Yemen's Unhappy Ending

Sometimes, the bad guys win.

BY CHARLES SCHMITZ | SEPTEMBER 27, 2011

Back in June, when Yemeni President Ali Abdullah Saleh left for Saudi Arabia for treatment of his wounds, most observers thought Yemen's political crisis would be resolved in favor of the political opposition and the revolutionary street protesters. If Saleh -- who was badly burned in an attack on his presidential mosque -- did not die, then he would at least be prisoner of the Saudis, who had been actively seeking his resignation. Few thought he would ever return. And inside Yemen, the pro-Saleh forces would be weak without the president, so it was a hopeful time for those opposed to Saleh's rule. A transitional government would oversee a new set of elections that would usher in a new post-Saleh era.

That was then.

Over the bloody summer, the Saleh clan proved itself more than capable of holding on to its political position. The president's sons and nephews, who preside over key security and military positions, aggressively sought conflict. Sporadic fighting raged all over the country: in Taiz, in Sanaa, in Arhab, in Abyan, in Aden, and elsewhere. 

In Sanaa, most victims of the fighting were civilians. Saleh's supporters seemed to almost relish provoking the military defectors aligned with Ali Mohsen al-Ahmar, the top general who joined the "revolutionaries" in March and promised to protect them.

The attacks on civilians not only sent a message to protesters, but also revealed the weakness of Ahmar's forces. Indeed, all the various groups opposed to Saleh's rule -- including Ahmar's 1st Armored Division, the revolutionaries in the streets, the forces allied with tribal leader Sadeq al-Ahmar (not related to Ali Mohsen al-Ahmar), and the political parties of the Yemeni opposition -- together appeared incapable of tipping the balance of power in their favor. There were no elections, nor was the opposition able to form a successful transitional government, despite attempts to do so.

And Saleh did not die from his wounds. As a "guest" of Saudi Arabia, he recovered and over the summer was seen acting presidential -- meeting in the hospital compound with some of the other Yemeni government officials who were injured in the attack.

Western officials tried to quickly manufacture facts on the ground by dealing with the vice president, Abd al-Rab Mansur al-Hadi, as if he truly were the acting power in Yemen. Formally, Hadi was the acting head of state, but Ahmed Saleh, the president's son and commander of the Republican Guard, locked Hadi out of the presidential palace and forced him to work at home -- sending a clear signal about who was in charge.

KHALED FAZAA/AFP/Getty Images

 

Charles Schmitz is associate professor of geography at Towson University and a scholar at the Middle East Institute in Washington.

PFNOVAK

3:26 AM ET

September 28, 2011

And other than the possible

And other than the possible exception of some Southern opposition figures, I doubt there are any real good guys in Yemen. Not saying this as an indictment of the Yemeni people, who most certainly deserve better than what they've had the past half-century. But the North is run by tribes that would make the Taliban blush and even the liberals in the South are the descendants of the YSP which could not stop its bloody internal power struggles from spilling over into massive civilian violence.
We Americans like to make bleak statements about Iraq and Afghanistan, but we should show some respect for those who have tried in vain to fix their own countries for so long.

 

KAMPER

10:19 AM ET

September 28, 2011

 

DIEGOANDRADE

12:25 PM ET

September 29, 2011

Yemen

I do not consider this an unhappy ending for Yemen's people. The first step was given, they recognised they are able to unite and try to change something. They only lost the first round. The fight goes on.

 

YARINSIZ

4:04 PM ET

October 25, 2011

Not saying this as an

Not saying this as an indictment of the Yemeni people, who most certainly deserve better than what they've had the past half-century. But the North is run by tribes that would make the seslichat Taliban blush and even the liberals in the South are the descendants of the YSP which could not stop its bloody internal power struggles from spilling over into massive civilian violence.

 

ELI

7:59 PM ET

October 25, 2011

The attacks on civilians not

The attacks on civilians not only sent a message to protesters, but also revealed the weakness of Ahmar's forces. Indeed, all the various groups opposed to Saleh's rule -- including Ahmar's 1st Armored Division, the revolutionaries in the streets, the forces allied with tribal leader Sadeq al-Ahmar (not related to Ali Mohsen al-Ahmar), and the political parties of the Yemeni opposition -- together appeared incapable of tipping the balance of power in their favor. There were no elections, nor was the opposition able to form a successful transitional government, despite attempts to do so. Search for mining jobs