Persian Poker

The stakes couldn't be higher as Israel's prime minister comes to Washington. But is Obama ready to go all in?

BY ROBERT HADDICK | MARCH 2, 2012

On March 5, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu will meet with President Barack Obama at the White House. The Iranian nuclear program will undoubtedly be the prime subject of the meeting, the outcome of which could decide for the Israeli leader whether to send Israel's air force to bomb Iran.

In a recent column, I discussed the time pressure weighing on Netanyahu and his military advisers, and why the sanctions effort organized by Obama and European leaders is not working fast enough for Israel. At next week's meeting, Netanyahu may ask that Obama publicly issue an ultimatum threatening U.S. military action unless Iran lays itself bare to international nuclear inspectors. Without such a dramatic escalation, Netanyahu and his colleagues may conclude that Israel will have to attack Iran alone, and soon.

Obama will be loath to commit the United States to such a drastic step to resolve a problem it sees as having much less urgency. With an Israeli strike imminent, Obama must select between two courses of action. First, he can attempt to forestall war by joining and reinforcing the Israeli military threat against Iran, in the hope that such a strong commitment will convince Iranian leaders to open their nuclear program to full inspections, or risk losing it to bombing. A March 1 Bloomberg article hinted at 11th-hour support from some officials inside the Obama administration for this course of action. And recent suggestions by unnamed Pentagon officials that Iran's Fordow mountain uranium enrichment site might not be impregnable after all, as previously suggested, could be a late-arriving signal of U.S. resolve.

However, such a late conversion to a hawkish stance would be a great gamble for Obama. Although the president has declared his opposition to an Iranian nuclear weapon and noted that he is considering "all options," he and administration officials have refrained from publicly committing to "red lines" that would convince Iran to open its program or reassure Israel that Iran will not become a nuclear threat. Opposition to a U.S. military strike on Iran seems to be the overwhelming majority view inside Washington, a view affirmed at a recent presentation by retired Adm. William Fallon -- former commander of both the Central and Pacific Commands -- and retired Marine Gen. James Cartwright, recently vice-chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Iranian leaders would thus likely view a sudden U.S. ultimatum as a bluff. And given the paramount importance of the nuclear program to the Iranian regime, it would likely be a bluff they see as worth calling.

For Obama, that leaves the alternative of accepting an Israeli strike on Iran and minimizing the consequences to the United States. Obama will want the Strait of Hormuz to remain open, for oil markets to remain calm, and for U.S. allies in the region to feel secure. He will attempt to accomplish this goal by having U.S. air and naval forces around the Persian Gulf make an ostentatious display, by sending reinforcements to the region, by calling on Saudi Arabia to increase its oil production, and by releasing crude oil from the U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve. Obama will also seek to avoid Iranian retaliation against the United States by disavowing the Israeli strike, but also threatening severe retaliation against Iran should it attempt terror attacks against U.S. targets.

SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images

 

Robert Haddick is managing editor of Small Wars Journal.

STRIVER

12:10 PM ET

March 3, 2012

Bleeding.....

...America to death, by design or by default.

Israel is one of the $-sucking economies. US is not out of the crisis yet. Another crisis is on the horizon. Europe is sinking deeper. Yet, Israel is dragging US into another war.

If Israel tries it alone. It is afraid of the consequences.

 

LEONIDASLEONIDAS

9:50 AM ET

March 4, 2012

 

STRIVER

7:55 AM ET

March 5, 2012

Typically

you have made too many false assumptions.

 

MOHAMEDABED

5:09 PM ET

March 5, 2012

no its not really an assumption that you are

an idiot striver. It's pretty self-apparent.

 

TARQUINIS

12:33 PM ET

March 3, 2012

Israeli attack upon Iran is a global catastrophe

WaPo 2/11/12: "Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu criticized economic sanctions against Iran as ineffective and warned that any military strike against the country’s nuclear facilities would inflame the region while doing little to curb Iran’s ambitions..."

“I am telling you, a military strike is a disaster,” Davutoglu told a gathering at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, a Washington think tank. “It should not be an option.”

I wish more Americans knew that:

1. Iran has signed the NPT which grants them in paragraph IV the "inalienable right" to develop nuclear technology for power generation and medical imaging isotopes. It is an easy google, see for yourself. Iran is not going to surrender their legal rights under the treaty.

