This Week at War: Petraeus's Next Campaign

The new CIA chief will take on the covert war in Pakistan.

BY ROBERT HADDICK | JULY 15, 2011

As a civilian, Petraeus will soldier on, in Pakistan

U.S.-Pakistani relations, under redoubled strain after the May raid on Osama bin Laden's Abbottabad compound, are only getting worse. This week, the Obama administration announced it would withhold $800 million in military aid to Pakistan, more than a third of Washington's annual allotment. The proximate cause of this reprimand was the apparent betrayal by Pakistani officials of plans to attack Afghan Taliban bomb-making sites inside Pakistan -- the bomb-makers, who undoubtedly have the blood of many U.S. soldiers on their hands, escaped.

Meanwhile, the security outlook in Pakistan's tribal areas bordering Afghanistan has darkened. In retaliation for the blocked U.S. aid, Pakistan's defense minister threatened to withdraw some of his soldiers from the badlands, including over 1,100 border checkpoints. This would come on top of a previous decision to throw out over 100 U.S. Special Forces soldiers who had been training the Frontier Corps. As it attempts to scare U.S. officials by threatening to cede territory to the Afghan Taliban, the Pakistani government didn't hesitate to take action against its own insurgents -- over the past six weeks, the Pakistan army has fired over 760 rockets and artillery shells into three Afghan provinces, killing at least 60 people.

The decision to finally impose a penalty on Islamabad for the duplicity of some of its officials will no doubt further worsen the relationship in the short-run. Policymakers in Washington will have to assess whether the relationship is a viable candidate for a "reset."

If not, the United States will have to tally up its options for expanded unilateral action against militants in the region. If it comes to that, President Barack Obama will undoubtedly turn to his incoming CIA director Gen. David Petraeus to implement more quasi-military operations. The CIA has had a covert presence in Pakistan for decades, a presence that has taken on a wide variety of forms as circumstances have changed. A continued downward spiral in the U.S-Pakistani relationship will cause the covert CIA presence to evolve again, or at least intensify in its present form. As a marker of what may be to come, the night of May 11 witnessed one of the heaviest drone bombardments of Pakistan, with four separate strikes killing over 50 people.

Petraeus will shed his Army uniform before he reports for work in Langley. But he will still be a battlefield commander, in charge of a robotic air force and a small army of U.S. and Afghan paramilitaries, many of whom are former special operations soldiers. Under U.S. law, Petraeus's campaign in Pakistan will be a civilian-led covert action, authorized under Title 50 of the United State Code. To Pakistan, it will look a lot like war.

PAUL J. RICHARDS/AFP/Getty Images

 

Robert Haddick is managing editor of Small Wars Journal.

MARTY MARTEL

6:26 PM ET

July 15, 2011

Hope Petraeus fights covert war better

Let us see if Petraeus fights covert war in Pakistan better than he has fought overt war in Afghanistan until now because Petraeus together with Defense Secretary Gates and Adm Mullen have offered nothing but alibis for Pakistani Army/government/ISI’s support and sheltering of Haqqani’s HQN and Mullah Omar’s QST.

At recent US Senate hearings, Secretary of Defense had offered alibis for Pakistani government’s arrest of five Pakistanis who assisted CIA in tracking Osama bin Laden’s compound in Abottabad.

Gates’ alibis like ‘reality on the ground’ and ‘all countries lie to each other’ are mind boggling coming from a Secretary of Defense who was overseeing US war in Afghanistan that has been fueled by Pakistani government who has been playing a duplicitous game of ‘running with the hares while hunting with the hounds’ with US since 2001 as he has to know. Even prior to these lame alibis, Gates had varnished Pakistani duplicity as ‘deficit of trust’. Gen David Patraeus had rushed in with an apologia for his Pakistani friends, by claiming that while Faisal was inspired by militants in Pakistan, he did not necessarily have contacts with the militants which turned out to be wrong. Both Adm Mike Mullen and Gen Patraeus fancy themselves to be “soldier statesmen” a la Gen Dwight Eisenhower. Adm Mullen has visited Pakistan 15 times and Gen Patraeus no less frequently. Both evidently have high opinions of their abilities to persuade Gen Ashfaq Parvez Kayani to crack down on the Haqqani network in North Waziristan and the Taliban’s Mullah Omar-led Quetta Shura.

