Pandering in Paris

With President Nicolas Sarkozy closing the gap in the run up to elections, challenger Francois Hollande is falling back on the tired, old Socialist battle cry.

BY JAMES TRAUB | MARCH 16, 2012

"Clomp! CLOMP! Clomp! CLOMP!"" That's the sound of French President Nicolas Sarkozy's high-heeled boots as they grow closer, closer, closer to Francois Hollande, the gentle lamb offered up by the hapless Socialist Party in next month's presidential election. Six months ago, Hollande lead Sarkozy 39 percent to 24 percent in the polls. Four months ago, it was 31.5 percent to 26 percent. And earlier this week, it was...Sarko, 28.5 percent, Hollande, 27 percent. Hollande still holds a strong lead in a hypothetical run-off between the two men, but Socialist partisans are beginning to tremble. Last week, the president debated Laurent Fabius, a leading Socialist standard-bearer, on television. "Sarko destroyed him," a leftist policy intellectual said to me grimly. Clomp!

Much of the press attention here has been focused on Sarkozy's utterly shameless courtship of France's xenophobic voters, most of them followers of the far-right National Front. In the debate with Fabius, Sarkozy said that France has too many foreigners, and repeated a proposal he had made to cut the annual number of legal immigrants almost in half. After National Front leader Marine Le Pen made the absurd suggestion that all meat in the Paris region was being slaughtered according to Islamic rules, known as halal, Sarkozy declared, with a straight face, that "the biggest concern of French people is halal meat." The New York Times accused Sarkozy of taking "the low road" in a way that will be "damaging to French society," if not necessarily to his own electoral prospects.

But the low road is where Sarkozy lives. He made a name for himself in 2005 by calling immigrant rioters racaille, or "scum," and more recently proposed deporting gypsies from France. Sarkozy is, in American terms, a little bit of Rudy Giuliani and a great deal of Richard Nixon. "The French recognize in him something that is in them, too," says Marc Weitzmann, a French novelist whose work captures modern political life. "That's why the French vote for him, and hate him at the same time."

But what's wrong with the Socialists? In 2007, they nominated Segolene Royale, an eccentric figure whom Sarkozy feasted off in the presidential debates. Hollande is, bizarrely, her ex-unmarried-spouse. He is, however, a much better candidate -- a careful thinker and a gentleman, witty and wry in the French manner. The one thing he lacks, unfortunately, is the all-important gift for the visceral -- this in the face of a man, Sarkozy, with a dark genius for the lowest common denominator. Hollande has been coasting on the public's overwhelming desire to get rid of Sarkozy, but it now seems that he won't be able to coast all the way to the Elysée.

This time around, France is in the midst of an economic crisis for which Hollande must come up with convincing answers if he is to close the sale with voters. France's unemployment rate is hovering around 10 percent, and its growth rate is around zero. Earlier this year, Standard & Poor downgraded France's credit rating (along with that of eight other European countries). Sarkozy ran in 2007 as a man prepared to wrench France into the future, and he still enjoys that reputation. Hollande, too, has tried to present himself as a modernizer and a pragmatist. "He's not stuck in nostalgia for the 20th century, or the 19th century for that matter," as one Socialist leader recently put it. His platform emphasizes fiscal prudence, economic growth and relatively modest expansion of the public sector (through he plans to hire 60,000 educators).

That is, in effect, one side of his reaction to France's predicament. But it is the quieter side. In public, he is the tribune of public outrage over the lords of finance. At his first campaign rally in January, Hollande declared that his "real adversary" was not Sarkozy but rather the "faceless rulers" of global finance. And when pushed into a corner, he has darted left. In late February, with Sarko closing in, Hollande unveiled a proposal to create a new tax bracket for those annually making in excess of 1 million euros, or $1.3 million, with a marginal tax rate of 75 percent. Even Ed Miliband, the leader of Britain's Labor Party, blanched at the proposal. Hollande seemed to be playing to French resentment of capitalism and wealth as cynically as Sarkozy was with the immigrant issue. Having spooked the forces of finance, the Socialists quickly backpedaled by having Fabius declare that the new tax rate would be probably just a temporary measure.

GERARD JULIEN/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: ELECTIONS, EUROPE
 

James Traub is a fellow of the Center on International Cooperation. "Terms of Engagement," his column for ForeignPolicy.com, runs weekly.

HIPPOPOTAMAX

8:44 PM ET

March 16, 2012

The French are allergic to the marketplace?

No doubt they are less committed to it than the US is, and have an ambivalent attitude. But how on earth did a nation which "doesn't consider the markets to have any valuable message to convey" get the economy it has? Even the Heritage Foundation gives it Business Freedom and Trade Freedom ranks not far below those of the United States. To conflate disbelief in the market with skepticism of how far it should extend is not useful.

