Crackdown in Cairo

Why is Egypt's military shutting down NGOs? I thought we had a revolution.

BY SARAH CARR | DECEMBER 29, 2011

CAIRO – There was a flurry of good news last week in Egypt. Activist Alaa Abdel-Fattah was released on Christmas Day, Cairo's Administrative Court issued a ruling banning "virginity tests," and thousands of women took part in a spirited march in downtown Cairo to denounce the military's brutal violence against women protesters during the breakup of a sit-in in front of the Cabinet building on Dec. 16 and 17.

That streak of good times was interrupted Thursday afternoon when public prosecution officials, assisted by armed Central Security Forces (CSF) soldiers -- Cairo's ubiquitous black-clad riot troops -- raided the offices of six civil society groups.

They started just after noon, with the 12th- floor headquarters of the Arab Center for the Independence of the Judiciary and the Legal Profession (ACIJLP), and continued on to five others, including three with ties to the U.S. government.

In early December, ACIJLP's director Nasser Amin was standing for election to the People's Assembly. Today, he watched as computers and files being were removed and his office sealed shut, his organization targeted as part of a sweeping campaign against NGOs accused of receiving foreign funding.

In the Hosni Mubarak years, civil society activity was heavily monitored and contained through two main mechanisms: arbitrary interference from the much much-feared State Security Investigations apparatus (now renamed National Security), and draconian legislation passed in 2002 that requires all NGOs to register with the Ministry of Social Solidarity (MOSS) and criminalizes the receipt of foreign funding without MOSS authorization.

Some NGOs registered as private businesses to avoid these restrictions, but the rules of the game have clearly changed. As Negad El-Borai, a rights lawyer, tweeted Thursday, "What never happened under the rule of Mubarak is happening after the revolution."

The authorities' harassment of civil society took a different form under Mubarak. While there were some incidents of government officials entering NGO premises, it was never on this scale. Thursday's raid on the six NGOs follows the slow boil of a smear campaign that began in July, according to which NGOs are receiving foreign funding as part of a nefarious plot to destabilize Egypt.

The raids seem to be the work of Fayza Abol Naga, a Mubarak stalwart who has headed the Ministry of International Cooperation, which deals with foreign organizations, since 2001 and has survived four government shakeups since February 2011.

We can't say she didn't warn us. On Dec. 21, state mouthpiece Al-Ahram reported that Abol Naga sent a report detailing foreign funding of local groups. Two of the groups supposedly named in the report -- the National Democratic Institute (NDI) and the International Republican Institute (IRI) -- were among those targeted in Thursday's raids.

I was among those gathered outside NDI's Cairo office on Thursday, where a tall CSF soldier dressed in a bulletproof vest carrying a shotgun stood sentry at the gate while behind him other armed men and men in suits occasionally appeared in the office's garden.

NDI employees drank coffee and smoked cigarettes in balconies, but were forbidden by CSF troops from talking to journalists. Nor were they allowed to leave the office for the duration of the search.

The tall soldier endured the journalists clustered at the gate. A young photographer asked his permission him to take a photo. The soldier replied that this is not allowed, and the two then engaged in a dreary, never-ending Mubarak-era type bartering session about where exactly on the pavement police control ends and public space and freedom begins. Luckily, this was interrupted by the soldier's mobile phone ringing. His ringtone was No Doubt's "Don't Speak" -- a fitting message on a day Egyptian civil society was being silenced.

The search went on for hours, until dusk. Gradually a collection of laptops, boxes full of files, video equipment, flip charts, and a safe accumulated behind the gate. Men in jeans and leather jackets gathered around it smoking. A friendly cat joined them.

A brief moment of drama was provided when a bad-tempered looking man in a suit, possibly a public prosecution office lawyer, slipped down the marble steps. He got up and turned around to remonstrate with the step, running his shoe over it in an attempt to identify slippery matter, possibly foreign-funded.

As this was happening, Egyptian activists resorted to their old standby: humor.

Hossam Bahgat, director of rights group the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights -- which itself is at risk -- tweeted, "All my life I've said that it's better that they take us from our offices with dignity than from our houses in sheets."

Later, he added that in addition to computers and files, the police had seized a kettle from one of the NGOs targeted, prompting a Twitter campaign for its release. (One joker suggested that the kettle had confessed that it is the "third party" in the military's conspiracy theory.)

Eventually, NDI's staff were permitted to leave. None would talk. The contents of the office were loaded onto the back of two police pick-up trucks and they disappeared into the night.

The CSF soldiers took rather longer to leave, as their truck wouldn't start and had to be pushed away. It was a fitting end to this shoddy and poorly disguised attempt to intimidate civil society, overseen by the ruling Supreme Council of Armed Forces (SCAF) -- itself funded by the United States to the tune of $1.3 billion per year, an irony that seemed to be lost on state television, which lapped up the SCAF's narrative of stopping the unseen foreign hand.

FILIPPO MONTEFORTE/AFP/Getty Images

 

Sarah Carr is a British Egyptian journalist based in Cairo. She blogs at www.inanities.org.

FRANK LAPLACE

2:50 PM ET

December 30, 2011

Next steps for Cairo

Sarah, I believe that in the aftermath of quite violent North African revolutions, one of the greatest fears was that what will replace the corrupt dictatorial leaderships would be leaders who are even worse.

It is critical that governance processes are quickly put into place to ensure a peaceful and effective transition to democracy. Having experienced such a transition, albeit largely non-violent in South Africa, the priorities Egypt and other North African countries should have are:

1. Collecting and destroying arms used during the respective revolutions

2. Accepting the support of international NGOs and aid bodies that have experience in implementing governance and electoral structures - the countries have neither the skill nor the infrastructure to roll out such change and they would be naive to think they can go it alone.