Clearly Gates had NO problem or NO qualms about the death of US/NATO troops at the hands of Afghan Taliban insurgents sheltered and supported by Pakistani government all these years.

It is NO wonder that with Secretary Gates, Petraeus and Mullen at the helm of US Afghan war efforts, Afghan Taliban has been able to mount so successful an insurgency against US/NATO troops.

 

JACKTOM

2:09 AM ET

July 16, 2011

It's become increasingly

It's become increasingly apparent that Pakistan has been duplicitous in it's dealings with the western world, but I wonder if this wasn't always apparent to the US and Britain. Maybe hiding Osama Bin Laden has just been the first of many issues plauging the government in Pakistan. Cut off all foreign military aid immediately!
blog

 

BEINGTHERE

12:00 PM ET

July 16, 2011

Agree! Petraeus is deceitful ...

Watch him run for president and juggle his CIA duties. It would be fascinating if it weren't so repugnant. There is so much stuff media never reveal about this man and his mission. Consider the NATO deaths, untold civilians deaths, rapes, billions spent in a pointless endeavor with P-4 doing some fine politicking for his brilliant career. Maybe Petraeus will slink on off after his CIA stint. Some rich contractors he's babysat in Iraq or Afghanistan will surely have a fat consulting job for him one day. This man is nefarious. Media write about Murdoch and assorted scandals, but they've missed a big one by ignoring the antics and moves of David Petraeus.

 

JACKTOM

9:14 AM ET

July 18, 2011

It's become increasingly

It's become increasingly apparent that Pakistan has been duplicitous in it's dealings with the western world, but I wonder if this wasn't always apparent to the US and Britain. Maybe hiding Osama Bin Laden has just been the first of many issues plauging the government in Pakistan. Cut off all foreign military aid immediately!
speech therapy lisp

 

ADRIAN ALDOUS

6:39 PM ET

July 15, 2011

Pakistan Friend Or Enemy

It's become increasingly apparent that Pakistan has been duplicitous in it's dealings with the western world, but I wonder if this wasn't always apparent to the US and Britain. Maybe hiding Osama Bin Laden has just been the first of many issues plauging the government in Pakistan. Cut off all foreign military aid immediately!

Adrian - http://www.vancouverrealestatelink.ca

 

BEINGTHERE

11:52 AM ET

July 16, 2011

Media, D.C. insiders still drool when P-4 speaks. But why?

Jane Harman, former Congresswoman and now think tank head, recently stated on NPR that David Petraeus is America's "favorite soldier." and she even compared him to George Washington. George Washington? Really? The average American seldom thinks of P-4 and when they do, it's not as a soldier but as a celebrity hog who is, indeed, smart enough to keep the cameras on him. Media have believed every word he has told them about himself and dutifully repeat these words - scholar-warrior, etc.. They and D.C.insiders never ask Petreaus hard questions. Never challenge him.

As new head of Central Command, Petraeus visited the inexperienced Obama the day after his taking the oath of office. The self-serving general, his head filled with a vision of his own future presidency, had to carve out his place in the spotlight. Stoking the war - taking advantage of a president with no foreign policy background but who wanted to appear macho - was a tactic that has worked since 2009. Petraeus has repeatedly "managed" information (according to recent IPS reports of the National Intelligence Estimate) about numbers of Taliban defeated. War is ugly, but he apparently lied to make himself look like ... well, General David Petraeus, Media Star.

Petraeus and his aging, white men's conservative support group - McCain, Chambliss, Graham, Dole - thought he had earned the Joint Chiefs head job or Sec. of Defense. Obama had to throw P-4 a bone after he took a demotion to command in Afghanistan last July. Score one for Obama - at last.

Please, media, let's help Petraeus ease into his new CIA job. His activities should be covert, and he should not be yapping publicly, making comments and issuing press releases every 15 minutes.Except in rare circumstances, he should be out of the public eye, Oh, you could ask him about how the CIA took an immoral turn to fake administering vaccinations to poverty-stricken people in Pakistan. Then let's let him be quiet and not in view.

