Parliamentary Funk

The United States isn't the only country whose legislature just doesn't work.

BY CAMERON ABADI | JULY 20, 2011

The debt-ceiling negotiations going on in Washington right now have not, to put it mildly, cast the collected membership of the U.S. Congress in the most flattering possible light. In theory, members of Congress are meant to serve as enlightened representatives of their local districts, virtuous stewards of the common good. But the last several weeks have offered instead a portrait of shallow partisans willing to risk global economic catastrophe for the sake of indulging their personal vanity and furthering their own agendas, and a legislature unable to accomplish even the most basic of tasks.

Sadly, the United States is not the only country suffering from its lawmakers in this fashion. Legislative gridlock is commonplace -- as are the partisanship and vanity at its root -- in governments around the world. At least the United States can blame the creakiness of its institutions on the fact that they were designed some 200 years ago: Most other countries don't have nearly such a convenient excuse -- and, yet, they act just as shamelessly.

BELGIUM

Think America's divided government is a hassle? Try not having a government at all. Belgium has lacked a functioning parliamentary majority for more than a year, ever since its last national election on June 13, 2010. Negotiations to form a new majority have broken down eight times over the past 400 days, as the country earned the dubious distinction of entering the Guinness World Records for the longest period of time without a government. The major Belgian parties aren't just talking past one another; they don't even share the same native language -- and that's a big part of the problem. Belgium's Flemish-speaking region wants to secure more financial autonomy, the better to enjoy the rewards of its economic success, but the country's French-speaking territories, dependent as they are on Flemish tax receipts to maintain their welfare provisions, have refused.

In the absence of any majority in Parliament, previous Prime Minister Yves Leterme has continued to preside over cabinet meetings, though proposals for ambitious legislation have been put on hold indefinitely. That's not to say, however, that Belgians necessarily notice any disruption in their daily lives. Many state functions, from education to welfare, are already administered at the regional, rather than the federal, level. Leterme's caretaker government, meanwhile, did succeed in serving its pre-scheduled six-month stint as president of the European Council in 2010. And in 2011, Belgium managed to send four fighter jets and 150 military personnel to enforce the no-fly zone over Libya.

Apparently, the reason that Parliament has yet to call for a new election is for fear that the international community (and bond markets) will judge the country incapable of solving its problems (though one would have thought that train had long ago left the station). Presiding over the stalemate, and tirelessly goading all parties to reach a final resolution, is the lonely King Albert II -- among the few symbols of national identity, apart from frites, that enjoys broad recognition throughout the country.

GEORGES GOBET/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS:
 

Cameron Abadi is an associate editor at Foreign Policy.

MIKEM

1:55 PM ET

July 20, 2011

Look on the bright side!

We Americans might be governed by selfish, incompetent morons who can't tell their ass from a hole in the ground, but it's better here than in Iraq!

Well, that really puts things in perspective.

 

NICOLAS19

4:40 AM ET

July 21, 2011

so much for a "leading great power"

Incredible how the author hopes to cover the US system's shortcomings by repeating the "there are a few countries worse than us, so we're good" approach. He easily foregos the fact that two out of five government on the list are under direct US control. "Hey, my dog is dirtier than me, so I'm not dirty at all!" Everybody knows about Belgium, they can live without a government just fine. And Japan... that's the best. When he runs out of ammo, he frames the government for failing to squeeze "truthful" testimonies. Judicial, not governmental matter! Plus, Watergate, anyone?

Shockingly amateurish journalism.

 

AMJDMG

10:35 AM ET

July 21, 2011

Lack of executive does not mean failing legislature

Concerning Belgium: the article confuses the legislature and the executive. It is true that there has not been a fully competent executive in over a year, but the legislature works just fine and has reached a.o. a deal on immigration reform. But what is even more important: with the executive out of the way, the parliament is finally growing balls, getting important things done and reaching deals with changing majorities (e.g. immigration reform had a centre-right majority, whilst some gender equality issues got a centre-left majority).

 

LILMADGUY

2:08 PM ET

July 22, 2011

Did anyone notice?

Of the five countries profiled here, the United States had a direct hand into the creation of their constitutions and government as a whole.

Maybe this legislative disfunction is purposeful.

 

LILMADGUY

2:09 PM ET

July 22, 2011

oops

forgot to say three of the five countries profiled here.

 

PCOLMAN

11:58 PM ET

July 25, 2011

parliamentary brawls

I was surprised that Sri Lanka did not get a special mention here. President Rajapaksa has managed to woo enough members of the “opposition” UNP (United National Party – sometimes known as the Uncle Nephew Party) over to his ruling coalition to get the two thirds majority necessary to amend the constitution so that he can run for office again and again. The speaker is his brother. His son is an MP and is being groomed for the succession.

