Crime Scene

The violence in northern Afghanistan today is so complicated that even Afghans have trouble untangling its roots.

BY ANNA BADKHEN | NOVEMBER 14, 2011

SIOGERT, Afghanistan — From time to time, Qasim looks at me in the rearview mirror of his taxicab and plays tour guide.

"See this shrine?" He nods toward a green flag that flutters from a stake jutting out of the ground amid the white flashes of unpicked cotton. Behind it rise the breast-shaped clay roofs of the village of Siogert. "Seven brothers were killed here. They were Uzbek. They were fleeing the Taliban, in 1997. We were all fleeing then."

"See this flag?" Another stake, this one driven into a mud wall by the road. Short, diagonal grooves dimple the wall: the palm marks of the men who molded it by hand out of the desert. "One brother killed another brother here, over land. It was after the fall of the Taliban.

Then someone killed the killer; I'm not sure who."

In rush hour Mazar-e-Sharif, Qasim's yellow-and-white Corolla crawls through a roundabout near the western gate of the Blue Mosque, the legendary burial place of Ali, the Prophet Mohammed's son-in-law. In the morning fog, the turquoise shrine shimmers, as if it were encased in ice. Men draped with thin camel-wool blankets stroll through the mist in reverent quietude to feed the 10,000 white doves said to flock here.

Qasim's eyes meet mine in the rearview mirror. "In the time of the Taliban in this place they hanged a young man."

At an unpaved intersection several blocks away, Qasim's car rocks gently over a bomb crater. On this spot last July, a suicide bomber detonated a device strapped to his bicycle, killing four people. "See this?" Qasim says. "I was at a cafe down the block, finishing my lunch. Had I left a minute earlier, I wouldn't have been here today."

Each murder clings to the Bactrian plains like soot from a bukhari stove, like a patina of rot, until it becomes part of the landscape: indelible, unredeemable, conditioning people's memories and yearnings. Until it takes root in a land harrowed by centuries of village-scale ethnic cleansings and fratricides. "The problem is in this soil," a local police officer once told me, "and it keeps cropping up."

I have been coming here for a decade. At times, it has seemed possible to render the war that torments northern Afghanistan in simplistic terms. Ten years ago, with the help of a U.S.-led invasion, the region's secularists, monarchists, Islamic conservatives, soldiers of fortune, and armed hangers-on kicked the Taliban out of power. Recently, after several years of relative calm, the Taliban have made a comeback here. They are steadily claiming territory and facing little resistance from either NATO -- which is too busy fighting in the south -- or the locals, who feel betrayed and abandoned by the West and its kleptocratic protégés in Kabul.

But the violence that torments the Khorasan's infinite plains does not boil down to a fight between insurgents and a weak government backed by a NATO occupation, with millions of disillusioned, and mostly destitute, civilians stuck on the ever-shifting battlefield. Sometimes it emerges from a helix of revenge that began with a property dispute. Sometimes it is a suppuration of an ethnic wound inflicted decades or centuries ago but never truly healed. Sometimes it is all of the above, or none.

Anna Badkhen

 

Anna Badkhen is the author of Peace Meals and Waiting for the Taliban, now out in paperback. She is writing a book about timelessness. Her reporting from Afghanistan is made possible by a grant from the Pulitzer Center on Crisis Reporting.

MASYNEE

7:42 PM ET

November 14, 2011

Shocked

Wow, that's a powerful article. I had no idea just how bad things were on a personal, daily level for the people in Afghanistan. It must be like living in a nightmare. What a gift peace would be in this part of the world.

 

A11242408

5:36 AM ET

November 15, 2011

As is obvious here, nobody in

As is obvious here, nobody in hell could know the answer to what ails this poor region. At least someone has been there to somewhat note its suffering though.YouTube Converter Mac

 

FORLORNEHOPE

7:57 AM ET

November 15, 2011

Great article - Good Book

For further insights into the horrible complexity of these problems, try reading "The Places In Between" by Rory Stewart. It's also a great read.

 

DDSNAIK

12:14 PM ET

November 15, 2011

I 2nd Forelorn's recommendation but...

This is quite an un-PC statement, and I'm not a cultural rube unable to appreciate nuance or complexity, but but the role of an indigenous culture that insists on medieval way of life has to factor in equally into the etiology.

The incessant reports of decapitations and subjugation of women and accepted deadly violence subsequent to offenses imagined or real aren't fabricated or incidental. Until the Pashtuns/Uzbeks/etc. themselves want to live in a stable, minimally modern and civil society with infrastructure, order, modest services, the cycle of revenge killings, physical degradation, and the pervasive hopelessness will only continue. I understand that not all Afghans embrace the status quo. Some even hope for progress and would be willing to meet the modern world halfway... but enough don't.

Before the liberal fringe rushes to dismiss my comments, keep in mind that the receptive quotient of Afghans still insist on accepting our "help" only as long as their way of life isn't threatened. That's the point I'm trying to make.

