Underground and in the Closet

The state of the gay Middle East.

BY DAVID KENNER | JUNE 15, 2011

SYRIA

The law: Article 520 of the Syrian Penal Code of 1949 criminalized homosexuality as "unnatural sexual intercourse," punishable by up to three years in prison.

The reality: The situation on the ground in Syria, as described by one Syrian author's account in FP, is if anything, grimmer than the law suggests. In March and April 2010, Syrian police raided four separate gay parties held in private homes. "[R]eports indicated that dozens of gays and lesbians have been imprisoned over the past several years after being arrested on vague charges such as abusing social values, selling, buying or consuming illegal drugs, and organizing and promoting 'obscene' parties," stated the State Department's 2010 human rights report on Syria.

Unlike in Lebanon, Egypt, or even Dubai, there are few informal support networks for gay people in Syria. Sami Hamwi, a Syria-based pseudonymous blogger for Gay Middle East, said a few activists are trying to change that, but they face both societal and political obstacles. "There is no way for me to survive in my line of work if I come out," said Hamwi, adding that he had lost two jobs already because of his sexuality.

Hamwi feared that the "Gay Girl in Damascus" hoax would cause the Syrian security forces to escalate their crackdown against gay activists. "I think they will not wait until the blogger is famous or well-read to seek them out," he said. "[And] arrests in Syria means actual disappearing.… No one can hear or know about the arrested people, sometimes for decades."

MUSTAFA OZER/AFP/Getty Images

 

David Kenner is an associate editor at Foreign Policy.

DKMAPME

7:35 PM ET

June 15, 2011

Great article

This story was thorough, helpful and well written. Thank for providing good information, although somewhat sad, still high quality.

Thanks

 

SOMEGUY

3:55 AM ET

June 16, 2011

More lies

More lies, half-truths and arbitrary ethical distinctions. Why is incest illegal here? Because of the high degree of genetic defects it causes. Whether that's right or wrong is open to debate (should it be illegal if the couple doesn't plan on having children?), but this discussion is about homosexuality, not whatever other topic you want to divert it to (also kind of funny that you chose this example since cousin-to-cousin incest is common in the Arab world).
There's almost too much nonsense in the rest of your post to bother responding to, but I'll try.

"It spreads AIDS"
The region of the world most severely affected by AIDS is Africa, and there it is mostly transmitted by heterosexuals. I guess we should start persecute them too.

"you recruit straight disillusioned males to 'try it'"
Old homophobic scare tactic. That you honestly think the real persecution of homosexuals can be justified by these bizarre fictions speaks a lot about you as a person.

"you touch little boys"
That's pedophiles, moron. Try and conflate them if you want, but no one with a working brain will take you seriously.

"it leads to effeminate men"
Oh no! Social norms might be challenged! We certainly have to have have people killed for that. No doubt. We certainly couldn't let people be free to live their own lives and act however the hell they want to act. Certainly not. Imprisoning and killing people is certainly the more civilized solution.
By the way, there are plenty of macho gay men too. Should they be persecuted as well, or only the effeminate ones?

"health issues"
These are exaggerated beyond their importance and apply to heterosexual activities as well. If a person isn't practicing safe sex, that's a problem for that individual, but that's no reason to make the wide-spectrum of gay sexual interactions illegal.

"immigration to make up for their low birthrate"
And this has nothing to do with homosexuals. Lowering birthrates go hand and hand with economic and social progress. Research it.

 

PINKWATCHER

9:51 AM ET

June 16, 2011

on Gay Middle East

How is it possible that the only source quoted for an article on Arab LGBTs is an Israeli organization? GayMiddleEast.com is an Israeli run and operated outfit. There are more than enough Arab LGBT organizations and online groups for you to source. Enough white men talking on our behalf please.

 

GEOF

3:09 PM ET

June 16, 2011

Gay Oasis

"White men?" stupid, stupid, American notion of race. Jews have more in common genetically with Syrians then we do with white Americans. And we're more ethnically diverse than any other nationality in the ME. And I know its painful to admit that in yet another area, Israel is the most free, most tolerant, most progressive society in the ME, yet it remains true. True supporters of LGBT rights need to stop identifying with their oppressors and accept that Israel is the model for what ME societies should look like.

 

ELLE JAY

9:54 AM ET

June 16, 2011

A Jihad for Love

Thank you for the interesting summary; however, once again FP excludes the rest of North Africa from its roundup. Morocco's laws (and its well-known gay tourism industry) ought to have been included.

More notably, there is a quite good 2007 documentary, "A Jihad for Love," on the experiences of Muslim men and women from the Middle East, (including Iran--don't tell Ahmadi Nejad,) that I highly recommend. It addresses a number of issues, both the very real discrimination in their home countries that you touch upon, and the problems they encounter as openly gay Muslims living in the West.

 

JIBRAN_PCC

2:29 AM ET

June 18, 2011

These are exaggerated beyond

These are exaggerated beyond their importance and apply to heterosexual activities as well. If a person isn'tpontevedrarealestate practicing safe sex, that's a problem for that individual, but that's no reason to make the wide-spectrum of gay sexual interactions illegal.

 

MARTINCDL

10:31 AM ET

July 13, 2011

The region of the world most

The region of the world most cdl severely affected by AIDS is Africa, and there it is mostly transmitted by heterosexuals. I guess we should start persecute them too.

 

MEDA169

1:08 PM ET

July 15, 2011

Underground and in the Closet

The state of the gay Middle East. How is it possible that the only source quoted for an article on Arab LGBTs is an Israeli organization? GayMiddleEast.com is an Israeli run and operated outfit. There are more than enough Arab LGBT organizations and online groups for you to source. Enough white men talking on our behalf please. lawyer Thank you for the interesting summary; however, once again FP excludes the rest of North Africa from its roundup. Morocco's laws (and its well-known gay tourism industry) ought to have been included. More notably, there is a quite good 2007 documentary, "A Jihad for Love," on the experiences of Muslim men and women from the Middle East, (including Iran--don't tell Ahmadi Nejad,) that I highly reco.

 

PATRICIAMOORE

1:22 AM ET

July 16, 2011

coming clean

Either the purpose of these posts through the kid from Gaithersburg would be to state that only Progressives lie/manipulate stories to create a point -OR- to express that only Progressives wish to offer the Arab Spring.

The very first point isn't worth an answer. Concerning the Arab Spring, isn't this precisely what George Bush said happens after establishing a democracy, "Iraq," within the learn about the center East. I believe that it's probably baloney to link both, however i believed that people about the Right would a minimum of prefer to declare that there is the best purpose for home solar power has a large number of Americans that died in the united states. Actually, is post stating that Progressives are wrong since the Middle East should only become democratic when being attacked by Republican presidents?

Truly, what's the point here? Could it be simply this guy lied; lying isn't good; this person is really a Progressive; ergo, Progressives can be harmful? How can you spell logical fallacy?