A few years back there was a brawl in parliament about swearing in a previous speaker. An MP who was a Buddhist monk had his balls squeezed so hard by government minister Mervyn Silva that he was hospitalized. This was captured on video and can be seen on You Tube.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R9l-ammORKQ

 

SOCIALENGINEERING

8:21 PM ET

August 9, 2011

US brinkmanship rivals Greece for lunacy

It is a toss up between Greece and US for the rotten government moment of the year award although both score 10/10 for entertainment value. A pity they both had to pick such important events to suddenly go doolally.

However both events have their silver linings. America got to know just how crazy the Tea Party. Greece got a nice chunk of money as a charity case which should last them at least till Christmas when it becomes apparent they have done precisely nothing to reduce their deficit.

 

POLAR CITY

2:25 AM ET

August 12, 2011

Legislature Brawls are ''Staged'' In Taiwan - Reuters 2007 files

Legislature Brawls are Staged

Reuters
May 18, 2007

by Ralph Jennings

[Jennings reported in 2007 piece what many in Taiwan have long
suspected: that the brawls in the legislature are staged so that
politicians ] ]Abadi in 2011 should have done his research first.]

Lawmakers put on wrestling shows as publicity stunts

Politicians know how to put on a good show.

But the brawling and histrionics in parliament that have put Taiwan
politics on the world map for the past 20 years are staged acts,
legislators and political observers say.

They are planned in advance to generate media attention and garner
favor with voters who like to see their representatives fight as hard
as they can on tough issues.

Lawmakers even call up allies to ask that they wear sports shoes ahead
of the choreographed clashes. They have been known to meet up
afterwards for drinks.

“It’s really a media event, staged for media coverage,” said
Nationalist Party (KMT) legislator Joanna Lei. “They have a strategy
session, like a war plan.”

The latest brawl erupted on May 8 when at least 40 lawmakers blocked
the speaker from his podium to head off a vote on reconfiguring the
Central Election Commission.

In the 1980s and 1990s, when minority parties had no procedural way to
change governing bodies controlled then by the KMT, regular fights
exposed inefficiency, crookedness and authoritarianism, said Shelley
Rigger, an East Asian politics expert at Davidson College in the
United States.

Today, despite full democracy, the fight strategy remains.

“It’s true that politicians use (brawls) to excite their core
supporters at home, but it’s unclear how effective that is,” Rigger
said. “We do know, though, that it hurts the legitimacy of the
democratic system as a whole. Mostly it’s a delaying tactic.”

In January, a brawl involving about 50 legislators who wanted to stop
Legislative Yuan Speaker Wang Jin-pyng from accessing his podium
lasted for four hours.

Shoes were thrown at the speaker, a microphone was ripped out and
thrown across the chambers. lawmakers shoved and pulled one another’s
ties. Wang never made it to the podium.

Some of the brawling legislators turned to reporters and cameramen,
yelling slogans to them and brandishing signs.

In 2005 one legislator needed stitches after he was struck by a mobile
phone. Last year an lawmaker used tear gas. Shouting exchanges occur
almost every week on the parliament floor.

Some legislators says it is just a ploy to win votes.

“They just want to steal the spotlight going into the primaries,” said
People First Party lawmaker Lee Hung-chun. “Parliament should be a
sacred and noble place.”

 

POLAR CITY

2:29 AM ET

August 12, 2011

Abadi was way off the mark. Silly Yalie visit Taiwan first

Dear Editor,

Cameron Abadi is the writer at Foreign Policy magazine in Washington
who recently write an article
that made a lot of politicians in both the DPP and KMT hopping mad.
How dare Abadi write such insulting
things about Taiwan, and its colorful Legislative Yuan, without even
living here or knowing much about the country!

I wonder when he will visit Taiwan for real, so he can
see her up close and personal, instead of relying on Google for his silly and incorrect "research."

Sincerely,
Lafcadio Ahearne
Taipei City

 

POLAR CITY

2:33 AM ET

August 12, 2011

Lawmakers refute article’s claim they are failing Taiwan

Even the Central News Agency in Taiwan took issue with Abadi's slamming of the Taiwan Diet without his ever having set foot in Taiwan proper. Is that the way FP does "research"? By remote control. Read below news:

[CNA] -- TAIPEI -- Taiwanese Legislators from across the political spectrum yesterday rebutted a US magazine’s criticism of the legislature’s performance, claiming that conflicts are just part of the democratic progress.

The retort came after an article in a recent edition of Foreign Policy named Taiwan, along with the US and various other countries, as nations whose legislatures do not work for the people.

The article — “Parliamentary Funk,” published on July 20 — also named Belgium, Iraq, Japan and Afghanistan as having sub-par legislatures.

