Crowded Waters

The superpower battle for regional supremacy in the South China Sea is heating up once again.

BY ABRAHAM M. DENMARK | JUNE 7, 2011

For the last two years, a quiet showdown has played out over the South China Sea, the body of water bordered by China, Vietnam, Malaysia, Singapore, Indonesia, Brunei, the Philippines, and Taiwan. This little-known body of water is of vast strategic importance: Fully one-third of the world's maritime trade traverses the South China Sea, and some optimistic estimates of its untapped stores of oil and natural gas would make it a second Persian Gulf. The South China Sea is also a major highway linking the oil fields of the Middle East and the factories of East Asia, with more than 80 percent of China's oil imports (and large percentages for Japan and South Korea as well) flowing over its waters. As influential Asia-watcher Robert D. Kaplan has put it, the South China Sea's importance to the region makes it the "Asian Mediterranean."

Due to these waters' importance, several countries -- Brunei, Malaysia, the Philippines, and Vietnam -- claim sovereignty over part of these waters. Yet China claims rights of sovereignty over almost the entire South China Sea, as detailed in the "9-dash line" included in its submission to the United Nations. While tension in these waters has waxed and waned for several decades, recent years have seen an uptick in tensions. Starting in 2009, two discernable rounds of geopolitical intrigue can be identified, and last week likely marked the beginning of round three.

The first round began in March 2009, when Chinese fishing vessels harassed the U.S. surveillance ship Impeccable in international waters, 75 miles off the coast of China's Hainan Island. Three months later, a Chinese submarine collided (apparently accidentally) with the towed sonar array of the USS John S. McCain near Subic Bay off the coast of the Philippines. Other aggressive moves followed, including reports that Beijing had declared the South China Sea to be a "core interest," putting it on par with Taiwan and Xinjiang as fundamental strategic priorities. China's assertiveness was noted around the world and caused a strong reaction.

Round two. In July 2010, the United States and much of Southeast Asia pushed back. At a meeting of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations Regional Forum in Hanoi, 12 Southeast Asian countries complained of Chinese assertiveness in the South China Sea, and U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton declared freedom of navigation within the South China Sea to be a national interest of the United States. China initially reacted harshly to this pushback, with Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi reportedly declaring Clinton's remarks in Hanoi to be "an attack on China" and not so subtly reminding his Singaporean counterpart that "China is a big country and other countries are small countries and that is just a fact." A subsequent statement by the Chinese military reiterated China's "indisputable sovereignty" over 1.3 million square miles of the South China Sea -- which much of Southeast Asia naturally disputed.

ADEK BERRY/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: CHINA, SOUTHEAST ASIA
 

Abraham M. Denmark is a specialist in U.S. foreign and defense policy in the Asia-Pacific region and the global commons. From 2007 to 2009, he served as country director for China affairs in the Office of the Secretary of Defense.

...

11:03 AM ET

June 8, 2011

arms race

since the usa loves selling arms, isn't this a good thing for the military industrial complex that the usa has become known as? i like the idea of the usa's presence in this area would be of benefit on some humanitarian level, but when one looks at the usa's presence around the globe, especially in the middle east at present, it is clear they have more to do with the killing of innocent people then with any sort of humanitarian goals....

a better question would be " can the usa help to foster an asian arms race?" it seems to be there countries mode of operation....

 

JACK FOXCROFT

3:11 PM ET

June 8, 2011

JAMSB3

America may have been "better than anyone else", but what about now? China is on route to become one of the biggest superpowers in the world.

Not slating you, but just saying the majority of people in power (senate governors etc.) shouldn't really be put in charge of a large demographic of people they don't understand.

I personally couldn't live in a country were someone with an IQ of ~80 is legally allowed to carry around a gun. And a country where they teach intelligent design in a lot of your schools. And Americans claim guns for protection, but there are plenty of other ways to protect your home from intruders, you can get DVR devices. And even cheap USB DVR devices.

"China might surpass the US in equity market capitalization terms by 2030 and become the single largest equity market in the world. By 2020, US GDP might be only slightly larger than China's GDP. Together, the four BRICs may account for 41% of the world's market capitalization by 2030, the report said."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BRIC

 

AARKY

8:22 PM ET

June 8, 2011

All that hype

The last two paragraphs of the article were the most relevant. The rest was hyperbole and speculation.

 

DAVID BROWN

11:49 PM ET

June 8, 2011

Round III

'Scuse me, but round three didn't begin at the Defense Forum in Singapore last weekend, but in a flurry of aggressive moves in the weeks preceding by China's maritime police against fishermen and hydrocarbons survey ships working for Vietnam and the Philippines.

China has put Washington and the ASEANs on the spot -- either they fashion a workable, rules-based approach to resolution of (at least) their claims, or China will continue to munch its way south through the South China Sea until it has swallowed it all.

more on this theme in my story June 8 at Asia Times: http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Southeast_Asia/MF09Ae01.html

regards, David Brown

 

MARTIAN150

6:07 PM ET

June 10, 2011

China's 1,000-year-old South China Sea sovereignty

Vietnamese and Filipinos should stop encroaching on thousand-year-old Chinese territory.

----------
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paracel_Islands

"The coast belonged to the Kingdom of Cauchi China. Map of Europe, Africa and ... There are some Chinese cultural relics in the Paracel islands dating from ..."

"China
618~1279

* There are some Chinese cultural relics in the Paracel islands dating from the Tang and Song dynasty eras[12][note 1], and there is some evidence of Chinese habitation on the islands in these periods.[13]."

 

UPBEAT1

8:49 AM ET

June 15, 2011

US Role

Although the US is not involved in this local conflict here, I think the US has a role as a mediator. With so many nations making claims and they are so small as compared to China, the risk of being bullied or unfairly treated would be there. MB

 

GREGORY H. BONTRAGER

5:50 PM ET

June 21, 2011

that 800-pound gorilla in the room

Potential presidential candidate Donald Trump has finally had the nerve to use the "C" word.

You know that 800-pound gorilla in the room that everyone seems to ignore. They steal our technology with impunity; they have implanted malware in our power grid. They have a specially designed ballistic missile just waiting to take out our carrier battle groups; they manipulate their currency to take unfair advantage of us and we owe them tons of money. But I guess we don't have anything to worry about, do we? They are our friends.

GREGORY H. BONTRAGER

Hutchinson