The Few, the Proud, the Unready

Can Afghanistan's army stand on its own?

MAY 10, 2011

Although Afghan President Hamid Karzai recognized the death of Osama bin Laden as an "important day" for the fight against terrorism, he remains convinced that the Western military presence in his country needs to be reconsidered. "Year after year, day after day, we have said the fighting against terrorism is not in the villages of Afghanistan, not among the poor people of Afghanistan," Karzai said, as part of his push for NATO to focus its attention on Pakistan.

He's soon going to get to make that decision himself. President Barack Obama has promised to begin withdrawing U.S. troops from Afghanistan in July; preliminary reports suggest that 5,000 troops could be removed then, with another 5,000 to come by year's end. As the Americans step back, the plan is for the Afghan National Army to step up. The United States has invested a lot in Afghanistan's military: It is drawing up plans to use its special operations forces to mentor Afghan soldiers, and it spent more than $9 billion in 2010 to develop the force.

Paula Bronstein/Getty Images

 

Although many questions about the Afghan National Army's capabilities still remain, it can also call on a deep reservoir of public goodwill. The military enjoys an approval rating of over 80 percent, easily making it the most highly regarded public institution in Afghanistan. Salaries are also rising, and the military hopes to meet its goal of reaching 171,000 soldiers by November.

BAY ISMOYO/AFP/Getty Images

Although the war in Afghanistan began before U.S. engagement in Iraq, the United States waited until late 2006 and 2007 to begin devoting serious resources to training local Afghan troops. In 2009, Gen. Stanley McChrystal made local forces a linchpin of his counterinsurgency plan.

PETER PARKS/AFP/Getty Images

Gen. David Petraeus, the top commander in Afghanistan, has been an enthusiastic supporter of increasing the strength of Afghanistan's military. Following the killing of bin Laden, he emphasized that the terrorist mastermind's death could weaken ties between al Qaeda and the Taliban. "The key is making sure there are no safe havens for those transnational terrorist groups in Afghanistan," he said -- a task that will soon fall primarily on the Afghan army.

BAY ISMOYO/AFP/Getty Images

From the beginning, it proved difficult to convince Afghan soldiers to stay in the army after training; desertion rates were high throughout the first half of the decade. In 2003 and 2004, soldiers received a mere $3 a day, while the Taliban were paying $5 to $10. Then U.S. forces gave everyone a raise. Now, the lowest-ranking Afghan soldier can earn $165 to $245 per month, while generals earn around $1,000. Here, Afghan soldiers walk pass the destroyed Darul Aman palace in Kabul on May 7.

MASSOUD HOSSAINI/AFP/Getty Images

The close relationship between the U.S. military and the Afghanistan National Army has also given the Americans a crash course in Afghan culture. Here, Afghan soldiers dance attan, a traditional national dance, at a U.S. Marines outpost in Helmand province on May 9.

BAY ISMOYO/AFP/Getty Images

The U.S. training effort has sometimes led it to partner with some unsavory elements. Here, an Afghan boy looks on as U.S. Marines carry out a patrol in Helmand province on May 5 with Afghan army soldiers and members of an arbaki, or local defense force. These arbakis have often been accused of being a greater torment to local Afghans than the Taliban they’re supposedly fighting.

BAY ISMOYO/AFP/Getty Images

An Afghan soldier stands atop a blast wall on April 6, trying to get mobile-phone coverage at a military base in the southern province of Farah. Taliban militants -- out of fear that NATO-led forces can track them through phone signals -- regularly demand that cellular companies switch off their networks.

PETER PARKS/AFP/Getty Images

The state of the Afghan National Army prior to the U.S. intervention was dismal. As recently as 2009, a mere 35 percent of troops passed basic marksmanship qualifications; today, after an intensive training push, the figure has leaped to 95 percent.

Paula Bronstein /Getty Images

As violence in Afghanistan escalates, local troops bear the burden of casualties and fatalities. More than 300 Afghan soldiers and about 500 policemen died in the first half of 2010 alone, about the same number that died in the entire previous year. Above, an Afghan soldier runs for cover during combat drills at the Kabul Military Training Center on Oct. 2, 2010.

Paula Bronstein/Getty Images

As NATO has intensified its military efforts in Afghanistan, the situation has also grown more dangerous. Insurgents have ratcheted up their attacks, employing everything from roadside bombs to ambushes and mortar strikes. Here, Afghan soldiers -- who will soon face these risks firsthand -- march during a graduation ceremony in Kabul in 2008.

SHAH MARAI/AFP/Getty Images

Afghanistan's police and army are due to take control of security in seven areas selected by Karzai in June, and they plan to expand their authority across the country by 2014. Here, Afghan officers march during a graduation ceremony at the Ghazi Military Training Center in Kabul on March 31.

