A More Perfect European Union

EU leaders may have their hands full with the debt crisis, but they can't ignore the crumbling peace in Serbia and Kosovo.

BY SEN. JEANNE SHAHEEN | DECEMBER 8, 2011

European leaders are gathering in Brussels on Dec. 8 to organize a collective response to the growing debt crisis -- but it's not only the euro that endangers European unity. Lost in the headlines is the possibility of renewed violence in the western Balkans, which threatens to roll back the significant progress we have made in the region over the past 15 years. The deteriorating security situation in northern Kosovo requires an urgent, united, and focused transatlantic response that re-commits us to helping bring the countries of the region into Europe and the West. Unfortunately -- judging by German Chancellor Angela Merkel's recent statements suggesting Serbia may not be offered EU candidate status this year -- we may miss an important opportunity to calm tensions and move the region toward Euro-Atlantic integration.  

Last week, the U.N. envoy in Kosovo called the situation in the north "extremely volatile," noting that "combined factors of frustration, fear, and mistrust could easily and quickly provide the spark that could ignite violence." The fact is, we have already begun to see violence.

Last week, more than two dozen NATO soldiers were hospitalized with gunshot wounds and broken bones when clashes broke out with local Serb protesters in northern Kosovo. The NATO troops were attempting to remove roadblocks in the north in order to ensure freedom of movement and supply lines for their forces.

The United States and our European allies support the right of all people to protest peacefully. However, violence against NATO troops attempting to maintain the peace is absolutely unacceptable. Attacks will do nothing to advance the objectives of Kosovar Serbs and will only isolate them further in the transatlantic community. NATO leadership has responded that it will use "all means available" to defend its troops, and the entire alliance will stand behind them.

One can understand, in today's current economic climate, why European eyes are turned inwards, as our close allies in Brussels, Berlin, Paris, and elsewhere attempt to stem the growing contagion within the eurozone borders. However, the situation in Kosovo and Serbia calls out for attention and transatlantic leadership. At a time when economic and security challenges are all around us, our alliance cannot forget about its own backyard.

Serbian President Boris Tadic has rightly called for the dismantling of the barricades in northern Kosovo, saying that they "do not defend a single national interest." I agree with President Tadic, and believe that all people in the region, Serbians and Albanians alike, have absolutely nothing to gain -- and much to lose -- by a return to violence. I would echo Tadic's call for all sides to demonstrate restraint at such a tense and dangerous time.

There is no appropriate military solution to the dispute in northern Kosovo. The alternative -- a sustainable, peaceful resolution -- will require time, patience, and diplomatic creativity. Leaders in both Kosovo and Serbia have boldly decided to return to the negotiating table to continue important technical talks, despite the unrest and the political difficulties these negotiations have prompted. This renewed round of discussions follows on several months of progress, particularly with respect to customs and border issues.

These talks need to accomplish much more, and both sides need to demonstrate their serious commitment to progress in the days and months ahead. None of us should allow a small number of extremist forces to undermine the significant progress being made between Kosovo and Serbia, and the United States and Europe should redouble our efforts to give political cover to both sides as they engage in politically difficult -- but necessary -- discussions on the future of their relationship.

SASA DJORDJEVIC/AFP/Getty Images

 

U.S. Senator Jeanne Shaheen is the chair of the Senate Foreign Relations Subcommittee on European Affairs.

CREMENTOSREX

10:08 PM ET

December 8, 2011

The true reality of Kosovo

Senator Shaheen,

Unfortunately, the premise of your argument is fundamentally flawed. The artificial state of Kosovo is merely a political construct. Quite simply, there are no "Kosovar" people. Individuals living in Kosovo identify themselves as Serbs, Albanians, Bosnians or Gorancis, not Kosovars. NATO's hamfisted attempts at nation-building and statecraft have failed to eliminate centuries old ethnic identification. Kosovo has historically been culturally and religiously significant for the Serbian people. However, throughout the 19th and 20th centuries Albanian immigration altered the demographic balance of Kosovo. Thus the only viable solution for the region is to dismember the Kosovar pseudo-state. Kosovo must be divided between the Albanians and Serbians in order to establish a permanent solution. Violence and civil strife will continue indefinitely until true settlement is in place.

 

NIHONSEAN

11:32 PM ET

December 8, 2011

Of Course You're Wrong!!!

shhhhh. You need to sit down and listen to your betters. Obviously politicians in Brussels, Washington and London know what is best for the little people of Kosovo. Melding them together into one happy nation is the only way. It has been decided! It'll work out, just you see! In fact almost one hundred years ago they created Yugoslavia. Look at how well that turned out.

 

BUREAUCRACYWARRIOR

8:39 AM ET

December 9, 2011

BINGO!

Becoming more involved with that region is just about the last thing we, or Western Europe, should do. We've already screwed things up badly enough.

 

METERNIK

4:07 PM ET

December 9, 2011

That went for Iraq too

Trying to meld together disparate ethnic and religious groups in Iraq has been a thankless and questionable task for the past decade. Iraq was a fiction since it was carved out of the Ottoman Empire at the end of WW1. Better to have carved it into semi-cohesive units based on Sunni, Shia, and probably Kurd influence. What's so special about an arbitrary nation held together at gunpoint by Saddam for forty years and now by us?

Cobbling nations out of pieces that don't want to be put together has a pretty spotty history. If it works, it's usually only out of the end of a gun. Some like to talk about the "stability" of colonial empires compared with the ethnic/religious fighting that characterizes many post-colonial regimes, but conveniently ignore that the empire-builders were more or less constantly involved in vicious wars to hold them together. Race and religion are like centrifugal forces, constantly pulling things apart.

