Election Hardball, Kremlin Style

In advance of Sunday's parliamentary ballot, the pro-Putin camp is cracking down hard on independent election monitors.

BY JULIA IOFFE | DECEMBER 2, 2011

On Sunday, Nov. 27, when Vladimir Putin accepted United Russia's nomination to be its presidential candidate, he mentioned something in his acceptance speech that seemed to come out of left field. "The representatives of certain foreign governments gather people to whom they give money -- so-called 'grantees' -- whom they instruct, find them 'suitable work' in order to influence the result of the election campaign in our country," he said, adding that "Judas is not the most respected biblical character among our people." It was old-school, West-bashing, Cold War-invoking Putin at his best.

It was also, it turns out, very carefully aimed. Over the weekend, as United Russia waved its flags and cheered its leader, two journalists from state-controlled television station NTV showed up at the offices of Golos ("Voice" or "Vote"), the only Russian NGO with the means and credibility to monitor elections. The uninvited film crew came to sit in on a training session for volunteers and, according to Golos's accounts, made quite the entrance. They watched a Golos training video and interviewed the organization's director, Lilia Shibanova (as she told me, "aggressively"), asking her about her organization's connection to the CIA.

The next day, the same journalists arrived to find Grigory Melkonyants, Golos's deputy director. They stuck a camera in his face and started yelling at him about the etiology of his salary (the United States, naturally) and alleging that Golos was attempting to disrupt Sunday, Dec. 4's parliamentary elections. The resultant video, recorded on Melkonyants's phone, quickly went viral when it made it onto the web a couple of days later. It shows the two screaming at each other: NTV insinuating sordid connections to shadowy Western organizations, Melkonyants repeating over and over and over again: "You are Surkov's propaganda." (He was referring to Vladislav Surkov, the architect of the power vertical, creator of United Russia and Nashi, and a man who makes Karl Rove look like a professional dilettante.) The repetition of the phrase -- 84 times in all -- was designed to make the footage unusable for the kind of hatchet pieces NTV airs on figures who suddenly fall from official grace.

The half-hour film segment, called "Voice Out of Nowhere," finally made it onto the air Friday, but not before three Duma deputies wrote a letter to Russia's prosecutor general, alleging that Golos's newspaper breaks the law by "giving direct assessments of the progress of the election campaign in our country." Furthermore, the organization, the deputies allege, is merely a shell organization for the U.S. Congress and State Department to influence internal Russian politics. The deputies' demand? Shut Golos down.

A statement by Vladimir Churov, head of the Central Election Commission and loyal Putin defender, followed, claiming that Golos was waging a campaign against United Russia. There was the sudden removal of a banner on Wednesday from the liberal Internet newspaper Gazeta.ru advertising its joint project with Golos: an interactive map tracking all election law violations submitted by users. (Asked whether Gazeta.ru had been pressured to remove this banner, Editor in Chief Mikhail Kotov only said, "I'd rather leave this without comment.") Then, Friday, in a hastily scheduled court hearing and verdict, Golos was found guilty, during just one morning session, of abusing media privileges -- and ordered to pay a roughly $1,000 fine.

ALEXANDER ZEMLIANICHENKO/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: RUSSIA, CENTRAL ASIA
 

Julia Ioffe is Foreign Policy's Moscow correspondent.

COSSACK

9:00 PM ET

December 2, 2011

He's getting ready for

He's getting ready for another revolution, when him and his cronies will flee to London

 

BRAUERR31

2:21 PM ET

December 4, 2011

Perhaps

I definitely agree with what you say here. I mean, what he's doing lately is preparation for a possible revolution of sorts. I doubt he'll flee but only time will tell what happens next. For now, I'm going to continue to putz around online.

 

YASIR QUANTUMSEOLABS

12:59 PM ET

December 3, 2011

How it works

This is the oldest trick in the book. Blame the CIA for rigging the elections so that if you lose you simply say I told you that before!

 

MAVEE22

1:47 AM ET

December 4, 2011

Let's see what happens next

I saw this news when I was jogging on one of my treadmills with TV. I saw this and I realized how the country would be like under Putin. I hope everything should go better this time. Well, let's see what happens next.

