Can a Supercomputer Predict a Revolution?

Not quite yet. But a new study suggests how it may one day be possible.

BY JOSHUA E. KEATING | SEPTEMBER 16, 2011

On Dec. 6, 1941, the Foreign Broadcast Information Service (FBIS), a radio monitoring operation set up by the U.S. intelligence community and one of the earliest experiments in what it now called open-source intelligence, delivered its very first report, an analysis of Japanese media sentiment. The report noted that Japanese radio stations had sharply increased their level of criticism of the United States and dropped their calls for peace. The next day, Pearl Harbor was attacked.

Obviously, no amount of media monitoring would have revealed when and where the attack would take place (that's what spies are for), but it's certainly possible that with a better sense of the likelihood of an attack, U.S. forces might not have been caught quite so unawares. Some 70 years later, one computer scientist believes that a somewhat more ambitious version of the same type of news monitoring may soon be able to predict social upheavals and conflicts -- such as the recent revolutions in the Arab world -- with a remarkable degree of accuracy.

Kalev Leetaru, the assistant director for text and digital media analytics at the University of Illinois's Institute for Computing in the Humanities, Arts, and Social Science, is one of the leading researchers in the emerging field of conflict early-warning. In a paper published this month in the peer-reviewed online technology journal First Monday, Leetaru argues that "computational analysis of large text archives can yield novel insights to the functioning of society."

Leetaru's study builds on recent economics research looking at how the tone of news and social media coverage can predict economic events. One recent paper, for instance, found that the general mood state on Twitter can anticipate the movements of the Dow Jones Industrial Average. Leetaru was curious whether the same type of analysis could predict social events.  

Leetaru employed several massive databases of news articles over the last 30 years, including the "Summary of World Broadcasts" -- English translations of foreign broadcasts done by the British equivalent of the FBIS -- the complete digital archives of the New York Times, and a web crawl of online news sites, to create a dataset of around 100 million news articles dating back to 1979. He then fed this raw material into one of the world's most powerful supercomputers, the University of Tennessee's "Nautilus," and began to look for patterns.

In recent years, companies have increasingly deployed "sentiment mining" software to gauge the tone of news coverage. Think of it as a hypersophisticated Google Alerts: These programs scan news articles for positive and negative words and can also distinguish the severity of feeling, knowing the difference between "loathe" and "dislike" for instance. The software misses a lot of nuance and can be fooled by sarcasm, but at the scale of data Leetaru was working with, it gives a pretty good indication of global media sentiment on a given topic.

Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: AFGHANISTAN
 

Joshua E. Keating is an associate editor at Foreign Policy.

JAMESLIP

1:03 AM ET

September 17, 2011

Japanese

I wonder on what OS it runs...

This study obviously was conducted in retrospect, but I wonder if it had been done before the revolutions and the data was announced to the world. Also I do I ask myself, what if that machine can compute its own impact on daily world events...unlikely.

Regarding the Japanese language and culture anti sentiment back in the Pearl Harbor days. Those included hatred, grievance, distrust, dehumanization, intimidation, fear, hostility, and/or general dislike of the Japanese people. I remember it as it if it was yesterday. Terrible.

Thanks for this great read.

Warm regards,
James L.

 

OYUNSON

3:38 AM ET

September 17, 2011

teoric capacity problem

Any computer can not be smarter than it's own creator. As James said, which OS will it use determine it's capacity. Also I think Facebook use such a super computer.

 

RESZKA

3:30 PM ET

October 13, 2011

Yes it is feasible if certain

Yes it is feasible if certain perimeters are imputed into the pc. Without every predetermined variables, the computer would be blind to proceed. As I make positive my web sites on what is a short finale sale along with health and wellness care cost, I give a qualified yes to your premise.

 

JONATHAN BROWNE

6:55 AM ET

September 17, 2011

Definitely Possible

It's definitely possible to predict a potential for revolution through a supercomputer. There would need to be more revolutions as well as access to the complete data on the revolutions that have happened largely as a result of the internet.

I think it could only have predictive capability if the cause of the revolution succeeding is largely the internet.

-Jon from last longer

 

ACOMPANHE

7:49 AM ET

September 17, 2011

Teoric capacity problem ...

