
A woman affected by flooding is seen along the roads of Badin District, Pakistan, on Sept. 17. In August 2011, heavy monsoon rains triggered flooding in lower parts of Sindh and northern parts of Punjab provinces. To date, the Pakistani government reports that more than 5.3 million people have been affected -- more than 200 people have lost their lives, over 4.2 million acres of land flooded, and 1.59 million acres of crops destroyed. Photojournalist Sam Phelps documented this nation underwater while on assignment for the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees.

Flood affected refugees guide a motorbike along the roads of Badin District, on Sept. 17.
A man tosses a snake into the flooded fields in Badin District, on Sept. 17.

A United Nations emergency relief camp for flood-affected communities alongside a canal in Zareen Khan, Sanghar District, Sindh, on Sept. 27.

Hori Tloo, age 8, holds her 18-month-old niece, Viji, in the United Nations
emergency relief camp in Zareen Khan on Sept. 27.

A boy holds a kid near an emergency relief camp in Zareen Khan on Sept. 27.

A female member of the Beel family walks outside their makeshift home in a camp for flood affected communities in Zareen Khan on Sept. 27. The family arrived at the site 15 days earlier after their village was inundated.

A man walks along the flooded roads of Badin District, on Sept. 17.
Two men travel by a motorbike along a flooded road in Jhati Tersil, Thatta District,
Sindh, on Sept. 28.

Muhammad Ismail, 56, is tended by his family in a U.N. camp alongside a road between the cities of Hyderabad and Thatta on Sept. 28. He suffered a stroke due to a brain tumor and has received some medical treatment, but the family does not have enough money to continue treatment.
A child in the U.N.
camp in Thatta District, Sindh, on Sept. 18.
A man walks along the flooded road in Zareen Khan, on Sept. 27.




(23)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE
MICHAELGERALDPDEALINO
7:58 PM ET
October 4, 2011
Sort of
I do not care about Pakistanis who persecute religious minorities, especially Christians.
ABDALI
8:39 AM ET
October 6, 2011
Sort of...who are the biggest evil
Yes you care about White Race isn't it
Who :
1) Killed innocent billions of native Americans
2)Killed millions of native Australians
3)Killed millions of Japanies (atomic)
4)Killed millions of Jews
5)Killed thousands of Vietnamese
6)Killed millions of Iraqies
7) Killed millions Africans and made them slaves
the list is very long , from killing women in the name of witchcraft to crusade and so on.
PALMER
10:41 AM ET
October 7, 2011
It's not just white people
Let's see--every day tens to hundreds of Pakistanis are killed by other Pakistanis because they are either the wrong flavor of Muslim or a Christian.
Most of the Iraqis who died after the U.S. invasion of Iraq were killed by other Iraqis. Much like Pakistan, Muslims in Iraq are quite happy to murder masses of other Iraqis because they are the wrong flavor of Muslim.
Rwandan genocide--black people on black people.
Nuclear bombing of Japan in 1945--pretty horrible, but fewer people were killed at Nagasaki and Hiroshima than the Japanese killed during their invasion and occupation of China. Or Korea, for that matter.
My reading of history is that human beings of all colors kill each other pretty regularly. It's not really a racial thing.
BAREKZAI
10:45 PM ET
October 4, 2011
Don't feel soory in the slightest
"Cowardice is the face that launched a thousand failures" (an American friend). The history of the Pakistani people indeed offers itself as a case-study into the cause and consequences of cowardice.
Unlike the Afghans next door who fought against every invader seeking to impose themselves upon them as their masters, had their nation destroyed as a consequence if only to stand free. The Pakistanis however - Punjabis, Sindhis and Mohajirs - have unfailingly succumbed to them in servitude. Even Islam came into the region through the sword weilding Arabs which I as a Muslim reflect upon as running contrary to the teachings of the Quran. They certainly took over the northern parts of Afghanistan, but it was in the Punjab and Sindh wherein their reigned supreme. The ancestors of today's Pakistanis caved in without much fight at all. In large parts of Afghanistan however, the Arabs were being killed at the hands of Afghans with no less ferocity as they managed with the Soviets, the British, the Mongols, and Alexander's army. While the ancestors of the Punjabis and Sindhis - much like recent years - allowed their lands as bases for ongoing Arab incursions into Afghanistan, however, it was an Afghan from the Arab-occupied parts of Afghanistan in the name of Abu Muslim Khorasani who later led an army that overthrew the Umayaad Caliphate and replaced it with the far more superior Abbasids that Muslims today reflect upon as the "Golden Age of Islam".