2. Iran's nuclear generation and enrichment facilities are currently under the constant inspection of the IAEA including the Fordo facility near Qom. This inspection includes 24/7 video surveillance.

3. There is no allegation by the IAEA that ANY enriched uranium has been diverted from its surveillance.

4. There is no allegation that Iran has enriched any uranium beyond the 20% required for medical imaging isotopes, whereas enrichment to around 95% is required for any weaponization purposes.

5. They can prove what they are doing. They cannot prove what they are not doing. You cannot prove a negative. "Might", "could", and "maybe" are not good reasons for another war that would certainly result in vast chaos from Lebanon to Pakistan militarily and politically.

6. Iran with no nuclear weapons is zero military threat against nuclear superpower Israel. Israel has not signed the NPT and is in possession of hundreds of nuclear warheads. More importantly, it possesses the most advanced delivery systems in the world including nuclear powered ballistic missile firing submarines. A nation with zero nuclear weapons does not attack another with hundreds.

Even if (a hypothetical) Iran did some day acquire a nuclear weapon (to secure itself from vicarious nuclear attack) it could never use it against Israel because of the intertwined nature of the Palestinian and Israeli populations. Al-Aqsa Mosque, the third holiest site in world Islam is in Jerusalem and they would never risk its destruction.

7. A war initiated by Israel would spread to our interests in about half an hour. Prices for petroleum would certainly skyrocket to who knows what level, collapsing our fragile economy like a house of cards. Same for the whole world's economy for the same reasons.

8. So if we really want all the hugely negative consequences, just raise your hands now. If not, this had better be prevented or it will be the capper that puts us in the crapper for good.

 

REALREALIST

6:02 PM ET

March 5, 2012

tarq...your so wrong on so many points

a) davutoglu is a racist jew bating islamist.

they are not developing their nuclear program for medical use. to do that you only need 5%...20% is unecessary... breakout to 90 % from 20% is the easy part. Much iranian enriched uranium from between 1987 and 2003 is missing according to the IAEA. Iran with a nuclear weapon is a threat to israel and the rest of the world. They have been sponsoring state funded terrorism for the last 40 years...you think nukes are gonna help that? lol... interwined populations as a deterrant? not so fast my stupid friend...see rafsanjanis comments in 2001, stating that if iran were to lose 10 million people to israels 6 million, it would be acceptable given that the muslim world has another 1.5 billion ...so yes, they ARE in fact happy to martyr their own and palestinian people if it means wiping out israel. Besides, your not israeli, so you get no say in their security. prices of petroleum are not israels concern to be honest. They have not created this situation, iran has. If the price of oil doubles, blame your friends the mad mullahs. blame the eu, blame obama, blame bush, and blame every previous US admin and EU govt who would not get themselves off mid east oil when they could have by now...israel? they dont care about that...they care about security...they also happen to have TONS of newly discovered oil and natural gaz AND they are developing a national infrustructure for electric cars...in joint venture with renault. So if blame is cast, send it to iran you jew hating moron.

 

STRIVER

3:51 PM ET

March 3, 2012

The MOSSAD and the Iran factor...

.....in recent bombing outside Israel's Dehli bombings cannot be ignored.

It is an indicator of how MOSSAD and other agencies (such as Indian and Afghan intelligence agency) that it as helped and train, create situations on the ground to assist their respective governments.

1. Israeli embassy, press and the government were pointing the figure at Iran and Hezbollah. The Israeli embassy went to the extent of giving a list of names of Iranian nationals to the Indian authorities before the bombing. Indian police however have found no such link.

Look out now, how this is used to browbeat Iran.

2. MOSSAD paid an Iranian kick-boxer to assassinate Iran's nuclear scientist Mustafa Ahmadi Roshan on January 11.

 

STRIVER

4:02 PM ET

March 3, 2012

MOSSAD and Afghanistan....

MOSSAD has trained the Indian and Afghan Intelligence personnel.

These operative are using their newly acquired skills to destabilise Pakistan.
New terror groups are emerging with weird names, bombing and killing innocent civilian in crowded shopping areas and gatherings.

One such terror group recently murdered a Chinese worker in Pakistan. Clearly aimed at sending a message to Pakistan to break its strategic and close relationship with China.

