Pregnant in Putin's Russia

An expectant mother's journey through the modern Moscow medical system. 

BY NATALIA ANTONOVA | AUGUST 26, 2011

MOSCOW — "Russia needs babies" may as well be the unofficial slogan of Prime Minister Vladimir Putin's ruling United Russia Party. The country is in a demographic crisis, shedding 2.2 million people (or 1.6 percent of the population) since 2002, and the government is trying to encourage more women to bring Russian citizens into the world. This year, when I unexpectedly got pregnant soon after receiving my visa to work in Moscow, I became a test case.

Related

Russia's Deadly Hospitals
Photos from a truly broken health-care system

Since the Soviet days, having a baby in Russia has been commonly understood as a nightmare of understaffed state hospitals and forbidding bureaucratic mazes. Feminist author Maria Arbatova's My Name Is Woman, an alternatively harrowing and hilarious account of childbirth in the 1970s, was the grim reality for many. Arbatova described being left completely unattended during the final stages of labor, which nearly resulted in her death and the death of her twin sons.

The fall of the Soviet Union did not improve matters. A 1996 Los Angeles Times article, titled appropriately "Childbirth in Russia Is Miserable," attested to Russia's "scruffy, ill equipped, and harried" maternity wards. The article described a health system caught in a straitjacket of leftover communist-era regulations, which even dictated the posture mothers must lie in to nurse their newborns.

These days, thankfully, maternal mortality is decreasing in Russia, according to the World Health Organization, but this doesn't mean that most women have renewed faith in the medical establishment -- horror stories still pop up in the press and the blogosphere.

It's only natural for the truly scary cases to make their way into the press, while the stories of regular birthing experiences remain generally untold. However, there are enough Russian bloggers out there recounting tales of being bullied and mistreated by medical staff to give a pregnant woman cause for concern.

Shortly before I gave birth, I was struck by a blog post by a recent mother, detailing a personal experience at a Moscow hospital not far from where I live -- yelling midwives, a doctor who was mostly busy somewhere else, and, for dessert, getting stitched up with no anesthetic by a staff member who threatened to walk away should she continue to squirm. According to the midwives, "it was my fault that I overshot my due date and was now screaming (and here I thought I was only moaning softly)," the author wrote.

That's not exactly good press if you're trying to get more women to give birth. This is why Putin is seen on the television news these days touring newfangled perinatal centers and holding high-profile meetings on maternal care -- to assure the childbearing public that the government is now watching out for them. The prime minister has also pledged to spend 1.5 trillion rubles (about $54 billion) over the next four years on demographics-related projects such as raising life expectancy and increasing the birth rate by 30 percent.

I hadn't planned on serving as a canary for Russia's new advances in state maternal care, but after my husband and I ran out of money, throwing ourselves on the mercy of free health care was our only choice. Last November, when I made my first appointment with an OB/GYN at the Norovkov Clinic, a private establishment in Moscow that came highly recommended by friends, my new doctor, Natalia Bovina, explained my options to me.

"You can pay for a special 'birthing contract' at a hospital that provides commercial services -- or you can call an ambulance once labor kicks in, but then it will all depend on luck," Bovina said. "Unless a nearby hospital is full, they won't legally be able to refuse to admit a woman in labor, but who knows what kind of doctors you will end up with?"

VLADIMIR RODIONOV/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS:
 

Natalia Antonova is the deputy editor of the Moscow News and a playwright.

BOSTON4

9:08 PM ET

August 26, 2011

Well written article

It was a pleasure to read. Thanks.

 

DISTANTSMOKE

10:00 PM ET

August 26, 2011

Thank God

Thank God the Democrats were strong enough to take a vote at midnight on Christmas Eve and shove a Russian styled Obamacare down our throats. Now we too can look forward to an overburdened medical system where doctors, nurses and hospitals all work for the State, rather than for the patient. We too can look forward to a medical system where those who manage to have more money than mere citizens like myself, (say, the Obamas and Maxine Waters, as well as Bill Gates) will be able to "pay" for better medical care than the rest of us will be forced to accept.

If it wasn't for the Democrats overwhelming sense of righteous indignation (how dare doctors expect patients to pay for extensive and expensive medical care), we would now be living in a society where market forces determine the quality and cost of medical care. The fact that a market based health care system (that we used to have in place) was the gold standard for health care all over the world must have daily grated on the nerves of every Democrat who is certain he or she is better prepared to run our lives than we are. If it weren't 2011, I would say "Welcome to 1984".