As Islam later grew in Afghanistan at the hands of Afghans, an Afghan known as Sultan Mahmud Ghaznawi led an army of his own that grew into an empire after taking the sword to the Pakistanis and forcefuly converting them all from Shia Islam to Sunnis. To some, this was a religious decree, but for me, this was yet another traditional example of Afghans securing their independance by putting to the sword those cowards who offered themselves as vehicles to brutal invaders in the past.
Today, we have a "Pakistan" that if not for their former British Colonial masters, would not have even existed. Ostensibly a soveriegn state, these Pakistanis exploited cold-war realities to once again destroy and dominate Afghanistan through their IslamoFascist proxies. As a state, we all know that the real rulers of Pakistan are the military, while the elected officials are no more than a side-show. Like before, the cowardly people of Pakistan listen to their latest masters and do as they say without the courage to oppose them and stand for their god-given rights as equals.
I look at the poor people on the pics above and can't help but remind myself that these people - either actively or passively - have made their own beds, so now they sleep on it. The same off course can be said about the sheer misery that my own Afghans find themselves in. However, we do not describe ourselves as "victims", for we too are reaping what we've sown. However, we've stood against the might of the Soviet invaders just as we stand in opposition to the Pakistani invaders today, albeit via proxy. While Pakistan's misery is permanent, ours is a blip in our proud history. We will again rise to take this war to its end within Pakistan and Balkanize it accordingly.
TRUTHSEEKER
6:43 AM ET
October 5, 2011
Hate only begets Hate...
and you are a shining example of it.. Drooling over past Afghan glories is pointless in your anti-Pakistan diatribe. You sure have some delusional notions of 'bravery' and 'cowardice'.. Hollow grandiose and imagined romanticism of bravery is good for patting one-self in the back but hardly anything substantive to work with.
To brush up some your fallacious understanding of history, Afghans have rarely been a 'free' people in their modern history. Almost always under occupation & fighting each other under long-outdated tribal customs. Apparently it was the Pakistanis next door who sent men, money & materials along with training Afghans to eject the Soviets from Afghanistan. Before that, Afghans were being massacred by the Soviets en-masse. Same is true today.
Apart from your cheap attempts to sow discord among Afghans and Pakistanis by your ridiculous comment, there is nothing else in your comment but a veiled hint that perhaps you are not even an Afghan; just another cheap Indian poster such as user, DR. KUCHBHI.
SAM90
2:36 AM ET
October 5, 2011
Pakistanis
Pakistan shouldn't receive any aid or sympathy. They don't deserve any.
TRUTHSEEKER
6:32 AM ET
October 5, 2011
Shocked!
Truly shocked by the lack of humanity by those people making comments about Pakistanis not deserving aid or help in a situation of a natural disaster..
Regardless of what its government's policies are; all I see is the same lot of Pakistan bashers who hijack every Pakistan related piece on FP, showcasing their racist ideals vis-a-vis a group of people.
What is a fault of a 8yr old child who wakes up to find her village washed away by a flood? The need to offer food and shelter is a basic tenet of humanity, and is NOT conditional up on ideologies.
What is North Korea today? But South Korea and other countries still send in food, medicine, etc as aid for its people. Should the world stop feeding the famine effected Somalia just because the country is a hot-bed for al-Shabab group?
The apathetic comments here truly show the ugly side of human conscience that can be so evil and detestable of others so as to make one question humanity.
SAM90
3:09 PM ET
October 5, 2011
Pakistanis
This has little to do with Pakistan's government and their disgusting terroristic policies.
