Shakira vs. the Democrats

For Morocco's would-be revolutionaries, a popular music festival is a corrupt symbol of the country's misplaced priorities.

BY LAILA LALAMI | MAY 19, 2011

But, aside from its association with Majidi, Mawazine also riles up Moroccans with its ostentatious displays. Imagine if, like 15 percent of Moroccans, you and your family lived on less than $2 per day. Three loaves of bread and a bottle of milk cost about as much as that -- never mind housing, health care, or education. Imagine if, like a large majority of working Moroccans, you were paid the standard minimum wage of 10.64 dirhams per hour; that's almost exactly the price of a liter of gasoline. (Assuming, of course, you've saved up the tens of thousands of dirhams it takes to buy a car.) Imagine, now, if you found out that Shakira were paid 6.5 million dirhams to perform -- nearly a million dollars.

There are others, however, who support Mawazine as a rare opportunity for the public to see Moroccan and international music stars perform locally. They argue that many of the scheduled concerts are free. They point out that the festival is funded by business sponsors and that only a small percentage of its budget comes from the government. In an interview with TelQuel magazine, Aziz Daki, spokesperson and artistic director for Mawazine, said that those who oppose Mawazine are "demagogues" who keep an "obscurantist discourse." And, just as there are anti-Mawazine groups on Facebook, there are pro-Mawazine groups as well.

It is true that Mawazine has many private sponsors, but these come at a much higher long-term cost for the country. In a lawsuit filed in Michigan, Peter Barker-Homek, former CEO of the energy company Taqa, alleges that he was asked by his employers to pay $5 million per year to unnamed Moroccan officials in order to finance a music festival. (Although the festival is not named, it is widely believed to be Mawazine.) In exchange, Taqa would be allowed to extend its electrical plant in Jorf Lasfar, a commercial port on the Atlantic Coast. The behind-the-scenes business deals are particularly relevant now, in the middle of a popular protest movement that has made an end to corruption a central demand.

Mawazine is scheduled to start on May 20. Despite the mounting rhetoric of the past few weeks, a cancellation had been unlikely for some time now. Since the terrorist attack on the Argana cafe in Marrakesh, all eyes have been on Mawazine, an event that normally attracts tens of thousands of spectators. Safety concerns were immediately raised, but the organizers have cleverly portrayed any rescheduling as tantamount to saying that the country is afraid of terrorists.

What's more, a cancellation would be seen as a capitulation to the demands of the February 20 movement. The Moroccan government's official position with regard to the reform movement mirrors that of Dr. Pangloss in Candide: All is for the best in the best of all possible worlds. Khalid Naciri, spokesperson for the government, has repeatedly declared that Morocco has long been engaged in a process of reform. The March 9 speech in which the king announced some constitutional reforms was part of this long-standing process, he said, and not a response to the street protests. In this context, the show must go on.

And while the show goes on, the Moroccan government can continue to deny that it practices torture, and its police can continue their brutal harassment of political activists, including, and especially, activists of the February 20 movement.

KARIM SAHIB/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: POLITICS, CULTURE, AFRICA
 

Laila Lalami, the author of Hope and Other Dangerous Pursuits and Secret Son, is associate professor of creative writing at the University of California, Riverside.

PULLER58

1:10 AM ET

May 20, 2011

Shakira

She's been doing the human rights thingee, but has stumbled several times. Her music style is essentially yodelling, and her constant focus on her bare feet is just looking to draw in fans with foot fetishes. Appearing at this event merely fattens her bank account, and gives her publicist something to do in terms of damage control.

 

MARK ANTELL

10:45 PM ET

May 20, 2011

Underlying Agenda: "Shakira vs. the Democracts"

This article blasts Shakira for participating in a music festival. It argues that her performance disrespects the Moroccan people and the cause of democracy.

Bull.

The hidden agenda of this article is a fundamentalist objection to modernism, and particularly woman performers.

 

GREGORY M

5:33 AM ET

May 21, 2011

It's So Sad

I think it's so sad that these people are making the hourly wage of 1 liter of gasoline (the equivalent). If my conversion is correct, that comes to like a $1 an hour in American dollars. And they live off a measly $2 a day in food. That's really sad to me, especially because me, my fellow Americans and other wealthy affiliates of the United States, and other wealthy countries in general are living so well off.

Not even to mention the things we take for granite.

I wonder just how much food we throw away each and every day that could be saved for poor people like this whose biggest worries are feeding themselves rather than how nice of a car they can afford like many people in America. Probably millions of pounds of food is thrown away each day, and it's truly sad to know some of this coukd be somehow saved for people like this who are extremely poor. It for one, makes me feel like a fool, for complaining about things like rising gas prices and other things.

I think we need to be more satisfied as a wealthy country that things like electricity, clean running water, and cars (even public buses) are pretty much a given for most americans.

Then you have these musicians like shakira and kanye west that are making a million dollars a show! It's truly sad that people are starving like this when other people are so well off; again performers getting paid a million dollars a show when the people can't even afford a ticket.

