The Lap of Luxembourgery

So what if it has the world's highest per capita GDP? A visit to the debt-ridden capital of European complacency.

BY ERIC PAPE | SEPT/OCT 2011

In the dark heart of Europe lies a nation rotten to the core. Renowned as a secret banking haven where North Korean leader Kim Jong Il allegedly squirreled away billions of dollars, its economy is tied to the whims of capricious global money markets. The country's per capita external debt is 84 times that of the debt-ridden United States (some $3.76 million for each man, woman, and child). Democracy is a joke, undermined by a hereditary and unelected head of state who not only can dissolve parliament, but appoints some of its members in the first place. Beleaguered citizens worry about just how sustainable their ever-more-fragile country is, which is no surprise given that foreigners make up 44 percent of the population and the equivalent of another 25 percent invade the country daily just to do its work.

So where is this armpit of the European Union, this cancer of the continent? Greece? The Balkans? Not exactly. Behold the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg, population 503,000, a tiny freckle on the map between Belgium, France, and Germany.

Sure, cyclists and hikers might see this bucolic country as a verdant paradise, with its rolling green hills and lush pastures. And bankers may marvel at its spectacular wealth: Luxembourg boasts the world's highest per capita GDP, $108,832 in 2010. But something must be wrong. The miserable Luxembourgers -- who rate lower than all but one other European country on the Happy Planet Index (they're tied with war-torn Sudan!) -- buy more cigarettes and alcohol and have a higher per capita carbon footprint than any other country. And yet their national motto is "We want to remain what we are."

I had to know: Could this hard-partying little duchy hold the secret to the dark forces now tearing apart Europe?

On the cloudless summer day when I arrived, the quiet, well-kept streets of Luxembourg's capital, creatively named Luxembourg City, seemed idyllic enough. The only time I sensed any sort of abyss was when I looked down from the elegant stone Pont Adolphe into the lush, precipitous gorge that cuts through town. An 18-piece military brass band was playing "Come Fly With Me" in the city center as well-dressed white people filtered in and out of luxury chain stores on the edge of the charming old town. In the distance, a row of investment banks glistened in the sun, identically armored with reflective, modern exteriors.

I wandered into a stylish bistro that leaked pulsing rhythms onto the Rue de la Boucherie, the trendiest street in the center of the old town -- the kind of place, the waiter told me, where bankers gather to knock back copious amounts of booze on weekends. A bottle of whiskey in Luxembourg, explained Panagiotis Meidanis, an 18-year-old server with a truncated pompadour, sells for half the price that it does in his native Greece, where people earn a fraction of the local income, especially now. "When we close on weekend nights, they always want more," said Meidanis of his customers. "But for some reason they never get into fights here."

But what did he know? I needed to find a real Luxembourger. Across from the 19th-century Gare de Luxembourg with its art nouveau flourishes, I met with Georges Hausemer, who has published one of the remarkably few novels in the native Lëtzebuergesch language. Hausemer's 1998 novel, Iwwer Waasser (Above Water), is a tale of a broken marriage set in the world of banking that the author describes as a "portrait in miniature" of Luxembourgian society.

But when I asked him whether his personal $3.76 million share of the external debt keeps him up at night, he said: "Is that true? No one is talking about this here." He sipped a Schweppes, sans alcohol, and then admitted soberly: "We are a bit lost." He spoke of the encroachments of "foreign" languages -- French is officially used, while German and English are more common in business circles -- and distant cultures. The end result, he says, is a country of commerce and banking that is "losing everything else." Even Hausemer, it turned out, is barely keeping the faith: He wrote his other novels in German.

To better understand modern Luxembourg's raison d'être, I tracked down Igor, a nattily attired 30-something banker who agreed to speak with me on the condition that I wouldn't mention his last name or the firm that employs him. He also insisted that we speak while he marched, in his designer shoes, from a business lunch to his car.

Igor told me of the sturm und drang that the 2008 financial crisis brought upon his poor country. "For clients, it was beyond stressful. They could lose their fortunes. They didn't know if the banks were going to go under. They were guaranteed €100,000 by the state, but above that, nothing."

Georges Gobet/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: CULTURE, EUROPE
 

Eric Pape is a writer in Paris.

KUNINO

1:39 PM ET

August 15, 2011

Well, one thing's clear

Eric Pape can probably make a tax claim based on his visit to Luxembourg.