What was once a duty to "civilize" the world is now pure hubris in the name of "stability."

 

DEDA CVETKO

10:20 PM ET

December 8, 2011

A More Perfect European Union

The "more perfect" European Union of 2014 gradually taking shape today is beginning to dangerously resemble the utterly imperfect European disunion of 1914 -- with ferocious, aggressive, unyielding, unforgiving, vengeful and expansion-bound Germany, revamped Austro-Hungarian Empire seeking to restore its former Hapsburg glory, timid France and Great Britain entirely disoriented and shell-shocked, and small and bullied Serbia waiting to be eaten alive. The only thing waiting to happen is for Austria to send it's Crown Prince (or the President) to Sarajevo on June 28, 2014 and for some lunatic to pull the trigger, and the continent will have come full circle.

While the Europe of 2014 may begin to look like 1914, I am pretty sure that, if Germany and Austria continue their Drang nach Osten, the Europe of 2018 will look nothing like the Europe of 1918. Someone should read these two nations - and their respective leaders - a riot act before they decide to proceed down this dangerous, dangerous path.

 

UK_RYEBACE

2:23 AM ET

December 9, 2011

WANTED: American Leadership

Dear SEN. JEANNE SHAHEEN,

Merkel has directly linked Kosovo serb violence with the serbian government. And rightly so, Serbia's proxy wars should end NOW.

Obviously Europeans can see it, but have no will to do anything about it.

You speak with blind admiration of Tadic calling for "dismantling" of barricades which his ministers themselves set up. That lip service is just for naive europeans, manipulating them to believe that he deserves accession talk without taking any actions. He has all the strings.
Do you believe that 10,000 civilians wake up one day and are ready to stand up to 2 million albanians? No ma'am, they have Tadic's backing.

You speak of Kosova and Serbian mediation are taking place, true, but the Serbian side never implements them. Serbia is making a mockery out of EU, US and international community.

That's why there is a big need of American leadership, where Serbia is no longer allowed to destabilize the region and play the international community like clowns. Have we forgot Bosnia, Srebenica and republica Srpska?

Since Europe can only carry carrots, its up to America to bring in the sticks.

Sincerely,

U_Krye Bace

 

F1FAN

11:39 AM ET

December 9, 2011

The right of self determintaion..............

Unless you are a Serb living in Kossovo. Then the EU determines your fate for you.

 

KRYPTER

12:48 PM ET

December 9, 2011

Senator

Why are NATO troops using violence against Kosovo Serb civilians? If Kosovo can separate from Serbia, why cannot Serbian Kosovo separate from Albanian Kosovo?

I supported NATO in its attack on the Serbian dictatorship of Milosevic, but this is going too far now. You're selectively and hypocritically applying the right of self-determination. Both sides are now democratic and have the right to decide their own borders, communities and fences without NATO violence.

 

DAVID EDENDEN

2:16 PM ET

December 9, 2011

Nato Values re: Minority Rights are Greek Values

Dear Jeanne Shaheen

Can you introduce a resolution in the US Senate urging Greece to recognize the existence of an ethnic Macedonian minority (as well as a Turkish minority)?

This will go along way to promoting peace in the Balkans.

The 50,000 strong ethnic Macedonian minority in Greek are denied basic human rights regarding minority education, access to media and the right to establish their Macedonian Orthodox Church and Macedonian cultural organisations.

Since Greece is a member of Nato, these values are also Nato values. Any Serb who puts an once of trust in Nato is naive.

 

RICINCT

4:38 PM ET

December 9, 2011

Illegal Aliens in Kosovo

Sen. Shaheen and the rest of the New World Order need a reality check!! Every time the U.S. enforces the will of the now defunct British Empire...Europe suffers...had America stayed out of WWI and allowed Europe to resolve its own geo-political issues...there would have been NO Versailles Treaty, No "Yugoslavia" and No "Czechoslovakia"...and most important of all...no Hitler or WWII...ignorant leaders in Washington with no real understanding of Europe or its ethnic boundaries do nothing but damage with their ham-fisted treaties and blind loyalty to the former colonial powers in London and Paris. Since the fall of the Soviet Empire the U.S has been busy...creating or supporting Muslim mini-states...Bosnia,Kosovo."Northern Cyprus" and the future Muslim state of Macedonia. Legitimate issues...like the return of Moldavia to Romania...the genocide practiced by the Poles and the Czechs against Eastern Germans and the rights of Hungarians in Slovakia are ignored. Of course once the Anglo-American majority dissapears in the U.S. a new foreign policy dictated by a new demographic will emerge and soon...will Sen Shaheen or her succesors then hand over the Southwest to Mexico??? No need...Latinos will have the whole pie...they won't need a slice!!!

 

KAULITS

6:16 AM ET

December 10, 2011

The Roma and Slavic Muslims

The Roma and Slavic Muslims are in an even worse position. NATO has done virtually nothing to help make Kosovo safe for its minorities and now it wants to impose the rule of Kosovo's racist regime on the Northern serbs

 

DOMINOES

8:53 PM ET

January 6, 2012

amazing what slips through the cracks

When people only focus on money and whether or not there is enough, there are so many things that slip through and get in the way of things....it is sad to hear what the minorities are going through in Kosovo...I just hope they get things worked out and do not have to go through what they went through in the 90s air ambulance here is to hoping that things get worked out soon.