 

MICHELLE SUMMERS

3:05 PM ET

December 30, 2011

Hope for Cairo

You're right to some extent but I do believe the Egyptian people need to drive the process with support only from the West. They don't have the experience of running a true democracy I agree, but they're certainly not incompetent.

In your South Africa example you give, SA did not get much help for post-apartheid reconstruction from the west but they sure turned out ok! Give the people in Egypt a chance - there is a learning curve but they'll be fine!

 

B3050612

8:52 PM ET

January 9, 2012

Always use caution when

Always use caution when giving out any personally identifying information about yourself or your children in any Communication Service. Deep River Sporting Clays and Shooting School does not control or endorse the content, messages or information found in any Communication Service and, therefore, Deep River Sporting Clays and Shooting School specifically disclaims any liability with mkv converterMKV ConverterYouTube Converter for MacYouTube To MP4 ConverterPdf Converter for Macregard to the Communication Services and any actions resulting from your participation in any Communication Service. Managers and hosts are not authorized Deep River Sporting Clays and Shooting School spokespersons, and their views do not necessarily reflect those of Deep River Sporting Clays and Shooting School.

 

OLI RIKOVA

4:00 AM ET

December 31, 2011

Cairo

I think it's going to be a long while before countries like Libya and Egypt get restored to any sort of order. One can only hope that some new despot doesn't take the place of those ousted.

@Michelle Summers - I'm not so optimistic.

 

OOFDA

10:28 AM ET

December 31, 2011

There has not been a revolution

in Egypt. There were protests, but there has not been a revolution. As far as "Egy" being restored to order-- there is already order. Only in a small part of Cairo and other cities are there demonstrations. The greater part of that city and the country are living as before.

 

FLAPPER

1:20 PM ET

January 2, 2012

Reprehensible

Let's see...Sarah Carr writes a blog post attacking in a most unprofessional manner the editor of a newspaper in Egypt for making an editorial decision to not publish an article by Robert Springborg, that Foreign Policy later picks up.

This diatribe (written in Sarah's typical Tourette Syndrome style) manages to get the attention of Foreign Policy and they ask Sarah to write an article too.

Sarah is smug, thinks she has stepped up one step in her career with this sleight of hand. But at what price? That of alienating the editor of another publication.

Watch out Foreign Policy editors, you may be next to fall under Sarah''s poison dagger keyboard. But watch out even more Sarah, your lack of respect for your colleagues in journalism is not going to win you a lot of assigments if you keep it up.

 

ALEXNUNNS

12:25 PM ET

January 4, 2012

Reprehensible indeed

Let’s see… FLAPPER thinks it’s wrong to criticise a journalist, even when they are in fact acting as a censor and not a journalist, and makes this point by attacking Sarah Carr, a journalist. The reason why it’s wrong to attack a journalist (unless that journalist is Sarah Carr) is the high moral principle that it might harm the chances of future assigments [sic]. The lesson that FLAPPER felt was so important that it warranted a comment is that journalists should not be fearless seekers of truth, but craven lickspittles of those in power.

As if to prove the point, except not, FLAPPER elaborates how Sarah Carr’s “most unprofessional” behaviour has (somehow) advanced her professional career. FLAPPER speculates (because speculation is the mark of the professional journalist) that as a result of her “sleight of hand” (skill) Sarah Carr was commissioned to write a further assigment, proving beyond any doubt that if she keeps this up she won’t be commissioned to write further assigments [sic].

When a journalist shies away from a subject because it could harm their career they are no longer a journalist but a hack, a tool. Sadly, FLAPPER’s grand ideal of a limp form of craven lickspittle reporting is a true description of most journalism, but it’s unusual for anyone to aspire to it in public. So hats off to FLAPPER for honesty.

And hats off to FLAPPER for the description of Sarah Carr’s “Tourette Syndrome style” and “poison dagger keyboard”, which suggests she is a hell of a writer (as well as suggesting that FLAPPER follows her work closely and is perhaps a tiny bit jealous of her talent). It brings to mind Dorothy Parker’s “lacy sleeve with a bottle of vitriol concealed in its folds.”

I’ll take a modern Dorothy Parker over a flapper any day. [Rather strained 1920s joke]

 

BGVFYDFDSHJ

7:53 PM ET

January 2, 2012

very good web: ===

very good web: === http://www.plzzshop.com

The website wholesale for many kinds of fashion shoes, like the nike, jordan, prada, also including the jeans, shirts, bags, hat and the decorations.

All the products are free shipping, and the the price is competitive, and also can accept the paypal payment., After the payment, can ship within short time.

We will give you a discount

WE ACCEPT PYAPAL PAYMENT

YOU MUST NOT MISS IT!!!

=== http://www.plzzshop.com

thank you!!!

Believe you will love it.

We have good reputation, fashion products,

come here quickly== http://www.plzzshop.com

Opportunity knocks but once

 

HECTORGREG11

12:39 PM ET

January 25, 2012

Nothing changes

Lets be honest. Nothing has changed in Egypt and I doubt that anything will for the near future. They had a revolution, but they did not have anything in place to come in and make the country any different than it already was. Egypt has a long way to go, but this is some disturbing news for everyone who believes in democracy modern furniture austin texas By the looks of things, the military is going to take over and it will be a police state for the next part of time.

 

YARINSIZ

9:26 AM ET

January 27, 2012

You're right to some extent

You're right to some extent but I do believe the Egyptian people need to drive the process with support only from the West. seslichat They don't have the experience of running a true democracy I agree, but they're certainly not incompetent.