Ultra Violence

How Egypt’s soccer mobs are threatening the revolution.

BY JAMES M. DORSEY | FEBRUARY 1, 2012

Wednesday's lethal soccer riots in the Suez Canal town of Port Said, which left more than 73 spectators and security personnel dead, marks a watershed moment in Egypt after the ouster of former president Hosni Mubarak. This tragedy is not simply a story of a match gone horribly awry: It will have important and wide-ranging political ramifications, further isolate militant, highly politicized, violence-prone fan groups, single out the police for renewed criticism, and strengthen calls for the imposition of law and order.

Initial reports said the violence erupted during a match between storied Cairo club Al Ahly, Egypt's most popular team, and Premier League team Al Masry, with only a minimal number of security forces in the stadium. While Wednesday's deadly incident constitutes the worst soccer-related violence in an Egyptian stadium in the country's history, it is not the first time that militant fan groups -- or "ultras," modeled on similar groups in Italy and Serbia -- have invaded the pitch. The incident is but one of a series of violent events involving soccer fans since Mubarak's fall.

Don't Miss

As in April, when fans of Al Ahly's arch-rival Zamalek club invaded the pitch during the post-Mubarak era's first African Cup match against a Tunisian team, rumors were swirling in Egypt about the reasons for Wednesday's incident. Some Egyptians speculated that the security forces deliberately allowed the clashes to take place to prove that the police are needed to avoid a breakdown of law and order. Others suggested that Egypt's military rulers engineered the lack of a police presence in a bid to provoke the ultras and further undermine their credibility in a protest-weary country frustrated with the country's downward economic spiral.

Neither assumption is totally off the wall. Ultras clashed with security forces in Egyptian stadiums almost weekly for the four years before Mubarak's fall and have been engaged in running battles in the past year in which scores of people were killed and thousands wounded. Ultras played a key role in the 18-day uprising and afterwards, including the storming of State Security Services offices in February, the hours-long siege of the Israeli Embassy in September, and in street clashes near Tahrir Square in November and December, in which more than 50 people were killed and thousands injured.

The stakes are high for the ultras, with leaders effectively having lost control of a rank and file that has swelled in recent years with thousands of disaffected, unemployed, and often uneducated youth who believe it is payback time against a police force that is widely despised (the ultras' motto: "All Cops Are Bastards"). After the clashes at the Tunisia match in April, in which no one was killed, the leaders discussed suspending their activities. They are certain to take pause after the shocking number of deaths in Port Said.

But can they rein in the radicals? Beyond the payback factor, the absence of security in the stadiums means that for the first time in their history, the ultras own the venue. At the slightest provocation -- a controversial decision by a referee, for example -- the crowd goes berserk. That is all the more true for militant fans who see themselves as the club's only true supporters and view managers as Mubarak appointees and players as hired guns who will switch allegiance whenever another club makes a better offer.

MAHMUD HAMS/AFP/Getty Images

 

James M. Dorsey is senior fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies at Nanyang Technological University in Singapore and the author of the blog, The Turbulent World of Middle East Soccer.

MICHAELGERALDPDEALINO

9:51 PM ET

February 1, 2012

Grow up!

Egypt is one of the world's oldest civilizations, and this is what some Egyptians are doing? Burning a public library and rioting in a football match? For crying out loud, GROW UP!

 

LEONIDASLEONIDAS

5:33 AM ET

February 2, 2012

The ancient civilization of Egypt has nothing to do

with the Muslim Arabs that invaded Egypt in the 7th century.

The only direct descendants of the ancient Egyptians are the Copts, who are today an endangered minority in Egypt.

 

MELDAGHAR

9:34 AM ET

February 2, 2012

I hope the media realizes no

I hope the media realizes no body in Egypt is referring to the PorstSaid incident as soccer hooliganism except SCAF...

 

MAGPC

7:53 AM ET

February 2, 2012

From Egypt

It's a political set up from the F***ing SCAF, I don't like football and those Ultras as well, but those Ultras were the injured ones not because they engaged in a fight, but because they stayed in their part of the stadium, and the thugs attacked them while being seen by the Police who didn't do a thing, thugs had the same weapon, and gates were opened by someone from he field.
There are many facts supporting this

 

LEONIDASLEONIDAS

8:04 AM ET

February 2, 2012

This latest atrocity is just the latest manifestation

of the violence that is inherent in Arab society.

Arabs brainwash their children to hate Jews, they debase women, they murder homosexuals, and they in general have no respect for human life.

 

LUSHSOURBALL

9:37 AM ET

February 2, 2012

Racist much?

Because soccer riots never happen in Italy or England or Brazil.

 

KUNINO

1:45 PM ET

February 2, 2012

The nature of revolutions

When revolutions "succeed," they include some element of mob rule and reward it. Naive beliefs such as grab Saddam Hussein and Iraq will become paradise; depose Hosni Mubarak and freedom and peace will rule; naive beliefs like this frequently don't pan out. What'll be the good news from Libya this month? And just how powerful remains the idea that the Iraq war was worth all those American and Iraqi lives because it was a successful regime change?

 

BALASTICMAN

5:16 AM ET

February 6, 2012

Not Everything is Politics

What exactly does this article add, apart from overlooking the proximate causes of the events that precipitated this tragedy to instead indulge in the conspiracies of how anything and everything that is happening in Egypt is somehow part of a careful plan to protect the ruling generals? When the aftermath of a lethal stampede at a sporting event becomes the rallying point for elevating tenuous political grievances, something fundamentally is wrong. http://balasticman.blogspot.com/

 

SUPAH

2:24 AM ET

February 9, 2012

Awful

Its incredibly awful how this level of violence could happen at a soccer game. Its not even like this game was at all an important match in the league/standings sense. The number of dead at 73 is astonishingly high, and I've never seen such brutality. You would think at this day and age this kind of act would be terrorism, not a bunch of soccer fans. Once again, Egypt is in serious need of Self Improvement.