America the Brutiful

Yanks are starring on foreign screens -- and it ain't a pretty sight.

BY MICHAEL IDOV | SEPT/OCT 2011

Night. Iraq. An American Humvee patrol, trailed by the ominous strains of horror-movie cello, nears an idyllic country wedding, all colored lights and thumping folk music. "Who's in charge of this, this gathering?" spits out the American commander, wrinkling his bulbous nose. We all know what's coming, and minutes later, there it is: the groom, spattered with blood; the bride, mid-howl, raising her eyes heavenward in slow motion. "We did a hell of a good job there, Lieutenant," drawls one Yank to another, puffing on a cigarette that must surely be a Marlboro.

Related

For more from FP's State of the Ugly American package
Dear Uncle Sam... - By Pankaj Mishra
900 Channels of the Great Satan - By Azadeh Moaveni

If you want to see the face of the Ugly American over the decade since the 9/11 attacks launched the United States into an aggressive "global war on terror," look no further than the rest of the world's movie screens. After decades as bumbling but well-intentioned tourists, G-men, cold warriors, and capitalist fat cats, Americans in global cinema of the early 21st century are door-kicking soldiers and torturing medics, from the brutes of Turkey's Valley of the Wolves: Iraq to the devilish Army doctor in the South Korean horror film The Host. Given U.S. preoccupations over the last 10 years, this is hardly surprising or undeserved. But it's a stark shift nonetheless -- to turn from abstract hegemon to ground-level menace.

Not all the grunts in foreign films are bad guys, of course: The soldier character manages to embody the entire gamut of American archetypes, roughly depending on the source country's stance on the Iraq war. The one unabashedly adoring, sunshine-and-Coca-Cola American character I have seen in non-Anglophone cinema of the 2000s was in the delightful California Dreamin' from Romania (which sent a force of 730 to Iraq). In this 2007 comedy, a minor paperwork error detains a U.S. troop at a rural Romanian train station, which gives the station agent's daughter time to fall in love with one of the soldiers.

Aggrieved Turkey, on the other hand, gave the world Valley of the Wolves: Iraq, the one with the wedding-crasher Yank commandos. The 2006 action film was Turkey's most expensive and highest-grossing ever, costing $10 million to shoot and making $28 million. Its plot piles a wild revenge scenario atop a real snafu: the accidental 2003 NATO arrest of several Turkish officers, with the detainees seen on TV in Abu Ghraib-style hoods. Barely a news blip in the United States, the "hood event," as it's known in Turkey, became such a sore point that, three years later, the country packed cinemas to cheer as a group of fictional Turkish supermen infiltrated Iraq and murdered the commander responsible for the errant raid. The real-life American officer found himself portrayed by B-grade villain specialist Billy Zane, who first shows up in a fedora and an ascot; his opening line is "Make no mistake. We will kill you." A comprehensive compendium of Muslim anxieties about American power, the film also throws in a fake Lynndie England, that Iraqi wedding bombing, and, for good measure, an Army doctor -- played by Gary Busey as a conniving Jewish stereotype -- who steals prisoners' livers for wealthy clients in New York and Tel Aviv. I haven't seen the latest installment by the film's team, Valley of the Wolves: Palestine, which apparently gives the same evenhanded treatment to the 2010 Gaza flotilla storming.

What's fascinating about Valley of the Wolves: Iraq, and the new crop of such films in general, is the increasing participation of Americans in America-bashing. Twenty years ago, the evil Yanks of Valley would have been played, in bad English, by bottle-blond Turks and perhaps a German or two. Now, there's Zane and Busey. In fact, a whole group of low- to mid-level Hollywood players has proven more than willing to accept such gigs: Armand Assante (who also happens to play a crusty but lovable captain in California Dreamin'), Michael Madsen, Rutger Hauer, and others. I'd love to posit some theory about Hollywood self-hatred here, but it's much more likely that we're seeing a curious byproduct of the globalized film economy. With Turkish studios now more able to compete with Zane's salary for, say, the straight-to-DVD Stephen Baldwin vehicle Silent Warnings, everyone can get their foreign villains directly from the source.

Images from 'Valley of the Wolves: Iraq'

 SUBJECTS: CULTURE
 

Michael Idov is contributing editor at New York magazine and author of Made in Russia: Unsung Icons of Soviet Design.

