My Drone War

American drones have changed everything for al Qaeda and its local allies in Pakistan, becoming a fact of life in a secret war that is far from over.

BY PIR ZUBAIR SHAH | MARCH/APRIL 2012

THE EVENING OF JUNE 18, 2004, was a sweltering one in South Waziristan, and the 27-year-old local Taliban leader, Nek Muhammad Wazir, had decided to eat dinner in the courtyard of his house in the village of Kari Kot, along with his two brothers and two bodyguards. Muhammad's satellite phone rang, and he picked it up. Moments later, a missile streaked through the compound and exploded, killing all five men.

At the time, no one in the Pakistani public or media knew that it was a drone. The government would say nothing, and everyone else attributed Muhammad's killing either to a Pakistani military operation -- after all, soldiers had gone looking for him without success on six occasions -- or to the work of U.S. forces across the border in Afghanistan. A Taliban fighter who was within earshot of the explosion told me later that the militants were totally taken by surprise. "There was a noise in the air before, and then we heard the explosion," he recalled. The villagers, however, supplied the explanation: They collected the fragments of the missile, on which was printed in black, "Made in USA."

Then, in late 2005, a similarly mysterious explosion killed Abu Hamza Rabia, a high-ranking Egyptian member of al Qaeda, outside North Waziristan's capital city, Miram Shah. President Pervez Musharraf refused to explain what had happened, saying only that he was "200 percent" sure Rabia was dead. But a local reporter named Hayatullah Khan, who lived in the next village over from where Rabia was killed, had gone to the site to sift through the rubble. Amid the debris were pieces of a Hellfire missile. He took pictures, which swiftly appeared in newspapers around the world.

The photographs directly contradicted the statements of Musharraf's government, which had variously claimed that Pakistani forces killed Rabia or that the militants blew themselves up by accident. The following month, Khan was abducted by gunmen. His body was found six months later near the Afghan border with handcuffs on his wrists; he had been shot in the back, apparently while trying to escape. When I visited his family in North Waziristan a year later, Khan's brother told me he blamed the ISI.

In January 2006, shortly after Khan's disappearance, I got an early-morning phone call at my home in Islamabad from a colleague at Newsday, where I was then working as a fixer and bureau manager. There had been another drone strike in the Bajaur tribal area, he told me; could I go investigate? I picked up a friend who worked for the BBC and drove north to Bajaur to see my first drone strike. It would be the first newspaper story to appear under my own byline -- and my first experience covering the drone war.

As we drove into Damadola, a farming village sprawled across a wide valley, I spotted the bodies of a cow and a calf, splayed out underneath a tree with their eyes wide open. Nearby were the fresh ruins of three houses.

The drone's presumed target had been Osama bin Laden's deputy, Ayman al-Zawahiri, who had been rumored to be in the area. I arrived on the scene ahead of most other reporters, and the families of the victims took me to see their newly dug graves. "All those killed, including women and children, are from this village," a villager told me as he showed me the burial site. "There were no foreigners here." Then I noticed something odd: Although I counted 13 graves, the locals would only tell me the names of seven women and children who had been killed. When it came to the men, they were silent. Later, a Pakistani official told me foreigners had indeed been present, including Zawahiri, though he had left some time before the missile hit. Drones were not yet common, but the fugitive al Qaeda No. 2 had long since become accustomed to moving quickly from place to place.

IT WAS IN SEPTEMBER 2006 that I heard a drone for the first time, flying over the mud-walled village of Ali Khel, a couple of miles west of Miram Shah. It was a hot summer night, too hot in the house of the building-contractor friend with whom I was staying, so I had gone out to sleep in the open along with several laborers who worked for him. The men were telling me about their travels in Afghanistan, how they would cross the border to fight for the Taliban and then return after a week or two to North Waziristan to work and make some money. Then I heard the buzzing, far above our heads -- like a bee, but heavier and unceasing, drifting in and out of earshot. The laborers said nothing.

