U.N. Rips Iran's Human Rights Record in New Report

An important reminder that the Islamic Republic's greatest victims are its own citizens.

BY BARBARA SLAVIN | OCTOBER 17, 2011

A forthcoming U.N. report, obtained by Foreign Policy in advance of its publication later this week, condemns the Iranian regime for wide-ranging human right abuses, including the secret killings of hundreds of prisoners under mysterious circumstances.

The report, compiled by Ahmed Shaheed, the new U.N. "Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Islamic Republic of Iran," makes for dismal reading: a compendium of violations of basic rights ranging from lack of free expression and assembly to summary executions and torture of detainees.

Iran's authoritarian rulers have abused their people for centuries; thousands died during and in the immediate aftermath of the 1979 revolution. The picture improved somewhat under the 1997-2005 presidency of Mohammad Khatami but has darkened again in recent years.

Hundreds of political activists, journalists, students, filmmakers, lawyers, environmentalists, women's advocates, members of ethnic and religious minorities, dissident clerics, and Iranians with ties to Western countries have been swept into the prisons of the Islamic Republic since the disputed 2009 presidential election. The government has freed some but replaced its stockpile with others. About 500 activists remain detained.

Those convicted of crimes -- both political and otherwise -- faced the ultimate penalty more often in Iran than any other country except China. According to the U.N. report, there have been more than 200 "officially announced" executions in 2011 and at least 146 secret ones in a prison in the eastern city of Mashhad. Last year, 300 people were secretly executed there, the report says.

Hadi Ghaemi, director of the International Campaign for Human Rights in Iran, says that those put to death in Vakilabad prison in Mashhad appear to have been charged with offenses that would not merit the death penalty elsewhere. "The Iranian government claims they are drug offenders, but they don't give the names, so there is no way to know," Ghaemi said.

Those whose executions have been announced include juveniles. More than 100 Iranians under age 18 remain on death row, despite the fact that executing minors is forbidden by international covenants that Iran has joined, such as the Convention on the Rights of the Child.

The new report was made available to FP days before Shaheed is to present the findings to the U.N. General Assembly on Oct. 19. Shaheed, a former foreign minister from the Maldives who assumed his position Aug. 1, has been rebuffed so far in his efforts to travel to Iran.

EMMANUEL DUNAND/AFP/Getty Images

 

Barbara Slavin is a senior fellow at the Atlantic Council and the author of the 2007 book Bitter Friends, Bosom Enemies: Iran, the U.S., and the Twisted Path to Confrontation.

CHARLESFRITH

11:58 AM ET

October 17, 2011

Human Rights

What are the human rights of the million killed in prosecuting an illegal war? Then apply the same question to the 2-3 million displaced by the same US provoked war? Reparations will need to be settled.

 

GRANT

12:39 PM ET

October 17, 2011

Interesting that people

Interesting that people forget that the U.S military is responsible for the minority of the deaths*. Apparently they simply can't understand the idea that the majority of Muslims killed over the past ten years (and indeed over the past few centuries) have been killed by other Muslims, often from the same nation.

* I find it outright hilarious that for some reason peacekeepers from the Third World are much more acceptable even though their discipline, adherence to human rights and equipment are generally far worse than First and Second World armies.

 

NICHOLAS WIBBERLEY

2:29 AM ET

October 18, 2011

Abusing Iran

The report presents deviations from an abstract ideal whereas looked at in a wider context, Iran’s record is no worse than many and better than quite a few. This is not to minimise abuses in anyway but simply to adopt a more realistic perspective.

Furthermore, many influences that might have been and would be working to free up Iran’s political system are inhibited by sanctions and isolation. Iran is surrounded by salivating wolves and one really cannot expect a nation to develop coherently under persistent threat, indeed it almost guarantees a tendency towards autarchy, repression and the institutionalisation of repressive force. Open to the air and the world, with healthy international interchanges at all levels, Iran would likely lighten up pretty fast since its educated classes are Western orientated. The leaking and promotion of this report is adding more straws to those currently being piled on Iran for highly suspect confrontational purposes.

 

LONEMODERATE

3:53 AM ET

October 18, 2011

Interesting new blog

Check it out.

For more analysis on the Israeli-Hamas swap deal and other global issues please check out this new blog - http://globalbear-ings.blogspot.com/

Thanks for the consideration.

 

NESSATOMLIN

8:39 AM ET

October 18, 2011

What Human Rights?

Iran has an appalling record on human rights. We have all seen the images on the TV of Iranians being stoned or executed for what we in the west would call 'trivial' crimes, if crimes at all...
I remember watching a news report one night a few years ago about how a poor Iranian woman was marched into her local town square to be stoned by the on-looking crowd. What was her crime? Well it turns out she was committed of wearing the wrong type of facial makeup. It was deemed too western! What!!! It transpires, that if she had been wearing a more natural makeup look she would not have caused a stir. And who was the judge of all this... A middle aged man with no legal education. He just thought she looked too western. Is it just me or is this a step far too far in the wrong direction? Human rights... What human rights!
Iran and other backward thinking places (of which I could name a few) need to be dragged into the 21st century. We don't live in the dark ages and woman should not be condemned for the simple reason of wearing the wrong type of makeup. This is one of many silly and pathetic rules that are allowed to live in a society that is lead by men whose only goal is to keep women chained to the proverbial kitchen sink!

 

NICHOLAS WIBBERLEY

10:31 AM ET

October 18, 2011

Old footage?

The Saudis routinely chop off heads and hands, the Hebrews stoned adulteresses, The Vatican burned heretics, Puritans burned witches, etc.. The world must appear ugly indeed to those whose sensibilities are so delicate and refined.

“The Iranian judiciary officially placed a moratorium on stoning in 2002, although the punishment remained on the books, and there were a few cases of Judges handing down stoning sentences in 2006 and 2007 In 2008, Iran's judiciary decided to fully scrap the punishment from the books in a legislation submitted to parliament for approval. As of June 2009, Iran's parliament has been reviewing and revising the Islamic penal code to omit stoning as a form of punishment” Wikipedia LINK

 
 

SERAFINNUNEZ101

2:29 AM ET

November 16, 2011

Under 18 in the death row??

Why do these juveniles be included in executions? What's strange is that those Iranians under 18 are in the death row! My friend recommended this site when I was checking for portable printers review. This does not really sound good.

 

RESZKA

3:55 PM ET

November 17, 2011

Iran shows no sign of

Iran shows no sign of buckling to remote demands on the nuclear front yet has actually been receptive to worldwide campaigns pertaining to specific political detainees. Last year, for instance, after a world-wide outcry, Iranian authorities lifted a death penalty by stoning in opposition to a female convicted of adultery.

 

HB209

12:58 AM ET

November 18, 2011

Was the album that bad? Maybe

Was the album that bad? Maybe he should have did a record on Nukes instead of human rights. windows tablet sylvania tablet sylvania netbook ipad alternatives

 

DANISHKHAN001

7:13 AM ET

November 18, 2011

Good One...

Nice article has been shared with all of us!! Its a good coverage having lots of information."Hundreds of political activists, journalists, students, filmmakers, lawyers, environmentalists, women's advocates, members of ethnic and religious minorities, dissident clerics, and Iranians with ties to Western countries have been swept into the prisons of the Islamic Republic since the disputed 2009 presidential election."
DUI Attorneys