The Least Free Places on Earth, 2011

20 places with nothing to celebrate this weekend.

TEXT BY FREEDOM HOUSE | JULY 1, 2011

North Korea: North Koreans enjoy the lowest levels of freedom in the world according to Freedom House's rankings. Kim Jong Il, who assumed power in 1994 upon the death of his father, North Korea's founding leader Kim Il Sung, retains all political power. The regime maintains a network of prison camps in which thousands of political prisoners endure brutal conditions. All facets of personal life -- including employment, education, residence, and access to medical care -- are determined by a semihereditary system that classifies citizens into subgroups based on family "loyalty" to the regime. Decades of severe economic mismanagement have left the country dependent on food aid -- which is tightly controlled by the regime -- and the population is starving. This year, North Korea made several leadership changes, promoting key members of Kim Jong Il's family to positions in anticipation of succession. In particular, Kim's son Kim Jong Un now appears to be confirmed as the heir apparent.

-/AFP/Getty Images

 

You can read more about these countries in Freedom House's 2011 "Worst of the Worst" report.

AHSON HASAN

9:09 PM ET

July 1, 2011

Incomplete list...

Pakistan missing from the list? Freedom House needs to re-visit that country and review its findings!

 

JEAN KAPENDA

10:43 PM ET

July 2, 2011

Open Letter to the Secretary- General of the United Nations

Dear Mr. Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon:

In response to the Freedom House publication entitled "Lands of the Unfree", I would like to draw your attention to Eastern Congo and request that immediate actions be taken to resolve the situation of violence against women in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. My proposal is very simple and cost-effective to end the crisis in a matter of weeks instead of years:

1. Have the Government of the D.R.C stamp the full name of each soldier and policeman at a visible place on the uniform. Uniforms that do not comply shall be withdrawn from regular forces. This will facilitate the identification of the perpetrators if the belong to the regular army. The absence of such identification shall point to foreign armed criminals from Rwanda or Uganda, also known as foreign rebels. The cost: just a few thousands dollars to be covered by the Congolese government!

2. Since mobile phones are widely used in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, have cell phone companies activate a 1-800 number so that victims can report crimes against women as soon as they occur. Advantage: it will reduce the response time!

3. Since Eastern Congo produces a good portion of the coltan used in the manufacture of cell phones we all use daily around the world, obtain cooperation of cell phone manufacturers to distribute cheap or free cell phones in Eastern Congo, especially in areas with little public safety protection.

Mr. Secretary-General, as you can see, my proposal is aimed at (1) reducing the response time, (2) facilitating the identification of the perpetrators, and (3) prosecuting and convicting the criminals involved, be they Congolese or foreigners (meaning Rwandans and Ugandans, the ones who triggered the current crisis).

I am optimistic the implementation of this simple proposal will save billions of dollars to foreign taxpayers and will contribute to the rule of law in the Congo, which is still another land of the unfree.

Sincerely,

Jean Kapenda, MPA

 

JACOB SINGER

12:48 PM ET

July 5, 2011

GAZA, West Bank, East Jerusalem...

While there are so many freedoms that can be taken away, the Israeli policy of a perpetual state of emergency, a perpetual occupation and no constitution, makes it impossible for Israel's palestinian minority to have any real representation within government, equal justice, equal services, and worse of all: no opportunity for happiness.

 

SHAVONNE.VAUGH286

4:57 AM ET

July 21, 2011

Pakistan isnt half of North Korea

Im Sure that North Korea is like 1000 times worse then Pakistan. I've been to both countries. Where in N korea I coudnt choose my own journey. I was guided by agents, and they only showed me some nice shops with smiling people. Where In Pakistan I could pick my own roads etc.

- Vincent Kelly ( partner to Shavonne)

 

VERNON MILES

10:56 PM ET

July 1, 2011

Don't mind us, we'll die quietly

So, I guess we can just forget about Chechnya then. Kadyrov suing Memorial for libel? The continuing Khodorkovsky fiasco? Not to mention the scores of missing or murdered journalists. It's no China or Myanmar, but if Belarus and South Ossetia made the list it's hard to imagine Europe's bloodiest conflict turned oppressive state couldn't be squeezed somewhere towards the end, especially with the conflict there crossing over into neighboring Dagestan. This combined with the previously mentioned absence of Pakistan makes for a bit of a poor showing. Chechnya, in every single sense of the word, should rank among the highest of the least free places on Earth.

 

GLOBALFORCES

11:05 PM ET

July 6, 2011

Kim Kares

While Kim Jong-Il is being showered with expensive gifts, the North Korean people are being tortured by their government as two forced combat campaigns of 150 days and 100 days are continuing, according to Open Doors. In these periods, almost every citizen has to work actively for the state or face imprisonment. Christians are even under more scrutiny during these combat campaigns.

It's illegal to be a Christian in North Korea, says Paul Estabrooks with Open Doors. "The house churches, especially in villages where they receive opposition, are made up almost only of immediate family members. They don't sing because they can't reveal the fact that they're worshiping together."

