Lagos, yet his ACN is nervous.

On April 16, Lagosians chose Goodluck Jonathan as President with a wide margin, saying they did so for his personality, but stressed that they did not vote for his PDP and would not do so today.

The ACN has alleged plans by the PDP to rig in the South West, which did not vote for the PDP in the NASS election on April 9, but which Jonathan carried a week later.

A massive deployment of troops has been noticed in some states.

Both the General Officer Commanding of the 2 Division of the Army in Ibadan, Muhammed Abubakar, and the Oyo State Commissioner of Police, Salihu Hashimu, warned the people not to do anything that would hinder a peaceful poll.

‘’Security arrangements are already on the ground the Oke-Ogun area, while as we did during the last Presidential election, we will be on the ground in the three Senatorial Districts

“Security operatives are already in possession of the list of trouble makers in Oyo State,” they said.

Police Public Relations Officer in Ekiti, Muhammed Jimoh, added that any act intended to undermine the peaceful conduct of the elections will not be tolerated.

The NASS election in Ekiti was shifted to today, and the Resident Electoral Commissioner, Halilu Pai, disclosed on Monday that election materials have been distributed to the 16 councils in the state.

Governor Kayode Fayemi has promised the arrest and prosecution of trouble makers.

From Abuja, the Commandant of the Nigeria Security and Civil Defence Corps (NSCDC), Ade Abolurin, noted that the elections are “more of the survival of the fittest.”

He said the NSCDC “cannot afford not to effectively monitor political activities and place actors under surveillance in order to checkmate some of them who are criminally minded and have resorted to the videos cristianos use of force to forment trouble and cause mayhem with their do-or-die attitude.”

Police Headquarters Spokesman, Olusola Amoren, warned youths to avoid being used by politicians who want to win at all costs.

“The police, in collaboration with all other security and law enforcement agents, are working together to ensure violence free and fair elections. All eligible voters are advised to go out and cast their votes without fear of intimidating and molestation.

“They are also enjoined to leave the immediate voting vicinity and allow their various party agents to take the responsibility of protecting and watching all votes cast until they are duly counted and recorded by INEC (Independent National Electoral Commission) officials,” Amoren explained in a statement.

The INEC itself clarified on Monday that it has rescheduled NASS election in the outstanding wards of Ekeremor and Sagbama Councils in Bayelsa State for April 28.

A statement issued by Kayode Idowu, the Chief Press Secretary to INEC Chairman, Attahiru Jega, confirmed that the Commission is ready for all the polls today and on April 28.

Another statement issued by the Chairman of the Presidential Committee on Public Awareness on Security and Civic Responsibilities, Lateef Adegbite, advised voters nationwide to conduct themselves in an orderly manner.

 

JIBRAN_PCCASD

1:40 AM ET

May 11, 2011

There is no major step

There is no major step towards democracy as the powerful Africa’s Cosa Nostra has virtually silenced its internal opponents: you speak against it and you’re dead on the streets the next day. Low turn out is expected in the North, especially in the flash points where Congress for Progressive Change (CPC) members wreaked havoc for days, andwatch online sportskilled and maimed, in their agitation over the result of the Presidential vote.Tough fights, particularly for Governor, are on the cards in Oyo, Ogun, Kwara, and Niger, among others.

 

MAC THELIN

6:20 AM ET

May 19, 2011

In Kwara, it is a dead heat

In Kwara, it is a dead heat between Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) Governorship candidate, Abdulfatah Ahmed, and Action Congress of Nigeria (ACN) candidate, Dele Belgore.Three parties have demanded a change in the elections in Niger, following the discovery that the logos of the African Democratic Congress (ADC) and Citizens Popular Party (CPP) are missing from the ballot paper.In Borno, the All Nigeria Peoples Party (ANPP), CPC, and PDP are locked down in a do-or-die battle.Down South, Accord Party (AP) Governorship candidate in Oyo, Rashidi Ladoja, warned the PDP against rigging, declaring that, “It is rig and roast.”ACN Governorship candidate, Abiola Ajimobi, told Governor Adebayo Alao-Akala to begin writing his handover note.The Peoples Party of Nigeria (PPN) and the PDP raised the tempo in Ogun, with the PPN accusing PDP Governorship candidate, Adetunji Olurin, of falsifying his age.The PPN recalled that Olurin had told the then Television Service of Oyo State (TSOS), now Broadcasting Service of Oyo State (BCOS), in an interview that he was born in December 1944 – which makes him 66 years old.“Whereas in a documentary on the same Olurin, regarding his Governorship ambition and broadcast on April 24 on Gateway Television (GTV), he claimed he joined the military in 1967 at the age of 21.