Putin and the Boo-boys

A new wave of anti-Putin sentiment is sweeping Russia, but with the once-and-future president still loved by more than two-thirds of the population, there's little hope for change.

BY JULIA IOFFE | NOVEMBER 29, 2011

MOSCOW – With a week to go until Russia's parliamentary elections, Prime Minister Vladimir Putin took the stage on Sunday, Nov. 27, in front of 11,000 hooting, flag-waving United Russia delegates. He delivered a vigorous, nebulous speech about how long he has served his country (his whole life) and led a few cheers (when I say "Russia," you say "Hoorah!"). Then he formally accepted the party's nomination to represent it in the March presidential elections, which he will win in a landslide. It was both a formality and a preemptory victory lap, as well as a strange repetition of the September party congress, at which he and still-president Dmitry Medvedev agreed, essentially, to swap places. But if September's convention -- held at the same Moscow sports arena as the one yesterday -- was a curve ball, yesterday's festival of triumphalism was both expected and bizarre.

"This optimistic tone does not correspond to the depressive, anxious mood of many in the country right now, and it was unclear who it was aimed at," says political consultant Gleb Pavlovsky, who helped Putin win his first presidential election, in 2000. Pavlosvky  pointed out that Sunday's fanfare smacked of the "pre-crisis" era -- that is, the end of Putin's first, petroleum-fueled run as president. That chest-thumping tone was fine then, says Pavlovsky, but "today, it just looks anachronistic."

Much has changed in the years since Putin formally stepped down from the presidency. With Medvedev's arrival came talk of modernization, a détente with the United States, a bit more oxygen in the system. But in the two months since the Medvedev-Putin swap -- which seemed to dismiss all of that goodwill as formalities -- something else has changed, too: What was once easily classifiable as public apathy has quickly fermented into a very palpable dissatisfaction, and it is one that is increasingly breaking through the surface, even in places where it is not expected.

The most notable -- and most symbolic -- of these bubbles has been the "booing revolution." It started earlier this month with a concert by a legendary Soviet rock group Mashina Vremeni ("Time Machine") in the Siberian city of Kemerovo, which was going well until an emcee announced that the concert had been sponsored by the ruling United Russia party. He couldn't finish his speech because the sudden wave of booing was so loud. Later, the local authorities threw the emcee under the bus -- they were not sponsoring the concert, and he was just a provocateur -- but Kemerovo started a trend. A couple of weeks later, at a Cheliabinsk hockey game, the captain of the local team ("Tractor") skated onto the ice and read a speech praising United Russia and the Cheliabinsk governor. The crowd didn't stop booing until the player had skated back to the bench. Afterwards, Tractor's fanclub clarified that "we were booing not Antipov [the team captain] who read that speech with a sour face, but the situation itself, the governor of Cheliabinsk, and United Russia with its inappropriate attempt to promote itself."

The main event, however, came on Nov. 20, when Putin showed up at a Moscow stadium for a mixed martial arts fight between Russian Fedor Emilianenko and American Jeff Monson. Emilianenko won, and Putin decided to congratulate his compatriot by climbing into the ring and praising him as "a real Russian knight." The problem was that few people could hear him over the sound of 20,000 people booing and shouting "go away!"

ALEXANDER NEMENOV/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: RUSSIA, CENTRAL ASIA
 

Julia Ioffe is Foreign Policy's Moscow correspondent.

CHIMASTER

6:37 AM ET

November 30, 2011

Interesting Post.....the election should be interesting

Great post. As a hypnotherapist, I meet a lot of paranoid people looking for hypnotherapy London to help panic attacks and anxiety. This definitely does not help them.

 

AARKY

9:34 PM ET

November 30, 2011

Putin Gets Boo'ed

There is probably an international dislike of politicians who show up at popular sporting events and expect the crowd to cheer them and clap. I remember a baseball game from many years ago when the announcer started announcing some big wigs from the US Treasury. By the second name the boos began and really increased as the announcer stupidly continued to introduce the bigwigs. The same thing happened recently at a NASCAR event when they tried to introduce Michelle Obama and Jill Biden

 

AINSLIEJONES

1:06 AM ET

December 1, 2011

Like This Site

This site is my favorite . I read all the articles over here .I like to write the articles . My topic is related to my profession as a fashion designer i write on women fashion , dressing style , Cocktail Dress , Red Carpet Gowns or Winter Dresses 2012 .

 

RAJMEEJ23

12:34 PM ET

December 1, 2011

this is one of my favorite site.

Every day i came here to get some great article from here. as AINSLIEJONES said "I like to write the articles . My topic is related to tech and gadget". so how to apply to become editors.

thank you again.

Best Regards,
PSEXAM
ICT TRENDS
Palletizer Machine

 

MASSAGENS TANTRICAS

7:50 AM ET

December 8, 2011

Putin Gets Boo'ed

i Agree in politicians who show up at popular sporting events and expect the crowd to cheer them and clap. I remember a baseball game from many years ago when the announcer started announcing some big wigs from the US Treasury. Thanks for sharing !

 

STEREOAGENT

3:21 AM ET

December 21, 2011

Putin

I thank that it is hard to judge Putin if you are not living in Russia. Off course he became a dictator, but still he is making a lot of positive things. Last week, Putin dismissed criticism of the vote by U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton as part of U.S. efforts to weaken Russia.
“They still fear our nuclear potential,” he said. “We also carry an independent foreign policy, and, of course, it’s an impediment for some.”

Best regards,
Edward from Stuttering Cure

 

YARINSIZ

4:16 PM ET

December 24, 2011

I remember a baseball game

I remember a baseball game from many years ago when the announcer started announcing some big wigs from the US Treasury. By the second name the boos began and really increased asseslichat the announcer stupidly continued to introduce the bigwigs.

 

EDDYTHOMAS

1:57 PM ET

December 26, 2011

A United Russia? Far From It

A couple of days prior to the election, I heard a rumor that United Russia could be pleased with merely a simple majority, instead of the two-thirds majority it's now - the party’s priority would be that the presidential election in March appear legitimate, to ensure that Mr. Putin can replace Dmitri Medvedev, his underling and also the current president, and remain in power until 2024. However in the finish, once the minimalist training asserted United Russia received 1 / 2 of the vote, most Russians knew the outcomes were manipulated, and suspected the party got less.