Red, Delicious, and Rotten

How Apple conquered China and learned to think like the Communist Party.

BY CHRISTINA LARSON | AUGUST 1, 2011

BEIJING - A friend in Beijing recently told me a story about the time a China Telecom technician came over to install the Internet connection for her Apple laptop. The man, an experienced worker, puzzled over the slim, silver device. He picked it up gingerly, holding it away from his body as one might inspect a suspicious package. After a few minutes, he set to work, but then grew frustrated when he couldn't find the familiar pull-down menus to configure the connection.

That was just three years ago. Today, it's highly unlikely that any Chinese technician would be similarly flummoxed. Since the first Apple Store opened in Beijing on July 19, 2008, the company has made astonishingly rapid inroads into the Chinese public's pocketbooks and imagination. In any high-end coffee shop like Starbucks or Costa Coffee in central Beijing or Shanghai, the ratio of Apple devices (iPhone,iPad, MacBook, etc.) to non-Apple devices is often more than 1-to-1.

Apple now has four flagship stores in China -- two in Beijing, two in Shanghai -- and plans to open an additional store in Shanghai and its first Hong Kong location within a year. There are also hundreds of licensed Apple resellers in major Chinese cities, as well as many more unlicensed venders (including the elaborate fake "Apple Store" in Kunming unmasked two weeks ago by an American blogger). And these stores are packed with customers: As the company's chief operating officer, Timothy Cook, revealed on a recent earnings call with reporters, "Our four stores in China [are], on average, our highest traffic and our highest revenue stores in the world." Each attracts as many as 40,000 people daily (to accommodate crowds, Apple's stores in China are designed to be much larger than in the United States). From 2010 to 2011, revenue in greater China has ballooned 600 percent, totaling $8.8 billion for the first three quarters of fiscal year 2011.

And yet the same company that enjoys such a sterling, virtuous image in the global press and that's now making buckets of cash in China is precisely the one singled out by China's fledgling civil society groups for its alleged indifferenceto labor rights and environmental enforcement, as well as an apparent tendency toward secrecy and obfuscation. In a nutshell, just as Apple has been consolidating its success in China, it has been acting depressingly like the Chinese Communist Party.

So how did this happen? As in the United States, Apple's extraordinary success in China owes to the fact that it's much more than a device maker; it's a dreammaker. But it has had to edit its dream a bit to translate to a Chinese audience. In the United States, after all, Apple launched its first Macintosh computer with an iconic 1984 Super Bowl ad in which, with a nod to George Orwell, a roomful of pale, listless drones stares unblinkingly at a projection of their leader on a giant TV screen. "Today we celebrate the first glorious anniversary of the Information Purification Directives," his voice crackles. "We have created for the first time in all history a Garden of Pure Ideology … secure from the pests of any contradictory force.… We are one people, with one will, one resolve." Just then, a chiseled blonde in red track shorts sprints down the center aisle and hurls a sledgehammer at the screen, shattering the illusion of unison. The voice-over intones: "On January 24, Apple Computer willintroduce Macintosh. And you'll see why 1984 won't be like 1984."

ChinaFotoPress/Getty Images

 

Christina Larson is a contributing editor at ForeignPolicy and a fellow at the New America Foundation. Follow her on Twitter at @larsonchristina.

ZATO

3:45 AM ET

August 2, 2011

Totally Rotten

I thought the days of this type of extremely ugly anti-Apple propaganda were over. It seems I was wrong. This article above is brought to you by the SLATE GROUP, A DIVISION OF THE WASHINGTON POST COMPANY, according to the footer. Microsoft used to own SLATE, and now claims to have sold it to the Washington Post. Yet the Anti-Apple propaganda continues. I guess I'm going to have to raise my game match or surpass this ugliness.

 

MOLZ

1:07 PM ET

August 2, 2011

Unintelligent or deliberately ignorant?

If this really is your reaction to this article you are either incredibly unintelligent or deliberately choosing to just categorize this article as Microsoft-driven slander. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and call it the latter.

I doubt you know the first thing about Chinese manufacturing. I also doubt you know the first thing about Apple's operating practices in China.

Likely, at a subconscious level, this approach to understanding anything potentially negative regarding Apple makes you feel better about using your Apple products. And frankly if you want to go through life quietly secured against all bad thoughts by your wall of ignorance...that's fine man.