The Pakistani people are even worse. Their society and culture is disgusting and evil. Anyone who gives them aid is beyond stupid and their actions run contrary to the good of humanity.
The same Pakistanis you pity are not human, they are beasts who treat minorities worse than the Nazis treated the Jews, murdering and raping them with impunity. They cry foul at the mere suggestion that an innocent Christian shouldn't be executed. They exclude Christians and Hindus from Western aid and flood their villages for the hell of it.
These people are so disgusting and inhuman no one should ever feel sorry for them.
TRUTHSEEKER
4:35 PM ET
October 6, 2011
Quit peddling...
your bickering bile DR KUCHBHI..
WHO said other people suffering shouldn't be helped? As long as the means allow, those in need should be helped without discrimination. On my way salary, I do what I can.. I have sponsored two children, one from India and one from Pakistan.. if I could afford more, I would support more.. What are YOU doing to help those in need?
Just because of Pakistan's govt policies that you disagree with, doesn't automatically mean that residents of that country deserve any less aid in times of crisis than residents of a country whose policies you approve of..
As for your ignorant rants of American aid to Pakistan thus far.. The $20b given thus far is PEANUTS compared to losses suffered by Pakistani economy in the decade long WoT - most conservative estimates range from $50b-$80b losses. And out of that $20b given, 85% has been given directly to Pakistan Armed Forces in the form of equipment, etc; NOT ordinary Pakistanis. So quit propagating fallacies.
I don't see any objectivity in your comments; if there was, you wouldn't be peddling anti-Pakistani sentiment on every Pakistan article here on FP. I only see prejudice and racist hatred oozing from your disgusting self.
PSHYEAHFOOL
11:03 AM ET
October 5, 2011
Missing the Point
I think a lot of the anger towards Pakistani people is being misdirected. The of majority Pakistani people want to be sovereign but are tied down by two opposing sides: terrorism within the country and the imposing US presence amidst a corrupted Pakistan government.
These amazing photographs capture the struggles facing the underrepresented people of Pakistan. Just like when tragedy struck Haiti, I hope those effected will recover and gain food, water, and shelter, and have a chance to redeem what they have lost.
I don't this is a topic to be argued over, I just wanted to share my thoughts.
KRADIAC
11:27 AM ET
October 5, 2011
Short answer:YES..
This cancer on Earth which spawns terrorism from Philippines to Xinjiang and blackmails the whole world by holding gun to its own head deserves to be wiped off the map.Come to think of it,what is the contribution of this corrupt failed state to the world except destabilizing&exporting violence to its neighbors.Its not just the military-jihadi complex..whole pakistani society is culpable for breeding terrorists.
Only "white dumb Americans/Euro" bleeding heart lefties will fall for this con job.
TIMWX
9:47 AM ET
October 29, 2011
lol, grow up.
And do some bloody research! Every country on earth is corrupt, failed, and falling into a black hole of debt. And talk about destabilizing & exporting violence to its neighbors. Just look at the latest scandal in the US involving the ATF. They got caught red handed giving guns to BOTH Mexican drug cartel's to frame the second amendment. The plan was to push for stricter gun control in the US because of the drug war that the US government was covertly orchestrating!
Vince Delmonte
SOMEGUY
12:01 PM ET
October 5, 2011
Moderator?
Would someone please delete some of these comments on here? I know this is probably a vain hope since this site apparently puts no effort into keeping the comment sections in line (spam anyone?), but on the off chance a moderator does see this, would you, for the love of god/allah/vishnu/buddha/the flying spaghetti monster, delete some of these offensive comments?
This is an article about people suffering from a natural disaster for god sakes. That certain posters are using these images to spread their hateful views, it's just... inhuman. I personally was so enraged that I wrote out 3 profanity-filled responses to these disgusting posts, but I deleted them because I realized they wouldn't lead anywhere productive. I don't know if others will be able to restrain themselves from being drawn into a flame war.
Honestly, I'm not in favor of censorship in general, but things like "let them eat yellow cake," or calling the people in these pictures "cowards," that is far out of bounds for any civilized discourse on how to deal with humanitarian disasters. It is simply hate-mongering. Amazingly insensitively-timed hate-mongering.