 

OLIVIER101

5:13 AM ET

August 16, 2011

So wrong...

This article gets so many things wrong, it would be too long to list... How can you get the essence of a country with such a short visit and by talking to largely unrepresentative persons? I've live there for more than 13 years and it's nowhere near what you are picturing.

Democracy is a joke? Where did you get that?? Does monarchy means no democracy for you? Isn't the UK a democracy? This isn't serious...
"Miserable Luxembourgers" ?? Check your data again! The happy planet index rates Luxembourg at 7.7 on the life satisfaction scale, that is higher than neighbors France, Belgium and Germany.

Did you only ask yourself why so much tobacco and alcohol was sold there? Simply because it's cheaper because of lower taxes, so most of the sales go to non-Luxembourgers who just shop there. You make it look like people smoke more and drink more, which is not true, and that is dishonest.

French, German and Luxembourgish are all official languages on an equal level. All Luxembourgers speak the 3 languages, often in addition to English. Luxembourgish is far from being declining, even if the written form is not yet common due to its spelling having been normalized only recently.

Finally, the figure that the author finds so astonishing isn't meaningful in the case of Luxembourg; if you look at the total national debt (not just the external debt) it amounted in 2010 to 16.2% of the GDP, to be compared with almost 60% for the US, and 225% for Japan!

"a nation rotten to the core"? "the cancer of the continent"??? Oh my God... I only see a small country that has been smart enough to find a niche market and make it flourish. This kind of journalism is rotten to the core.

 

DEMGAR

3:27 PM ET

August 16, 2011

Maybe Humor?

Right on all counts, Olivier.

The first page comes across a smear and scare piece, and then the second page tries to pull back with a half-hearted attempt at self-effacement. It you are going to write things so offensive, you need to either be clear that it's sarcasm or be ready to back up your claims. Pretty weak on either count.

To be clear on the "External debt" issue, this number includes ALL debt issued in Luxembourg, not just government debt. Because Lux acts something like a flag of convenience for a lot of multi-national corporations, this number as compared to pop or GDP is nonsense. Companies like Apple and Amazon have their European HQ there, and companies like Arcelor Mittal and Skype have their global HQ there. Just because Apple (hypothetically) issues 1bln in EUR debt using the Lux markets, doesn't mean that the citizens of Lux have any obligation to pay it back at all. No more than US citizens have an obligation to pay back the debt of GM or Bank of America for example... Oh wait! HA! Well, I don't see Lux making that same folly.

Anyways, this piece comes off poorly and is full of half truths and outright fabrications that are either badly implemented humor or just the ramblings of a jealous Parisian.

 

JENDRIK

8:08 AM ET

August 24, 2011

completely wrong ...

About luxemburgish debt : it is the second best situation after Estonia with 16,2 % of the GDP.
For information , Mr Pape, Luxembourg debt per habitant is around 15,300 EURand not 3,310,000 USD as the global debt amount is 7,661 million EUR in 2010.
So before to write a stupid article, check your information source.

 

MARTEILLE

4:12 PM ET

August 27, 2011

I understand you

For a moment, I though the author was being serious here. Kind of wish I was born Luxembourg. Oh well.

 

PETIT MALIN

7:31 AM ET

August 16, 2011

Olivier101

Uh, I think you are missing the irony. The writer seems to be making fun of himself and journalists for using worthless statistics and making ridiculous assumptions more than he is making fun of your adopted homeland. The Santa Claus banker at the end seems like a fairly contented gentleman, as do the people who want things to stay the way they are. Luxembourg simply sounds like a place where people lament very small problems that the rest of us would be glad to have.

 

OLIVIER101

8:57 AM ET

August 16, 2011

Wow

The thing about irony is that it is tricky to handle because if not done properly, the doubt remains about the author's actual message. I read it again with this in mind and even though I have a hint that it is actually an attempt at irony, to me it's a failed attempt.
Anyway, I might be taking this too personally :)

 

XENOS66

7:48 AM ET

August 16, 2011

This is a humor column,

This is a humor column, right? Because the external debt quote just makes no sense. There are a number of hedge funds in Luxembourg, and they do a fair bit of options trading. This skews the numbers a fair bit, just like if you figured out the external debt for Greenwich, CT.

As noted above, the public debt is very much under control.

