Turkey's War on Journalists

As Prime Minister Erdogan's government grows increasingly intolerant of dissent, the media is bearing the brunt of its effort to silence its critics.

BY ALIA MALEK | DECEMBER 22, 2011

ISTANBUL —When the terrorism trial of jailed Turkish journalists Ahmet Sik and Nedim Sener began in Istanbul on Nov. 22, only a handful of their colleagues -- far fewer than expected -- gathered in protest outside the courthouse that will decide their fate.

A mosaic of the smiling photographs of many of Turkey's detained journalists was laid out on the ground at the foot of a swarm of TV tripods, their cameras aiming for a glimpse of the defendants. Sik and Sener's case is perhaps the most high-profile example of what critics see as the Turkish government's crackdown on critical voices, which has transformed it into one of the world's leading jailers of journalists.

Some of the protesters wore T-shirts with a cartoon of a hand covering the mouth of someone trying to speak. Others carried signs written in English and Turkish. "TURKEY SET JOURNALISTS FREE; THERE CAN BE NO FREE SOCIETY WITHOUT FREE JOURNALISM," read the centerpiece.

Only one prominent columnist from the mainstream daily Haber Turk, Ece Temelkuran, was willing to risk joining those outside the courthouse. Already that morning, a colleague dropped by her office to tell her he was too afraid to go. He had moved his wife and children abroad and will join them as soon as he can.

"I too am afraid," Temelkuran admitted, eyeing the size of the crowd. "I'm freaking out." Having written repeatedly against what she sees as a crackdown on those who oppose AKP or Erdogan, she keeps a lawyer on stand-by should she be summoned.

Indeed, during the demonstration several people approached Temelkuran, a recognizable public figure, and said, "Next time, we'll be here for you."

Sik and Sener have been detained since March, on charges that seemed at first too ludicrous to stand. They are accused of being members of Ergenekon, a shadowy, ultranationalist group that allegedly has been trying to foment a coup against the Turkish government - despite the fact that Sik is known in Turkey for having written the definitive exposé on the group.

Sik's supporters believe he ran afoul of the Turkish justice system when he began to investigate the influence of the Fethullah Gulen movement, a powerful Islamist network that is one of Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan's most important pillars of support. Sener's research into the murder of the Armenian-Turkish journalist Hrant Dink -- which asserted that the police and the state were involved in his killing -- touched on another of Turkey's taboo subjects.

Sik and Sener's detention are hardly an anomaly in today's Turkey. Currently, 76 Turkish journalists are in jail, more than in any other country. In a Dec. 20, roundup, several more journalists were among those newly detained when the Turkish government jailed roughly 40 people, accusing them of links to Kurdish militants.

In addition to journalists, Erdogan's government has jailed lawyers, academics, and students, also ostensibly on terrorism-related charges that critics counter are transparent attempts to stifle freedom of expression and dissent.

The arrests, however, have yet to shock the conscience of most Turks. In June, voters returned Erdogan's Justice and Development Party (AKP) to power in a landslide. The current narrative that dominates discussion about Turkey -- both internationally and domestically -- emphasizes its booming economy and regional ascendance. For admirers in the Arab world, the AKP's devout orientation represents a path they seek to emulate. And for those in the West concerned by Arab Islamist parties' success at the ballot box, Erdogan's party is a comforting model for reconciling piety and democracy. Similarly, with the United States eyeing an opportunity to weaken Iran's influence in the region, specifically in Syria, Turkey has become ever more strategically important.

With Turkey and Erdogan basking in the glow of such electoral and international approval, watch-groups and critics say AKP feels entitled to have an equally friendly media and public at home.

MUSTAFA OZER/AFP/Getty Images

 

Alia Malek is the author of A Country Called Amreeka: U.S. History Retold Through Arab-American Lives and the editor of Patriot Acts: Narratives of Post-9/11 Injustice.

CERIAN

8:20 PM ET

December 22, 2011

Narrative is there..

but substance is missing. Author is quite good at identify what "bad" is by just talking to Ms.Temelkuran, but she lacks to put whole story in a historical perspective, thus, traps herself into just being an another ideologue on a crusade.

 

RMDUENAS

10:56 AM ET

December 23, 2011

Excellent piece

Thank you to Alia Malek for this report. It certainly helps understand what is currently going on in Turkey these days. It might be brief, but it certainly does not lack substance. It gives us a glimpse into how repression starts breeding in so called "democratic" governments. I wish all FP articles would have this quality!

 

ANYA KHAN

11:26 AM ET

December 23, 2011

Piety and democracy

In what universe is Erdogan either pious or democratic. The routine slaughter of Kurds? The continual denial of the Armenian slaughter? The breaking of treaties?

 

DUBLIN

6:06 PM ET

December 23, 2011

What speech?

