The Renminbi An Exorbitant Burden The New Triumvirate

The WikiLeaks of Money

Is Bitcoin a revolution or a bubble?

BY JOSHUA E. KEATING | JUNE 23, 2011

For something that few had heard of a month ago, the online currency Bitcoin tends to elicit pretty strong responses. Depending on whom you ask, Bitcoin is the "future of money," a "crypto-geek Ponzi scheme," an "online form of money laundering," or a tool for "libertarian hipsters and criminals."

The publicity has not been kind to Bitcoin, which has faced attacks from law enforcement, hackers, and cybercriminals alike. The currency's value has seen several sharp fluctuations. The currency has been used to spread malware over Twitter. Early supporters appear to have lost confidence, and U.S. lawmakers are starting to ask tough questions. But shutting down Bitcoin may prove more difficult than its critics hope. And whether or not the experiment succeeds, its rise may herald the emergence of a new form of decentralized currency trading.

Bitcoin's origins are appropriately mysterious, in keeping with its cyberpunk image. The idea for the currency was first described in a paper in 2009 by Satoshi Nakamoto, supposedly a Japanese programmer whom no one has ever met or communicated with. The name is almost certainly a pseudonym, and many believe "Nakamoto" may not be only one person.

It's not the first attempt at creating a digital currency. There have been several attempts, including the now defunct eCash, the "Linden dollars" used in the virtual online world Second Life, and, more recently, the Facebook Credits users can use to purchase goods and services through the social network.

What makes Bitcoin unique is its peer-to-peer structure. There's no start-up company or central authority that can go out of business or be shut down by the police. Bitcoins can be purchased through online exchanges by wiring money from your bank account, and there are also sites that will provide users with a few free coins to get started.

"All previous digital currencies required a central trusted authority, which created a single point of failure," says Gavin Andresen, a programmer who develops websites and applications to help users acquire Bitcoins. "And almost all previous private digital currencies turned out to be untrustworthy, because they failed." ECash went out of business, for instance, and the use of Linden dollars remains confined to the still-small world of Second Life users.

The number of coins in circulation, as well as all transactions, is tracked by a distributed server that uses the computing power of Bitcoin users. New coins are "mined" at a rate determined by the computing power of the users involved. Like commodities such as gold or silver, there is a finite number of Bitcoins in the universe -- mining will stop when the total supply reaches 21 million. There are currently about 7.2 million in circulation. The value of these coins grew rapidly throughout this year, hitting a high of nearly $32 dollars per coin in early June.

Economists have been skeptical about the currency's future viability, though, seeing its rapid rise as a sign of irrational exuberance as new users rushed to sign on. University of California-Berkeley economics professor Barry Eichengreen wrote in the Washington Post: "If it is possible to imagine one private electronic currency, then it's possible to imagine several, and there would be no guarantee that other people would accept the particular electronic money you use." George Mason University's Tyler Cowen sees Bitcoin's rapid rise as "a sign of the dependence of the Bitcoin upon expectations, and a sign of its bubbly nature."

 

Joshua E. Keating is an associate editor at Foreign Policy.

CEP

8:44 AM ET

June 24, 2011

interesting source of money

I think the more important is what paypal does. It's interesting to see nobody speaks on it for ecurrency.Bitcoin is too small economy when compared with paypal. For the sentence "If it is possible to imagine one private electronic currency, then it's possible to imagine several, and there would be no guarantee that other people would accept the particular electronic money you use." I fully agreed. cep forum

 

BTCVC

8:54 AM ET

June 24, 2011

Bitcoin is being attacked by the media just like Wikileaks

A lot of online articles have been trying to to call Bitcoin a 'pyramid scheme'.

Bitcoin is no more of a pyramid scheme then any other fiat currency.

If you wanna talk about a real pyramid scheme, look at the United States Social Security system.

It is the DEFINITION of a pyramid scheme.

 

HAWKS5999

1:30 PM ET

June 24, 2011

The wrong argument

If BitCoin is as much a pyramid scheme as fiat currencies then it loses a lot of its appeal. Making the argument that it is no worse is the wrong argument. It HAS to be better than fiat currencies or what's the point?

 

HARNY34

1:30 PM ET

June 24, 2011

Bitcoin is for printed money,

Bitcoin is for printed money, what the web is for printed press. Wake up. There is no way to kill bitcoin, and as people figure out how to use it securely it's value will only increase. Bitcoin gives the people full and complete control over their money, and takes the privilege from central entities to print more of it. tummy tuck

Take some time and watch the excellent movie - "the money masters" about the federal reserve and money creation, I'm sure that would change your perspective on bitcoin.

 

HAWKS5999

1:35 PM ET

June 24, 2011

Is it the Internet or CompuServe?

Before the world wide web and internet will all fabulous, there was Compuserve and a handful of other online services. These services arguably paved the way for broader acceptance of the internet and world wide web - and then they died.

I'm invested in BitCoin and believe it will have an impact on international currency. My only question is whether BTC will be the platform that ends up as the ultimate international money Messiah or just the Prophet announcing his coming.

 

CBEAST

3:25 PM ET

June 24, 2011

Bitcoin ore.