Now, of course, there are regular and often amusing temper tantrums between Luxembourgish and French politicians as many French consider the Luxembourgers and their private bankers to be leeches and ingrates. The Germans do not make a public fuss, but regularly pull over German pensioners visiting the Grand Duchy and dig out hundreds of thousands of Euros out of the upholstery of their car seats. A pretty fun game for all concerned, really.

 

SEGISMUNDO

8:31 AM ET

August 16, 2011

Steel mining

Can somebody please tell me exactly what "steel mining" is?

 

MIKEYMANNON

8:39 AM ET

August 17, 2011

I am a teacher in Luxembourg

I am a teacher in Luxembourg and one of my students brought in this article to know if it was really as uninformed as it appeared to her. I was flabbergasted by terrible quality of journalism. The sources Pape cites are poor representations of the country: an 18-year-old waiter from Greece, novelist, and a disaffected Luxembourger living in London whose main complaint is that teachers here make too much money and that you can’t find decent Chinese food?

Couldn’t Pape have come up with any substantial gripes against Luxembourg?

And what of the young banker who only agrees to talk to Pape while he walks to his car? So that means…a 2-minute interview? The piece gives the impression that Pape spent an afternoon here while in transit and got the rest of his information from either Wikipedia or an anti-Luxembourg website.

I agree with the other poster who wrote that this piece is “full of half truths and outright fabrications that are either badly implemented humor or just the ramblings of a jealous Parisian.”

Shame on the editors of Foreign Policy for allowing such drivel to be published. Shame on Pape for reducing a nation, culture, and people to a few (incorrect) factoids. It might have been helpful to have a writer who shows the most minimal familiarity with the country.

 

MIKEYMANNON

8:39 AM ET

August 17, 2011

I am a teacher in Luxembourg

I am a teacher in Luxembourg and one of my students brought in this article to know if it was really as uninformed as it appeared to her. I was flabbergasted by terrible quality of journalism. The sources Pape cites are poor representations of the country: an 18-year-old waiter from Greece, novelist, and a disaffected Luxembourger living in London whose main complaint is that teachers here make too much money and that you can’t find decent Chinese food?

Couldn’t Pape have come up with any substantial gripes against Luxembourg?

And what of the young banker who only agrees to talk to Pape while he walks to his car? So that means…a 2-minute interview? The piece gives the impression that Pape spent an afternoon here while in transit and got the rest of his information from either Wikipedia or an anti-Luxembourg website.

I agree with the other poster who wrote that this piece is “full of half truths and outright fabrications that are either badly implemented humor or just the ramblings of a jealous Parisian.”

Shame on the editors of Foreign Policy for allowing such drivel to be published. Shame on Pape for reducing a nation, culture, and people to a few (incorrect) factoids. It might have been helpful to have a writer who shows the most minimal familiarity with the country.

 

ICRISTIAN

9:48 AM ET

August 23, 2011

I thought teachers were

I thought teachers were supposed to be educated, intelligent human-beings. Irony shouldn't escape them with such ease.
Try re-reading the column.
Then think a bit. :)

 

PETRI ORAVAINEN

2:56 PM ET

August 23, 2011

Well, irony or not, this must

Well, irony or not, this must be the most ludicrous piece of "journalism" I've read for a long time. What's the point of all this attitude? Surely not humour, because it sure ain't funny. Foreign Policy might want to review their quality control procedures...

Having lived in Luxembourg for a short time, I would just like to point out the following blatant absurdities and misrepresentations in this article:

- Luxembourg MPs are not in part appointed by the monarch, but democratically elected (and, as has been pointed out by another commentator, monarchies are not that uncommon among democratic states ;)

- on the external debt figure: cf. Oliver101's explanations. Luxembourg is, along with Finland, the only Eurozone country that actually meets the Maastricht criteria on debt and budget deficit at the moment

- although the independence of the country has been the result of a conjunction of historical developments and geographical factors (but then , doesn't that apply to most countries in some way or another), a "Luxembourg" identity has developed and strengthened over time, and not the least out of resistance to the Nazi occupant in WW2.

- as for the country's problems: well, they are very similar to some of those faced by most European countries: an unsustainable pensions system, a bloated state-run social security system and a lack of smart urban and territorial planning (not as bad as in the US though). And yes, they do tend be complacent about stuff sometimes...

 

RUSKALUX

9:09 AM ET

August 24, 2011

Hitler....

