The Dark Closet

Don’t let the Amina hoax distract attention from the plight of the real gay community in Syria.

BY AHMED DANNY RAMADAN | JUNE 14, 2011

DAMASCUS, Syria In a city like Damascus, with its beautiful culture, amazing people, lovely food, and unmatchable history, one feels like they could be anything -- anything but gay, that is.

When Tom MacMaster, an American master's degree student living in Scotland, revealed himself to be the writer behind the Gay Girl in Damascus blog, it shattered the trust between the Middle Eastern blogosphere and the foreign media, and endangered the lives of queer people across the region who stepped out of the closet to answer questions about "Amina," MacMaster's fictional creation.

I remember sitting on a balcony overlooking rainy Damascus this April with my best friend in the city, who happens to be a lesbian, chatting about the queer community here.

She once asked me to pretend to be a fictional man interested in marrying her girlfriend to assuage the suspicions of the girlfriend's family that she was gay. The family needed to hear a voice behind this man, and we gave them one: I pretended to be a Syrian man living in the United States who met their daughter online and was calling on Skype to chat with the mother about future arrangements. The mother was so relieved to receive evidence that her daughter was not gay. The conversation was short, and I felt awkward about pretending to be someone I wasn't.

The conversation on the balcony turned to another problem my friend was facing: She was having problems coming out to her close friends and family members. I could see it in her eyes -- she was struggling. And sitting on the balcony with her, I suddenly had a suspicion about Amina. If my friend, one of the bravest women I've ever met, can't be out of the closet in Damascus, and if I faced so many problems with my family since my teenage years due to my homosexuality, how could the "gay girl of Damascus" be so boldly out -- not to mention critical of President Bashar al-Assad's regime -- and gain acceptance and protection from her family?

My suspicions hardened when I went back to her blog to read the post, "My father, the hero," that had first garnered her widespread attention. Honestly, I didn't believe a word of it. Any person who lived in Syria knows that authorities coming to pick up a suspect in the "wee small hours" are not going to back off because of a speech, as Amina described the incident. They are not going to be shamed by anyone. Actually, after such a confrontation, arresting both Amina and her father would have been unavoidable.

It all felt so fictional, so unimaginable, so untrue. Upon Amina's fictional arrest, I shared my views with my lesbian friends, asking them on a secret Facebook group whether anyone knew of her or had any idea who she was. I came back empty-handed. I later shared my concerns with NPR journalist Andy Carvin, whom I'm happy to call a friend, and he started asking questions.

MacMaster's admission on June 12 that the blog was fictional has spurred fears within Syria's LGBT community of a potential backlash. The media has been targeting minorities who are seen as critical of the current regime, and the LGBT community is an easy target. They don't need to change people's opinion of homosexuals; it's already a negative one.

 SUBJECTS: SYRIA
 

Ahmed Danny Ramadan is a Syrian writer. This article was initially written under a pseudonym, but the byline has been changed to the author's real name upon his request.

STEVE_M

10:36 PM ET

June 14, 2011

People like your dad

There are still people that believe that people can "spread around the gayness"? I guess broad gay acceptance will be a generational change. The following (in a nonviolent interpretation) represents a personal conflict as I seek a medical research career to improve quality of life and lifespan:

Death is the only cure for the terminally ignorant.

 

STEVEN BENNETT

11:24 PM ET

June 14, 2011

And what is that supposed to mean?

The situation the author describes sounds remarkably like what I understand the situation for the American gay community to have been like in the 1950's. Now, of course, we're debating same-sex marriage at a national level, but there's still an unnervingly large portion of the American population that thinks being gay is an "illness" that can be "cured", so I don't know how superior we can be. I suspect some of the things the author describes still happen in some conservative families here.

And wishing for the death of someone, no matter how...backwards and ignorant some of their beliefs may be, is in poor taste.

 

AR

11:46 AM ET

June 15, 2011

The US and West in general

The US and West in general have more to learn from Syria concerning family values than the Syrians do about 'tolerence' from the West. I guess next we should be encouraging them to let their 17 year old daughters get pregnant and be un wed. It's so modern and therefore cool. Stop dictating your 'norms' onto other peoples.

 

NORSE SAGE

1:29 PM ET

June 15, 2011

Pot calling the snow black

When the 'family values' in question includes treating your children like property and stoning them to death for having the audacity to choose their own path in life, please forgive me for not embracing such stone-age thinking together with the rest of the civilized world. The 21th century is here, didn't you get the memo?

 

AVILLA

7:18 PM ET

June 15, 2011

Nonsense.

Advocating for the basic human rights of individuals who were born a certain way is not a "norm", it's decency.

 

AR

2:14 PM ET

June 17, 2011

Answer this simple question.

Answer this simple question. Are you a moral relativist?

 

JOFFREY PRINTZ

4:49 PM ET

June 19, 2011

Fake blogger

Daniel Nassar is NOT a Syrian or in Syria and has never been in that country. Nassar is a sock puppet of English-Israeli propagandist Dan Littauer. Shame on Foreign Policy for falling for this

 

LIAMREGLER

3:57 PM ET

July 12, 2011

plight of the real gay community

In a city like Damascus, with its beautiful culture, amazing people, lovely food, and unmatchable history, one feels like they could be anything.. anything but gay, that is.