On the other side of the Tochi River, in the village of Khatai, lived a famous Taliban commander whom the Pakistani military had once tried to kill. The operation had been a debacle; the military lost at least two senior officers, and hundreds of soldiers found themselves besieged not only by Taliban fighters but by the local villagers. But the small, lethal machine flying far overhead had accomplished what the Pakistani soldiers could not. "Nowadays he doesn't live here all the time," my host that night said as he pointed toward the commander's nearby compound. "There are drones in the air now."

Deb Smith/U.S. Air Force/Getty Images
Map by Gene Thorp for FP
Illustration by Jeffrey Smith for FP
EPA (photo); official Pakistani government figures, 2011

 

Pir Zubair Shah is a fellow at the Nieman Foundation for Journalism at Harvard University.

SYED ARBAB AHMED

2:51 AM ET

February 27, 2012

Drone attacks & what Pakistan has got from "War on terror"?

Drone attacks & what Pakistan has got from "War on terror"?
http://bit.ly/nTHdBF

 

KBC

8:48 PM ET

February 28, 2012

Drone Attacks Guilt Question

For any reason in the world, no one can condone drone attacks nor deny their strategic importance in the war on terror. If we look at the drone war fare, the first drone attack started 3 years after Taliban was vanquished in Afghanistan.

Pervez Musharraf, with his personal liberal image has never been accused of Islamizing Pakistan. In reality it was Musharraf's policy of hunting with hair and running with hound that prolonged the war on terror and Islamized Pakistan.

http://thepoliticalopportunist.blogspot.in/

 

REALREALIST

11:18 PM ET

March 5, 2012

 

KHANJEE

11:48 PM ET

March 5, 2012

Good Fiction Story!

I wonder why Pir Zubair Shah has not written a novel so far, which could easily be adopted as a Hollywood Blockbuster by now. This story amply proves that he has the skills to write one, with potential to win an Oscar.

The way he has tried to stretch the imagination of the readers by giving accounts of his personal bravado (albeit experience) and twisting of facts in the story, is incredible, yet very intereting (if true!).
Sitting in US and attempting to write an analytical story on the subject, which is sellable to the outside world is indded challenging. be truthful to your soil! You know the realities well - the number of innocent victims of drones is much more thatn what you have tried to depict. writer should not mislead the readers, exploiting the credible forum of FP.
By any standards of international norms and rules, even the killing of lesser number of innocent people as quoted by Pir is unacceptable and illegitimate to say the least.

 

KUNINO

2:43 PM ET

March 6, 2012

Knowledgable, yes. Reliable? Less so.

There's no controversy about whether drone attacks kill enemies. The controversy is about whether they kill innocent civilians, lots of them, and I challenge the reliability of what this article represents. The author tells us that Pakistan residents he talks to prefer having a house "vaporized" (presumably vaporizing everybody alive in it -- people unseen by the drone operator) to other forms of aerial bombing. How these anonymous people feel about any form of bombing at all seems outside the author's interest.

He also relies to an extraordinary degree on a briefing by a Pakistani military chief who offers a guess about how many insurgents drones vaporize, while in the currently fashionable military way adding a soothing generality about how very few civilians are being killed -- in lieu of any guess about how many of those violently dead used to be innocent civilians.

This nonsense the author describes as unusually candid, which also is nonsense.

Here's the relevant stuff: "Pakistani Maj. Gen. Ghayur Mehmood, the commander in North Waziristan, appeared before reporters in Miram Shah and told them, "Myths and rumors about U.S. Predator strikes and the casualty figures are many, but it's a reality that many of those being killed in these strikes are hard-core elements, a sizable number of them foreigners. Yes, there are a few civilian casualties in such precision strikes, but a majority of those eliminated are terrorists, including foreign terrorist elements." It was an unusually candid public statement on the drone strikes from a high-ranking Pakistani official.

Candid? Really?

 

STRIVER

6:32 AM ET

March 7, 2012

YOUR DRONE WAR

My anger
My sorrow
My Grief
My despair

YOUR DRONE WAR

My injury
My mental anguish
My ovewhelming pain
My loss

 

MALDONADOCHARITY

2:03 PM ET

March 7, 2012

Make Money working from you Home

my classmate's step-aunt makes $73 every hour on the computer. She has been unemployed for six months but last month her pay check was $12870 just working on the computer for a few hours. Here's the site to read more ....... http://LazyCash9.com

 

MARTY MARTEL

8:29 AM ET

March 10, 2012

Pakistani State safeguards Al Qaeda/Taliban fighters

The fact that Taliban fighter was safely able to talk to Mr. Zubair Shah in Peshawar points to why America’s drone war is and will fail.