The Great Game is still being played in Afghanistan. Only this time intelligence agencies of the world have come together to lynch Afghanistan.

 

BVDJSKIF8DS9

7:36 PM ET

March 4, 2012

very good web: ===

very good web: === http://www.plzzshop.com

The website wholesale for many kinds of fashion shoes, like the nike, jordan, prada, also including the jeans, shirts, bags, hat and the decorations.

All the products are free shipping, and the the price is competitive, and also can accept the paypal payment., After the payment, can ship within short time.

We will give you a discount

WE ACCEPT PYAPAL PAYMENT

YOU MUST NOT MISS IT!!!

=== http://www.plzzshop.com

thank you!!!

Believe you will love it.

We have good reputation, fashion products,

come here quickly== http://www.plzzshop.com

Opportunity knocks but once

 

SPOOD

9:17 PM ET

March 4, 2012

Geez, how long are they going to milk this non-story?

Outside of some wannabe armchair generals and media people looking for filler material for their international news section, this story is still a non-starter.

The practical issues of a unilateral Israeli strike are insurmountable, especially since its been discussed ad nauseum for several months, eliminating any hint of a surprise. I have yet to see an article here which discusses what actually would be needed for such a strike(s) to be successful. Of course that requires doing something other than navel gazing and bloviating.

Any strike against Iran will require the approval of the US and Arab nations (who are more willing to greenlight it than anyone dares admit to).

Its apparent that Iran is bluffing. Playing just on the wrong side of credulity with its atomic efforts to get people upset, announcing to the world what they are doing, and trying to see if everyone jumps. No Tarquinis, Iran's hands are not clean here. They are being deliberately uncooperative enough that it invites skepticism over any of their claims.

It is pretty clear by the lack of substantive action in this situation that the US and Israel know Iran is bluffing as well. However, it is politically advantageous for all parties (including Iran) to let this play out.

 

REALREALIST

7:59 AM ET

March 5, 2012

news from germany and japan...not good...

http://www.debka.com/article/21794/

 

SHUHAO65

9:34 AM ET

March 5, 2012

http://www.imadeshopping.com

very good web: === http://www.imadeshopping.com

The website wholesale for many kinds of fashion shoes, like the nike, jordan, prada, also including the jeans, shirts, bags, hat and the decorations.

All the products are free shipping, and the the price is competitive, and also can accept the paypal payment., After the payment, can ship within short time.

We will give you a discount

WE ACCEPT PYAPAL PAYMENT

YOU MUST NOT MISS IT!!!

=== http://www.imadeshopping.com

thank you!!!

Believe you will love it.

We have good reputation, fashion products,

come here quickly== http://www.imadeshopping.com

Opportunity knocks but once

 

REALREALIST

5:49 PM ET

March 5, 2012

striver...great name ahole

so funny!

I love these low life neo's that think they are so smart...its hilarious!

all they do is repeat slogans, repeat racist indoctrination, repeat spoon fed lies, while deep down, they're just very unhappy unfulfilled people. So they need to blame others...like the occupy wall street idiots....do nothing, lazy, suck off society anf then blame others who work hard ..."oh come on man, give me your money man....give me your car man... give me your house man"....

it was sooooo funny watching these BUMS occupy nothing but the bongs they were smoking, standing out there day after day rather than putting themsevles back in school to try and find some meaningful work so they can HELP their country rather than hurting their country. Selfish entitled lazy stupid kids....

maybe go volunteer for that loser in illinois names arthur jones, the neo nazi republican candidate who is a lot closer to ron paul than to reagan....those arent republicans, they're isolationist neo nazi fools.

 

NATIVIDAD DARCANGELO

4:50 AM ET

March 30, 2012

Israeli military threat against Iran

As for me, Israeli military will strike Iran...Iran will Level telaviv....Israel will nuke Iran. Themo Nuclear war will break out between just about anyfucker? who has nuke. Game Over, we're all in the astral world going fuck me.It is good to be patriotic but what exactly does that mean? If I see my country doing wrong am I being patriotic if I say so? I believe you are. I believe the occupy Wall Street protesters are very patriotic. Some will think the opposite. If people are satisfied to lie to themselves and just believe every thing is great, they are contributing to the down fall of their nation no matter? what nationality you are. Unfortunately a majority just follow and never really think for themselves.