But best keep your mouth closed, lest the rest of us catch on to your "game".

(And yes, I use Apple products...but I'm not blind to how things are in the real world.)

 

BARBRO66

2:19 AM ET

August 3, 2011

Strange article

This is a strange article.

It makes three accusations of misconduct, through suppliers, towards Apple:

- That it has not paid the medical expenses of workers injured in the n-hexane/wintek incident.

- "Apple's Chinese suppliers have been involved in a string of labor and environmental infractions, from a string of suicides linked to poor or inhumane working conditions at plants managed by one of its major suppliers, Foxconn, to allegations by green groups that chemicals leaching out from its factories are polluting China's fields"

- That it has not replied to a NGO's enquires about pollution and workers' safety

The first is the most serious. However, it should be pointed out that Wintek is the employing company here. There is no evidence that Apple has not acted in good faith over this incident - certainly it has reported the incident openly. The evidence would suggest that it is Wintek that is fault here and that Apple has attempted at length to help those influence by the accident. The existence of one industrial accident should not be evidence of misconduct in itself.

- The number of suicides per worker at Foxconn was considerably below the Chinese average. I have yet to see any documents or evidence of "inhumane" working conditions at Foxconn and this article does not give any evidence. As for the accusations of 'chemicals leaching out' from its plans, this is almost certainly true (as it is true of any industrial facility), but this is not evidence that it is 'polluting China's fields'. (what, all of them?)

- Apple does not respond to requests and letters. That's there policy, seems sensible as any response from Apple - on any topic - is bound to get extensive media attention.

I would love to see some serious journalism on China's supply chains, and the serious issues they have in developing humane and environmental working conditions. It is not clear that this article is part of that.

 

CADILLACTIGHT

8:45 AM ET

September 4, 2011

Rotten?

As the company's chief operating officer, Timothy Cook, revealed on a recent earnings call with reporters, "Our four stores in China [are], on average, our highest traffic and our highest revenue stores in the world."
directory List
ge directories

 

MATTOS ANDREC

8:01 AM ET

August 2, 2011

Chinese

Interesting article, why I love the Chinese

Visit: http://gnt.globo.com/assuntos/spfw.shtml

 

TARDALOVA

9:22 AM ET

August 2, 2011

poisoned workers

I don't get it. Apple poisoned what 168 workers where health care is very inexpensive, they pay pennies on the dollar to produce thier products, and they don't have the empathy to make it right by taking care of these folks. It's wrong.

 

WILLWISH

1:43 PM ET

August 5, 2011

It's Wintek

It should be pointed out that Wintek is the employing company here. There is no evidence that Apple has not acted in good faith over this incident - certainly it has reported the incident openly. The evidence would suggest that it is Wintek that is fault here and that Apple has attempted at length to help those influence by the accident. This is serious business, they are not selling handmade jewelry. The existence of one industrial accident should not be evidence of misconduct in itself

 

FABIENDACE

10:27 AM ET

August 2, 2011

I remember that super bowl ad lol

haha I remember that superbowl ad (that was the year I actually started doing some fitness and changed my life) but despite being an Apple fanboy, I still don't agree to the way they're treating their chinese labour. Although, I would probably do my research. Its important to note that many top companies have the same bad working conditions, its just how they do business. Without it your computer your using now would probably cost you double the price.

 

ST.ENDS

10:48 PM ET

August 2, 2011

Is this really new information?

The important question, while finger pointing at Apple, is what electronic manufacturers in China are good, safe, and clearly care about their workers? I want the people of China, I want all people, to work in safe, humane, conditions, earn good pay, have health benefits, and feel good about their jobs... but in this world that is a dream.

If you're going to hold your breath for an electronic product that is completely non-toxic, and was made by happy, healthy, well paid employees you're in for a long wait.

 

JOE MCKEAN

11:37 PM ET

August 2, 2011

Red, Delicious, and Rotten

How does all of this make Apple different from other companies doing business in China? Seriously...