 

SEGISMUNDO

2:33 PM ET

March 17, 2012

Bad article

First, the past tense of the verb "lead" is "led," not "lead." And Marine Le Pen's statement that Parisians eat ritually slaughtered meat (the animals' throats must be slit while they are still conscious) is entirely accurate, as the slaughterhouse managers in the Paris region have admitted (and as has been reported in dozens of legitimate media outlets). It's simply too expensive for the slaughterhouses to slaughter in two different ways and keep the resulting meat separate. Since non-Muslims don't usually object to halal meat, the slaughterhouses simply do the logical thing from an economic viewpoint and slit animals' throats rather than stun them unconscious.

But I'm going to guess that pigs don't get their throats cut.

 

MIZAH

5:03 PM ET

March 17, 2012

turkey reply

href="http://www.avrupacambalkon.com" target="_blank">cam balkon hakk?nda bilinçlendirmeye devam ediyor,
bu sayede hem tüketici ve üretici hemde türkiye ekonomisi kazan?yor, Cam Balkon bizim i?imiz derken biz firma olarak sadece ticaret yapm?yoruz ayn? zamanda, türkiye ko?ullar?nda tüketicinin ekonomik durumunu göz önünde bulundurarak, cüzi miktarda taksit secenegi sunan tüketiciye al?m gücü sa?lamaktay?z,Hani bir ara çok s?k reklamlarda duydugumuz al?n verin ekonomiye can verin slogan? tv lerde görürdük, sadece görmekle kalmad?k biz bu slogan? firmam?z taraf?ndan bire bir tüketiciye uygulad?k, Umuyoruz diyer sektorlerde bu duyarl?l?g? gösterir tüketicinin al?m gücünü yülseltir.Temennimiz bu yönde, gelelim bize biz Avrupa katlan?r cam balkon sistemlerin'de kullan?lan ürünlerin dier cam balkon sistemlerindeki ürünlerle k?yasland?g?nda ne gibi sonuçlar ortaya c?kmaktad?r.
cam balkon , sistemlerinde kullan?lan ürünlerin birço?u bir birlerinden farkl?d?r, profil kullan?lan aksesuar, cam balkon sisteminin ba?l?ca ana ürünüdür, su s?zd?rmayan, ?s? yal?t?m?na katk?da bulunan, damal?kl? sistemi ürettik, damlal?k sayesinde yagmur suyu kasan?n içine girmeden direk olarak atmakta, bu sayede profilin ömrünü uzat?r ve ?s? yal?t?m?n? korumu? olur. katlanir cam balkon y?l?n 4 mevsimi ya?ad?g?m?z ülkemizde, teknojojinin günümüze getirdigi cam balkon sistemi her mevsim kulanabilme özelligi, sayesinde balkonlar?m?z? daha s?k kullabilme imkan?n? saglayan cam balkon sistemi hertürlü hava ?artlar?na dayan?kl?, temizligi kolay, kullan?m? basit, bina ile ömür biçilen 100 y?l?n bulu?udur.Cam balkon Sistemleri bilindigi gibi özel sektörtler (firmalar) taraf?ndan serbest piyasan?n rekabet ortam?nda tüketiciye sunulan bir üründür, fiyatlar m2 olarak verilmekte birim fiyatlar? firma taraf?ndan belirtilmekte, firmalar aras?nda fiyatlar de?i?iklik gösterilebilir ama bir birine yak?n olmas? görülmektedir.Peki nas?l anl?caz hangisi kaliteli daha iyi hizmet veriyor, tabiki bunu anlamak için, firman?n kurulu? tarihi, verdi?i hizmetleri, referanslar?, üründe verdigi garanti süresi, bunlar önemli olmas?yla beraber belirtilen tarihte teslim edilmesi firman?n misyonunu ortaya koyar. Genelde cam balkon, firmalar? sistemlere 2 y?l garanti vermekte,peki 2 y?l yeterlimi? hay?r tabikide de?il, 5 y?l?n alt?nda garanti verilen sistemler’den sagl?kl? kullan?lmas? beklenemez.Biz Sistemimizin tamam?na 5 Y?L garanti vermekteyiz, katlanir cam balkon yapt?rmak veya bilgi almak için firma websitemiz www.Avrupacambalkon.com mutlaka u?ramal?s?n?z.

 

TARDALOVA

11:36 AM ET

March 19, 2012

Sarko

I will just be glad when I don't have to read his insulting ravings about other Governments, and his own people. He is a snob and pig.

Free markets have always been and are a wonderful mechanism for producing jobs and personal wealth. However, mixing in globalization with the principles of capitalism is proving to be a disaster. How much more of this will the world take before a conflict that trumps all previous wars consumes us all?

Why the powers have been championing and vigorously moving to a one world government (or New world order) is right up there with Dr. Evil and Mini Me in terms of sanity, The idea is flawed, but I guess learning from the failures of the Romans (just one example) has been long forgot.

 

TIMWX

4:45 AM ET

March 25, 2012

Isn't it...

Funny that Sarkozy's ratings have gone way up after the latest terror attack. He probably staged it himself to help him win the coming election. If you think that's a bit far fetched ask yourself how the person that carried out the attack broke out of jail? And don't forget we were watching him the whole time. Smell's fishy to me.

Zygor