 

SIDROCK23

6:44 PM ET

July 16, 2011

U.S bark bigger than its bite

funny to see how americans are still foolish enough to think everyone should bow down to them. News flash morons!! we are broke, we've been sleeping with the enemies for decades, and our military really isn't all that great.
1.) we are currently having intense budget talks in d.c. it is well known that everyone will be affected. schools, social security, medicare, are all breaking down in front of us, but we still approved $600 billion dollars to the military. keep it up, let's see how long people will put up with that.
2.) we not only slept with the enemey, but got it pregnant, and raised its kids to be our enemies. we support the saudis, israelis, pakistanis. we supported the likes of sadaam, shah or iran, zia ul haq, zionists, wahabi islam. what exactly do you think is the outcome when we fund,. train, and protect our enemies. ? taliban is a U.S creation. just like sadam was, and more in the future. U.S made its bed, now sleep in it.
3.) U.S military is chicken shit. a couple of soldiers die in an IED blast and its "wann wann waaan, mommy i got a boo bood", yet we go and kill a few women and kids and we pound our chest and tell everyone how bad we are.

 

BEN-PK

2:23 AM ET

July 18, 2011

Give Pakistan a break...

Please give Pakistan a break and concentrate on catastrophic fallout of Afghanistan endgame. The journey from the Great Game to end-game is not very long and the endgame has already started looking like a game-changer. If this continues, militants may end up owning half the world after the draw-down comes to an end. Emboldened by the end-game (read: US defeat), they will have South and Central Asia to themselves and will have the lever too. And they have proved that they can fix the lever wherever they want. They will move and shake the whole world at will and with incredible ease. South and Central Asian region will not be the only candidate for destabilization. The instability has the inherent tendency of traveling faster than the bush fire. Read more at: http://pksecurity.blogspot.com/2011/07/from-great-game-to-endgame-militants.html

 

POLITICALAGENDA

11:11 AM ET

August 9, 2011

Pakistan needs to face the music for housing Bin Laden

I think we need to remember that there is clear evidence that Pakistan supported and housed America's Number One enemy for a considerable period of time. They need to be made to face the music over this. They are making a huge song and dance about how they did not know but it is unconvincing.

The good news is that Petraeus as well as being highly competent has huge clout policy wise and is very shrewd. Do not underestimate him. You can expect some nasty leaks from the CIA's files if the tit for tat actions do not work plus......... The party is over for those elements of the ISI who support the Taliban. Good thing too.

 

ANTON MALTBY

5:11 AM ET

August 13, 2011

This Week at War: Petraeus's Next Campaign

In Kabul, the hard-as-a-rock, 5-foot-9, 150-pound, -distance- running, push-up-pumping Petraeus has conducted the war from a rundown Edwardian villa, surrounded by a labyrinth of shipping containers piled into two-story blocks of offices and sleeping quarters, and all of it behind high walls. concertina wire. and a lot of firepower. An aide loaded down with three laptops follows him everywhere he goes: one laptop for unclassified emails, one for U.S. secret traffic, one for classified NATO/International Security Assistance Force material. In the colorless corridors of Langley, Va., he’ll be largely on his own. But rachel starr has been preparing a long time for this post. “History will regard him as one of the nation’s great battle captains. ” then–defense secretary Robert Gates said in 2008. “He is the preeminent soldier-scholar-statesman of his generation.” Even then, Gates might well have added “intelligence director.

 

RICKIE124

6:08 AM ET

August 13, 2011

This Week at War: Petraeus's Next Campaign

The new CIA chief will take on the covert war in Pakistan. It's become increasingly apparent that Pakistan has been duplicitous in it's dealings with the western world, but I wonder if this wasn't always apparent to the US and Britain. Maybe hiding Osama Bin Laden has just been the first of many issues plauging the government in Pakistan. Cut off all foreign military aid immediately! blog internet fax Jane Harman, former Congresswoman and now think tank head, recently stated on NPR that David Petraeus is America's "favorite soldier." and she even compared him to George Washington. George Washington? Really? The average American seldom thinks of P-4 and when they do, it's not as a soldier but as a celebrity hog who is, indeed, smart enough to keep the cameras on him. Media have believed every wo.

 

MICHEALHOLDING

8:39 AM ET

August 13, 2011

Petraeus and his aging, white

Petraeus and his aging, white men's conservative support group - McCain, Chambliss, Graham, Dole - thought he had earned the Joint Chiefs head job or Sec. of Defense EurekaEnviroSteamer. Obama had to throw P-4 a bone after he took a demotion to command in Afghanistan last July. Score one for Obama - at last.