 

CLADOE

3:51 AM ET

August 29, 2011

European Health Care

Have you ever had any experience with continental europe's HCS??
Of course, the Russian HCS has its problems, vastly underfunded and understaffed... but they simply don't have the economic ressources to do better.
But the USA are economically a lot better off, you COULD afford a system similar to europe, where the only thing you need to see a doctor is the health care card every citizen gets upon birth... and maybe up to 5 € to purchase any drug your doctor prescribes you.
What about living in a system where the next hospital is a maximum of 30 min drive away? (by observing the speed limit, for ambulances even less).
What about living in a system where the question of whether you die of cancer or live to see your grandchildren doesn't depend on your income?
The US HCS is one of the most expensive ones worldwide... and one of the most ineffective ones ($/treatment and $/patient) as well. So where are the market forces that you came up with?
I lived on both continents for a while and I would never ever trade our system for the American one.

 

TBARBE

12:01 PM ET

August 27, 2011

Costs

My wife ( a Russian national who immigrated to USA with me )

has had children in both Russia and in USA...and tho the Russian services can at times be scary - the cost differential between the same thing is incredible...in the states we have paid now over 15k for giving birth and ancillary subsequent costs...and the arguing with insurance company is literally no different than arguing with a Russian hospital worker -- except the American feigns politeness but can easily hang-up on your call forcing you back into a 'virtual' line on hold again....

I think the differences are growing smaller - and whilst American services appear shiny and good - there is something lacking brewing underneath that facade....

So the grass is always greener on the other side... in America's case that green = money cost...and when it reaches a certain level - we realized we could have probably paid for better services in Russia - and still saved a bundle at the end of the day whilst getting decent hospital help...

 

HELPDADDY

1:05 AM ET

August 29, 2011

Sad State

I feel bad reading this article. Expecting or having a baby is supposed to be a joyous event, exciting times especially for first time parents. Unfortunately, this is not the case, hope the sad condition can improve, not sure how this is possible. Hopefully, when the baby arrives, despite the condition surrounding his or her birth and the delivery, he or she grow as a happy child.

 

GINCHINCHILI

9:59 PM ET

September 23, 2011

Sick in SO many ways

Technology and medical science has progressed a lot that, within this era, there isn't any reason everyone can't be afforded good quality healthcare. There isn't any reason everybody cannot enjoy a healthy body. Indeed, this ought to be regarded as a simple human right. Instead we face waiting lists and shortages of doctors and beds.

The questions I've been inspired to address would be the following: That which was a policy from the Soviet state regarding health? That which was the USSR’s record on health? How was healthcare organised within the USSR? What developments were made? Within the pages such as the following I'll make an effort to tackle these questions.

 

RICKIE124

1:07 AM ET

September 24, 2011

Pregnant in Putin's Russia

An expectant mother's journey through the modern Moscow medical system. I feel bad reading this article. Expecting or having a baby is supposed to be a joyous event, exciting times especially for first time parents. Unfortunately, this is not the case, hope the sad condition can improve, not sure how this is possible. Hopefully, when the baby arrives, despite the condition surrounding his or her birth and the delivery, he or she grow as a happy child. stress management Thank God the Democrats were strong enough to take a vote at midnight on Christmas Eve and shove a Russian styled Obamacare down our throats. Now we too can look forward to an overburdened medical system where doctors, nurses and hospitals all work for the State, rather than for the patient. We too can look forward to a medical system where those who manage to have more money than mere citizens li.

 

TAYFA34

5:19 AM ET

September 26, 2011

Sick in how money terror

And Palestinian land will shrink, suicide bombers will respond, rockets will be launched and Israelis killed. Now Hezbollah and Sunnis have started up again in Lebanon. And Iran is powering up its nuclear capacity. Israel may feel impelled to react at some point if it calculates either Lebanon or Iran needs to be nipped in the bud. Add Syria to the toxic mix in Lebanon; and if things boil over there then Palestine will be left to sit and stew on the perennial international back burner. Hope, at this point, is not even a diamond in the rough. porno porno porno porno sikiş web tasarım