Bitcoin is a new fundamental technology. The current face of bitcoin is like raw ore. You don't really know what you have until you smelt it and make it pretty, but the technology itself is elemental and very durable. Analogies, metaphors, and allegories aside, ask not what bitcoin can do for you, but what you can do to capitalize on the next-big-thing since social media itself.

Indeed, there were BBSs before the internet, but the fundamental use of modems to turn analog information into digital has not changed since it was initially developed. Only the speeds have changed and applications have evolved and improved steadily. Sure, someone can copy the idea and try to market it, but why re-invent the wheel? There is plenty of room for developing primary and secondary markets and technologies. There will be many bitcoin moguls to come.

 

CRUZRE

8:34 PM ET

June 24, 2011

How to such ignorant people get job's with Foreignpolicy.com

Wow, just wow. I don't know where to begin. I'll start by asking Foreignpolicy.com why they pay you to write articles without doing any research at all.

Just as microcosm of the whole article:
It is "Cypher punks" NOT "Cyberpunks". As in the "Cypher punk Mailing List"

#2
"... by Satoshi Nakamoto, supposedly a Japanese programmer whom no one has ever met or communicated with."

Completely wrong, Ya, Nakamoto posts on the bitcoin forums and IRC all the time. Gavin Andresen (the technical lead for bitcoin, and a computer science major form Princeton University.) would have told you that if you would have asked him, or you would have known had you done any research at all.

#3
"It's not the first attempt at creating a digital currency ..."

Nope, it is the first Decentralized P2P currency. That is the operative phrase. No bank or business to regulate, shutdown, nor manipulate the money supply like with Fed Notes. Your USD bank account and credit cards are electronic.

#4
The rapid rise in value is do to the rapid rise in adoption. There is a fixed number of coins that will created, and over a fixed time span. This puts the total control of the value into the hands of the buyers. If demand grows so dose value because there is no way to increase supply. Also, there will only be 21M, however each bitcoin is infinitely divisible. The idea is that we will be spending microBTC's not whole bitcoin's. Also, the only way for the bitcoin economy to grow is for the value of the bitcoin to rise, because no more then 21M can ever be made.

Each rise in value is directly related to a News event. Slash dot, form $0.50 to $1.10. Time Magazine ~$2 to $5. Forbes $5 to $9 CBS News $9 to $30... plus loads of increasing blogs. If you look at the rise in network computing power and translation you will see the same spikes in adoption.

#5
("It's the same concept as open-source [software]. It can be trusted because nobody owns it," says Rick Falkvinge)

It is Open Source so no one has to trust anything or anyone but yourself. Read the code. The reason why a Decentralized currency is so trusted is because there is no why for your account to be frozen, audited, stolen, nor can the currency have it's value hurt by a nation's political unrest, nor do to the Fed printing too much.

I am to tired to go in. You get the point. If you want to learn about bitcoin this is not article will not help you.

Foreignpolicy should fire this incompetent reporter.

 

AUKPERSPECTIVE

1:02 PM ET

July 7, 2011

Actually it is a complicated economics question

Actually whether a currency will succeed as as universal unit of exchange and possibly as a store of value (much harder by the way!) too is a very complicated question. The issue of whether an individual or group of individuals could "print" additional currency effectively stealing value is an important one. There is also the issue of who is effectively guaranteeing the currency.

The likely break up of the Euro - I was at a corporate event in London listening to a US economist speak very convincingly about this - is likely to make it harder for any new electronic currency to gain wide credence except as a linked unit of exchange (eg paypal which is linked to your bank account) which is not quite the same thing as being a universally accepted unit of exchange anyway.

But what about the second test of a currency as a store of value....... would you keep five million dollars in your pay pal account? No because there is no government guarantee behind it - so even pay pal which is the most established electronic currency is not yet a store of value and hence a real currency.

I am not by the way arguing against the growth of micro currencies which the iternet of course really helps but that is not the same thing as being the dollar or the pound.

I agree the reporter (well this is a foriegn policy not an economics journal) did not really understand the issues which are actually very technical.

 

EILENE175

1:08 AM ET

July 23, 2011

The WikiLeaks of Money

Is Bitcoin a revolution or a bubble? Actually whether a currency will succeed as as universal unit of exchange and possibly as a store of value (much harder by the way!) too is a very complicated question. The issue of whether an individual or group of individuals could "print" additional currency effectively stealing value is an important one. There is also the issue of who is effectively guaranteeing the currency. The likely break check out Before the world wide web and internet will all fabulous, there was Compuserve and a handful of other online services. These services arguably paved the way for broader acceptance of the internet and world wide web - and then they died. I'm invested in BitCoin and believe it will have an impact on international currency. My only question is whether BTC will be the platform that ends up as the ulti

 

PERSON_GUYZZ1

8:47 AM ET

July 23, 2011

Before the world wide web and

Before the world wide web and internet will all fabulous, there was Compuserve and a handful of other online services. These services arguably paved the way for broader acceptance of the internet and world wide web - and then they died earnextramoney.I am not by the way arguing against the growth of micro currencies which the iternet of course really helps but that is not the same thing as being the dollar or the pound.