Return of the Renditioned

A Libyan rebel commander claims he was captured and tortured by the CIA. Who else has surfaced from the murky depths of the war on terror's list of the condemned?

BY KATHERINE HAWKINS | SEPTEMBER 7, 2011

THE SYRIAN PRISONERS

For all its condemnation of President Bashar al-Assad's human rights record, the United States appears to have had few qualms about sending terrorism suspects to Damascus. Although Almalki, Arar, and El-Maati have been released, seven prisoners whom the United States rendered to Syria remain missing. In interviews with journalist Stephen Grey, Almalki named six of them as his fellow prisoners in the underground cells at the Palestine Branch.

The first detained was Muhammad Haydar Zammar, a German citizen arrested in Morocco in December 2001, whom the United States questioned and then flew to Syria. Five others were transferred to Syria in May 2002: Barah Abdul Latif, Bahaa Mustafa Jaghel, Abdel Halim Dalak, Omar Ghramesh, and a teenager captured in the same raid as Abu Zubayda, whose name Almalki never learned.

The teenager -- who would now be well into his 20s -- was most likely Noor al-Deen, whom the Washington Post reported in 2009 was 19 years old when he was captured with Zubayda. Former CIA operative John Kiriakou told the Post that Deen cooperated with interrogators because "[h]e had come to the conclusion that his life was over," and was terrified that he was about to be executed. Instead he was transferred first to Morocco and later to Syria.

Another Syrian, Mustafa Setmariam Nasr, a high-level al Qaeda strategist who also holds Spanish citizenship, was detained in 2005 in Pakistan and turned over to the United States. Human rights groups have long suspected that Setmariam, who is also known as Abu Musab al-Suri, was later transferred to Syria. The Guantánamo documents released this spring by WikiLeaks confirm that Suri is detained "in his native Syria."

The U.S. and Syrian governments are unlikely to answer any questions about the detainees' rendition or their current whereabouts. If Assad's regime falls, perhaps activists or journalists will find the answers in a binder labeled "CIA" in one of the mukhabarat's many offices. Until then, they remain missing.

LOUAI BESHARA/AFP/Getty Images

 

Katherine Hawkins is a human rights lawyer who has closely followed U.S. rendition policy.

SEPPOIN

1:18 PM ET

September 8, 2011

Basis for labelling someone Terrorist

New Dawn,

You seem to know a lot about the terrorists "these guys train to withstand torture", "they KNOW that it goes with the job they volunteer for". If you have more details about the terrorists, Please inform the CIA.

How did you decide these folks are terrorists? Don't tell "They are terrorists because US renditioned them". The question would be "Why did US rendition them?". Why did Canada pay compensation to a terrorist?

Actually, you have no idea about them.

 

CINGOZ439

4:58 AM ET

September 30, 2011

Crisis

Now looking to get rid of the curse of terrorism turkey bulunu?u in states all over the world thought otherwise, all states should fight against terrorism is a terrorism problem will continue. Terrorism be fought on one front
sikiş sikiş
sikiş
sikiş
web tasarım

 

CRUNCHBERRY21

10:52 PM ET

October 3, 2011

I think it has to be done

The abuses within Temara prison are no longer the secret to demonstrators in Morocco. Upon May 15, people in the country's February Twenty protest movement tried to hold a picnic close to the site of the jail they refer to because "Guantemara." Police spread the gathering and defeat protesters with truncheons.

 

YARINSIZ

2:15 PM ET

October 6, 2011

and yes, anyone and everyone

and yes, anyone and everyone who has done the slightest research into the topic knows that the terorists train to withstand torture...even the US army does.. seslichat as do most militaries and spy agencies..