Is Sarkozy Fini?

The French president is having his worst month in a long time -- and the best he can do is raise taxes on soda.

BY ERIC PAPE | SEPTEMBER 29, 2011

He's an incumbent president and a telegenic leader who has become strikingly vulnerable ahead of the 2012 presidential election. His achievements might have seemed impressive in another era, but have been undone by grinding hardships: a limping economy, stubborn unemployment, fierce political opposition, panic over the debt, a disappointed electoral base. Yes -- France's Nicolas Sarkozy is in trouble.

Barack Obama's reelection challenge, formidable as it is, has little on Sarko's. Beyond a slew of Obama-esque political crises, Sarkozy faces a rising tide of corruption allegations against those around him that no amount of "Free Libya" photo-ops is likely to stop. Nearly two-thirds of the French hold a negative opinion of him -- more than the fraction who disapprove of former International Monetary Fund director and noted philanderer Dominique Strauss-Kahn. As the Socialist opposition prepares to select its presidential candidate in mid-October, its two most popular figures, François Hollande and Martine Aubry, hold double-digit leads over Sarkozy in a theoretical runoff.

These days, Sarkozy's spinmeisters are working overtime to make him respected, given their failure to make him likeable. They point to his foresight in budgetary restraint and note his success in increasing France's retirement age from 60 to 62, while also eliminating civil servant and teaching positions. But this is exactly Sarkozy's problem: Acting as Mr. Austerity (which he has to, in any case, to avoid losing France's AAA credit rating) certainly doesn't offer an easy path to reelection. Add to that a flurry of scandals, and it's clear that Sarkozy could be headed for the ranks of France's unemployed.

Like Obama, Sarkozy arrived with broad support; but he began to plummet just months into his presidency. The French, including many of his supporters on the right, quickly became troubled by Sarkozy's flashy nouveau riche style. It didn't help that he couldn't seem to keep his private life private -- whether it was his visible suffering during a rare presidential divorce or his courtship and marriage to a former supermodel, Carla Bruni -- in a country where people expect greater discretion from their leaders. To be fair, Sarkozy has, more than four years into his presidency, largely reined in such tendencies. But the impression stuck; and voters are, in any case, now more concerned with his unpopular policies, the dire economic situation, and ethics issues that, while rarely proven, won't go away.

The Bettencourt scandal, which came to a head in 2010, has done the most damage to Sarko's promise to be a more ethical leader. One of Sarkozy's first major moves as president was to push through what amounted to a 10 percent tax cut for France's wealthiest people. For octogenarian billionaire Liliane Bettencourt, the largest stakeholder in the L'Oréal cosmetics empire and the country's richest woman, this would have spared her tens of millions of euros annually -- if she paid all the taxes she was supposed to. But a legal battle between Bettencourt and her daughter over whether the old lady is mentally capable enough to control her own money (after she gave a dandy artist "friend" more than a billion dollars worth of gifts) brought forward a plethora of revelations.

ERIC FEFERBERG/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: ECONOMICS, FRANCE, EUROPE
 

Eric Pape is a writer in Paris.

DEBANJAN

9:56 PM ET

September 29, 2011

Sarkozy

He could gain the votes by being more Islamophobe. Poles after poles suggest that French public resoulutely supports Islamophobe policies like banning veils etc. In fact I bet he is going to try something like that sort , very quickly.

 

CHRISAK

8:55 AM ET

September 30, 2011

Hmm...

You talk about the Betancourt Affair and the Karachi Affair, but you make no mention of the Bourgi/Pean Affair? According to journalist Pierre Pean, Jacques Chirac's former adviser Michel de Bonnecorse claims that Sarkozy received suitcases from African "leaders in 2007. Bourgi, a friend of Sarkozy (whom he decorated for his services to France), has admitted carrying suitcases for Chirac, de Villepin--and accuses French politicians of all sides to have participated in this French-African culture of corruption?

Is it because French Africa is globally irrelevant that you do not mention it? Or is it because this is an embarrassment to the entire political French class of the last 50 years?

Funny, on a related note, how a search on the international state-owned French radio delivers a "plethora" of results on both Bourgi and Pean on the French website, but NONE WHATSOEVER on the English website.... (at least as of now, 9/30/2011 at 9:54AM Eastern Time US)

See for yourself (if you care):

http://www.rfi.fr/search/sinequa_search/bourgi
http://www.english.rfi.fr/search/sinequa_search/bourgi

http://www.rfi.fr/search/sinequa_search/pierre%20pean
http://www.english.rfi.fr/search/sinequa_search/pierre%20pean

 

DANADAMS

1:26 PM ET

September 30, 2011

Sarkozy will win. The

Sarkozy will win. The Socialists are a mess and Sarkozy at least has the benefit of being the incumbent. Though what his achievements are I dont know.

 

DR. SARDONICUS

11:16 AM ET

October 1, 2011

Money for nothing and the death for free

As usual with American commentary, no-one mentions the gorilla in the room: our military-industrial love affair with perpetual world war. The Afghanistan War is so unpopular in France; its politicians have bunkered their troops in base camps to avoid additional casualties until their soon-promised evacuation– yet another exercise in the bloody futility and ruinous mindlessness of neocolonial military occupation.

With no existential threat that massed troops can addressed adequately, all these troops should be summoned home STAT.

Sarkozy can’t possibly get them back home fast enough (literally) and his popularity has taken repeated hits for refusing to bring French troops home sooner. Obama staffers, take note.

 

ARAUTOMOTIVO1

10:23 PM ET

October 1, 2011

Those Damned Islamic Islamophobes

i Agree in those damned Ni Putes Ni Soumises putes... and then jump in line to help gang rape that improperly veiled pute begging for it in ton banlieue--you'll feel so much better... Thanks!
Ar Condicionado Imoveis Acompanhante Massagistas

 

DARREN ROGERS

1:46 AM ET

October 3, 2011

Poor Sarkozy

It seems like just the other day Nicolas Sarkozy was basking in the limelight, new wife in hand, waving at the adoring fans.

Now, with 3 years of economic hardship brought on by the restricted money supply, it seems Sarkozy can do no right. Even Ms. Bruni is no longer seen on Letterman these days. What are we to think?

Does the Bettencourt files show a more human side of a true leader? One that has learned to go with the tidal forces he is surrounded by? Look at the French newspapers online, I can see support for Sarkozy still, but Francois and his female competitor seem to be gaining steam day by day, even though there is no real foundation of a better France.

 

IRISHSILVER

6:11 AM ET

October 3, 2011

Two time president

i think that sarkozy will win a second term, mostly because of the lack of a real challenger. his star is on the wane, and even the lovely carla can't seem to raise his ratings. however the left is in disarray, and can't seem to pull together. maybe DSK could give him a run for his money, but it doesn't seem too likely. he hasn't done a bad job, and france has done ok in the last two years, while the euro, (and greece, ireland, spain) has been circling the drain. maybe the devil you know is better!