Am Luxembourger, proud of my country, of our Grand Duc and of what we are, and even if 40% of the population isn't luxemburgish, we are an open minden, cosmopolitan and multiculural nation.. and that's the futur.

This guy is Hitler's son... (Il n'y a que les vieux cons pour pouvoir écrire de telles cochoneries... mais bon.. vieux, donc bientôt sous terre... les jeunes serront encore la demain pour faire évoluer le monde.. heureusement).

 

ADHOC

9:44 AM ET

August 24, 2011

All wrong

I live in this country for the last 30 years. The article is entirely misleading; I wish many other countries had a small portion of the democracy, happiness and fairness that citizens of Luxembourg enjoy. I can bet that many countries in the world would have loved to have a 'total external debt' as high as Luxembourg's, instead of their unsustainable 'public debt' /GDP.

 

JOIWDHIOEH

10:17 AM ET

August 24, 2011

Eric Pape is the cancer in any reputable magazine or newspaper

Whoever wrote this thing is superficial and very uneducated. Irony does not count as an excuse because Luxembourg is being criticised by some people on grounds of unfair taxation, banking secrecy and other issues. What this "writer", and I use the term very loosely writes here is his honest opinion, and it's complete bullshit.

As was pointed out already, alcohol, tobacco and carbon emission tied mostly to car fuel are all consequences of tourism. European truck transport goes through Luxembourg to fill up on gas, and French and German citizens come for cheap cigarettes and alcohol.

Furthermore, even though almost 40% of residents are non-Luxembourgish, they take advantage of the whole social security system and this massive immigration has had positive consequences for the multi-lingual and very open-minded population.

I'm myself am from Luxembourg, 20 years old, and I love my country. There may be things to improve, as with every other nation on Earth, however one thing Luxembourg never did was unrightfully lash out against other nations. It never did and never will. Its size is one of the causes - maybe if the country was as big as the United States and if it had more space for such small-minded idiots like this journalist it would also attack some nations for oil and tactical supremacy.

Anyways, just look at the reactions to this article - even though, as the article says, Luxembourg's citizens seem very miserable and do not feel like having a united national identity, they are proud enough to take the time to tell you what an idiot you are. And they seem to like their country quite a bit more than you. At least in Luxembourg you can study without having to take on debt for the first 20 years of your professional life, and we can go to the doctor when we're sick and are not refused life-saving treatment because our credit score is too low.

I've been to many countries, the USA among them, and frankly, I think many should imitate Luxembourg on some points.

MIR WËLLEN NËT NËMMEN BLEIWEN WAAT MER SIN, MIR WÄERTEN ËT OCH BLEIWEN. An wann sou ën Rendvéih vun Tourist deen eng Headline sicht mengt en misst sëch um Nationalstolz vun eis Lëtzebuërger vergräifen, well ën mengt ët géng keen meckeren, dann huët ën sëch gudd geschnidden. "Vous êtes un gros cochon sans honneur, Monsieur Pape", vous dirais-je en une langue que vous comprenez (ou même pas?), puisque malheureusement vous n'êtes pas aussi éduqué que les Luxembourgeois qui comprennent quand on essaie de leur taper dessus en anglais, français ou allemand.

 

LATVIAN

4:38 AM ET

August 25, 2011

Look at the photo!

What is the photo of the former President of the Central Bank of Latvia and ex-Prime Minister of Latvia, Einars Repse doing in this article anyway?

 

MIKHAILSHEFERD

7:41 PM ET

August 26, 2011

Good eye.

That should have been our first clue.

 

SUPERJHEMP

6:27 AM ET

August 25, 2011

Typical American style

Typical bullshit article to fool the American John Doe, who still thinks that the US is the only legal country on earth and all others are either evil communist leftovers or some lost spots undermined by the Islam.

When do you people actually wake up and realize that you're living in Disneyland and that all your superheroes are just inventions of Martin Goodman?

Forgive me my judgment, I'm just a native atheist Luxembourger who is happy not living in the States.

Oh by the way, for your records (or next well researched article): nearly 20% of Americas pension capital is invested in Luxembourg. I really wonder why...?

 

YBAUER

8:33 AM ET

August 25, 2011

geiff daat do net als serieux bezeechnen

an dofier mech net opreegen ! ;-)

 

ALEXEIKARP

8:33 AM ET

August 25, 2011

Poor journalism. Twisting of facts. Misleading.