Pakistani ISI has moved Mullah Omar’s QST to Karachi to protect them from drone attacks as well. Haqqanis live comfortably in Islamabad/Rawalpindi area under ISI protection.

American drones can not attack can not and do not attack populated areas like Karachi or Peshawar for fear of civilian casualties as Pakistan State knows too well and so has been able to protect them from drone attacks.

As former Pentagon official Gen (rtd) Jack Keane said at a discussion on Afghanistan organized by the Institute for the Study of War, a Washington-based think-tank on June 30, 2011: "The truth is, the (Pakistani) ISI aids and abets the sanctuaries in Pakistan that the Afghan (Taliban) operate out of. They provide training for them, they provide resources for them and they provide intelligence for them. From those sanctuaries, every single day Afghan fighters come into Afghanistan and kill and maim us (US/NATO troops)". General Keane also added that “There are two ammonium nitrate factories in Pakistan. 80 per cent of the explosive devices that are used to kill our soldiers, kill Afghan security forces and kill Afghan people come from Pakistan."

With an ally like Pakistan, America’s Afghan war was doomed from the very beginning.

 

KHANJEE

7:12 AM ET

March 12, 2012

Marty Martel - The Great Indian Strategist (at th cost of USA)

DR. KUCHBHI and marty martel are the strategic assets of RAW - no one can doubt this fact.
To me it appears as if the author of the story is Marty; Pir Zubair Shah's name has been misquoted as a cover-up, in an attempt to render credence to their propaganda.
There are over Potasium Nitrate factories in India, which are supplying the commodity free to Taliban for hitting two birds with one stone. Firstly, provide this devastating material to TTP elements for causing havoc inside Pakistan; aim is to destailize Pakistan; the country vanguard against GWOT. Secondly, provide the same material to Afghan Taliban to create problems for ISAF and ANSF inside Afghanistan - ensuring The ISAF troops are not withdrawn, since it could compromise their authority and hold in Afghanistan which enables them to create troubles in Balochistan and FATA fro Pakistan.
India is the so -called largest democracy in the World, so it should be champion of the human rights. Unfortunately, our Indian friends like Marty and Dr Kubachi ignore to condemn the drones, involved in killing of innocent civilians.

 

KHANJEE

7:12 AM ET

March 12, 2012

Marty Martel - The Great Indian Strategist (at th cost of USA)

DR. KUCHBHI and marty martel are the strategic assets of RAW - no one can doubt this fact.
To me it appears as if the author of the story is Marty; Pir Zubair Shah's name has been misquoted as a cover-up, in an attempt to render credence to their propaganda.
There are over Potasium Nitrate factories in India, which are supplying the commodity free to Taliban for hitting two birds with one stone. Firstly, provide this devastating material to TTP elements for causing havoc inside Pakistan; aim is to destailize Pakistan; the country vanguard against GWOT. Secondly, provide the same material to Afghan Taliban to create problems for ISAF and ANSF inside Afghanistan - ensuring The ISAF troops are not withdrawn, since it could compromise their authority and hold in Afghanistan which enables them to create troubles in Balochistan and FATA fro Pakistan.
India is the so -called largest democracy in the World, so it should be champion of the human rights. Unfortunately, our Indian friends like Marty and Dr Kubachi ignore to condemn the drones, involved in killing of innocent civilians.

 

PENYAKIT DIABETES

3:19 AM ET

March 11, 2012

Hard war against Al Qaeda

the main purpose of war against Al Qaeda is already accomplished with the assanation of Taliban leader Osama. In America want to continue the war then they must have strong purpose. If not. Leave it to UN.
Cara membuat blog

 

THUSALWAYSTOGENIUS

12:09 AM ET

March 12, 2012

Ambassador of Death: Attack of the Drones

In our world and our time, Drones (Unmanned Aerial Vehicles), which were experimentally manufactured in 1916, were first armed in order to attempt to kill Osama bin Laden.

