Waltzing Past the Graveyard

Austria may have buried the final heir to the Habsburg crown on Saturday, but the empire's political culture is far from dead.

BY ARMIN THURNHER | JULY 18, 2011

VIENNA — On Saturday, July 16, central Vienna assumed the bearing of a costume drama, as Austria's democratically elected leaders, members of the European aristocracy, church representatives and military regiments in historic dress assembled in St. Stephen's Cathedral to pay their respects to the House of Habsburg -- or, more specifically, to Otto Habsburg -- Lothringen, son of Austria's last emperor, who died two weeks ago at 98. He was born in Vienna on the cusp of World War I -- the conflict which put an end to his family's long-lived empire.


Goodbye To All That
Pictures from the funeral of the last heir to the Habsburg throne.

But the nation still focused its undivided attention on his funeral: indeed, the public broadcaster ORF covered the funeral for nine straight hours. The viewers at home, and the 1,000 guests invited to St. Stephens -- including the Austrian President Heinz Fischer, Chancellor Werner Faymann -- bore witness to formal funeral rites that may never be practiced again. They listened intently as representatives from the Vatican offered their condolences on behalf of Pope Benedict, and Cardinal Christoph Schönborn pronounced a solemn homage to the Habsburg family. A part of the audience then marched through the city center, past a cordon of tourists -- some bewildered, others in awe - toward the Imperial Crypt. There, the Master of Ceremonies knocked three times on the door before the monks inside opened it to make way for the coffin.

All this ceremonial pomp, however, was not a mere exercise in nostalgia; it was a tribute to a past that never really died. Yes, Vienna is no longer a world capital -- the ubiquitous portraits of the emperors have all been packed away, but Habsburg political culture (including some of its pernicious aspects) is still very much alive.

From the moment of its establishment in 1438, the House of Habsburg was never a modern centralized nation-state, but rather a multi-national empire that left its mark not only on Austria, but across the continent. The most concrete reminders of its rule -- in cities from Lviv to Warsaw, Prague to Sarajevo -- are the many remnants of Habsburg architecture in the form of train stations, schools, and government buildings.

But it is the Habsburg's animating political philosophy -- informed as it was both by hierarchy, and tolerance; authority, and plurality -- that is its most significant legacy. The nations subject to Habsburg rule earned the privileges of law, but were also forced to learn the caprice of imperialism, most prominently in the form of special privileges for a German-speaking minority, and the strict, unquestioned, power of the Roman Catholic Church.

The Habsburg indulgence of the Catholic Church, and its anti-Enlightenment and anti-Protestant fervor, led to cruelty across the continent. Protestant aristocrats were routinely beheaded, their heads and hands displayed in public as warnings to others. (In Prague in 1621, for instance, after the Habsburg regime quelled an incipient reformation, the Catholic rulers ordered that a Protestant city official be nailed to the gallows by his tongue and left to hang there for twelve hours.) Subjects of the Habsburg crown who practiced the wrong denomination of Christianity were often summarily disowned of their property. (Indeed, most of the opulent baroque palaces in Vienna that today attract tourists were built with the fortunes the Catholic aristocracy stole from Protestants.)

 SUBJECTS: EUROPE
 

Armin Thurnher is editor-in-chief of the Falter magazine in Vienna and the author of several books on modern Austria.

CITIZENWHY

2:05 PM ET

July 18, 2011

important positives omitted

It would have helped to detail some of the positive aspects of Austro-Hungarian rule. The Hapsburgs after the 1600s seemed to have learned from the Turkish sultans the art of keeping "the faithful" on top without persecuting other religions.

The Austrian creation of 27 state parliaments spread the rule of law and prepared the way for some sort of democratic behavior throughout eastern Europe, in great contrast to the backward Russian Empire.

Austrian reform of education was exemplary.

Austria showed genius in using the religious sects for orderly rule. For instance, to go to university you had to have a record of exemplary attendance at your Catholic or Protestant church, or your synagogue, or your mosque. This tamed fanaticism and tied religions to the success of the state.

There was a good reason that their was a thriving Jewish intellectual and business community in Vienna but not in Moscow.

 

DENNISHOBSON

3:15 PM ET

August 12, 2011

positives

Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read anything like this before. So nice to find somebody with some original thoughts on this subject. realy thank you for starting this up. this website is something that is needed on the deck de madeira web, someone with a little originality. useful job for bringing something new to the internet!

 

AUSTRIA

2:55 AM ET

July 19, 2011

HABSBURG IST ABGESETZT

Habsburg hat 1914 das Ultimatum/Kriegserklaerung an
Serbien unterschrieben und wurde nach dem verlorenen
Weltkrieg 1918 abgesetzt.

ÖSTERREICH IST FREI !

 

ANONMOOS

12:30 PM ET

July 19, 2011

Kurt Waldheim

Don't know much about Austrian internal politics, but the collective Austrian superficial and shallow feebly-dismissive reaction to the whole Kurt Waldheim matter was not very impressive. In the summer of 1986, I overheard some Austrian students explaining to U.S. students at an elite U.S. university how the Waldheim affair was merely a joke beneath contempt, in the most sneering and jeering manner. Those students were not good ambassadors for Austria's international reputation. On the other hand, people were still dancing to "Rock Me Amadeus" during that same summer ;-)

 

AIMIER

2:46 AM ET

July 20, 2011

erratum :)

Mistah Habsburg – he dead. A penny for the Old Guy. Anyway that’s Cracow not Warsaw what you meant. Warsaw unfortunately were never under Habsburg rule (vide: “The most concrete reminders of its rule -- in cities from Lviv to Warsaw...”).

 

AR

2:26 PM ET

July 28, 2011

Typical leftist and

Typical leftist and multi-culturalist agitprop. Austria is quite tolerant of foreigners and immigrants, but it has also realized that its culture will only be preserved by Austrians and those immigrants who integrate, not stick to little turkey's or little bosnia's.

 

DORTHA KEASLER

12:04 AM ET

August 16, 2011

Otto von Habsburg to be buried in Vienna

Otto von Habsburg, the last heir to the Austro-Hungarian Empire, will be buried in Vienna, Austria, along with his wife, officials said. Habsburg died July 4 at his home in Pocking. Germany, at age 98. His wife, Regina, who died last year, will also be buried in the imperial crypt, amid the pomp and ceremony associated with the former empire, the BBC reported. No date for the funeral was given. While Habsburg's body will be buried in the official crypt where his ancestors lay, his heart will be buried at an abbey west of Budapest Sunday, in accordance with a Habsburg tradition. Habsburg served as a member of the European Parliament for two decades. "It would always be wrong to only remember him in the context of the old monarchy or only remember him in the context of the European Union," said his son. Karl Habsburg. "I think he should be remembered in the whole arch that his life has been creating ... over the whole changes that happened to Europe in his lifetime." Jose jenny mccarthy Barroso, president of the European Commission, called him "a great European … who gave an important impetus to the European project throughout his rich life."

 

MARRIOND

10:06 AM ET

August 16, 2011

Habsburgs were indeed a very

Habsburgs were indeed a very influential in the past and as somebody mentioned, they ruled a lot more of the world, not just Europe. The tradition ran positive in Otto von Habsburg as he was a very respected member of the European Parliament and a diplomat well know all over the world. He was using his royal and diplomatic connection and tomtom android to get to presidents, kings and other influential people where others found only shut doors.