If Hugo Goes

It's unclear whether the charismatic Venezuelan president is really all that ill. But what is clear is that his country is in serious trouble, whether or not he returns from convalescing in Cuba.

BY MICHAEL SHIFTER | JUNE 28, 2011

See a slide show of our favorite photos of El Presidente.

Until now, the most frequently asked question about Hugo Chávez's virtually one-man rule in Venezuela was whether he would be prepared to relinquish power if he lost an election. That question has become even more germane in view of next year's presidential contest, as El Presidente faces a country arguably in worse shape than at any moment since his regime began a dozen years ago.

Today, however, another crucial question -- one that has seldom been posed -- looms: What would happen if Chávez were incapacitated and unable to serve as president? What if he died while in office? Who would succeed him? How would a successor be chosen?

The current mystery surrounding the usually omnipresent and glib 56-year-old former paratrooper has given rise to such questions. Since June 10, Chávez has been hospitalized in Havana, Cuba. Senior Venezuelan sources reported that Chávez had surgery on a pelvic abscess. A spokesman now says he plans to return to Caracas by July 5 -- just in time for Venezuela's bicentennial, when Chávez is scheduled to host a major gathering of Latin American and Caribbean leaders.

Yet rumors and speculation about Chávez's condition and intentions abound. Reports from Havana have been few and far between and lacking in any detail. Some believe Chávez is actually as fit as ever, but is relishing being the center of attention and is getting ready for a return to cheering throngs. Others cite last week's declarations of Venezuela's foreign minister, Nicolás Maduro, that Chávez is "fighting for his health" and reports that his daughter and grandchildren visited him in Havana; they are convinced that his condition is far more serious than the public has been led to believe.

Whatever theory turns out to be correct, Chávez's first prolonged absence from the reins of power suggests just how precarious Venezuela's institutions now are. It also shows the extent to which the country relies on his arbitrary rule. True, the 1999 Constitution says that the country's vice president should take over in the event that the president becomes incapacitated. But few can imagine strict adherence to rules -- certainly not in an era when Chávez has basically rewritten the book at his fancy -- not to mention it's hard to see the nondescript Elías Jaua succeeding the president.

Instead, within the broad movement -- some might call it a sensibility -- known as Chavismo that underpins Chávez's ongoing Bolivarian revolution, it is almost certain that a fierce power struggle would ensue. In fact, the maneuvering has already started. On Sunday, June 26, Chávez's elder brother, Adán, currently governor of their home state of Barinas, garnered attention for suggesting that "as authentic revolutionaries," Venezuelans could indeed use "other methods of struggle," including "the armed struggle," to ensure continuity in government. It's an ominous sign of battles to come within Chavismo.

Dan Kitwood/Getty Images

 

Michael Shifter is president of the Inter-American Dialogue and an adjunct professor at Georgetown University.

THOMASMC

11:39 AM ET

June 29, 2011

Read between the lines

He was probably poisoned by the CIA and Bush III (aka Obama).

 

AARKY

5:20 PM ET

June 29, 2011

Is Chavez Sick?

I'm not certain if this article is propaganda for Israel or the US, but it's full of lots of wild speculation and lots of If's. People should remember that's how we wound up in Iraq. The fact that Chavez and Amedinejad of Iran have met makes him the enemy of Israel. The fact that he has nationalized foreign oil companies (think US) makes him the enemy of the US. There is a no point in putting out an article that is speculative and full of hyperbole/BS.

 

FERRARI333SP

5:48 PM ET

June 29, 2011

Are you guys commenting on

Are you guys commenting on the article itself? Because it doesn't seem like you are. I've actually been to Venezuela itself, and the author of the article presents a very real picture of the potentialities of what could potentially happen, with different situations. I personally believe Chavez is just waiting it out to return on July 5th for the country's 200 year anniversary of the country's independence. But in regards to the country's presidential election next year, we could very well see a picture of Chavez trying to stay in power, should he actually lose the election, which at this point is fairly likely. Venezuela's economy is pretty crap right now, so much discontent exists among the majority of the public. Very interesting times in Venezuela.

 

PIERINA GARCIA

7:01 PM ET

June 29, 2011

Unfortunately true

I am Venezuelan. I like to think of myself as a young law student who believes in freedom and democracy and of course rule of law. None of which are found here. I'm currently working actively to give venezuelans what we truly and rightfully deserve.

Chávez represents the opposite of my believes. So I guess you can call me "anti-Chávez".

Everything written in this article is true. From the illness of the President, to the latent thread of an armed conflict.

There are approximately 14million illicit arms in the country. We are 30million citizens, this means almost half the country is armed, and most of them, are "chavistas" who will stand by Chávez when his government falls.

Chávez failed. He came with the empty promise of a revolution that never came. 12 years after many are still waiting. Hoping that he won't forget them.

Polarization can't nearly define what we have to life through every single day. Families torn apart, people that lost their jobs because they weren't "revolutionaries", and the President's speech always promoting hate between revolutionaries and "burgueses" (bourgeois).

And then there's us, the youth, who instead of concerning our minds with education and banalities, have the enormous responsibility of building a country over again once this thing is over.

I work with many main political actors. And know from a very close source that Chávez illness is actually colon cancer.

The situation is so tense that the government doesn't want to tell the truth to the citizens. But we know for sure, that it will be far worse if Chávez dies, than if he es democratically overthrown.

This is my view of the situation in Venezuela, believe it or not, I ask you to never let this happen in your country, for it is too painful to see a country struggling to beat the domination of a macabre tyrant willing to do anything, no matter how "maquiavellian", to make himself with the power until his last breath.

 

RYDDLE

8:49 PM ET

June 29, 2011

Dead on

I'll ask again, are these guys even commenting on the article?
Whether or not they are, every single word in the article is true. I am a Venezuelan (and live there), and this is one of the most accurate depictions I have read of the country in a while.
The country is completely lost in a swirl of insecurity, poverty, corruption and economic woes. Do not be surprised if a small civil war brews up, general chaos, or anything else the author of the article proposed.

 

LALOPARSAD

6:16 AM ET

July 25, 2011

it doesn't seem like you are.

it doesn't seem like you are. I've actually been to Venezuela itself, and the author of the article presents a very real picture of the potentialities of what could potentially happen, with different situations. I personally believe Chavez is just waiting it out to return on July 5th for the country's 200 year anniversary of the country's independence waystoearnmoneyonline.The situation is so tense that the government doesn't want to tell the truth to the citizens. But we know for sure, that it will be far worse if Chávez dies, than if he es democratically overthrown.