The 'Untouchable'

Meet Mayawati, India's multimillionaire lower-caste power broker and politician.

BY SADANAND DHUME | FEBRUARY 6, 2012

Millions of voters will head to the polls this week for the first phase of what are often called India's second-most important elections -- for a new government in Uttar Pradesh, the country's largest state and home to about one in six of its 1.2 billion citizens. If it were an independent country, UP, as it is commonly known, would be the world's fifth-most populous, roughly the size of Brazil.

In the drama of Indian democracy, UP has always played a starring role. Eight of India's 13 prime ministers, including Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi, have come from the Hindi heartland state, which sits along India's northern border with Nepal. UP is also home to the parliamentary constituencies of Nehru's heirs, Congress party leader Sonia Gandhi and her son, Rahul Gandhi, arguably the country's two most powerful politicians.

In recent weeks, the media has dwelled upon the 41-year-old Gandhi scion's effort to reclaim UP for Congress for the first time since 1989. Few expect him to pull this off: India's ruling party holds only 22 seats in the 403-strong state assembly. Nonetheless, a strong performance will be interpreted by pundits and party insiders as a sign of Gandhi's readiness this year to replace Singh as prime minister, an office held by Gandhi's great-grandfather, grandmother, and father before him.

Standing in Gandhi's way is a streetwise 56-year-old politician with a starkly different pedigree. One of nine children born in a New Delhi shantytown to a postal clerk and his illiterate wife, Chief Minister Mayawati (she uses only one name) leads UP's ruling Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP), best known as the party of India's Dalits -- the people once called "untouchables" -- who comprise about 16 percent of the country's population.

Historically, Dalits occupied the lowest rung of Indian society, beyond the pale of the four-tiered caste system. Members of Mayawati's Chamar subcaste were traditionally leather workers, a trade considered unclean in Hinduism. In American terms, Mayawati's position is roughly akin to a granddaughter of slaves being elected governor of New York just a half-century after the abolition of slavery.

Thanks to UP's electoral weight and political symbolism, should Mayawati win another term -- she's been in power since the last election in 2007 -- she will be one step closer to her stated goal of becoming prime minister (though her limited appeal outside her home state still makes her a long shot). Even if she loses, though, the chief minister will remain a symbol of both the promise and the perils of India's burgeoning democracy.

For Mayawati's many detractors, she's a vivid reminder of everything that's wrong with Indian politics. Soon after she became chief minister of UP for the first time in 1995 -- she has lost and returned to the office three times since then -- Mayawati earned a reputation for megalomania, staggering corruption, and the privileging of narrow identity politics above the most elementary norms of governance.

STRDEL/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: INDIA, SOUTHEAST ASIA
 

Sadanand Dhume is a resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.

WEARELIMPING

7:21 AM ET

February 7, 2012

Jesus. When will my country

Jesus. When will my country stop getting raped by corrupted minds and child-minded politicians? When will our human development index show some semblance of real progress? What can i do as a citizen to improve this? Maybe i can help a child attain a degree. And i will to do just that in the near future. I could help out financially. But as long as those in the assembly do not act responsibly, i guess gap between haves and have-nots would not shrink. I am ashamed of myself. Each and every citizen should be.

 

COREDIN

8:19 AM ET

February 7, 2012

Soon...

You should not be ashamed of your country. I am not Indian but I think India is a great example of how countries can gradually progress.
India does not have great natural resources, its huge population means change cannot be easy, or fast.
India's progress is based on its people's hard work and their desire for education and self-improvement.
Yes, at the moment the central and local governments are corrupt compared to some other countries but they are less corrupt than in the past.
The fact that India is a true democracy should be a comfort to you as it means that at least there is a chance to get more and more honest leaders using the ballot box.

 

WEARELIMPING

1:52 AM ET

February 8, 2012

Hello coredin. Thanks for the

Hello coredin. Thanks for the comment. I did not say i am ashamed of my country. I said i am ashamed of myself. More specifically, my inaction towards doing my bit to change the landscape for the better. But of course, i could take comfort in the fact that at least India is a true democracy. I always have.

 

KAMATH

8:12 AM ET

February 8, 2012

bigrock1934

Fellows: You people never lived in a day in god foresaken parts of India, never drank a glass of germ infested water, never defecated by the road side or pee in the open.... and here you are you and your BS about democracy! You think mayawati is here to solve the problem of the poor?

 

T JAY

3:20 PM ET

February 7, 2012

Well said COREDIN! I'm

Well said COREDIN! I'm totally agree with you, I'm also not Indian but I really like India and Indian people but not their politicians though.

 

KBC

12:06 PM ET

February 8, 2012

Poor potrayal of Mayawati

Mayawati, a small time Dalit woman who aspired to become a civil servant is an enigma. The lady can't be compared with anyone in Indian politics where most of the women politicians have dynasty. What makes her case different is her poor past and untouchable status.

Though she has been accused of corruption and excesses, she has brought a sense of pride in the most backward people in India. Whereas Ambedkar was a failure in Indian politics, Mayawati is the undisputed queen of largest Indian state. She has done what I would say no other Dalit has done since Indian independence.

 

LECHEB

3:25 PM ET

March 4, 2012

Mayawati - A Shinning Example

Besides rumors and suggestions of corruption, she is an amazing example of someone rising up the ranks of society. There is nothing wrong with her and she is not a shinning example of everything this is wrong with Indian politics. The high price, determined after reading several other articles about her on my iphone 5g she paid and dedication shown is impressive. A great example for everyone around the world.