Famine Is a Crime

Civilization has defeated mass starvation. So why are so many Somalis dying of hunger?

BY CHARLES KENNY | JULY 25, 2011

Deprived of food long enough, the bodies of starving people break down muscle tissue to keep vital organs functioning. Diarrhea and skin rashes are common, as are fungal and other infections. As the stomach wastes away, the perception of hunger is reduced and lethargy sets in. Movement becomes immensely painful. Often it is dehydration that finally causes death, because the perception of thirst and a starving person's ability to get water are both radically diminished.

Thousands of Somalis have already suffered this tragic end, and it is likely to kill tens of thousands more in the coming months. The famine now starving Somalia affects 3.7 million people, according to the U.N. World Food Program. Writing on his personal blog, the U.S. Agency for International Development's Edward Carr, who works on famine response, estimates that on current trends Somalia's south could see 2,500 deaths a day by August.

For all its horror, starvation is also one of the simpler forms of mortality to prevent -- it just takes food.  Drought, poor roads, poverty -- all are contributing factors to the risk of famine, but sustenance in the hands of the hungry is a pretty foolproof solution. As a result, famine deaths in the modern world are almost always the result of deliberate acts on the part of governing authorities. That is why widespread starvation is a crime against humanity and the leaders who abet it should be tried at the International Criminal Court (ICC).

Historically, famines were sometimes the simple result of collapsed local food production, limited resources, and weak infrastructure to bring in food. But as infrastructure and markets have spread, the failure of local crops has become a contributing factor rather than a sufficient cause of widespread death by starvation. For example, economists Robin Burgess and Dave Donaldson have found that peacetime famine in India ended at the same time (1919) as railroad networks finally reached every corner of the subcontinent.

Infrastructure is still a barrier to famine response in many parts of the world -- studies of modern famine suggest being near a main road significantly increases the chance of survival. But roads and rail are far more widespread worldwide than they were 50 years ago, and a global famine relief industry now has significant capacity to provide food to those in need even in remote areas of the world. Humanitarian aid financed by the major donors climbed from a little over $1 billion in 1990 to $9 billion by 2008 -- a size and capacity which, even with the aid industry's well-documented faults, is enough to ensure the ability to stop mass death by starvation wherever it is allowed to operate.

Thanks to globalization, the spread of infrastructure, and the growing capacity of agencies like the World Food Program, famines have become very rare over the last 30 years. Somalia's is the first official famine declared by the U.N. worldwide since 1984. Because declaring a famine is usually the responsibility of the government (a requirement waived by the U.N. in the case of Somalia), the official count is far from exhaustive: North Korea saw somewhere between 600,000 and 1 million people die from famine in the second half of the 1990s, and Omar al-Bashir's Sudan and Robert Mugabe's Zimbabwe have seen outbreaks as well. But, in general, starvation is on the wane. According to Bill Easterly of New York University, less than three tenths of a percent of the population of Africa was affected by famine in the average year between 1990 and 2005.

So why do famines still happen at all?  As the economist Amartya Sen famously observed, famines rarely occur in democratic or even relatively free societies. In fact, they don't happen any more in any country where leaders show the slightest interest in the wellbeing of their citizenry. Thanks to spreading markets and improved international assistance, famine is no longer associated merely with passive or excessively weak governance. In order to ensure widespread death by starvation, a governing authority must make a conscious decision: it must actively exercise the power to take food from producers who need it or deny food assistance to victims.

TONY KARUMBA/AFP/Getty Images

 

Charles Kenny is a senior fellow at the Center for Global Development, a Schwartz fellow at the New America Foundation, and author, most recently, of Getting Better: Why Global Development Is Succeeding and How We Can Improve the World Even More. "The Optimist," his column for ForeignPolicy.com, runs weekly.

MICHAELGERALDPDEALINO

7:42 PM ET

July 25, 2011

The Tragedy that is Somalia

The tragedy in Somalia-the internal conflict, the islamic fascism, the drought, the famine, and the failed state-is the worst manifestation of a dysfunctional political culture.

 

PADURAR1978

10:22 AM ET

July 26, 2011

People in advanced countries

People in advanced countries throw millions of tons of waste in the trash, food for the people of Somalia and would give life. I do not know if it's something right in this life. Our neighbors are still. Are not we as guilty as the authorities there.

 

NATALIEME

5:38 PM ET

July 26, 2011

“…it hardly seems likely that

“…it hardly seems likely that the international community has much to lose…” How about what little wiggle room the international humanitarian community has at present to access people in al Shabaab controlled areas?!

 

RAJMEEJ23

11:37 PM ET

July 26, 2011

i knew many of advance

i knew many of advance country throw lots of waste in the trash. it better to provide some food from advance country to Somalis. to do some great works and help to kills starving crisis.

Best Regards
Online Computer Tips

 

VIVID_HAZE

10:29 AM ET

July 27, 2011

Can the moderators be a bit

Can the moderators be a bit quicker in banning and removing these idiots who post lame spam links please.