Turkey is an infant when talking about freedom of speech having realized that phenomena less than 10 years ago. A mighty service will be done if this piece talked about the U.S - Does freedom of speech still exist in America?

 

UNIVERSALRESULTS

6:54 PM ET

December 23, 2011

Rather be worried if economic administration distressed

"provided its solid economic constitution" - on the foundation that the Lira is at an all time low ever since devaluation, and the cost of import goods owns actually leaped amazingly up by a minimum 25% Any more stable and it falls apart! Still, tell the country it's actually good comparable to indonesia in real estate investment such as Century 21 broker properti jual beli sewa rumah indonesia!

Turkey’s economic administration has the crucial experience and maturity to generate decisions without having panicking and take steps within a proactive way

 

AR

8:10 PM ET

December 23, 2011

Why are you assuming that

Why are you assuming that freedom of speech every existed in turkey? Just consider Article 301 of the Turkish penal code, the so called 'insulting turkishness', whatever that is. This is often used to silence the honest Turks who want to discuss the Armenian genocide, and have dialogue with Armenians.

If it were not for turkey's geo-strategic location, it wouldn't get nearly as much aid and attention from the West.

 

B881428

4:50 AM ET

December 25, 2011

It gives us a glimpse into

It gives us a glimpse into how repression starts breeding in so called "democratic" governments.PDF Editor for Mac
PDF Editor for Mac

 

CASA1

9:48 AM ET

December 25, 2011

'PKK are terrorist'

Merry Christmas to all!
He has acknowledged an armenian slaughter genius just not a genocide. Show me one western country that hasnt broken the majority of the treaties they signed....Thanks !
massagista

 

JOSSEFPERL

11:43 AM ET

December 25, 2011

Edrogan is Turkey's Vladimir Putin

Edrogan has shown himself to be exactly the same "wolf in sheep clothing" as Vladimir Putin. Just like in Putin's case who initially was considered to be a potential reformer (George Bush "looked into his soul and saw a friend" and Margaret Tatcher concluded "we could do business with him") both the Turks and the West thought the same of Edrogan; both are finding out that just like Putin who took control of the Russian media through intimidation (and often killings) of journalist, so does Edrogan. Both Putin and Edrogan have no reformer "bone" in their bodies, one is a product of the KGB and the other of a rigid Islamic background. The only difference between the two is in temperament; one unimotional and reserved (Putin) and the other is prone to staged temper tantrums (Edrogan.)

 

B3050612

8:50 PM ET

January 9, 2012

Always use caution when

Always use caution when giving out any personally identifying information about yourself or your children in any Communication Service. Deep River Sporting Clays and Shooting School does not control or endorse the content, messages or information found in any Communication Service and, therefore, Deep River Sporting Clays and Shooting School specifically disclaims any liability with mkv converterMKV ConverterYouTube Converter for MacYouTube To MP4 ConverterPdf Converter for Macregard to the Communication Services and any actions resulting from your participation in any Communication Service. Managers and hosts are not authorized Deep River Sporting Clays and Shooting School spokespersons, and their views do not necessarily reflect those of Deep River Sporting Clays and Shooting School.

 

LEVANTEN

10:48 AM ET

December 28, 2011

AR: Ask this question to

AR: Ask this question to yourself: Without its victim-playing and Russian bases, who cares about Armenia? Why Armenians are escaping from their own country?

Turkey is surrounded by oppressive regimes in its east: Armenia, Iran, Iraq, Syria...and surrounded by countries in crisis in the west, Greece, Bulgaria and rest of the EU. Oh yes, its geo-strategic location saves Turkey. Looks like that's the best Turkey could handle under these circumstances.

ALIA: What is missing in your article is diversity and objectivity. It's composed of selective use of sources presenting a biased view. The major discussion in Turkey is not jailing of journalists but longevity of court process, which is in some cases more than 3 years. And nobody knows what is going to happen in the end. Come on, there is no homeland security act in Turkey, and article 301 is not equivalent of it.

But, render unto Alia, this is a nice collection, but without context.

 

HECTORGREG11

6:37 PM ET

January 15, 2012

sad

This is sad that freedom of the press is not a worldwide right. We need a worldwide constitution of rights that all people have bestowed upon them at birth this will be hard to police the enforcement of these rules. We are all human beings and deserve the best in the world and a chance to make something of our lives Houston party bus...the world will be a great place when this is a reality no matter of skin color, religion, or place of birth. The world can become a great place for all people. I do not want to learn how to get rid of depression anymore, and it is not worth my time.

 

YARINSIZ

7:23 AM ET

January 21, 2012

but substance is missing.

but substance is missing. Author is quite good at identify what "bad" is by just talking to Ms.Temelkuran, but she lacks to seslichat put whole story in a historical perspective, thus, traps herself into just being an another ideologue on a crusade.