7 Things You Didn’t Know About the War on Terror

From an attempt to negotiate with Osama bin Laden to a proposal to threaten to bomb Mecca, it's been a wild decade for the U.S. national security establishment.

BY ERIC SCHMITT, THOMAS SHANKER | SEPTEMBER 6, 2011

Our new book, Counterstrike: The Untold Story of America's Secret Campaign Against Al Qaeda, is in many ways a summary of the past decade of our reporting on the military, intelligence community, and domestic law enforcement as it entered a new era of Darwinian evolution to counter violent extremism.

It also is our deep dive into a decade of American counterterrorism efforts -- from the work of commando trigger-pullers and spies on the ground up to senior political leaders who wanted to defend the nation (and get re-elected). Our efforts to report and write this book allowed us to uncover many new missions never discussed before -- and gave us an understanding of how the "war on terror" had changed over the last decade.

Our book assesses the 10 years since 9/11 as the military divides the fight: into tactical missions on the battlefields of modern terrorism; then the operational advancements that provided the means to success while not securing final victory; and at the top, the strategic level of policy debates about how the nation should combat this threat to its security.

Here are seven vignettes from Counterstrike that offer glimpses into the thinking of policymakers and commanders in early days after the Sept. 11 attacks and how that thinking evolved over the following decade into a more whole-of-government approach to combating terrorists:

ALEXANDER NEMENOV/AFP/Getty Images

 

Eric Schmitt is a terrorism and national security correspondent for the New York Times. Thomas Shanker is a Pentagon and national security correspondent for the Times.

BRAUERR31

2:31 PM ET

September 6, 2011

Wow.

As 9/11 approaches I'm actually getting a lot more nervous. I remember the exact place I was when the first tower went down. I was only in high school, yet I'll never forget exactly how I felt that day. I honestly hope that nothing bad happens on the 10th anniversary of this tragedy. Now, ten years later my emotions that arose on that day are still clear. In the mean time I'm going to express how to get your ex boyfriend back and flirt with a girl. I pray for all of those that lost loved ones on that horrific day in September.

 

EZONLINEATM

5:12 AM ET

September 7, 2011

Who would support murderers?

Why do people mix religion with politics? America is the big brother, the peacekeeper because it is a Super-Power. Most Muslims immigrate to non-Muslim countries for their safety and equality that they don't have back home!

America has a healthy and happy society!

Why don't the Muslim people realize that their own terror and abuse first comes from other Muslims ... their tyrannical leaders {Saddam/Qadaffi} and other Muslim sects. The Muslims do not tolerate other religions - but they want to be treated with dignity??

Even so, I think Americans bend over backwards for the general public Muslim who are a wonderful people when they are not involved in any form of hate or terrorism.

Unfortunately, so many atrocities in the world are committed by a few Muslims and they all get tainted by the same brush!

Wishes for Peace and love to all ...

 

SCREWED AND TATTOOED

1:31 PM ET

September 7, 2011

Slip

You are a bit dillusional and an outright pessimist. But then, the comments section has indeed turned into a hate mongering gripe session for the far left, blame America for everything, mind numbed zombies lately, so I guess you fit right in. Someone actually tries to be a little patriotic and express empathy for those who lost on 9/11 and you turn to bashing the country again. You my friend, and those like you, are the primary problem in this country. But I will continue to serve and protect your right, as well as the others like you, to be dopes and spout out silly notions and conspiracy theories. You're welcome.

 

SCREWED AND TATTOOED

10:34 AM ET

September 9, 2011

Whatever

"What makes you think serving increases my freedoms?

Military action increases terrorism. The military is the wrong tool to fight terror.

Aggressive policing and snatch operations work best.

What makes you think you serve the nation better than the CIA officer I quoted who ran the Osama bin Laden desk at the CIA and helped catch and kill him?

Weak dude."

First, if those who serve didn't serve, you'd be speaking German right now.

I never said the military was the best tool to fight terror. In fact, I agree whole heartedly that the military should not necessarily be used to police. However, the way it is used today and has been for a long time now, is just that in large part. It is a tool that is used to meet the political goals of those in charge. Which are civilians by the way. The argument that military action increases terrorism is still debatable too. IMO, those that hate us now wouldn't hate us any less if we hadn't gone to Iraq and Afganistan. They would just be able to train to carry out their hate in peace without having to watch their back.