 

KAM KAMINSKE

8:28 AM ET

August 5, 2011

Camel's milk

Ease hunger with camel’s milk

Starvation in Africa is in the news every day, yet there is an obvious, neglected food resource walking around in front of everyone’s eyes. Camels – but more specifically, camel’s milk. How tough is it to see that we have the perfect match here?
Camel’s milk is an indigenous, renewable food resource in countries like Somalia, Kenya and Ethiopia. Nomadic peoples have been drinking this “superfood” for thousands of years – sometimes using it as their sole sustenance in times of drought. Not only does it nourish, but its anti-viral and anti-bacterial properties make it ideal in the treatment of diseases like TB and HIV/AIDS. Does anyone see Africa in this picture?
As the founder of Camel Power Now, an advocacy group promoting awareness of this renewable, underutilized food resource, I am calling on existing NGOs working in areas with camel populations to use this milk to feed the starving. Please see www.camelpowernow.com for more info.

 

THEODORE RONZONI

10:58 PM ET

August 11, 2011

Famine Is a Crime

Regarding as: jada fire
In November 2009 controversy erupted when Krekar in an interview with the Arab television channel al-Hiwar said he wanted to establish a new Islamic Caliphate,
claiming that for Jihadists there is no legitimate state, with the exception of the Taliban-led Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan. For the Islamic "super-state" he wanted Osama bin Laden,
Al-Qaida-top Ayman al-Zawahiri or Hizb-e Islami-founder Gulbuddin Hekmatyar as leader, and other radical Islamists as leader, citing for instance Gulbuddin Hekmatyar or Ayman Al-Zawahiri as the foreign minister.[4] As a result the Progress Party continued their call for the imprisonment of Krekar,[5] and the Labour Party stated for the first time they would form a new task force which would examine if people officially labeled as "danger to national security" (as Krekar is) could be imprisoned.[6] Azzam Tamimi, a supporter of Hamas,
who had done the interview with Krekar, also said that he felt Krekar had been treated badly in Norway.

 

CASANDRA PROHONIC

11:44 PM ET

August 11, 2011

famine is a crime

In my opinion, my Foreign Policy column this week suggests that in the Twenty-First Century.
famines can only occur with the active engagement of local leadership – taking away food from producers and/or denying access to agencies delivering emergency relief.
In Somalia, the leadership that is denying access is al-Shabab – the group in control of the areas of the country where famine has already begun.I don’t mean to let donors off the hook.
They should have responded earlier and with greater generosity to a situation that has developed over months, to ensure that the lack of outside assistance would never be the binding constraint to preventing death by starvation.
But at the moment that isn’t the biggest constraint. Al-Shabab is the biggest constraint. And its leaders should be held to account.
Regarding as:lexi belle

 

AXELBROOK

5:10 AM ET

August 19, 2011

What you do is take the

What you do is take the knowledge you have gained through study, get your thoughts together in coherant form, and put the words on paper, or on your computer. There are plenty of sources, you just have to do some research. You'll wind up a better student for doing so. Once you graduate, there won't be anyone to do your work for you. RIO You'll be expected to produce on your own..

 

MARKHORTON

5:59 AM ET

August 21, 2011

People in advanced

People in advanced countries throw millions of tons of waste in the trash, food for the people of Somalia p90x and would give life. I do not know if it's something right in this life. Our neighbors are still. Are not we as guilty as the authorities there.

 

CRUNCHBERRY21

10:27 PM ET

August 21, 2011

simple result of flattened local food manufacturing

In the past some famines were occasionally the simple result of flattened local food manufacturing, limited resources, as well as weak infrastructure to usher in food. But because infrastructure and marketplaces have spread, the actual failure of nearby crops has become a adding factor rather than a adequate cause of widespread dying by starvation. For instance, economists Robin Burgess as well as Kyle Leon have found which peacetime famine in Indian ended at the same time (1919) because railroad networks lastly reached every part of the subcontinent.

 

JAMESMICHEAL

4:09 PM ET

August 23, 2011

Camel’s milk is an

Camel’s milk is an indigenous, renewable food resource in countries like Somalia, Kenya and Ethiopia waystoearnmoneyonline. Nomadic peoples have been drinking this “superfood” for thousands of years – sometimes using it as their sole sustenance in times of drought. Not only does it nourish, but its anti-viral and anti-bacterial properties make it ideal in the treatment of diseases like TB and HIV/AIDS. Does anyone see Africa in this picture?But at the moment that isn’t the biggest constraint. Al-Shabab is the biggest constraint. And its leaders should be held to account.

 

SEO IN KENT

9:38 AM ET

August 24, 2011

Many factors

You have to look at all the underlying factors that can cause famine such as war, weather,economy etc. With these factors involved you will never stamp out famine it has happened in coutries such as China and Ireland in years gone by. however modern society in the western world thrown food away like its going out of fashion, there should be a lesson to be learned here. seo kent