Collateral Damage

The "war on terror" still casts a long shadow in some unlikely places.

BY PAUL SALOPEK | MARCH/APRIL 2012

Eastleigh slum in Nairobi, where I found Iftin again, is nicknamed "Little Mogadishu." Hotels sheathed in smoked glass -- built, the residents whisper, with loot from the epidemic of Somali piracy -- squat amid mounds of filth. There are wire-transfer offices and the "Heltz" driving academy. Sewage pools like tar. Women wear hijabs. Open-mouthed young men throng trucks bringing in khat, the chewable narcotic. Iftin marveled at all the unarmed people. But Eastleigh has its own dangers. "There is no freedom of speech here," he told me in his tenement cubbyhole. "The Shabab I saw in Mogadishu are here too."

Iftin wore a clean shirt for our reunion. A poster was tacked to his wall, a still life of fruit on a table. Out in the roofed courtyard of the honeycombed building, laundry hung in tiers, five stories high, as in an African prison. Refugees, crouching over charcoal braziers in the halls, stared warily up at me.

"They must go," huffed my taxi driver, an old Nairobi hand named Joseph, referring to the Somalis. "They are taking over. They push up the prices of property and control too much!" Joseph refused to park while I visited Iftin. Instead, he circled the block, fuming, with his windows rolled up.

AL-AMIN KIMATHI DIDN'T SHARE Joseph's contempt for the new arrivals. He liked Somalis. Many had been his clients. Kimathi is a tall, bookish man of 50 who dresses in a white djellaba. I had met him in early 2007, when he challenged Kenya's illegal deportations of more than 100 people, mainly Somalis, who had stampeded across the border after the Ethiopian army rolled into Mogadishu. Teams of agents from the FBI flew to Kenya to sort the tide of refugees for wanted terrorists, such as the men who planned the 1998 bombings of U.S. embassies in Kenya and Tanzania. U.S. special operations soldiers rode with the Ethiopians as "observers."

Certainly there were bad guys among the deportees -- apprentice and veteran jihadists, including at least two Americans, fighting for al-Shabab. But the dragnet scooped up mostly noncombatants, including 11 women and 11 children. Most were freed after enduring detentions that lasted as long as a year, without legal representation or trials, in secret compounds in Ethiopia. It was the second-largest case of extraordinary rendition in the George W. Bush era, after the inaugural post-9/11 shipment of prisoners to the Guantánamo Bay detention center.

To me, Kimathi is one of the net positives in the aging war on terror, like the schools that Green Berets built in the Philippines or the old Cormac McCarthy novels appearing in Baghdad book stalls. Kimathi proves that even in a tough neighborhood like the Horn of Africa, civil society can stand up to the culture of fear and surveillance that permeates an open-ended war that Barack Obama's administration has so blandly renamed the National Strategy for Counterterrorism.

Kimathi was working for the Muslim Human Rights Forum in September 2010 when he was arrested in Uganda. He had traveled there to advise a group of renditioned Kenyans accused of planting bombs for al-Shabab in that country. The bombs had slaughtered 76 people gathered in pubs to watch soccer. The attack was seen as evidence of the spreading "Somalization" of the Horn of Africa.

EPA

 SUBJECTS: MILITARY, AFRICA
 

Paul Salopek, a Pulitzer Prize-winning foreign correspondent, is at work on The Mule Diaries, a book about wandering.

CHRISAK

9:31 PM ET

February 27, 2012

Tragic

Very compelling story. There sure is a vicious quality to the kind of learned cynicism that has clouded stories about places like the Horn of Africa since the 80s. Too easy to tell oneself that in places like that, the rule of law MUST be a luxury, at least from the perspective of a western public immunized even to stories of child famine and political chaos.

 

BILL KELLER

9:45 PM ET

February 27, 2012

99% grows broadly worldwide.

A long wave of injustice is spreading from the trifecta that bin Laden created. Are the winners the profiteers, the zealots, the financiers or the swindleer in the first comment? Maybe in the short term. But I'd not abandon the war's forgotten...that 99% in which the spirit of rights and dignity exists may have God's incurable virus - a bitter distaste for a rich man's dirt.

 

YANI'S 21CENTURY REALIST PHILOSOPHOS HYPOTHESIS

3:46 AM ET

February 28, 2012

Not Collateral Damage

Author...
Your story is very heart warming. However that's about it! You have launched an attack against World Security and Peace interests on the basis of your fond memories of some guys you happen to have met a while ago. The fact of the matter is we in the West are not responsible for the disruption of these people's lives. They must account for the mess they have caused for themselves. The real shame is these poor folks, from failed states, who have contributed nothing to world, for example, in the Horn of Africa, have made up their decision to not live civilly but to instead pervert and promote their own backward views of Islam and attack each other and their neighbors in the international system. The gentlemen you refer to like Mr. Kimathi and Iftin and others like them should, instead of focusing their time opposing the negative virtues of rendition, use their time, effort, and resources to combat their very own cousins, brothers, and neighbors from causing trouble, chaos, and terror. If one wishes to prevent the continual misery plaguing the Islamic world in general then the real solution is for the efforts of muslim's caught in between the conflict to speak out and take action against the bad apples that are the root cause of the conflict that they and their innocent children get caught in the middle of. Do not blame the Kenyan, Ethiopian, or US government for trying to substantiate what folks will not or can not do for themselves. The fact of the matter is terrorism is like cancer it spreads and needs to be cut. Just like a cancer patient loses hair teeth and an immune system (Collateral Damage) that is the cost to rid them of cancer. Lastly, if the patient can't stop the cancer them self then let the Professionals handle it. ;)

 

ALIFELIX

7:00 PM ET

March 2, 2012

Not Exactly

While my thoughts and prayers go out to the author's two mentioned friends, the notion that Somalia is in an worse place after the invasion by Ethiopia is ridiculous. Let's say this did not happen and Somalia was able to exist as it did before the invasion in 2006. You don't think that after 6 years the country would be in even worse shape. I think so and unfortunately it is true. While the present day situation is not even close to being a solution, some of the picture I have seen on my i phone 5 have been terrible to look at, it's far better than if nothing happened at all. I still believe the US and the world in general has an obligation to help out the current situation. Only time will tell if indeed they do.