The stalemate between the nation’s two primary political parties could be compared with the situation in the US Congress, which has recently put the global economy at risk because of its refusal to compromise over its debt crisis, Cameron Abadi wrote in the piece.

Abadi said the pan-blue and pan-green camps “have a greater tradition of engaging in fistfights in the halls of government than cooperating on policy.”

Legislative Speaker Wang Jin-pyng (???) dismissed the article, saying that it had been more than three years since the last physical brawl in the legislature and that Abadi’s views were out of date.

The physical conflicts took place during the reviews of some highly controversial political issues, Wang said, adding that the reconciliation of differences is part of the democratic process.

Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) Legislator Tsai Huang-liang (???) said the article was hurtful and humiliating for the legislature, dragging up information that belongs in the past.

Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT) caucus whip Chao Li-yun (???) and DPP Legislator Wong Chin-chu (???) also dismissed the criticism.

The past legislative session passed more than 100 bills and if that makes the legislature incapable, then the US Congress is even worse, Chao said

 

DOUGLAS MCCLAMMY

3:16 AM ET

August 15, 2011

Parliamentary Funk

The collective's origins date back to the doo-wop group The Parliaments,formed in the late 1950s in Plainfield, New Jersey. Under Clinton's direction,by the early 1970s the groups Parliament and Funkadelic were operating concurrently and consisted of the same stable of musicians playing different types of funk music for two different labels. The name "Parliament-Funkadelic" became the catch-all term for the multiple bands in Clinton's stable. By the late 1970s the collective had grown to include dozens of musicians recording and touring under many different group names and solo projects. (See P-Funk offshoot groups and solo ventures.) Overall, the collective achieved thirteen top ten hits in the American R&B music charts between 1967 and 1983, including six number one hits. Funkadelic is a funk band with a psychedelic rock touch whose influences include the amplifier sounds of Jimi Hendrix and Led Zeppelin, James Brown's funk, blues, Sun Ra's experimentation, Frank Zappa's and the Coasters' humour,the concept albums of the Beatles and the Who and southern soul artists like Otis Redding and lisa annParliament is a funk/R&B band whose influences are the funky side of Hendrix and Sly Stone, Motown soul groups turned funk groups like the Temptations, the political songs of the Impressions, Rufus Thomas' southern funk, doo-wop groups like the Coasters for the humour and Frankie Lymon & the Teenagers.By the early 1980s, Clinton consolidated the collective's multiple projects and continued touring under the names "George Clinton and the P-Funk All-Stars" or "George Clinton and Parliament-Funkadelic." Some former members of Parliament perform under the name "Original P". Sixteen members of Parliament-Funkadelic were inducted to the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1997.

 

AXELBROOK

1:25 PM ET

August 18, 2011

He was educated for a short

He was educated for a short time in Indonesia as a child. relevé d identité opérateur This is drawing claims from some people that he has terrorist connections, as Indonesia is a mostly Muslim country..

 

AXELBROOK

1:25 PM ET

August 18, 2011

Good question if it is

Good question if it is absolutely true what you're saying. But I think they are all freaking because as the DOW sinks, so do the tax dollars. rio virgin No tax dollars no government..

 

GINCHINCHILI

2:48 PM ET

August 19, 2011

Afghan parliament

The Afghan parliament is among the couple of structural checks about the power of Leader Hamid Karzai, but that's not saying it's a particularly efficient one: Its self-reliance has repeatedly belong to attack by Karzai and the allies.

Karzai's own perception that he needn't protect the legality from the tribunal process signals the waning national self-confidence in the parliament. That may allow it to be harder for Kabul and Wa to eventually achieve a political negotiation to end the ongoing battle, as it might confirm the Taliban's hojo motor that the only way in order to effectively oppose Karzai is thru military, rather than tranquil, means.

 

PETER MURRAY

4:58 PM ET

August 19, 2011

Funk

Yes I also read that somewhere that he was educated for a short time in Indonesia as a child. It is certainly true that Indonesia is a mostly Muslim country..

Simply Ibiza
Cosmetic Surgery
Jewellery Shop Reviews

 

FREESPIRIT

5:25 PM ET

August 19, 2011

Re : Goverments

SocialEngineering wrote: "It is a toss up between Greece and US for the rotten government moment of the year award although both score 10/10 for entertainment value. A pity they both had to pick such important events to suddenly go doolally. "

Is there ever a Government that is not rotten?

Jewellery Quarter Birmingham
Tattoo Removal Federation
No Win No Fee Solicitors

 

DAVID BYRNE

6:42 PM ET

August 19, 2011

Funk

MikeM very true, as the saying goes there is always somebody whose off than you.

Irelands World Simply Magaluf Billy Garraty