Any computer can not be smarter than it's own creator. As James said, which OS will it use determine it's capacity. Also I think Facebook use such a super computer
I also agree! the machine can never be smarter than the creator .... I think, because nowadays it is no doubt the technology, but who creates them is smarter!
Ar Condicionado
Massagista
Acompanhantes

 

HECTORBD

11:17 AM ET

September 17, 2011

Interesting

This is again a scenario possibly on a not so distant future. Who knows, this can indeed be possible, with a supercomputer with supersoftware from super programming as well.

 

GRANT

7:41 PM ET

September 17, 2011

It also relies on good

It also relies on good intelligence. That usually wouldn't be a problem, but in a mostly-closed state like North Korea or even Eritrea it would have much more difficulty in making predictions. Of course even with that I have to face the possibility that I might have just been made obsolete.

 

ASKSCOTTS

8:30 AM ET

September 18, 2011

teoric capacity problem

Well, well what we have here? I agree with the fact that a computer cannot be smarter than his creator and that the creator of the supercomputer has to feed it with datas for it to work properly and yield the required information.
Then again what was impossible yesterday is today completely possible, even beyond the wildest dream of the postulants of the idea. Now, i know for sure the human mind has the capacity to create whatever it set it to.A good example of it is in the world of video editing creators of home movies or videos are being so creative that 20 years ago, we could not have imagined that we will be able to enjoy such master piece as The movie Avatar.We are incredible being when our mind is set for good or even bad, if that is what we pretend to achieve.
So my conclusion is yesterday is gone, but bold minds and real dreamers are those who build our world, our universe one step up; it is quite possible that supercomputer someday will predict a revolution.

Think again....

 

SEANMARTINSVILLE

2:34 PM ET

September 18, 2011

Yes with right variables

Yes it is possible if certain perimeters are imputed into the computer. Without any predetermined variables, the computer would be blind to proceed. As I make good my blogs on What is a short sale and health care cost, I give a qualified yes to your premise.

 

BJOLF9D0SA

8:07 PM ET

September 18, 2011

very good web: ===

very good web: === http://www.plzzshop.com

The website wholesale for many kinds of fashion shoes, like the nike, jordan, prada, also including the jeans, shirts, bags, hat and the decorations.

All the products are free shipping, and the the price is competitive, and also can accept the paypal payment., After the payment, can ship within short time.

We will give you a discount

WE ACCEPT PYAPAL PAYMENT

YOU MUST NOT MISS IT!!!

=== http://www.plzzshop.com

thank you!!!

Believe you will love it.

We have good reputation, fashion products,

come here quickly== http://www.plzzshop.com

Opportunity knocks but once

 

KRITHELLDE

8:30 AM ET

September 19, 2011

http://www.chic-goods.com/

Wonderful.

Share a website with you ,

( http://www.chic-goods.com/ )

Believe you will love it.

We accept any form of payment.

 

GREGBUNT

1:47 PM ET

October 7, 2011

Leetaru's study builds

Leetaru's study builds on recent economics research looking at how the tone of news and social media coverage can predict economic events. One recent paper, for instance snowblower2011, found that the general mood state on Twitter can anticipate the movements of the Dow Jones Industrial Average. Leetaru was curious whether the same type of analysis could predict social events

 
 

DEBTDUE

2:13 AM ET

October 14, 2011

If the Mayans can

With 2012 fast approaching...why can't a computer predict conflicts? The Mayans might have been accurate with the prediction of the end of the world, and all signs point that they were right in their prediction (sarcasm). But regardless, I think there are things that you can monitor that can predict chaos or conflict arising. For instance, there is so much data know that computers are so well connected. All of the usage stats have to be mind blowing, and in these there has to be some data that occurs when things are getting hot. I bet there are some signals that showed up in Syria, Libya, and Egypt in terms of social media and the types of tweets....All I am saying is that there are a ton of different ways to sort through the data and find a common thread among the dates and times of past conflicts and what was happening online. If there is a day when these predictions can be made, I will know when to travelinsurance compare before I head into any of these areas...Very interesting article and if you spend enough time and money you can accomplish anything, just ask the US military.

 

YARINSIZ

7:50 PM ET

October 14, 2011

Then again what was

Then again what was impossible yesterday is today completely possible, even beyond the wildest dream of the postulants of the idea. Now, i know for sure the human mind has the capacity to create whatever it set it to.A good example of it is in the world of video seslichat editing creators of home movies or videos are being so creative that 20 years ago, we could not have imagined that we will be able to enjoy such master piece as The movie Avatar.