Trouble Down South

For Saudi Arabia, Yemen's implosion is a nightmare.

BY ELLEN KNICKMEYER | JULY 5, 2011

"Let's call them friends of Saudi Arabia," Khashoggi said of those receiving patronage. "Saudi Arabia pays them money handsomely for various services such as influence, protection, stability. That's what matters in Saudi Arabia."

In fact, said Barbara Bodine, former U.S. ambassador to Yemen, "the Saudis have really gotten very little for their money, but have a dilemma in that they can't cut it off entirely. Yemen needs the money, and without it, it would probably implode."

Saleh himself likewise governed through his own patronage system, divvying out Yemen's wealth and influence to elites to keep them on his side and blocking development of state institutions in the process.

The lack of focus on government-building, including the failure to build a functioning tax system, means that whoever succeeds Saleh "is going to need Saudi 110 percent," said Fernando Carvajal, an expert on Saudi-Yemeni relations at Britain's University of Exeter. Yemen will need Saudi Arabia's money "for restructuring and to pay a new patronage network."

As a result, rival candidates for power seem to be pitching a line that they think will hook the conservative Saudis -- with members of the official coalition of opposition parties telling reporters that democracy is an adventure that Yemen's not quite ready for, Carvajal noted.

Saudi Arabia, other Gulf countries, and countries around the world that have pledged aid to Yemen say they will open the taps for development and aid in Yemen after the GCC deal clears.

For now, though, all wait for Saleh to quit, if he ever does. From his hospital bed, Saleh promised King Abdullah in a phone call last month that he would sign the GCC deal, according to Prince Turki. (Saleh has reneged on the same promise to others at least three times. The Yemen leader will try to go back to Yemen, one official predicted, if he has to roll himself there "in a wheelchair.")

If Saleh signs, Saleh's son and nephews, who have refused to yield up the presidential palace or their loyalist forces in Saleh's absence, will be no problem, Prince Turki predicted. He made a shooing gesture: "Boys, go on."

Beyond that, the al-Saud family has no desire to immerse itself in Yemen, the prince maintained. He cited the second cautionary tale on Yemen from the late King Abdul Aziz: In the 1930s, the king's sons Saud and Faisal entered Yemen in a dispute with the then-ruling Yemeni imams. Faisal, in his youthful enthusiasm, raced with his troops far down the Yemeni coast and urged his father to take advantage of his military advance.

No, pull back to the border, King Abdul Aziz is supposed to have directed his headstrong son. "That is Yemen. You don't stay in Yemen."

GAMAL NOMAN/AFP/Getty Images

 

Ellen Knickmeyer is a former Washington Post Middle East bureau chief and Associated Press Africa bureau chief. The Pulitzer Center on Crisis Reporting contributed to the costs of reporting this article.

DANIELSERWER

12:39 PM ET

July 5, 2011

All the King's horses

men, money and medical help can't keep Saleh out of Yemen or get him to resign in favor of his VP? As Barbara Bodine suggests, the Saudis don't seem to get much for what they give. Or is there something else going on here?

Daniel Serwer
www.peacefare.net

 

MARKVERMOUH

7:05 PM ET

July 11, 2011

Saudi Arabia & Kuwait Would Raise Moral Issues For West

It will get difficult for West if it is our closest allies in Middle East putting down democratic revolutions violently. So far that has not really happened in the Libyan sense (although SA involvement in Yemen getting a bit too close for comfort I think) . Really not sure what West would do if that event did happen though. Could we turn our back on Kuwait & SA and risk our oil supplies. What would West have done if it was Libya sending in support to Yemen - although to be fair SA seem to be brokering a peaceful resolution too. Hmmmmm.

 

TAVARES

9:12 AM ET

July 14, 2011

The "coalition of the

The "coalition of the interested" rally behind the Saudis to stamp out all opposition on the entire peninsula - Emirates, Oman, Jordan, Yemen. The U.S., Britain, France Tavares all have multiple military bases on the peninsula, and together with Germany "train" the repressive forces and equip the military with many billions of the best armaments.

 

DANNY41

2:07 PM ET

August 1, 2011

Trouble Down South

I don't think the Muslim Brotherhood can be trusted to limit themselves as they keep saying (and forgetting). The secular revolutionaries and those muslims who do not want an actual islamic state need to combine against this. Unfortunately the Brotherhood has always been allowed to wait in the wings by the regime just for this purpose, so the speed of the elections plus the military rule favours their pre-existent organisation.

If they win elections, in this way some in the west and the rightists can have their predictions proved - that the consequences of the Egyptian revolution, and by default any revolution, is bad, worse, evil, despotic, not worth to have psychic jobs for it, etc., but they would also get what they want politically, a return to a 'stable' authoritarian rule, another easily manipulable capitalist despotism.