Pushing Back

Hungary's beleaguered opposition takes to the streets to contest Prime Minister Viktor Orban's growing authoritarianism.

BY MARISA MAZRIA KATZ | MARCH 16, 2012

BUDAPEST — The warm sun balanced just above the jagged Buda Hills as hundreds of thousands of Hungarians spilled into the streets of Budapest to commemorate Revolution Day, an annual celebration honoring the country's 1848 uprising when Magyar nationalists fought for independence from the Habsburgs. Yet, the postcard-perfect backdrop stood in stark contrast to the widening political split between the government and growing opposition movements, each of which staged their own competing demonstrations -- at precisely the same times -- just far enough from the other to prevent the din of their rallying cries from overlapping.

Boulevards were emptied of cars as the city transformed into a patchwork of fervent and sometimes volatile protests. In front of the neo-Gothic parliament building, skirting the edge of the Danube River, was the pro-government rally featuring headliner Prime Minister Viktor Orban. A mile south of Parliament, past a boardwalk lined with tables of foot-long pretzels doused in sugar, and perched at the foot of the chalk-white Elisabeth Bridge, was the main opposition's demonstration run by the civic group "Milla" (which stands for "One Million for Press Freedom in Hungary"). And in the center of one of the city's main intersections, the radical, far-right Jobbik Party set up a small stage flanked by a 12-foot high television screen.

Preaching to a clogged square of roughly 100,000 supporters, Orban warned the European Union that Hungary would not tolerate interference on any level. Since sweeping into office in 2010, Prime Minister Viktor Orban's center-right Fidesz party, which has a two-thirds super-majority, has locked horns with critics at home and abroad -- including the European Union, International Monetary Fund,  and even the U.S. State Department -- over swipes at media freedoms, an overhauled constitution, the economy and judiciary reforms. It's become something of a bête noire for the international media, alarmed that something awry is happening in this small, landlocked country of 10 million. "We will not be a colony, we will be slaves no longer," said Orban, referencing a passage from a poem written by Hungarian poet and revolutionary, Sandor Petofi, amid chants of his name and repeated bursts of applause. "We do not need the unsolicited assistance of foreigners wanting to guide our hands."

His fiery rhetoric came on the heels of an unprecedented decision from the European Commission (EC) to withhold 495 million euros of aid, unless steps are taken by Hungary to lower its deficit. The punitive measure was softened slightly by an addendum stating funds could be reinstated by as early as June should the country's budget policies align with EU stipulations.

News of the EC announcement made no dent in the prime minister's appeal to 75-year old Tamas Buranyi, who attended the March 15 rally with a Hungarian flag fastened to his lapel and another in his hand. "In this extremely difficult time, Fidesz is doing what is best for the country," he said. Interweaving between the crowds were several hundred right-leaning Polish citizens who had traveled to Budapest for the holiday as a show of support to Orban and his policies. "The criticism against his personality," Buranyi added, "[It] makes it very difficult to govern the country properly."

FERENC ISZA/AFP/Getty Images

 

Marisa Mazria Katz is editor of Creative Time's forthcoming website featuring artists' perspectives on world issues.

RENEMF

8:03 AM ET

March 19, 2012

sad

"bêtes noire"? If an author is using exotic sounding expressions to try to impress readers it's rather self defeating if the grammar andor spelling is wrong. What's going on in Hungary deserves much more attention than it gets; in that sense any mention is welcome, but an informed analysis is needed more than superficial reporting.

And there are no comments - is that because nobody cares or because people are turned off by all the fake bs 'comments' ? In any case, I asked before and never did get an explanation as to why FP is allowing this crap.

 

NICOLAS19

8:24 AM ET

March 19, 2012

you beat me to the post

On the other hand, dear FP, could someone kindly remove the traces of the spambot? It has been plaguing the other article about Hungary as well.

 

NICOLAS19

8:22 AM ET

March 19, 2012

how can one take this seriously?

Some fact-checking is in order.

- The pictures above show the rally of the far-right opposition party (called 'Jobbik', you can read it on the banners). That is the party with links to the perpetrators of the despicable and criminally persecuted attack on a minority family. Do you really consider them the symbol of Hungarian opposition? The head-count was around 1-2 thousand.

- The 'other' rally, the one you talk about was so tiny and unpopular - merely one hundred participants - that the media didn't even take pictures other than close-ups. That's why you had to attach a different illustration.

- Why is that? Because the leaders of the Hungarian opposition merely consist of the leaders of the Hungarian post-communist regime, who all got themselves discredited in the 2006 hate speeches. Take Mr. Gábor Molnár, who you quote several times - he was in the government (1994-1998) with the de facto and de jure heir and successor of the Communist party. Talk about democracy, right?

 

SPOOD

8:29 AM ET

March 19, 2012

The reasons for the lack of discussions

"And there are no comments - is that because nobody cares or because people are turned off by all the fake bs 'comments' "

My take for the paucity of comments
1. It was written on a Friday. There isn't much traffic here on the weekends
2. The fake comments DO turn people away
3. European matters tend to go over the heads of the American commenters
4. There is nothing here to appeal to the usual shills here.
5. And yes, you are absolutely correct, the efforts to turn Hungary away from authoritarianism deserves much more attention.

 

TOMMY007

11:51 AM ET

March 19, 2012

Why Always Demonstrated!

I read much news about demonstrate every day, every time... News about it always appears on media.. demonstrate is one ways to voices but must be responsible, don't make negative causes in every activities.. who will suffers any way?

 

TOMI

3:43 PM ET

March 19, 2012

“The most truthful part of a newspaper is the advertisements.”

Spelling mistakes, which are quite embarrassing if you write about Hungary:

Viktor Orbán (not Victor): prime minister of Hungary. If you make some effort to criticize someone in a long article, try to write down his name correctly.
Sándor Pet?fi (not Petrofi): one of the most influential poets in Hungarian history.
Habsburgs (not Hapsurgs): they’re also pretty famous to deserve the correct spelling.

This article is astonishingly superficial, biased and one-sided. I've been an enthusiastic reader of FP and I've been always satisfied with its analytical and mostly objective reports. Maybe you shouldn’t break with this nice tradition and employ unprofessional and naive scribblers like Marisa Mazria-Katz.

Greetings from Budapest,

Tomi

 

ZACKARY GOLDFEDER

8:52 PM ET

April 15, 2012

seriously worried about Hungary

I think that, It's time to get seriously worried about Hungary. Thursday's debt auction was a disaster. The country was obliged to pay 9.96% for short-term debt and didn't even raise the 45bn forints it was seeking via auction; it got just 35bn, presumably because it turned away bids pitched at 10% or more. The backdrop is well known. The Hungarian currency is in freefall (down 18% against the euro in six months) despite rate hikes designed to shore up confidence and protect mortgage borrowers who have (ridiculously) taken out loans in foreign currencies. The government needs to raise about $16bn this year and Hungary's banks require foreign lines of credit. Protesters are on the street, raging against a new constitution that it widely criticised as anti-democratic. Prime minister Viktor Orbán's regime is at loggerheads with the European Union and the International Monetary Fund over a new law that limits the central bank's