March of the Freshmen

Each year, China's incoming university students must partake in a ritual of patriotic military training. Is it brainwashing? Do they care?

BY ERIC FISH | NOVEMBER 10, 2011

BEIJING — Under the hot September sun, columns of university freshmen in army fatigues march into Tsinghua University's main stadium. The tallest young man in a company of 170 leads with a red flag as his classmates train their eyes forward, trying to keep perfectly synchronized. Patriotic music blares, and an announcer yells, "Make sure to practice the good thoughts, good behavior, and good habits you learned during the military training in your future study and life!"

Crowds of parents and curious locals try to catch a glimpse through the stadium's fence as the final platoon settles into standing formation. Tsinghua University, considered "China's MIT" and alma mater to Chinese President Hu Jintao, is celebrating the conclusion of 20 days of marching, drilling, and adherence to commanders' orders. Across the country, nearly every university is staging the same pageantry -- part of the Chinese government's efforts to keep its citizens patriotic and, perhaps, obedient. In today's rapidly changing China, however, this traditional rite of passage, known as Junxun, seems less relevant for a generation grown used to peace and prosperity.

Since 1985, every school year has begun with the training. Participation is mandatory for every incoming freshman -- young men and women alike -- and a poor performance can blot a record that stays with them throughout their professional lives. Over a speaker at the Tsinghua stadium, an announcer says that military training is "one of the holiest tasks given by the People's Republic of China."

Unlike its neighbors Taiwan, North Korea, and South Korea, which also have mandatory military training, mainland China faces little threat of foreign invasion. Yet it still maintains the world's largest army, with a 2.3 million all-volunteer force. But national defense isn't necessarily the main concern with Junxun, which tends to include very little practical combat education.

Individual schools list their own objectives for the training, but according to China's Education Ministry, the official purpose is "to enhance students' sense of national defense and national security awareness." It also aims to improve "patriotism, collectivism, and revolutionary heroism" and "enhance organizational discipline" so the country can "develop socialist builders and successors of the future."

Some see more nefarious plots. Kai Pan, an American blogger in Shanghai, said on the China blog CNReviews that foreigners who see the training are often "thoroughly constipated with disgust for the nationalism being 'brainwashed' into the innocent but ever-so-impressionable youth." And Peng Guoxiang, a professor of Chinese philosophy at Peking University in Beijing, says Junxun is designed "to train [students] to be sheep."

One mile south of Tsinghua University is Renmin ("People's") University, a top school for aspiring government cadres. In August, a 19-year-old language student who goes by the English name Rachel was preparing for her military training. Just under 5 feet tall and 90 pounds, she'd never done anything like it before. "I'm very nervous," she said.

Rachel was born in 1992 in the east-coast province of Zhejiang, one of China's richest regions. She has traveled throughout the country with her family and hopes her language skills will one day land her a job that'll allow her to see the world. The daughter of a middle-class government official, she, like most Chinese her age, is an only child. "I'm so lonely," she said, laughing about her home life. "But I was very spoiled. I didn't need to worry about anything."

Rachel's upbringing is a world apart from that of China's previous generations. Her grandmother was 9 years old when her future husband was arranged for her in the late 1940s, after years of civil war and the Japanese invasion. Rachel's parents were both born in the early 1960s and bore the brunt of Mao Zedong's Cultural Revolution, eating tree bark at one point to survive. But with the decline of socialist dogma and the subsequent economic explosion that resulted in a 14-fold increase in per capita GDP from 1990 to 2010, members of China's next generation found themselves growing up in a radically changed society. Those like Rachel born in this booming era are referred to (often pejoratively) as China's post-1990s generation. According to the Chinese newspaper Global Times, these kids are routinely labeled "lazy, promiscuous, confused, selfish, brain damaged and overall hopeless."

Ed Jones/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: CHINA, MILITARY
 

Eric Fish is a freelance writer in Beijing.

JYS390

3:22 AM ET

November 11, 2011

Nicely written

I'm the first to notice Foreign Policy's tendency to hew the China-fear tropes with reporters ill-versed in Mandarin or the region, but I'll also readily acknowledge a well-balanced article with nuance that paints Chinese people as individuals with humanity.

I like how the article showed the students as both clear-headed about the intentions yet patriotic, to their country cynical about the party propaganda but proud of their soldiers. Mostly, I really appreciated the nod to the universal effect of these training camps, whether they be boot camps in the U.S., China, Israel or Timbuktu. By allowing the "others" to share traits as "us" the author does a great service to our understanding of the world.