Dear Mr. Pape,

To start of, may I ask what, exactly, is it about Luxembourg that has angered you to such an extent? What could possibly be the reasoning behind your twisting of facts and misleading, poorly executed journalism? Possibly jealousy?

I would like to continue by responding to some of the comments you made about Luxembourg.

National debt:
Mr. Pape, out of all the ridiculous and misleading half truths you have written in your article, this one is probably the most outrageous.
Like many cities and areas in the world, Luxembourg has picked an strategic economic niche to excel in and derive its wealth from. Silicon Valley has IT, China has manufacturing, whilst New York, London and Luxembourg have finance.
One of the unique points of the Luxembourgish legal and economic framework is that is allows for multinational companies to open parent or subsidiary structures in Luxembourg under highly attractive conditions. It is beneficial for these multinational companies, which usually merely have a "virtual" presence here, to issue debt in the form of Eurobonds, which is then redistributed to other parts of the company, regardless of physical location. Companies which issue eurobonds from Luxembourg include Ford, General Motors, IBM, Gazprom, Amazon, Fiat and many, many others.
What you are referring to as 3.76 Million US Dollars of external debt per capita includes the debt of multinational companies issuing debt through Luxembourg and has no negative effect on the state of the Luxembourgish economy. If anything, it is a reflection of the trust that investors show when subscribing to a eurobond in the political and economical stability of Luxembourg.
You may also want to consider that Luxembourg's national debt per capita, which is an indicator of the government's debt, is one of the lowest in Europe or in the world.

Miserable, heavy smoking, heavy drinking Luxembourgers:
Mr. Pape, knowing how to find statistics is one thing. Knowing how to interpret them is another. You obviously have no understanding of the latter.
The "Happy Planet Index" is a statistical ranking made out of three factors: life satisfaction, life expectancy and environmental impact.
In terms of life satisfaction and in life expectancy, Luxembourg ranks highly (17th and 25th in the world, out of 142 nations). Luxembourg falls short in terms of environmental impact, the core reason being consumption of fossil fuels. And the reason for that, Mr. Pape, is seeing how Luxembourg is a "Freckle of a Country", it is also one of the highest transit points for automobiles, including trucks, from all over Europe. With fuel, tobacco and alcohol being considerably cheaper due to lower taxation, it is a planned stop for most travelers to fuel up their car and buy alcohol and tobacco. For this very reason, the "Aire de Berchem" is the world's largest gas/petrol station in the world by volume sold. In essence, the environmental impact statistic used to calculate Luxembourg's overall HPI index is flawed in that most fossil fuels sold in Luxembourg are consumed elsewhere. It is also the reason why we don't smoke or drink anywhere nearly as much as a lousy interpretation of a statistic would lead you to think. If we did, then our average life expectancy of 78.4 years would truly be nothing short of miraculous.

Population:
We are a very happy community. We salute the fact that 40% of our population is comprised of generally highly qualified foreigners, contributing to a socially healthy, cosmopolitan community, unique in a city and a country this size. And yes, it so happens that a lot of the workforce necessary to run our exceptionally healthy economy comes from neighboring countries. But it so happens, Mr. Pope, and I am not sure you know of this, that a lot of economically significant cities in the world derive their workforce from surrounding (commuter) towns.Please consider that our capital is no further than 10 miles from the borders of Germany, France and Belgium.

Happiness:
It's true. We do have lousy weather. Not every place on earth is California.
But other than that? We have the safest capital in the world, we have exceptional health care and social support systems, a free education system and even a university (in our "freckle on a map" of a country, that is).
We have a diverse offering of culture, sports, entertainment, gastronomy (highest number of Michelin stars per square km) and nightlife unique for a city so small.
And yes, our teachers are well paid. So are our secretaries and workers and electricians and cleaning ladies and bankers. And everyone in between.
I understand that a high quality of life for its residents is a goal that you may think unnecessary for a nation to pursue. Respectfully, we think otherwise, and yes, thank you, we would very much like to “remain what we are”.

Alexey Karpov

 

ALEXEIKARP

9:26 AM ET

August 25, 2011

Mr. Pape's comments on the subject

Mr. Pape, on another online publication, has in fact explained that the article in question is satirical/sarcastic. View his comments here:

http://www.presseurop.eu/en/content/article/878931-europe-s-troubled-el-dorado