Day of the Hooligans

The tenuous relationship between Egypt and Israel is going up in flames.

BY MOHAMED FADEL FAHMY | SEPTEMBER 15, 2011

CAIRO - Egyptians were rallied to the streets on Sept. 9 for protests that were dubbed as a step toward "correcting the path of the revolution." But anger over a political transformation that has been slow in coming turned into an attack on the Israeli Embassy in Cairo that dramatically altered the course of Egypt's domestic uprising.

The Israeli Embassy raid in Giza was caused by the convergence of multiple factors: a spike in anti-Israeli anger, which was already running high over the killing of five Egyptian soldiers just across the Gaza border following an Aug. 18 terrorist attack near the Israeli city of Eilat; the outpouring of anger at the Egyptian police that has accompanied the revolution; and even the hooliganism of some local soccer fans. But whatever the cause for the violence, it is clear that Egypt -- as well as Israel's other stalwart ally in the region, Turkey -- is looking to distance itself from its former partner, with potentially drastic effects on the entire Middle East.

The mood in Tahrir Square, around two miles from the Israeli Embassy, on Sept. 9 remained festive, until groups of pro-democracy protesters carrying hammers marched toward the embassy. They were intent on breaking down a concrete security wall that had been built a week earlier after previous protests threatened the embassy. Egypt's military rulers, who had previously moved to shut down popular demonstrations, had issued a statement the previous day that allowed protesters to take to the streets in Tahrir, as long as they didn't remain overnight.

"We will withdraw all our police and Army officers from the square for 24 hours to give way to a peaceful protest," Lt. Col. Amr Imam, the media spokesman of the armed forces, told me before the protest. "We urge political powers and organizers to control the crowds to avoid any attacks on public property, which we will not tolerate."

Imam would not get his wish, but then again, he didn't keep his promise either. Outside the embassy, hundreds of charged protesters hammered down and scaled the concrete wall as residents and bystanders cheered. As nighttime closed around 6 p.m., most of the wall was destroyed, and the sky lit up with celebratory fireworks. The protest seemed to have a momentum all its own: "Are we going to war?" Ashraf Nagi, one of many protesters watching the rowdy crowd in shock, asked me.

Violence erupted around 9 p.m. on a back street between the Israeli and Saudi embassies, when dozens of angry protesters attacked an anti-riot police unit stationed there. The police officers were outnumbered, and they fled, running toward the Giza police headquarters several hundred meters away and leaving behind two trucks filled with supplies. By the time the violence was over, 1,049 people had been injured, many from tear gas inhalation, and three were dead, according the Health Ministry.

The angry crowd was a combination of soccer hooligans and pro-democracy protesters who had two common enemies: the police and Israel. Ever since the first day of the uprising on Jan. 25 -- Egypt's Police Day -- one of the revolution's original demands was the end of police brutality. Now, almost eight months later, the police have remained committed to their old ways: On Sept. 6, they stormed the bleachers of a soccer match, attacking a faction of supporters of the popular Al Ahly club, known as the "Ultras." Post-match clashes spilled outside the stadium, leaving 133 people, including 71 security officers, injured.

On Sept. 7, dozens of Ultras showed up outside the trial of deposed President Hosni Mubarak and threatened the police, chanting, "We burned your trucks and took you down on the 25th, you rats; we'll do it again on September 9th."

The Ultras made good on their promise. Protesters burned the first two trucks they came across, and thick clouds of black smoke billowed in the sky. The demonstrators claimed their victory as they ran out of the trucks, waving two stolen machine guns, tear gas bombs, helmets, and protective gear.

The Giza police headquarters was the next target of the protesters. Outside the building, armed police stood in two rows, urging the protesters to refrain from hurling stones at them. One Army officer who had been attempting to negotiate with the protesters was struck on the head with a stone, which drew blood. Another police commander waved an Egyptian flag, but the growing number of protesters refused his appeal to patriotism as they chanted in defiance, "Our police are pimps; who do we go to? Forget your Mubarak; you only have us to teach you a lesson."

-/AFP/Getty Images

 

Mohamed Fadel Fahmy is the author of Baghdad Bound and works as a freelance news producer/journalist for CNN in Cairo.