THEHOLEINTHEWORLD

9:39 PM ET

August 16, 2011

Mmmmm...

I am not implying anything, but you might want to mention that that specific scene from "The Host" was based on real events. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0468492/trivia

 

DANIELGARCIASANZ

11:37 PM ET

August 16, 2011

The world has changed.

For decades, Russians, Asians, Latin Americans, Arabs, Africans have seen themselves (and their countries) depicted in American films in very demeaning ways. It seems now's the time for retribution.

 

MARTEILLE

12:17 PM ET

August 17, 2011

About time

Demeaning is a little soft a word to describe what American films today portray of other people. Even in sitcoms and other popular television programs, it still portrays certain individuals in a negative light.
You're right.

 

LUNABELLA

1:34 AM ET

September 5, 2011

and the British!

Mustn't forget the British who have been a staple fodder as bad guys in American movies!

 

ZORRO

8:36 AM ET

August 17, 2011

The Risk Is...

...that this might feed the American fear/persecution complex (a.k.a. Manifest Destiny) rather than trigger some soul searching.

 

KEITH MCDONALD

10:41 AM ET

August 17, 2011

How True

@ DANIELGARCIASANZ
Yes, the big arm of the propaganda machine has swung back in the direction of the United States. The amazing thing to me is that as unpopular as the current foreign adventures (wars) are in the United States, the controlled entertainment industry has not produced much product to echo these sentiments.

 

MARTEILLE

12:22 PM ET

August 17, 2011

My opinion

I believe that it does make sense for a producer to not want to create a film that is responsive to the sentiments of the American public because there is a small, but politically powerfull group of individuals with certain ideological aim (conservatism, I think) that will raise a lot of noise if they were to do this. The producers might be branded as "anti-american", "against freedoms and our troops" by some of these groups that are claiming to be fight for these ideals.
Well, so much for freedom, but it true... :(

 

HURRICANEWARNING

1:49 PM ET

August 17, 2011

hmmmmm, rather than blindly

hmmmmm, rather than blindly buying into this authors view, I think we should look at the facts. While it is interesting that movies like this are being made, and that SOME of them do Surprisingly well, I think it's worth noting that American films, which portray American characters in a positive light (I.e. classic hollywood filmmaking) are still BY FAR the most successful films worldwide. Hollywood blockbusters still bring in truckloads of money from all the same countries this author talks about. Lets see, which movie did better worldwide: Transformers (the most blatantly pro-american film EVER) or Valley of the wolves Iraq? End of discussion.

 

ACK

5:55 PM ET

August 17, 2011

Character

"newly widespread Russian attitude -- American villainy stems from the American national character"

If we are to be honest, this is the most truthful statement in this piece. Our national character HAS changed. And NOT for the better.

I barely recognize what passes for rational thought in the press or public fora today.

Torture? Majority approval

Rendition? Barely a peep.

Assassination? Well, isn't that how we SHOULD do it?

Civilian collateral fatalities? Hey, It's just the price of doing business.

Pay for it all? No, we couldn't possibly tax the rich, what are you thinking?

I realize these actions have existed since time immemorial, but NOT with such a level of public approval, or with such openness by the government.

The chickens come home to roost, what?

 

OJ.SAL92

7:26 PM ET

August 17, 2011

I agree

I agree. American character has lost many of the attributes and values that it had in the past. Even as relatively recently as the 1970s, we had more classic American independence, self-reliance, and healthy skepticism. But since the late 1970s/early 1980s, consumerism has turned our culture into one of petty brats, where everybody (especially people in my age group, 30 and under) thinks they're a movie star and god's gift to the green earth. Too many people are too busy stupefying themselves with Jersey Shore and other pointless and trashy reality shows and distracting themselves with constant consumption of the latest cell phones or novelty to actually take notice about what's actually going on in this country and the rest of the world. Present day American attitudes are THE example par excellence of the negative impact consumerism has on a culture. We've honestly become quite pathetic, where once we *admired* (not worshipped) great compromising leaders and ingenious thinkers, and now we *worship* (not simply admire) overblown actors and arrogant athletes who do absolutely nothing for society except 1) make the big bucks from hypnotized fans paying for tickets and merchandise, and 2) distract people from reality. Sports, movies, video games, political parties, externalization of cost, etc., are all simply a complex, intricate system of distraction and social control that many think we, as a people, are immune to, but so sadly are not.