They were and still are proven to be unreliable due to the fact that their target abilities are far from surgical precision, they are unstable when flying in less than perfect weather and they crash very often. In addition, loss of communication with these drones is one of the many technical issues that lead to their sub par performance. After consideration, President Clinton decided to shut down the project.

Later on, Bush reopened the project, refinanced it and made used of these drones 44 times, despite the acknowledgement of the performance reports. The attacks evidently lead to casualties; bodies were often hidden and buried by troops on the ground.

However, for now, most drones aren’t exploited for military purpose. They are mostly used for surveillance, reconnaissance, news reporting, border patrolling, intelligence and inspection.

As such, most industrialized countries such as China, France, United Kingdom, Germany, Russia, India, Canada, Australia, Pakistan, Japan and Brazil do “harvest” drones. Some of the super drones have even been baptized. Israel named theirs Heron; the United States upgraded their Predator with the Avenger; and, last but not least, Iran named theirs Karrar, which is Farsi for Striker. President Ahmadinejad infamously nicknamed his Persian Menace: the Ambassador of Death.

Episode X : The Persian Menace

Do not let the Ambassador of Death mislead you into being alarmed. The Ambassador of Death is not Darth Vader’s vehicle of choice. This drone is intended for, and I quote: “Peace and Friendship“. Logically, why should we be nervous over Iran since they have not initiated any attack towards any other country in over 200 years? And yes, the Persian Gulf War has been taken in consideration when making that statement.

That being said, it evidently is not the case when shifting our attention towards the previously mentioned pro-drone countries. Over 239 drone strikes were ordered under the Obama administration. Many of these attacks were carried out against the advice of U.S. Officials and Diplomats. In fact, that tendency has led the Obama Administration of being responsible for at least 85% of drone strikes around the world, particularly in Pakistan.

This is the same Obama that won the Nobel Peace Prize in 2009. Even then, his addition seems unsuited and undeserved, when one remembers past laureates.

As mentioned in a previous article of mine, the five countries (United Kingdom, United States, France, Russia and China) that have secured permanent United Nation seats are also the top global arm dealers. These same countries have been accusing Iran of secretly building nuclear weapons and pressuring them to halt their nuclear program.

It is important to understand or remember that the U.S. did not only assist but also coordinated the launch of the Iranian Nuclear Program in the 50s. This program was maintained for decades, until the 1979 revolution.

This support was even symbolized and categorized as the “Atoms for Peace” Program, implemented in 1953 by Eisenhower. Let’s acknowledge that a program would not be complete without an appropriate inaugural speech. And where else but at the United Nation General Assembly can a prestigious one take place? In this case, the cleverly named “Atoms for Peace” speech quickly followed Eisenhower’s “Chance for Peace” speech.

All this backing did result in the inception of Iran’s first nuclear power plant, which was completed and activated thanks to Russian assistance, in 2011.
The irony! The Atoms for Peace Program’s main principle was to reassure the world during the Cold War (between 1945 and 1991). Sarcastically, the Russians presided over its closing ceremony.

As a counter attack, the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) board, nations and multinational entities officially reprimanded and sanctioned Iran. This judgment was internationally supported by detailed tangible and evidence. The Iranian authorities, or should I say THE Iranian Authority, Ayatollah Seyed Ali Hosseini khamenei, has not yet been successfully coerced by the international pressure. The U.N. inspectors can come and go as often as necessary, it’s all in good faith, from both parties. Remember, it’s a ll about Peace and Friendship.

“Look up in the sky, it’s a bird, it’s a plane… No, it’s a drone!”

The Empire Will Strike Back. It is just a question on which Empire will strike first.

Guess who’s building nuclear power plants now?

READ MORE AT : THUSALWAYSTOGENIUS

 

LODYANN

8:52 PM ET

March 27, 2012

online jobs $40/hour

my neighbor's sister-in-law made $14228 the prior week. she gets paid on the laptop and got a $398600 house. All she did was get blessed and put in action the advice written on this web site
MakeCash10.com

|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||\\\