 

SHANDONGER

12:24 AM ET

August 5, 2011

re: perspective

"As for Jia, now resting at his parents' home in the tiny village of Heze,"

I spent a very unfortunate, wasted year in Heze, Shandong. The population of the city is between 8 and 9 million. They use of the phrase 'tiny village' is indicative of what happens when a foreign journalist relies on distant contacts to write an article that at the last minute, she feels a need to punch up in order to achieve the degree of dramatized sympathy. Her agenda was merely confirmed by this blatant misunderstanding of geographic reality.

 

WNGMV

12:13 PM ET

August 7, 2011

My Chinese perspective

I spent 18 years growing up in Shandong Province, and I can tell you that the "geographic reality" is, Heze is considered a tiny village. The only few cities that Shandong-ese flow to are Qingdao and Jinan (possibly with Yantai and Weihai). I might be biased since I'm from one of them, but consider the attitude of the all the Shandong-ese I've talked to, who are not from those two cities, I think it's pretty valid.

Also, the point jumped out to me, is that how Apple released in their report that "the sick workers had been taken care of and Apple checked that they were nurtured back to health", while in face they were not. I'm not saying in general the working condition in China is splendid and Apple is the only "rotten" company. But the fact that Apple couldn't be bothered to get the fact right, or even they failed to, while on the other hand they label themselves as the something else, is utmost disgusting to me.

One cannot reply on the Chinese government to make sure that the Chinese workers get secured and safe working condition, I would expect some multinational company, especially ones like Apple, at least to make more effort for those basics. But again, they don't have any responsibilities to do so.

One thing I do find interesting is that how Apple advertises them in China. I've used iMac, iPhone and iTouch. They are very fine products that I admire. But I really don't like how Apple products are perceived in China. Because of the "oh look how rich I am I have a Mac Book/Air/iPhone/iPad" attitude I've stayed away from all of them.

I guess had I been born and raised in the US, I would totally have been into Apple's products.

 

NICOLEDOM

12:25 AM ET

August 6, 2011

Come on

Not only in China, internationaly apple is communist party. Check the "Apple Logo" only one unique bite, it's called "Communist Party Bite" karmaloop codes. And only China among of other Cummunist nations. Tuely "Monopolistic Communist Party" APPLE.

 

WERTHE

10:24 AM ET

August 8, 2011

Amazed

I was astonished when I read that each day 40 000 people visit Apple store. Man that is really huge and for me unimaginable number. That must be huge profit from such a number of customers. However the good Company should never forget that it should invest some of its profits to the well-being of its employees.

Just my 2cents,
WerThe - member of http://lastlongerguide.com/ webpage.

 

HB209

4:08 AM ET

August 12, 2011

Apple is a beast...

Apple is a beast! They're now the highest earning US company earning more that the oil companies. I really wish Apple would get into the video game console market. I think they are the only company that has a chance at beating both XBOX and PS3. I wish Apple made cheaper items such as netbooks under 200 but you can't even find an old 2002 Apple laptop for less than that. I wish I could afford to invest in Apple's stock because they are going nowhere but up!

 

TINATINKA

12:58 PM ET

August 13, 2011

Apple is just great

Fact that 40000 people visited Apple shops each day in China shows how much powerful is Apple company. That's really,really great!tv stands for flat screens

 

JEFFREY PALIAK

2:56 PM ET

September 8, 2011

considering most apple

considering most apple products are MADE in China, it's kind of normal that they are consuming a lot of Apple products, even if the price is pretty high for Chinese standards.

posted via Samsung Galaxy Tablet

 

AXELBROOK

5:32 AM ET

August 19, 2011

The terrorists have been at

The terrorists have been at it for years; through presidents - time and space - it is about a hunger and thirst for power, fueled by hatred, brainwashing, and a deteriorating environment. Being a "terrorist" is a career choice. There will always be a target for the terrorist; it isn't just America, they have a lot of people in their sights. Foreign policy changes when our elected officials change. Funny how the more western-leaning countries in the Middle-East have asked us to please come there - and protect them from those nasty old terrorists. Hmmm............ RIO .