COMETLINEAR

1:58 PM ET

September 15, 2011

Do Egyptians really believe that their govt's Israel policy

...is going to improve their lives in any way?

Hatred against Israel is a perfect reflection of bitterness over one's own life.

 

MUTT3003

3:07 PM ET

September 15, 2011

Bribed no more...

Since Obama allowed the ouster of Mubarak, Israel has one less bribed neighbor willing to play patsy. With Turkey on the offensive against it and AIPACs war in Iraq not working out so well, who is Israel going to turn to for help in the Middle East? Saudi Arabia? I don't think the US can bribe them enough. Besides, they have enough trouble on their hands with Iran. Maybe they can try lording over Syria. Yeah, that'll work. Lebanon? Nah.
Looks like Israel is on its own. And about time.

 

ALEXWORK

4:12 AM ET

September 16, 2011

Agree with Mutt3003...

"Looks like Israel is on its own. And about time."

I agree. They are big boys. They certainly don't need our billions in aid, or "stalwart" allies like Turkey (who haven't been a huge fan of them lately either). My only feeling that runs contrary to this is that Israel will feel the need to further colonize the Palestenians out of a need to feel that they are further strengthening their borders.

Time will tell.

 

HUNTER14

4:26 AM ET

September 16, 2011

Anti Semitism

You might want to mention the fact that, as far as I can see, no Arab commentator is willing to tackle--Antisemitism in the Arab world. Jews have been ethnically cleansed from Arab countries. Since 1948 more than 1 million Jews were driven out of Arab countries. In addition Egypt is a hotbed of antisemitism with the Protocols of the Elders of Zion and Mein Kampf being best sellers. The only issue that all Arabs can get behind is their hatred of Jews. And please don't start telling me that they are anti-zionists and not antisemites. The favored Arab chant of Itbach al yehud is slaughter the Jews, not slaughter the Israelis.

 

PUPIL

10:24 AM ET

September 16, 2011

Anti Semitism and the Aryans

Nicely and politically correctly put:
As usually, it is going to backfire on the face of the jews.

Well, you guys played this tune before. The music stopped in some Berlin bunker. It is going to happen again.

 

SKELMOSS

1:22 PM ET

September 16, 2011

You can be anti Israel but

You can be anti Israel but not anti Judaism, it is you who chooses to link the two. Don't link an otherwise beautiful religion to the actions of Israel. Did you know that the zionist movement was originally offered Ethiopia, but they refused that land. Why? This is not about religion it is about land and it is fundamentally wrong. If the British and the rest of the world had not caused such an upheaval of Palestinians I am certain that everyone would have coexisted peacefully on the lands. Israeli often forget that at one point in history they were also called terrorists, but once they put on uniforms and called themselves military that was no longer the case. Arab's who are anti Semitic are absolutely in the wrong. They should not link a religion that is suppose to be based on peace to the actions of a Zionist nation. Let us not forget the immense sufferig that those people have endured in that region. You speak of ethnic cleansing, but remember Muslims were killed by Hitler as well, and lets not forget Bosnia... and before the turn of the century there were people and they were called Palestinians. You can be a Jew and recognize that what Israel is doing is fundamentally wrong. People have reached their breaking point in the Middle East. They are oppressed and if this past years events have not made that clear, then I do not know what will. Everyone deserves their basic human rights, equality, the right to raise a family, the right to food, work ect.. Regardless of whether you are Muslim, Christian, Jewish or Atheist. Leaders in that part of the world seem to have forgotten that. It is the leaders that used religion to leverage their war for land and is so sad that a people who were so severely oppressed and experienced genocide, would turn around and do the same to others.

 

JACOB BLUES

9:32 AM ET

September 16, 2011

Soccer Hooligans?

Please, more excuses from the Arab world.

What we firebombed an embassy? Who us? Nah, couldn't be.

Oh it was? Oh wait, we must have been provoked, it must have been a cartoon, it must have been a story, it must have been something because after all, we're a peaceful state here in Egypt?

What's that? We already rioted against our brother state of Algeria? Well OK, we'll fess up to that, but that was football, and the bastards rightfully deserved it.