Estabrooks says North Korea is the most difficult area in which they work. Despite that, he says they do have a network of believers there. "These networks do have some communication with one another, which lead our hunter fans co-workers to estimate that there are about 400,000 Christians in North Korea. Up to a quarter of them are in labor camps because when it is discovered that someone is a Christian there, he is considered a traitor."

 

NERP

11:34 AM ET

July 3, 2011

Definition?

What is their definition of "free"? Technically the US has more laws than most of these places. Politically free I suppose?

 

FREEZEICE04

1:37 AM ET

July 11, 2011

Good Points

The US has laws which allows everyone to have freedom/choice unlike the countries mentioned. It's pretty ironic that the only thing keeping countries like USA a free country is that everyone must obey the laws...

 

VISIONTUNNEL

11:03 AM ET

July 6, 2011

Marxists, Islamists, Despots and Tribal

Glancing through the list the least free places in the world have one or a combination of power structure lead by Marxists, Islamists, Despots and Tribal.

It is indeed surprising that the terrorist breeding and exporting Pakistan is left out of the list.

 

GLOBALFORCES

12:26 AM ET

July 12, 2011

Pakistan suthorities tied to militants

Pakistani authorities have long had ties to militant groups based on their soil that largely focused their efforts in Afghanistan and India. But with Pakistan joining the United States as an ally in its "war on terrorism" since 9/11, experts say Islamabad has seen harsh blowback on its policy of backing militants operating abroad. Leadership elements of al-Qaeda and the Afghan Taliban, along with other terrorist groups, have made Pakistan's tribal areas (the semi-autonomous region along the Afghan border) their home of silver necklace and now work closely with a wide variety of Pakistani militant groups. On May 1, 2011, al-Qaeda leader and 9/11 mastermind Osama bin Laden was killed by a U.S. raid in Abbottabad, a military town not far from Islamabad, raising questions about the Pakistani government and intelligence services' knowledge of his whereabouts.

 

GLOBALFORCES

9:02 AM ET

July 25, 2011

militants and resistance

the more you keep your eyes and ears open the less clear it is about right n wrong. Terrorists are often those who take up arms against armed invaders and dictators.

The rhetoric seems to be "those who resist who should stay powerless are terrorists". Western interference and best ceiling fans doesn't go down in poor and self-crushed countries especially when it goes in with heavy hands and duplicitous standards that are easily seen by the locals as self serving. Doesn't often look as if we know how to do things even if we have a clear idea of what we want to do.

In my own self serving way I guess I am happier with our view that it's always better to have the bloodshed and destruction in someone else's backyard.

 

AUKPERSPECTIVE

2:13 PM ET

July 6, 2011

A big thumbs up for democracy

I liked the list and no way Pakistan or US (come on that is ridiculous) should be on this list. A big thumbs up to democracy too as all the regimes listed are non democratic in the Western sense (elections where the chocies are controlled are not free elections by the way).

A much more interesting question is how many of these regimes are going to be around in 5 years time. Syria, China (Tibet by implication), Belarus and Libya (of course) seem most likely to see change in a positive sense. Alas for some of the African nations listed there may be change but most likely into a failed state or more of the same (different tribe etc)

China change really? Yes I think so and China is the country we really have to watch. I attended a corporate event in London and heard Nassim Nicholas Taleb talk about instability in financial markets which I found unconvincing but the same analysis applied to political regimes seemed spot on. The Chinese regime has got enough secret police and loyal troops to get rid of people on a one by one basis till the cows come home and the will to do it. Could it cope with 10 demonstrations of 100,000 people in its 10 biggest cities simultaneously? Could it trust its average army regulars to open fire? Would that even work if the next day there would be 10,000 videos on YouTube? China is unstable and like the Arab Spring it could fall very very fast. Good thing too!

 

FOCUZ

7:43 PM ET

July 6, 2011

I love the US

Yeah some of our laws may be weird but they all started with good intentions, and yes you can have beer in the car it just can't be opened. Its basically the same as the gun law, yes you can have it in the car you just can't be using it... This is the best article on the web hosting any information like this, Korea sucks

 

MASINI

11:06 AM ET

July 12, 2011

no good at all

I wonder what those people were wrong. Do not want or can not remove that tyrant. There are already several generations since these dictators enslave that country. I refuse to believe that Koreans can not make a revolution for the sake of their children. I am so selfish? Or maybe the dictator was able to form a system in which those people have no chance at freedom. Maybe we should intervene as much as we can. colectoare propolis

 

HIDROCIL SP

2:16 PM ET

July 18, 2011

I agree with you MASINI. I

I agree with you MASINI. I told that to a friend from Desentupidora wich do a great work with Desentupidora de pias, ralos e etc...but anyway, he seems to disagree with that. Well, there is nothing I can do to make him believe that Koreans can not make a revolution for the sake of their children. I do believe that.