CNIRU
1:05 PM ET
October 5, 2011
Pakistan flood
Pakistan's sufferings are a direct correlation of their pathetic effort to be something that they are not. Pakistanis, Afghans and the rest of South Asia always had more in common among themselves than desert Arabs who thrust Islam upon them, and which is today leading them to distort their own cultural nay civilization and geographical reality.
This is apparent from idiotic posts by commentators like Barekzai above, who think as Afghans they are somewhat better off than the Pakistanis. If today (or even 40 years back) an earthquake struck Afghanistan (god forbid), the situation of the poor in the Afghan street would be similar and they would also ask for aid from others or see their family perish from disease, starvation or conflict. There is no honour in poverty or in intolerance.
For the likes of him - even Pashtuns became Islamic after the Arabs slashed through fathers and brothers to rape your mothers and daughters. Who are you trying to call spineless and people of little belief in their own culture and history ? Look at the Indians, in spite of a 1000+ year of rule by Arabs and Islamized Turks, Afghans, Mongols, and Persians they have held on to their culture, faith and belief in tolerance. True, they have their problems, but in general violence is more of an anathema to the Hindu Indian than to his non-Hindu brethren (especially Muslim ones).
Afghans should remember how they could remove the Soviets only with the help of US/Pak arms, otherwise the godless Communists would have had the last laugh.
As for Pakistan, the sooner her people realize that they have been taken for a ride this past 65 years by their Islam-in-danger crowing military-political leadership, and that there have been little or no necessary development in spite of being a great country with lots of resources the better it will be. Islam is not going to solve any problems, get rid of it, and get some plain common sense. That way you can focus on the needful job at hand instead of declaring Jihad on someone because his concept of the Almighty differs from your own. The Almighty will have the last laugh at your foolishness anyway. This applies to the people of Afghanistan also.
A few lines to reflect upon (in my native Bengali) referring to the Chariot Festival of Lord Jagannatha (a form of transcendental & non-anthropotheistic for of the Almighty worshipped as a deity in Eastern India), in Puri:
Ratha Yatra Lokaronno, Moha Dhum Dham
Poth Vabe ami Deb, Rath Vabe Ami Deb
Murti Vabe Ami Dev, Hasen Antarjami.
(The Chariot Festival is on, followers and festivities galore /
I am God, thinks the Road, the Chariot thinks the same /
The Idol also thinks "I am God", the Almighty merely smiles)
COURTFIG
1:31 PM ET
October 5, 2011
No matter what the
No matter what the government/people of Pakistan have done, they are still human.
How could you possibly look into the eyes of the children of Pakistan and say that they deserved the devastation that faces their country?
The key is foreign aid! With foreign aid, Pakistanis will be granted education and can change their ways.
MARTY MARTEL
2:40 PM ET
October 5, 2011
Pakistan - the victim of its own creations
The malaise of Islamic radicalism runs deep across Pakistan’s entire establishment - civilian and military as well as society.
Nobody forced Pakistani government to facilitate relocation of Osama bin Laden from Sudan to Afghanistan in 1996. Democratic government of Pakistan chose to do so of its own free will.
Nobody forced Pakistani Army and Intelligence to create what ex-CIA official Bruce Reidel called ‘this jihadist Frankenstein’ monster in 1990s. Pakistani Army and Intelligence chose to do so with the full financing provided by Pakistan’s democratic governments at the time.
Is ’poverty, lack of economic development or lack of education’ a valid excuse to promote, spawn, shelter and support umpteen terrorist outfits on Pakistani soil?
Is ’wanting strategic depth’ a valid excuse to terrorize neighbors like Pakistan terrorizes Afghanistan and India or even take over a neighbor like Pakistan took over Afghanistan in 1996 and wants to do so again once U. S. troops depart? Should India create terrorist outfits to terrorize Pakistan and take it over because India feels sandwiched between China and Pakistan?
Lawyers showered the suspected killer of a prominent Pakistani governor with rose petals when he arrived at court and an influential Muslim scholars group praised the assassination of the governor who was recommending to reform Pakistan‘s sharia laws.