SHAH MARAI/AFP/Getty Images

The Afghan military is still extremely vulnerable to improvised explosive devices, which is one of the primary threats it faces along the roads in Helmand and surrounding towns in the south. In an attempt to stem the casualties from these attacks, American medics traveled to Afghanistan to help train 600 nursing students at the Davoud Khan military hospital over a period of two years. Here, an injured Afghan soldier lies on a bed at the hospital on April 23.

Majid Saeedi/Getty Images

There are about 130,000 international forces deployed in Afghanistan, under the leadership of NATO. Here, an Afghan soldier smiles for the photographer in a U.S. Marine compound in Helmand province on May 7.

BAY ISMOYO/AFP/Getty Images

 
 

KILGORE_NOBIZ

2:00 PM ET

May 11, 2011

Only part of the story

This article talks up how much the population trusts the ANA; however it completely ignores the fact the populace completely distrusts the Afghan National Police. The ANP is widely considered corrupt and incompetent, yet in many key areas controlled by the Taliban it's the only formal security presence. If all the ANSF were just ANA then there's a reasonable chance we could turn things over within a year or so, but that's the good half of the force. Barring some dramatic changes it will take a very long time, if ever for the ANP to get there.

 

SAIL1999

2:09 PM ET

May 11, 2011

Can Afgan army stand on its own

Instead of training an army in traditional tactics, the USA should be teaching these young me in special force fighting. This is the future of warfare as attested to by the attack on Usama Bin Ladin. These men look like a bunch of boy scouts, out of their element. They should be ruthless, like the enemy they are fighting.

 

JACK BOOT

10:31 AM ET

May 12, 2011

Afghan Army

The Afghan Army can no more stand on its own than could the South Vietnamese Army in 1972.

Question: Who was the bright spark who replaced the Afghan Army's AK-47s with M-16s?
There is no way in Heaven or on Earth that a bunch of Third-Worlders can conceivably keep those temperamental prima donnas in working order...

 

DUNCAN-O

8:01 PM ET

May 14, 2011

They might only use them for

They might only use them for training. I never saw an ANA or ANP with anything other than an AK...unless it was an RPG. Speaking of good ideas. Don't know though, haven't been there in awhile.

 

JAYDEE001

12:18 PM ET

May 12, 2011

And who really cares?

The Afghan Army had better learn to stand on its own - because I doubt the US and NATO will be around to wipe its nose for very long. We have over 100,000 of our troops there to fight several hundred al Qaeda - many of whom spend most of their time in the FATA on the Pakistan side of the border. The majority of the effort in Afghanistan has been to tamp down the local Taliban insurgency - who we defeated in 2002; we then got distracted by our Iraq mis-adventure and let them reconstitute their strength. The Afghan Taliban are home-grown fighters who for some reason consider Afghanistan more their home than ours - imagine that!

It should be very clear after the hardly-revelatory events of the past 10 days that al Qaeda has been the guests of the Pakistani people. Whatever happens in Afghanistan after the US and NATO depart will matter very little if al Qaeda does not again become entrenched there - and there are many reasons to doubt that Afghanistan really wants al Qaeda to be there. There are plenty of signals that our puppet, Karzai, would make peace with his Taliban if the US would get out of his way. As for Pakistan, it has proven to be the most unreliable ally; let it go back to its obsessive worry about India without our financial and military help. That will always occupy its attention anyway.

While we are getting rid of our pups, lets withdraw the rest of our troops from Iraq. The latest news from that front has al Maliki suggesting that he might ask the US to keep troops there beyond the agreed December 31 date - if there is support amongst Iraq's politicians for doing so. Since Iraq was a war we did not need to fight at all, and since we have lost the lives of another 22 brave US personnel in 2011, it is long past time to get the heck out. Enough already!

 

DRSTUPID

12:46 PM ET

May 12, 2011

On the salaries

The slide on soldiers' salary is probably wrong, if not in the value presented, than in its logic. It says that the taliban paid 5-10$ a day, which caused defections, which were controlled by paying soldiers 165-245$ per month, which is still 5.50-8.17$ a day.

It seems the amount was not the motivating factor to curb down defections.

 

CEOUNICOM

5:40 PM ET

May 13, 2011

Afghan Army: A Documentary

Too not-funny.

youtube.com/watch?v=O2F80llZ5F4

The quote from the Afghan officer @ 3:00 is pretty hot.

The motivation speech by the Marine is embarrassing.

I love lines like, "After 7 years of training, most show no signs of any soldiering ability"

Its actually understatement.

 

DUNCAN-O

7:58 PM ET

May 14, 2011

Is that a female officer in

Is that a female officer in photo #9?

 

TEJAS RAMAKRISHNAN

12:29 PM ET

May 20, 2011

Looks like a female officer, yes

Yes, that indeed looks like a female officer indeed...

I did not know that Afghans and other muslim nations advocated women working, and one in a military vocation is quite unheard of...

Still, you might notice that the best of things happen at times... I've for you the best ping services