 

FORLORNEHOPE

9:13 AM ET

November 11, 2011

Sounds familiar

Sounds awfully like the cadet corps at an English boarding school in the 1960s. We all thought that we were being trained to resist the revolution though were not at all sure what side we'd be on!

 

SOULSEARCHER

3:32 PM ET

November 11, 2011

Well Chinese people are

Well Chinese people are always humans. This fact does not change when a group of congressmen shout about how bad Chinese human rights records are in Congressional hearings, or when a group of Tibetan monks burn themselves to death, or when some people think that the Chinese Government is actively supporting tobacco companies giving cigs to kids at Chinese middle schools (The Government, meanwhile, is providing sex ed classes, first ever in China), or when newspapers run news headlines on China that are factual but trivial. I am Chinese and I am proud to be human beings, regardless whether other people treat me as such. I think that the Iranians are also humans, so are the Pakistanis, the Afghans, maybe everyone on this Planet Earth. As for the CCP, it is dying and it will die one day. Parliamentary democracy will take root in China some day, perhaps before 2020.

 

KEYBASHER

9:58 AM ET

November 14, 2011

RE Well Chinese people are

"As for the CCP, it is dying and it will die one day. Parliamentary democracy will take root in China some day, perhaps before 2020."

That's my assessment, too - after hosting an Olympics a one-party state invariably circles the drain, if it isn't already down it.

But I highly doubt the CCP/PLA Complex will go quietly. When the Chinese economy tanks by the end of this decade and the people demand democracy, the Powers-That-Be-in-Beijing may attempt a patriotic distraction with an attempt on Taiwan a la the Argentine junta on the Falklands in 1982. How Washington would then react would determine the Pacific economy and balance of power for the next 50 years.

 

AIMIER

8:09 PM ET

November 11, 2011

It's the same old song

I’m a little perplexed by how the author write about junxun. We are informed that it is a ritual, just in the question bellow the headline, a little bit later even more that it is a rite of passage. And for me that is the answer to what the whole thing is all about! Coming from homes where the whole attention was concentrated on a one child to an institution of a regime like (Chinese) University students need an initiation. If the opinions of the participants after the ritual are possitive it means that it is as relevant as it should be. The initiation in this form is just a derivative of the institution and the funding ideology. Three weeks of marching across the dusty playground, in a cheap green uniform are nothing compared to the next four or five years of intensive ideological training, studing as obligatory subjects like marxism, leninism, maoism and communism with Chinese characteristic, learnig how to look at (zenmekan) the current problems of the society (by reading books like “shishi baogao” etc.) and living under some quasi-military conditions – the bachelor students during first 3 years have to live on-campus, the domitory rooms look almost the same all across China – from 4 to 8 bunkbeds in a one room, dormitories have no kichens (there is always one big common dinnig hall on campus), very often no bathrooms as well (you have a public one), at 11 o’clock the electricity goes off (exept Fridays and Saturday when you can stay up till 12), the freshmen have to attend so called self-study classes (zixishi) and if the weather is nice they have to get up at 6 a.m. and run few times around the playground (!!!).
And about the revolutionary songs (“Unity Is Strength”, “Without the Communist Party, There Would Be No New China” are “classical” revolutionary song)? Next time we will learn that the “East Is Red” has been played from the clock on the Beijing Railwaystation and does it mean anything exept that in the field of ideology it is as it was? Besides ask the Old Man who wrote a book “On China”, maybe he sings the same thing while shaving ;P
http://blogs.wsj.com/chinarealtime/2011/06/30/you-cant-have-a-party-without-music-a-red-song-primer/

 

CLOCKWORK ORANGE

9:00 PM ET

November 11, 2011

It works.

Rachel in the article is aware of the intention but how about other students? Do they make connections between China' authoritarian regime and the brainwashing? I doubt it. Even they are clear-headed, they are still patriotic, which is not necessarily negative. The problem is , patriotic in Chinese is ai guo, literally means loving (the)country. "Loving the country equals loving the government , loving the Party and loving socialism."This is what they are told during Junxun and in their textbooks.

 

FREETRADER

1:53 PM ET

November 12, 2011

Out in the Noon Day Sun

Good, nuanced article.