The Pakistani parliament’s joint session convened on 5/13/2011 after Osama’s killing and ended after adopting a unanimous resolution condemning the American raid on the Abbottabad compound in which al Qaeda chief was killed.
Pakistani parliamentarians did not appear to be bothered about Osama living in Abbottabad for the past five years and in other parts of the country since 9/11.
Osama bin Laden was a hero in Pakistan even prior to his death and remains one now as well.
Previous US ambassador Anne Patterson to Pakistan, wrote in a secret review in 2009 that ‘Pakistan's Army and ISI are covertly SPONSORING four militant groups - Haqqani‘s HQN, Mullah Omar‘s QST, Al Qaeda and LeT - and will not abandon them for any amount of US money‘, as diplomatic cables released by WikiLeaks show.
Ambassador Patterson had NO reason to mislead her own State Department and U. S. government.
How can Pakistani State or its nuclear weapons be threatened by Islamic fundamentalists when its Army, Intelligence Agency and Democratic governments SPONSOR such Islamic fundamentalist outfits like Osama bin Laden’s Al Qaeda, Mullah Omar’s QST, Haqqani’s HQN and Hafiz Saeed’s LeT and will NOT abandon them for any amount of US money as reported by ambassador Patterson?
TRUTHSEEKER
2:57 PM ET
October 14, 2011
Repeating lies...
... consistently doesn’t change the facts on the ground. There exists NO evidence that Pakistan facilitated OBL’s relocation from Sudan to Afghanistan. Claiming to do so without citing irrefutable evidence goes to show your utter anti-Pakistani bias that you constantly peddle in every single Pakistan related article here on Foreign Policy.
Bruce Riedel? Who really takes Bruce Riedel seriously apart from the bureaucrats who have been working on the so-called Af-Pak American policy for years now and have gotten nowhere with their ill-conceived notions of success in the region! Taliban didn’t come crashing to Earth from Mars; they were the same ‘jihadi Frankenstein monster’ that the Americans (CIA) & Saudis created and funded to fight the Soviets in Afghanistan.. Pakistan merely re-organized them to quell the Afghan civil war that had erupted post Soviet departure and American abandonment of the region. Obviously, Riedel is too ashamed to admit some cold hard facts.
NO one in Pakistan ever says that whatever methods of implementing its own foreign policy objectives Pakistan employs is because of lack of development or lack of education, etc. The methods that Pakistan employs are a direct result of American intransigence regarding Pakistani interests in Afghanistan. How does putting terrorists of Northern Alliance (Taliban competitors bankrolled, financed and armed by India) in to positions of power in the puppet Afghan gov’t of Karzai help Afghanistan prosper? The performance of Karzai's stooge govt is for all to see.. bribery, corruption, feudal lords stacking looted cash from national coffers in Dubai and Swiss accounts while ordinary Afghans suffer!
Your ignorance is starkly visible from your statement, "Should India create terrorist outfits to terrorize Pakistan and take it over because India feels sandwiched between China and Pakistan".. this is sheer ignorance in the face of the fact that India has consistently financed Northern Alliance to counter Taliban in Afghanistan. Let’s not forget that these Northern Alliance terrorists were regularly supplied with finances and arms/ammunition via Indian forces base/outpost in Tajikistan that also includes an air-field. India doesn’t even border Afghanistan, so why all this jostling for influence?
Surely, Pakistan will do what it can to root out India’s nefarious designs in Afghanistan wherever and however possible. It’s a legitimate security concern for Pakistan that borders Afghanistan and it should come as NO surprise. Come 2014, the Pashtun majority, who support the Taliban by and large will make their influence felt in Afghan politics one way or another – which has thus far been sidelined by the current Afghan govt which is staffed by a plethora of minority Uzbeks, Tajiks, Hazara, etc who peddle the interests of their masters in India and by extension their benefactors in the United States.