But Israel? Why would we go after the Jews, I mean look at us, they're practically neighbors? Oh wait, you mean neighbors that we ran out of town under threat of death during 1948 and 1967? Well, it couldn't have been that bad, look at all the presents they left us - property, jewlery, bank accounts - everything. I mean why would they just do that.

And its not like the Egyptian government has been spouting anti-Semitic hatred for 60 years? C'mon, what, like we've been broadcasting the Protocols of the Elders of Zion? Get real, next you'll be telling us that Israelis are training sharks to eat tourists off the Sinai Penninsua . . . oh wait, that was us. Well that was only because they deep-sixed our man who tried to become the head of UNESCO last year? What?!? No way, he wouldn't say that he would burn Jewish books if given the opportunity, that's just a Zionist lie, just let me put my torch down over here on this pile of books and I'll show you that we didn't mean to do it.

But hey Israel had it coming, after all they shot our guards. . . so what if HAMAS did the same thing a year ago, they don't have an embassy to burn down, and besides, they're a good export market for everything from AK-47's to rocket launchers. Wait, you mean that the terrorists who came from the Sinai were dressed in Egyptian military uniforms? Couldn't be, next you'll be telling us that the gas line explosions were works of terror as well.

 

JOSSEFPERL

10:43 AM ET

September 16, 2011

The Mob Attack on the Israeli Embassy Makes Egypt Looks Like Ira

The mob attack on the Israeli emabassy in Cairo looks exactly like that on the US embassy in Iran in the 1980s. According to the western media, the people who stormed the embassy were supposed to be the young educated Egyptians who would make Egypt into a liberal democracy. With every day passing, the Egyptian revolution looks less like a freedom revolution and more like an Egyptian version of the Iranian revolution, where the Muslim Brotherhood is the Sunni version of the Iranian Mullahs.

 

TOUFU

4:50 PM ET

September 16, 2011

When Egyptians protest

When Egyptians protest against Israeli embassy, they are called "hooligans", have you no shame? How is legitimate people's protests against the principle of democracy? This shows that westerners' notion of "democracy" is "do what we say".

 

ACOMPANHE

8:17 AM ET

September 17, 2011

Agree with Mutt

I agree. They are big boys. They certainly don't need our billions in aid, or "stalwart" allies like Turkey (who haven't been a huge fan of them lately either). My only feeling that runs contrary to this....and indeed they are strengthening their frontiers, thank you for the beautiful work

Ar Condicionado Massagista Acompanhantes

 

BEVERLEYYOUNCEQN

6:06 PM ET

October 2, 2011

RE

Thank you for assisting to consider this opinion, I feel intensive about opinion and would like to learn a great deal of things on this item. If possible, as you master knowledge, would you mind updating your web site with loads of more info? It’s very benificial for me.

Mike HGH CEO

 

YARINSIZ

3:47 PM ET

October 6, 2011

You might want to mention the

You might want to mention the fact that, as far as I can see, no Arab commentator is willing to tackle--Antisemitism in the Arab world. Jews have been ethnically cleansed from Arab countries. Since 1948 more than 1 million Jews were driven out of Arab countries. In addition Egypt is a hotbed of antisemitism with the Protocols of the Elders of Zion and Mein Kampf being best sellers. The only issue that all Arabs seslichat can get behind is their hatred of Jews. And please don't start telling me that they are anti-zionists and not antisemites

 

DEBTDUE

12:03 AM ET

October 8, 2011

Has anything changed?

There has been some time since the regime was in power, but I don't see that anything has changed in this matter. Here we are a couple of months later and now we are right back at square one. There are innocent protesters getting killed by the military, so how have things gotten better? The problem with all of this is that there is no plan after the revolution succeeds, and you are left with a little chaos and a lot of the same things, because there are no plans on how to run the country. From what I can tell from the pictures coming from my tv stand nothing has changed and it doesn't seem like things will. As bad as a dictatorship is with repression, at least there is some order and things are able to function somewhat....anyways...just kinda irked that nothing has changed in Egypt.

 

CHRISBIKER

5:37 AM ET

October 13, 2011

They should not link

They should not link a religion that is suppose to be based on peace to the actions of a Zionist nation. exercising bike Let us not forget the immense sufferig that those people have endured in that region. You speak of ethnic cleansing, but remember Muslims were killed by Hitler as well, and lets not forget Bosnia