Lastly, I never said I, or anyone, served any better than anyone else, CIA or otherwise. All who serve in whatever capacity to ensure freedom are patriots and deserve your respect. If you or anyone doesn't like the US you are all more than free to leave too. Go live where the women get their noses and ears cut off because they might have accidentally looked at another man or something. But don't bad mouth the military or anyone else who helps ensure our freedoms here don't go away.

I'd say you are the weak one here. Continue your nonsense conspiracy theories and criticisizing of this country if you will, but it is they who serve that help ensure your right to do so.

 

KASEMAN

10:51 AM ET

September 9, 2011

our leaders are AQ's force multplierse

At peak 9/10 AQ numbered less than 1000. Yes, less than1000
Our"leaders" conflated this to smear 1.4 billion Muslims as if they are one homogenous mob who "hate our freedoms"
Last year CIA capo Paneta said AQ numbered 50, all in Pakistan
Gen. Jame Jones countered its 100, also all in Pakistan. Correctly in Pushtoon areas east of the Durand Line. Pushtoons in A'stan and P'stan do not recgnize this boundary deliberately drawn to split them

So a few hundred wahabis scared /deranged this country of the brave into a paranoia unmatched in history. Our thuggish leaders got the excuse to launch 2 wars and all sorts of illegal killings elsewhere, effectively a crusade against Muslims, and imposed a high teach and expensve STASI on us.

The result? $2 trillions of our taxes, $6 trillions in economic losses, and rising. Ostensibly to wipe out few hundred AQs. Mission not accomplished despite spending $10 billion/AQ!

By launching on false pretences 1000 9/11 on the innocent Iraqis and then smashing the lives of 20 million Iraqis. Of course the media and Govt never recognize the Iraqis and Afghans killed by our bombs and bullets. They are collateral =un human, just as the German speaking Christians viewed Jews.
The Pentagon/ Dept of War, can't eliminate AQ and is being fought to a standstill by a mere 25,000 Taleban. Never has a military proved to be so incompetent and corrupt.
This war is for the benefit of the military-industrial--contractor complex. And Israel. It will go on for years
In effect our leaders have become AQ's force multipliers to the factor of 10! ObL's objective was not to impose anything Muslim or Islamic on us.. given his limited force. AQ is not that stupid unlike our leaders. ObL wanted to hurt us, and boy! has he trumped!
And these AQ force multipliers also messed up our economy big time.

FYI: There are over 100+ different Muslim sects, loke there are Protestants, broken down by race and interpretation. They are AQ's real enemies not the US or other Christian states . Arab is a language not a race. There are dozens of ethnicities within.

One emigrates to; immigrates into.

 

ANTIE

10:25 AM ET

September 13, 2011

War’s Victory over Terror!

Since the U.S has declared war on terror post 9/11, there have been many instances where the U.S legislative heads have secretly tried to strike a compromise, retaliate, threaten and even persuade the terror-inducing forces to alter their path and bring the massive destruction they are incurring to the world to an end. When all these tactics have failed, the government has finally decided to put their strong feet down by permitting the U.S. Navy Seals to attack Osama bin Laden. Like systemic enzymes, all the mollification strategies used by the government has only reinforced the notion that terrorism should be combated blatantly with all their might.

 

ANTHONIO

5:09 AM ET

September 20, 2011

What we need

why there is war ? when peace can be realize. Travel to the world and spread the peaceful joy.

Period Loan

 

TAYFA34

3:11 AM ET

September 30, 2011

Terror Very Bad

And Palestinian land will shrink, suicide bombers will respond, rockets will be launched and Israelis killed. Now Hezbollah and Sunnis have started up again in Lebanon. And Iran is powering up its nuclear capacity. Israel may feel impelled to react at some point if it calculates either Lebanon or Iran needs to be nipped in the bud. Add Syria to the toxic mix in Lebanon; and if things boil over there then Palestine will be left to sit and stew on the perennial international back burner. Hope, at this point, is not even a diamond in the rough. porno porno porno porno web tasarım

 

COWBOY69

4:39 AM ET

October 5, 2011

might be better

as bad as terror has become i am thankful for our troops and nato forces every day out there protecting us from this scum of the earth!
acne treatments

 

COWBOY69

4:44 AM ET

October 5, 2011

finally

the government has finally decided to put their strong feet down by permitting the U.S. Navy Seals to attack Osama bin Laden. Like systemic enzymes, all the mollification strategies used by the government has only reinforced the notion that terrorism should be combated blatantly with all their might.
acnezine