Surely your nonsensical narrative of events from cherry-picked information couldn’t more deviant from the actual ground realities. Yes it is wrong that some sections of the Pakistani society celebrated the killing of Salman Taseer and venerated his killer. So what? Big whooping deal! Which society doesn’t have right-wingers? A simple look across the border in India will reveal how much love fanatic Hindus have for the guy who assassinated Mahatma Gandhi and who decry Gandhi as a traitor and a Muslim-lover. Need I say anything about the Tea-Party in America? The delusional likes of Sarah Palin and/or Michelle Backman? Bottom line is, the killer has been sentenced to death and the court’s decision is resolute in punishing a criminal of his magnitude. Simple as that.
Ofcourse Pakistani parliamentarians passed a resolution condemning U.S unilateral action against OBL on Pakistani soil.. Hardly any parliamentarian (except those from the religious far-right) had any issue with OBL being killed. Ofcourse OBL is hero to some just like Anders Behring Breivik , the Norwegian killer is a hero to many right-wing Europeans who rejoiced in the killing of innocent ‘Muslim-lovers’ and ‘left-wing softies’.. What does this point raised by you prove? Absolutely NOTHING. What almost everyone in Pakistan, not just the parliamentarians, had a problem with was U.S flagrant violation of Pakistan’s sovereignty. That is a legitimate and understandable grievance. Your rants to the contrary are nothing but an exercise in rhetorical polemic with very little substance.
In your condemnation of Pakistan’s elected parliamentarians and labeling them as somehow pro-OBL, you forget to mention that most of the Pakistani population today regards the regime of Asif Zardari as nothing but a puppet of the United States in its continued support for American operations in Afghanistan via intelligence sharing, military cooperation, etc. Hence the dichotomy in your argument is fully exposed.
To date, no concrete evidence exists of ISI’s current support of Haqqani or anyone else.. Opinions, assumptions, conjecture by this official or that official, whether it be Anne Patterson or Adm. Mike Mullen; its all about political maneuvering to put more pressure on Pakistan by making an scapegoat in the failed saga of American adventurism in Afghanistan, which after a decade, still has no certain end. Here’s some refreshing information (excerpt) for you from TIME magazine’s recent report:
…’ But Thomas Ruttig, a co-founder of the Afghanistan Analysts Network (AAN) and expert on the Haqqani network, thinks ISAF may be crowing over very little…’ , Ruttig of AAN, says, "It is difficult to prove that the ISI is behind, or advises in, particular operations of the Haqqani network, or, for that matter, other Taliban subgroups or other terrorist organizations. Often, reports about the Haqqani network or other organizations' involvement in certain attacks remain unclear. This is still the case in the latest attacks." For what it's worth, both the Pakistani and Taliban spokesmen have denied that links exist between the ISI and the Haqqani network.’ Courtesy TIME
http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,2096545-1,00.html
You got one thing partially right – Pakistan will not abandon its interests for any amount of money. Only way to seriously engage Pakistan in a constructive manner is to listen to what it says. Wind-up the endless Indian consulates popping up everywhere in Afghanistan and limit Indian influence in Afghanistan to a legitimate minimum as would be required to conduct the ‘good’ work that Indians are doing in Afghanistan as per their claims. Negotiate with the Taliban (which the U.S is doing off and on but trying to outflank Pakistan in such negotiations – another misstep and height of foolishness) and other such concerns. Then only will Pakistan respond positively and favorably and do what it can by using any leverage, if there, it has over any sort of militants.
Your comments in every other Pakistan related thread are highly ignorant and have very little logic or understanding of the complex situation that involved Afghanistan-Pakistan region. I am extremely tempted to think that you are nothing but an alternate user I.D of another user here on FP who goes by the name ‘DRKUCHBHI’. May very well not be the case but surely, you both have nothing better to do than regurgitate the same anti-Pakistan bile again n again.
