The Return of the King

It's official: Vladimir Putin is Russia's once and future president. So how come we're surprised all over again?

BY JULIA IOFFE | SEPTEMBER 24, 2011

MOSCOW – Back in December 2007, with his second presidential term running out, Vladimir Putin decided not to violate the letter of the Russian constitution. Instead, he chose to step down, become prime minister, and nominate one of his old St. Petersburg buddies, an aide named Dmitry Medvedev, for president. Back then, a good joke started to make the rounds: Russia, 2023. Putin and Medvedev are sitting in one of their kitchens, drinking and shooting the breeze. "Listen," slurs Putin. "I've lost track again. Which one of us is prime minister, and which is president?"

"You're the president now, I think," slurs Medvedev.

"Well," slurs Putin, "then it's your turn to go and get more beer."

It was a prophetic joke, and one that turned out to be all too accurate Saturday, when Medvedev announced the latest switch: Putin will return to the presidency in next year's election and Medvedev will take up the prime minister's post. And yet the joke was somehow lost on us over the last four years as we (rightly) let other debates get in the way, from the long silly distraction of wondering who was actually in charge (answer: Putin, of course) to the disputes over whether to believe Medvedev's talk of modernization. Even despite these last few months, when it became clear that Putin would come back, we managed to be surprised all over again when it actually happened.

"It was the most obvious and therefore the least probable move of the ones I could have predicted," said Andrei Kolesnikov, the Kommersant journalist who, in his intimate chronicles of Putin, has become the man's hagiographer. We were standing in the press section of the grandstands at the convention for the United Russia ruling party, looking down on the swarm of thousands of delegates filing their paper ballots in unanimous support of Putin's party platform.

"We all waited for this moment for a long time, and still this is a surprise precisely because it's so obvious," he said. "It'd be nice to have some actual surprises because the situation is just so stable" -- Putin's watchword -- "that when they made the announcement, I got really sleepy. Really. Because this is for keeps."

While Kolesnikov drifted off, the Twittering masses of Russia were either euphoric or in despair, depending on their political leanings. The despairing liberals, a dwindling crowd after two decades of dashed post-Soviet hopes, were utterly winded and deflated. Why does God hate Russia, one asked. And then everyone started doing the math: How old would we be when Putin finally leaves office in 2024 (a date that supposes he serves two more consecutive terms, which were extended to six years back in 2008)? Russia's digital airwaves quickly filled with a younger generation bemoaning their lost youth: Many of them will be pushing 40 by then, and they've already spent their last 12 years under his watch.

"When Putin finishes his second six-year term, I'll already be 58," one older blogger wrote. "Almost my entire life will have been spent with him." He punctuated this with a frown.

But Kolesnikov, at least, was still seeing a glimmer of opportunity in this latest Kremlin machination. "I hope we'll see a new Putin, this is my only hope," he told me, "because the earlier iterations have exhausted themselves."

NATALIA KOLESNIKOVA/AFP/Getty Images

 

Julia Ioffe is Foreign Policy's Moscow correspondent.

NICHOLAS WIBBERLEY

9:39 AM ET

September 25, 2011

Good luck to him.

Monarchy of some kind (benevolent of course) is quite the best way to run a large country with a significant foreign policy agenda. The US system is hopeless for foreign policy, like trying to plough a field in a tux and patent leather pumps.

 

OWENGOLDSMITH

8:43 AM ET

September 26, 2011

good luck

Monarchy is far better than other systems in my opinion. Owen @ wrestling shoes

 

ALEHANDRO20

3:24 AM ET

September 26, 2011

Russia against Putin

Damn this fucking Col. KGB!!!

 

BING520

10:33 AM ET

September 26, 2011

Russian

I wonder how Russian people feel about Putin's running for the president. Julia Ioffe barely touched the subject. After all, it is the Russian voters who decide Putin's future. Is there any way to gauge the mood of Russian peopl toward Putin now?

 

LITTLEMANTATE

12:33 PM ET

September 27, 2011

Good question

and for Western interventionists, an uncomfortable one. What if Russians are ok with a figure like Putin? If they are in favor of Putin, then, we must, as good Messianic, Manichean Americans, assume it is because the Russians are irredeemably evil. Democracy, after all, even if it does consist of ill-informed, easily manipulated and/or frightened, emotional voters who operate on pathological ideologies or crass spoils systems politics, is obviously the only acceptable form of government. A further definition of democracy would be that form of government most pliable to the demands of GE and other corporations.

Is anyone under any illusions about Putin, even his supporters? What is the realistic alternative, that will not bring Russia back to the brink, as she was in the 1990s?

All the hand-wringing over Putin boils down to he's not an incompetent, pliable degenerate like Yeltsin, who let his country get raped by multinational corporations and oligarchs. It was under Yeltin's watch, sometime advised by one of Larry Summers' proteges, that the life-expectancy for Russian males declined by something like 15 years. Note the American lionization of the Ukrainian oligarchs a little while ago. That type of corporatist, pro-Western good governance plan, which has done so much for the Russians, is now coming to an America near you.

 

BRIGIDDA

6:02 PM ET

September 26, 2011

None of us are surprised--except that Foreign Policy is...

Saw this coming from the time his term had temporarily concluded and he became Prime Minister. Conclusions aren't permanent in Russia unless you're an opponent.

 

COMETLINEAR

11:22 PM ET

September 26, 2011

Way too much plastic surgery

Mr. Putin clearly understands how to use the media, but he needs to find a new plastic surgeon.

 

GETLIKES

7:50 AM ET

September 27, 2011

I would like to hear just

I would like to hear just what currency would replace the US Dollar these days? The Euro? Not likely, that leaves China's RMB, which they don't want to use as a reserve currency because it would have to float freely.