It makes me realize why the worldwide brands the United States as a "selfish country" that pretty much does what it pleases. Sometimes it seems like the USA basically thinks that they are the leaders of the world and that we/they should be able to dictate what happens around the world.

Anyways, I was getting a little off topic, but the point is that it's extremely sad that people are working for a $1 an hour or so barely surviving - and rich performers won't perform for them because it's not as much money. It's very sad and selfish.

People need to be more compassionate towards others and do some things for the good instead of the money.

It's definitely sad how people treat other people these days.

 

JUDITA

9:42 AM ET

May 21, 2011

Going backwards

Yes, I hope it's not a going backwards for music and women. I hope there's no hidden agenda. eamidas

 

MATTHEW S

6:41 PM ET

May 21, 2011

A Shame

As a semi Shakira fan, she has been fronting the human rights game for a long time now and has definitely made her mistakes along the way. I think it's a shame but can't help but think that this is money oriented, in order to buy the big houses, yachts, sweets, cars, etc, as it is for most artists now unfortunately.

At least her management will have a busy couple of days next week!

 

PRIVATEER

6:13 AM ET

May 22, 2011

Personal VS Party

shakira now is one of world top singer, she has earn it by hardwork and great management. But remember, she's a singer not a politician. Your can't put it at the same bowl, they have different interest.

i think its understandable if she made some mistake since regular people do with their own interest, different with some political party that had so many hidden agenda.

 

MESSUP

1:14 PM ET

May 23, 2011

shakira and poor nations

If Shakira is a poster person for human rights, why then does she mostly perform in venues sponsored in mostly poorer nations? For example, her concerts in Brazil: the average minimum wage is R$575,00/month (equal to about US$340.00/month or US11.00/day, US$1.37/hour), generate millions...how? Each show is about three hours long. Average ticket price is about R$40,00 (or US$24.00). Crowds frequenting her shows are mostly unemployed or underemployed Brazilians. Isn't this "mass" exploitation? And this is what her promoters, managers and corporate sponsers encourage...soaking the poor? For shame, a true oxymoron!!!!

 

THE GLOBALIZER

5:07 PM ET

May 23, 2011

Apples and oranges.

If the idea is that all money should be spent on bettering the less fortunate, ask Europe where that leads. They're pouring money down a bottomless hole and still get the same pissed off youths and labor unions.

The corruption angle is valid, but this is hardly "Shakira vs. the Democrats". More like the King vs. the Democrats; but that doesn't really make headlines or attract readers, does it?

 

EBASSOUS

9:55 PM ET

May 28, 2011

Shakira ancestry

Shakira's father is from Zahle, Lebanon

 

DANNY41

4:47 PM ET

June 8, 2011

Contrary world

Whats good about this when Shakira actually does it all for the money? If she and specially her management said.. let's do this concert for 1/20 of that price (still lots of money) and invest that other money in the country.

No no we are hypocrites and make a big media party of this festival by having a big big main act. Please understand the philosophy of supporting the local artists. Maybe it's not a big crowd rocker but it would lower ticket prices and even then the locals can have a great time for less the price. I can't say i love reading this kind of stories but it is so so true and happens every day. Please organisations wake up! Oh no they don't because they are the corruption behind all this..

 

ROSEMARIE ALNIC

6:08 PM ET

June 17, 2011

Shakira vs. the Democrats

For Morocco's would-be revolutionaries, a popular music festival is a corrupt symbol of the country's misplaced priorities. If Shakira is a poster person for human rights, why then does she mostly perform in venues sponsored in mostly poorer nations? For example, her concerts in Brazil: the average minimum wage is R$575,00/month (equal to about US$340.00/month or US11.00/day, US$1.37/hour), generate millions...how? Each show is about three hours long. Average ticket price is about R$40,00 (or US$24.00). Crowds frequent savings bank account I think it's so sad that these people are making the hourly wage of 1 liter of gasoline (the equivalent). If my conversion is correct, that comes to like a $1 an hour in American dollars. And they live off a measly $2 a day in food. That's really sad to me, especially because me, my fellow Americans and other wealthy affiliates of the United States, and other wealthy countries in general are livin.

 

EDIE OLSEN

10:17 AM ET

June 21, 2011

Probably millions of pounds

Probably millions of pounds of food is thrown away each day, and it's truly sad to know some of this coukd be somehow saved for people like this who are extremely poor. It for one, makes me feel like a fool, for complaining about things sázkové kanceláre like rising gas prices and other things.I think we need to be more satisfied as a wealthy country that things like electricity, clean running water, and cars (even public buses) are pretty much a given for most americans.
Then you have these musicians like shakira and kanye west that are making a million dollars a show! It's truly sad that people are starving like this when other people are so well off; again performers getting paid a million sázkové kanceláre dollars a show when the people can't even afford a ticket. Please understand the philosophy of supporting the local artists. Maybe it's not a big crowd rocker but it would lower ticket prices and even then the locals can have a great time for less the price. I can't say i love reading this kind of stories but it is so so true and happens every day.