 

IANW

12:25 PM ET

November 15, 2011

Ddnsniak

Yes, and thats why we shouldnt be there.

He who serves the cause of the Revolution in South America, or Texas, or Afghanistan, is plowing the sea.

 

DDSNAIK

12:38 PM ET

November 15, 2011

Maybe but that's another argument altogether

Wasn't this one supposed to be the valid war ? I.E. Due to an actual threat instead of an imagined or fabricated (cough, cough, Iraq) ?

I won't pretend to know what we should have done exactly, but AQ running around setting off bombs, then scurrying back to their hideouts in the mountains - sanctuary provided by the Taliban due to financial incentives as much as ideological overlap - invited a response for sure. I'm not sure what, if we're ostensibly not in the business of national building, we're still doing there, but this article was more about the sense of hopelessness/despair/etc. and much less yet another commentary on our involvement, so...

 

MARTY MARTEL

4:42 PM ET

November 15, 2011

Nothing new here

What else is new?

This was the predictable outcome when U. S. decided to recruit terrorist State of Pakistan to fight the very terrorists that Pakistani State had created.

Sandy Berger, Clinton’s national security advisor told 9/11 Commission in 2004 that 'Pakistani Army was the midwife of Taliban'. UN report on Bhutto killing released on 4/15/2010 confirmed this fact when it flatly noted that "The PAKISTANI MILITARY ORGANIZED AND SUPPORTED THE TALIBAN TO TAKE CONTROL OF AFGHANISTAN IN 1996“.

Intentional and willful denial of Pakistani State’s terrorist connections by Bush administration since 2001 and then Obama administration have brought this untold suffering to not just American troops but to Afghan – civilian and security - people as well.

The seeds of the ‘current Afghan tragedy’ were sowed in Washington when Bush administration decided to allow Musharraf to spirit away by airlift hundreds, if not thousands, of Taliban operatives cornered by the advancing Northern Alliance in Kunduz in November, 2001. Pakistan relocated those Taliban cadres including Mullah Mohammed Omar in Quetta, the provincial capital of Baluchistan (now relocated to Karachi by Pakistani ISI to protect them from possible US drone attacks) and Haqqani network (HQN) in North Waziristan from where Mullah Omar’s QST and Haqqani’s HQN have been planning raids in Afghanistan ever since.

U. S. has deliberately deluded itself about Afghan Taliban’s Pakistani connections in fueling and sustaining Afghan insurgency as reported by Matt Waldman in ‘The sun in the sky‘ on 6/13/2010, corroborated by WikiLeaks leaks on 7/25/2010 and then further corroborated by Chris Alexander, Canadian ambassador to Afghanistan from 2003 to 2005 and Deputy Special Representative of the UN Secretary-General for Afghanistan from 2005 until 2009 in his article on 7/30/2010 titled ‘The huge scale of Pakistan‘s complicity‘.

Duplicitous Pakistan has U. S. under the barrel of a gun - US can NOT use its aid leverage to force Pakistan to stop supporting terrorist groups who have been killing US/NATO troops in Afghanistan day in and day out since 2001 because US needs Pakistan’s help in ferrying supplies to those very US/NATO troops.

Obama administration is already asking Pakistan to provide access to Afghan Taliban leaders safely ensconced under Pakistani ISI/Army's protection. A facade of peace deal as dictated by Pakistan will be reached with Afghan Taliban leaders chosen by Pakistan. US will begin its drawdown and finally exit the theater of a war it is desperate not to be seen as having lost, not so much to the Taliban and Al Qaeda as to the wily Generals of Rawalpindi who have proved to be smarter than the Americans.

That facade of peace will crumble within few years after the departure of US troops and Pakistan will bring Afghanistan under its suzerainty with reimposition of Taliban rule just as it did in 1996 while Uncle Sam will helplessly look the other way.

 

KSUBAHAGIA

11:40 AM ET

December 8, 2011

Living in Afghanistan

Living in Afghanistan, I have witnessed many kinds of violence during my lifetime. Afghan men always say that they respect women more than men in Western countries. This may be true pe treatment , but not within their own families

 

KJWILSON

3:58 AM ET

December 11, 2011

Nothing shocking here

Before the Pashtuns/Uzbeks/etc. themselves wish to reside in a reliable, minimally modern and civil society with infrastructure, order, modest guide, periodic revenge killings, physical degradation, and also the pervasive hopelessness is only going to continue. I realize that does not all Afghans embrace things as they are.

 

FRIVCITY

4:43 AM ET

December 13, 2011

Generals of Rawalpindi

A facade of peace deal as dictated by Pakistan will be reached with Afghan Taliban leaders chosen by Pakistan. US will begin its drawdown and finally exit the theater of a war it is desperate not to be seen as having lost, not so much to the Taliban and Al Qaeda as to the wily Generals of Rawalpindi who have proved to be smarter than the Americans. Miniclip Starfall Funbrain Miniclip Friv. The Answer either. As is obvious here, nobody in hell could know the answer to what ails this poor region.