SIDROCK23
2:53 PM ET
October 5, 2011
these comments here prove, y pakistan should do what it is doing
afhans are always be a backward and barbaric form of life. it doesn't matter oif its taliban, haqqani, india, arabs, america, pakistan, someone will always play the afghans for puppets. the americans have proven they cannot beat taliban or pakistan and afraid to admit they have lost, so they are just trying to find a scape goat. first it was osama, then al qaeda, then taliban, now haqqani, even with their big bad military they lost to a bunch of rag heads. the euro-pee-ons have been irelevant for 2 decades now, but they had been riding the coat tails of the U.S for so long. they will drown and die in their own stupid economic mess. thought u were so smart hunh/ so sophisticated and powerful? how's ur economy looking? haha, all ur people losing their houses and jobs, guess what, pakistan didn't do that. u did. it was pakistan that actuall fought the soviets, if not for pakistan, america would still be frozen scared in the cold war and afhganistan would just be a whore house for the russians. we watched how americans let their own people die in katrina, u couldn't even do anything for them, just because they were black. this is how u treat ur own, what makes u think someone else should care for u. if ur cry baby soldiers are too scared then tell them to go back.
CHICLETS
4:29 PM ET
October 5, 2011
As an Indian, I always feel sorry for Pakistanis
and yet you'll probably see in the comments below how my sympathy is frowned upon.
VISIONTUNNEL
3:15 AM ET
October 6, 2011
2010 Pakistan flood: India was among the top 10 aid-givers
The people world wide and countries would do that they can and Pakistan will do what is damn easy.
There are few facts about aid given by nations during floods in 2010.
The most hated country for average Pakistanis, U. S. led the pack with a commitment of $ 200 million, followed by the U. K., Saudi Public Relief Fund, Saudi Arabia, the European Union, Germany, Canada and the United Nations.
India with $ 25 Million aid had topped even developed countries like Japan, Norway and Sweden.
China gave $ 9 million which Pakistanis has always regarded and gloated over as its “all-weather friend and now a trophy savior.
But there have been instances of very strange behavior pattern shown by The Pakistani Aid administrators as far as India aid was concerned.
They thought it was much batter to blacken out and tear off Indian signs from the Indian materials.
Why they thought it was fit to do so, relates to certain twisted ideals and stereotypes they love to reinforce and extend further
There have been instances of aid material being sold in road side shops and monies diverted/pocketed by the powerful people who matter in Pakistan.
TRUTHSEEKER
11:07 AM ET
October 14, 2011
Utter nonsense..
that you've been peddling makes little sense. Just because the United States gave away more aid than any other country, doesn't mean Pakistanis as a society have to agree with what Americans do around the world.. You exhibit the common misplaced perception that somehow Pakistanis hate Americans and/or Indians.. This myth has already been busted by various books written on this topic and everyone who's actually been to Pakistan, is an ambassador of Pakistani hospitality which does not discriminate based on nationality or any other factor.
Whether the Americans give $200m in aid or $2m, there is NO compulsion for Pakistanis to like or agree with American foreign policy in their region. Pakistanis do not hate Americans at all - your assumption that they do goes to show that you've never been to Pakistan. What the Pakistanis DO hate, like most of the Muslim public around the Islamic world, is American foreign policy. The $200m Americans give in aid has little leverage when drone strikes kill entire families in the FATA region and Americans continue to challenge Pakistan's sovereignty.
Corruption in aid distribution is nothing but a curse that plagues most less developed countries. It is nothing different in Pakistan to what happens to aid distribution in Haiti, Somalia, or even India and China or the United States itself (hurricane Katrina anyone?) when local cronies try to take advantage of the situation. The world is full of opportunistic breed of individuals.
Your anti-Pakistan hate and prejudice only goes to show that you really do not have a logical argument to put forth other than trying unsuccessfully to thinly veil your true intent.
NEGIYINELIM
8:55 AM ET
October 6, 2011
Negiyinelim
www.negiyinelim.com
APRA
4:33 AM ET
October 12, 2011
Karma, Karma, Karma
Can I just say that karma is all around? Do good to others, then you can very well expect a lot of good things to come towards you. Do evil, then, expect more evil to come your way. Let’s just say that the Pakistan people indeed made a lot of evil actions in the past and the present and who knows what they can do in the future. I think they need something like anti inflammatory agent. Will you really let bad karma hit you too (just like what they are experiencing), by not helping people who are in need, or perhaps sympathize with them at the very least?