I'm second to no one in my contempt for the CCP dictatorship, but the quasi-military training does little or no harm and probably does a lot of good. Taking a bunch of the spoiled, lazy, post-Tiananmen generation and getting them some discipline and exercise is all for the good. There is very little chance that anyone who wasn't already brainwashed would be further brainwashed by this process, since the younger generation are mostly able to make the distinction between the idea of China and the Communist Party dictatorship.

Rachel seems pretty typical, in my experience. The training is a challenging rite of passage but it really has very little to do with the military and won't do anything to shore up the rotten edifice of the Chinese Communist Party once it starts to collapse.

Frankly, kids in the West these days could probably use a little exercise in the hot sun as well. Maybe there is something we can learn from China after all.

 

LIZARDO

5:41 PM ET

November 12, 2011

Evolution

It's for certain that Communist Socialism as evolved into Nationalist Socialism.

Could have been worse though, might have gotten our Feminist Socialism.

 

PUBLICUS

11:25 AM ET

December 9, 2011

21st Century Fascism

Well said concerning Chinese 21st century fascism, which is what the CCP have morphed into in China. When I taught at a China technological university 2008-11, I witnessed this Junxun so I agree based on personal observation and the recurring feedback of the students that it is a meaningless exercise by an authoritarian one party state. It's always the female students who try to find significant lifetime meaning from the facile tripe that is so well described by the writer (and by AIMIER). Rachel's classmate Li pretty much summed up the life changing significance of the Junxun experience to the boys, "It changed my skin color," albeit temporarily. These kids hate the experience, but love China. Their eyes gleam any time they sing the song quoted at the conclusion of the excellent FP piece.

One day at the university I tried to lighten up the somber and serious future gray flannel suits so I asked my classes which movie or signing star they would marry if they could. One girl stood up and said Hu Jintao. I laughed, told the girl Hu already was married and that in English she would be called a homewrecker. Half the class got a kick out of my point, which was at least somewhat encouraging. But overall my three years teaching in China until earlier this year were most discouraging. In fact I was profoundly discouraged to find a nation with a population of sheeple.

The Guangzhou (Canton) CCP reformist Wang Yang does offer some glimmer of hope for a more humane and just PRC, however, he as with Gorbechev is a hard core CCP who does not forsee any withering away of the authoritarian state Lennin and Mao created as the core of Marxism.

 

DARWIN

4:26 AM ET

November 13, 2011

Bright Future

I am an American living in Spain and just finished a Spanish language course. In my class there were 10 Chinese students. I was the oldest student by about 20 years (yikes). My new Chinese friends were as varied and gregarious as any western college students.
What struck me was how many of them befriended me and never failed to greet me in the hallways. They were always fun to be around. They loved to laugh, seemed to support each other in this new culture and were all very patriotic.
Our shared futures will be brighter because of them. And I was not payed to say this!

 

DELMONTE01

4:44 AM ET

November 14, 2011

If only...

What your saying about Chinese people is true. But It is very hard to see a bright future with the world being so utterly insane. Take the Libya situation for example. We were told that the mission was to protect civilians. What, with love bombs? Go and look up the death toll from this war. All NATO has done is murdered thousands of civilians under the pretext of protecting civilians. Utterly insane.

Vince Delmonte

 

BETALOVER

4:34 PM ET

November 18, 2011

non-mainalnd China and history of being invaded

"Unlike its neighbors Taiwan, North Korea, and South Korea, which also have mandatory military training, mainland China faces little threat of foreign invasion."

Well, having been invaded and brutalized just 60 some years ago, I think the Chinese in the “mainland” have more reasons to be vigilant.

What foreign invasion does that non-“mainland” part of China, Taiwan, face? May be from Japan, the Philippines, or Vietnam.

 

OLSON46

9:54 AM ET

November 26, 2011

Very informative

Many thanks for this balanced, well-researched and highly informative piece, Mr. Fish. It's a good glimpse at a powerful ex-communist world. Nice flow of the story too.

Some thoughts:
1. The class gap in China is ever widening, which is completely natural in post-commie societies.
2. You can see older commies who are nostalgic and romantic about the good old days.
3. A little taste of militarism could be healthy and beneficial for bringing discipline and physical exercise to spoiled rich kids. It's an essential chapter in thier lives to maintain balance.
4. "Brainwashing" and "indoctrination" is perfectly "normal" and expected in ANY military training, but today's generation know better than to be programmed as red zombies.

Much love folks,
Lisa