 

LLLZZZ08

1:50 AM ET

December 4, 2011

www.voguebloom.com

Christmas gifts from here == http://www.voguebloom?com/ ====
Good quality and many kinds of fashion goods for you ...
Come on!!!won't let you down...

 

LLLZZZ08

1:54 AM ET

December 4, 2011

www.voguebloom.com

Christmas gifts from here == http://www.voguebloom.com/ ====
Good quality and many kinds of fashion goods for you ...
Come on!!!won't let you down...
a nice place just for you
you can find many ch`eapest and fashi0n stuff
Regret is youpaying no attention to this and miss this
I think you will like this , To see is to earn !easy for you to refering to you frends tks!
http://www.voguebloom.com/

 

ANDY33

3:00 AM ET

December 4, 2011

Election hardball

This is the same old story again, $1,000 fine is that it..ukseoservices footballers get hefty fines just for swearing at the ref.

 

JS_2011

5:34 AM ET

December 4, 2011

Election hardball

It is interesting to see Putin put his proxy back on the shelf and come back out again in true style. Despite the hyped up "reset" relations designed to make Hillary look like a true leader, Putin has really reset relations in his own style. What the real shame of it all is that none of this is necessary, a little logic, a bit of negotiation and a bit of campaigning he could have it all. Too bad - maybe he just needs some reputation management and a bit of tough love?

 

SOPHIE84

7:35 AM ET

December 4, 2011

http://www.vogueboom.com

Christmas gifts from here == http://www.vogueboom.com/ ====
Good quality and many kinds of fashion goods for you ...
Come on!!!won't let you down...
a nice place just for you
you can find many ch`eapest and fashi0n stuff
Regret is youpaying no attention to this and miss this
I think you will like this , To see is to earn !easy for you to refering to you frends tks!

 

FFBBFFGMAIL

8:07 AM ET

December 4, 2011

See what happens next

I Agree in saw this and I realized how the country would be like under Putin. I hope everything should go better this time. Well, let's see what happens next, good work! Seguro Imoveis Massagistas Acompanhantes Ar Condicionado Carro

 

BOHNMJFGHJ

8:36 AM ET

December 4, 2011

we are accept credit card free shipping

Wonderful.

Share a website with you ,

http://mcaf.ee/6e4ac

Believe you will love it.

we are accept credit card free shipping

 

RNRJVJ

8:42 PM ET

December 4, 2011

let's see what happens

Let's see what happens next as a result of his actions burnham boilers

 

FRIVCITY

2:49 AM ET

December 5, 2011

Still Kremlin gets on

The good news is in the last part of this article. Whatever kind of parliament the Kremlin gets on Sunday, Surkov will find a way to work with it or around it. But, given the public rumblings of the last two months as well as the Kremlin's crass response, it seems that the Kremlin is increasingly uncertain about how its citizens will spend that hour. Friv | Friv Games

 

PENYAKIT DIABETES

4:47 AM ET

December 5, 2011

Long live Russia

Long live Russia. Russia shall be great again.
Cara membuat blog

 

GUTSHELL

9:11 AM ET

December 5, 2011

It would be nice to see at

It would be nice to see at least a little democracy in Russia, if nothing else than to give the opposition a voice. Sadly, it looks like business as usual, with the government preventing the media from reporting anything negative, and the elections "managed" by the ruling party. Such a shame really. Tennis Blog

 

TOM ELLIOTT

10:32 AM ET

December 6, 2011

Democracy in Russia does'nt

Democracy in Russia does'nt exist i'm afraid - bottom line until Putin and his cronies are gone the people still live in the same old corrupt world of communism

Tom

 

JOCURI0212

2:43 AM ET

December 9, 2011

Intersting article

I have to agree with Tom on this.Democracy in Russia doesn't exist and never will in a country with communist mentality. | jocuri

 

YARINSIZ

6:16 PM ET

December 31, 2011

It is interesting to see

It is interesting to see Putin put his proxy back on the shelf and come back out again in true style. seslichat Despite the hyped up "reset" relations designed to make Hillary look like a true leader, Putin has really reset relations in his own style.