 

AR

10:26 AM ET

September 28, 2011

Ioffe is just a good stooge

Ioffe is just a good stooge for her handlers in the States. Her articles are always full of bile, distorted, and free of substance. And yes, Putin is still popular with the Russian people. For every bad twit that was made after the announcement, there were at least a 100 positive ones. Don't believe key-board warriors like Julia, after-all, it is her job to demonize Russia.

 

DOTMAN

10:17 AM ET

October 9, 2011

Comparison

It would be nice to hear a Political Analyst/Actual Journalist compare the fact that Putin took on a basket case that was waging a war against Islamists very unsuccessfully, had been sold to corporations at a token price, had no economy to speak of and felt it was dying (in some corners of Russia it was!), turning it around in less than a decade, with........say, a US President (who was "(s)elected" chuckle) who took on the worlds richest and most dynamic nation, took it into unending wars with Islamists very unsuccessfully, Sold it to the corporations, bailed them out to the tune of 100's of billions of dollars, failed to get them to act in the interests of the Americans so investigated them and fined them Millions (Slippery Oligarchs or what!) handed over to another President who having promised loads did the exact opposite and gave the corporations more 100's of billions ( bank robbers, car jackers, drug dealers, pimps et al must be wishing they had paid attention in class, if only they had made Ivy league) continued the unsuccessful wars, backed a new one, made heavily subsidized arms deals with Israel in case they want a war with Islamists, oversaw the death of what few non militarily useful industries the US has, won a Nobel peace prize for making promises (or was that for being black? coz if so surely that belongs to the US electorate, I'm black in case anyone wants to make something of that last statement), a peace prize for promises never kept nor intended imo and a brand spanking new "Badge Of Honour".

I think America needs its own Putin, if only to turn the thumb screws on its own Oligarchs and some so called Journalists.

Does America take itself seriously anymore?

 

APOSTOL_K

10:59 PM ET

September 28, 2011

Pecisely!

AR, you hit the bull's-eye! :)

 

WILDTHING

1:51 PM ET

September 29, 2011

King for a day

At least they know who is in charge whereas here the power behind the Imperial President is unknown and even the President doesn't have a need to know... there was the cold war shadow government maybe that is it or maybe it is just the CIA... but now the Bushes are out that is not so clear anymore but with Putin what you see is what you get. What we do know here is that the number of unsolved suspicious mysteries just keeps growing all the time.

 

AR

10:49 PM ET

September 29, 2011

Spot on!

Spot on!

 

NOISYDUDE2

1:42 AM ET

September 30, 2011

I agree

I think this attitude is suitable for russia's needs...
See more info at http://marferiky.com/

 

DARREN ROGERS

1:07 AM ET

October 3, 2011

Putin is good

I have followed Vladimir since he first came on the scene, and I still believe he's the best guy for Russia. Look at the growth of their economy, the increasing number of jobs, the decrease of domestic violence - it all shows just how good a job a strong leader can be for a country, especially a complex one like Russia.

For him to come back at this time means there is a good future for Russia, and the federation that has become one of the world's great economies.

 

WORDPRESSER

3:02 AM ET

October 3, 2011

He reminds me of the Russian version of Jersey Shore

Actually that is because of the difference in the political setuips between the countries.

In the US, since we dont have a Prime Minister, the President is essentially 2 rolls in one - Head of State and Leader of the country.

Medev is President and form what ive researched is their Head of State. Putin is essentially like the Queen of England except with more power. He gets to do all the "fun" stuff - ribbon cutting, wresteling with polar bears, boxing with leopards and riding around on a horse that has not been seen since the dinosaur age shirtless.

Yes - he reminds me of the Russian version of Jersey Shore.

 

DOTMAN

12:15 PM ET

October 9, 2011

Jersey Shore

Jersey Shore fans and research don't go together. The Russian President is head of state and has full executive powers. The Prime minister is head of The president's Government.

PS Head of State is the leader of the country. You probably meant leader of the government.

Now you know what it does to your brain say no to reality TV.

 

YARINSIZ

6:14 PM ET

October 18, 2011

All the hand-wringing over

All the hand-wringing over Putin boils down to he's not an incompetent, pliable degenerate like Yeltsin, who let his country get raped by multinational corporations and oligarchs. It was under Yeltin's watch, sometime advised by one of Larry seslichat Summers' proteges, that the life-expectancy for Russian males declined by something like 15 years. Note the American lionization of the Ukrainian oligarchs a little while ago. That type of corporatist, pro-Western good governance plan, which has done so much for the Russians, is now coming to an America near you.

 

ELI

6:21 PM ET

October 24, 2011

It was the most obvious and

It was the most obvious and therefore the least probable move of the ones I could have predicted," said Andrei Kolesnikov, the Kommersant journalist who, in his intimate chronicles of Putin, has become the man's hagiographer. We were standing in the press section of the grandstands at the convention for the United Russia ruling party, looking down on the swarm of thousands of delegates filing their paper ballots in unanimous support of Putin's party platform. Search for executive jobs Melbourne.

 

RESZKA

9:08 PM ET

October 24, 2011

What's infallible to me is that ...

What's infallible to me is that the office of head of state, upheld as it was by the ignominy of every other institution over the last ten years, has squandered quite a bit of its legitimacy here. United Russia, concocted a decade ago to be the state's new dominating political body, has obviously been struck a body blow. It is being steadily destroyed by the nebula that is a new body founded by Putin identified as the National People's Front, while United Russia will certainly at this moment be guided through the parliamentary polls by Medvedev, a gentleman who was recently publicly deprived of his sceptre. That may be positive news for many people who are of the opinion that United Russia is a party of scoundrels, robbers and build my rank oligarchs. But what does this imply for Russia? That's not a sound situation; still, it may be with us for years to come.