 

WICKBAM

7:58 PM ET

August 17, 2011

pardon

I'm not really understanding how California Dreamin' is an example of the villainous American genre.

 

INDAYMANDRAXX

7:20 AM ET

September 23, 2011

absolutely true

Right you are. I don't understand it eighter what they meant about the article and it's really confusing that I can't bear reading it anymore.
pacquiao vs marquez 3 fight live stream I just wish it was written much clearer. watch pacquiao vs marquez 3 online I am glad however that you posted your reply so that it could clear things up for me. Thank you. pacquiao vs marquez tickets

 

ANDDINU

3:34 AM ET

August 18, 2011

think

maybe cause they kinda of always bomb other countryes for petrol and money, and packing ...think that may have influenced a little.....

 

SAMILES2010

3:52 PM ET

August 18, 2011

On a related note

Something that really angers me about Hollywood is ethnic stereotypes; especially when it comes to Italians and Russians (or anyone is vaguely Eastern Europeans). I cannot think of any Hollywood film where Italians were somehow portrayed as mobsters or in some other way criminal. The same is true for Russians; every Russian is involved in the clichéd Kraznaya Mafiya. It's tokenism at its worst. I'm not even going to get into Arabs, Turks or Persians.

 

DAYE

9:53 AM ET

September 2, 2011

The Brutally Brutiful!

When there is a widespread resistance against the American pseudo- imperialism prevalent in the world, it is only but natural that, the movies like ‘Captain America’ are being made to reflect the people’s sentiments. Albeit, the anti-American sentiment of the people of various nations is trying to repel the US hegemony, it definitely is not the bestmosquitorepellent this world has ever got against them. Then again, such film noir will not only mirror but also strengthen the sentiment and contribute to a collective consciousness which will devise more and more ways of defending themselves from the ‘Brutiful’. A worthy honest effort indeed!

 

MARCUS_HOLCOM

11:32 AM ET

September 14, 2011

Don't Fear the American City!!!

Crime -- both property crime and violent crime -- is down to its lowest level in 40 years, especially in America's biggest cities, according to newly released data from the FBI's annual Uniform Crime Report. The data was collected from January through December 2010 and breaks out metropolitan and non-metropolitan areas as well as cities of various sizes. For the fourth year in a row, there has been yet another substantial decline in crime: 5.5 percent fewer murders, forcible rapes, robberies, and aggravated assaults were reported in 2010 than in 2009; property crimes fell by 2.8 percent over the same period and reported arson dropped by 8.3 percent. "In all regions, the country appears to be safer," reports the New York Times.Affiliate Programs Review "The odds of being murdered or robbed are now less than half of what they were in the early 1990s, when violent crime peaked in the United States."

 

PETERBEXLEY

12:02 PM ET

September 17, 2011

Interesting

Just read the article. I found it very informative and agree with posts and points made above. Peter.

 

MWSCHNEIDER

10:54 PM ET

September 19, 2011

The comments

We see a bunch of comments by a group of sanctimonious jerks envious of the U.S. as a superpower. Any honest look at Americans would reflect the huge diversity in outlook and background of the American population. Instead, you idiots get your kicks out of pseudo-intellectual anti-Americanism. Having a balanced perspective would be much less fun.

 

KARLABOFIL

6:49 AM ET

September 23, 2011

Let There Be Peace

This is what the world needs nowadays. Peace among our brothers and sisters. Stop the wars they only bring destruction. Let us enjoy ourselves by watching sports like this November we can Watch Pacquiao Vs Marquez 3. This will make us all forget about the problems surrounding us. Enjoy life and not think of destruction.

 

GALLYCIUDAD

7:44 AM ET

September 23, 2011

Very Good Article

This is a well written article about how American soldiers are depicted in Movies. Well this is just a movie and does not necessarily mean that this is how the Americans soldier behave in real combats. But I am sure that they want to Watch Pacquiao Vs Marquez 3. If they have children at homes then these children who are left behind needs the tutor that they can get like
Cool Math. We are very lucky because we are not there fighting. Cityville Cheats. Let us all think of the soldiers in the field sacrificing their lives.