 

TAWANNA STAMP

9:09 PM ET

August 19, 2011

Red, Delicious, and Rotten

There is nothing worse than cooking with a rotten red potato. It can ruin a whole recipe. There are a few tricks that you can use to find out if your red potato is still good or rotten before you use it to cook with. Your guests will thank you for being cautious and cooking a delicious meal.Smell the red potato. If it is rotten, it is going to have an unpleasant odor. Potatoes don't have much of a natural smell, so if you smell something, you can be pretty sure that you don't want to use the potato.Taste the red potato. Cut the potato down the middle and then lick the inside of the potato. If the potato tastes bland, it is still good. If it tastes sweet, it is bad. Throw it away. Keep checking the rest of the batch as they might not all be bad.Look at the potato with your eyes. If you see green, the potato is on it's way to going bad. If there is just a little bit of green, you can peel it off and still use the rest of the potato. If there is a lot of green or there are large indentations in the potato, throw it away.Put the red potato in your hands and feel it. If it is mushy or slimy, it is bad and you should dump it right in the trash bag. Uncooked red potatoes should be firm.Check for wrinkles. Sometimes a red potato can start to wrinkle when it is going bad. You want a red potato to have skin that is tight.

 

KEVEN RAX

2:06 AM ET

August 20, 2011

Red, Delicious, and Rotten

There is nothing worse than cooking with a rotten red potato. It can ruin a whole recipe. There are a few tricks that you can use to find out if your red potato is still good or rotten before you use it to cook with. Your guests will thank you for being cautious and cooking a delicious meal.Smell the red potato. If it is rotten, it is going to have an unpleasant odor. Potatoes don't have much of a natural smell, so if you smell something, you can be pretty sure that you don't want to use the potato.Taste the red potato. Cut the potato down the middle and then lick the inside of the potato. If the potato tastes bland, it is still good. If it tastes sweet, it is bad. Throw it jesse jane away. Keep checking the rest of the batch as they might not all be bad.Look at the potato with your eyes. If you see green, the potato is on it's way to going bad. If there is just a little bit of green, you can peel it off and still use the rest of the potato. If there is a lot of green or there are large indentations in the potato, throw it away.Put the red potato in your hands and feel it. If it is mushy or slimy, it is bad and you should dump it right in the trash bag. Uncooked red potatoes should be firm.Check for wrinkles. Sometimes a red potato can start to wrinkle when it is going bad. You want a red potato to have skin that is tight.

 

YARINSIZ

10:11 PM ET

August 28, 2011

The first is the most

The first is the most serious. However, it should be pointed out that Wintek is the employing company here. There is no evidence that Apple has not acted in good faith over this incident - certainly it has reported the incident openly. seslisiteler The evidence would suggest that it is Wintek that is fault here and that Apple has attempted at length to help those influence by the accident. The existence of one industrial accident should not be evidence of misconduct in itself.

 

RON PLYMEL

10:14 PM ET

August 29, 2011

Red, Delicious, and Rotten

For more than two years , China's two leading mobile operators, China Mobile and China Unicom, jockeyed for negotiating position with Apple to become the official iPhone distributor in China. This was unusual: China Mobile is the largest mobile telecom operator in the world (more than 522 million subscribers as of March 2010), and sasha grey was not used to NOT having its way in business negotiations with any company.Except for Apple. With Steve Jobs, they met their match.
For large state-owned enterprises like China Mobile and China Unicom , it is normal for them to ask for special changes and amendments because "China is different from other markets." With any other company, they would get the changes they wanted. China Mobile wanted control over the App Store; Apple said no.. And it went on and on.

 

BERN

9:58 AM ET

September 1, 2011

Clever Marketing Move

I think Apple is clever enough to see the potential market n the China. China has grown tremendously in capital, economy, technology, and almost every aspect we can imagine. Entering Chinese market is the right decision to do.

China has about 1.3 billion people. I believe a lot of American companies won’t miss this opportunity to grab this huge market. Besides technology, I heard that a lot of Chinese people do experience poor circulation in legs. This can be a great opportunity for American health products in entering the market. However, this movement may also bring a new problem that we all know, such as the labor problems in U.S.A.

 

READWRITE

2:59 AM ET

September 6, 2011

Not that bad

It is perhaps what I hate about it the most: the over-zealous fans (or shall I call addicts) who are eating, drinking and breathing Apple and are basically walking billboards for the company. Copy Games I like Google and Facebook and you don't see me shamelessly promoting them like crazy every chance I get. And it's not even just that, Apple owners think they are better than other people, that they are some sort of super-humans. buy backlinks Let me tell you this: owning a Mac or an i-related device and flaunting it in front of the whole world doesn't make you cool, its makes you a douche.