Tortured Justice

Bahrain’s leaders talk a good game about reform, but protesters in the streets still face unremitting brutality.

BY BRIAN DOOLEY | MARCH 22, 2012

MANAMA, Bahrain – In a house at the end of a maze of narrow streets, I sat listening to a dozen young men as they described their close encounters with the full force of Bahrain's government crackdown. We were in one of the poor, Shiite villages scattered across the country, which have remained hotbeds for revolt despite the government's persistent attempts to suppress the uprising that began last year.

The boys wore an assortment of soccer shirts, and those awful rat-tail haircuts teenage boys all over the world think look cool. They said they had been severely beaten by the police in the previous two days. "They beat us until they got tired, then other policemen would take over and beat us more," said one boy.

For all of the Bahraini government's efforts to show progress on human rights in response to the inquiry it commissioned last year, not much seems to have changed in places like this. The regime touts that "leading international legal, police and other experts" that have been shipped in "to advise on ... practical reforms," as Minister for Human Rights Fatima Al Balooshi told the U.N. Human Rights Council. These experts include John Yates, a former assistant commissioner to the London Metropolitan Police Service, and John Timoney, a former police chief in Miami and Philadelphia.

Some in Bahrain's government may be sincere about reform, but the gap between rhetoric and reality is huge. A new police code of conduct declares "a zero tolerance policy on torture and any other type of mistreatment" and that "force shall be not be used except when absolutely necessary or when it is used in self-defense in accordance with the law." But according to the young men from the village and others I met, these reforms are no more than empty words.

Local human rights activists say hundreds of young men have been taken to secret torture centers over the last few months. Instead of being formally arrested, booked into a police station and mistreated, they say they're more likely to be simply grabbed by a group of riot police, robbed of their phones and money, and then taken to one of these buildings to be beaten for several hours and abandoned somewhere remote. Trusted local human rights organizations report tear gas attacks on villages almost every night.

Some of these young men told me they had been at a peaceful protest last week to mark the anniversary of the death of one of their friends, who had been killed in the pro-democracy demonstrations last year. "It was a peaceful protest in our village," said one. "About 150 men and 50 women, we were holding banners above our heads, not throwing anything at the police."

According to the young men, the riot police suddenly appeared at the protest and opened fire with rubber bullets and tear gas. "They chased us for about 200 yards and cornered about 12 of us in a house. They put us in the kitchen," said one. "They told us all to lift our shirts up over our heads to cover our eyes and stole our phones. They pushed us all into the kitchen and started beating us."

The young men said that about 25 policemen, three at a time, took turns beating the group over the next 90 minutes. "They hit us with rifle butts, broke kitchen plates on our heads, said things about our moms and sisters," another told me. Several showed me severe bruises on their backs and arms, marks they said were from the beatings.

Meanwhile, the police are using tear gas canisters as weapons. There are nightly reports of tear gas being used against peaceful protests and shot directly into people's houses. It is unclear how the police are supposed to account for the number of canisters they take per shift or to detail how many they used and why. The government justifies its use of tear gas by pointing to a fringe group of protestors who throw steel rods, petrol bombs, and other missiles at the police. The police, however, appear to be using as much as they want, whenever they want -- not only against protesters, but also against random civilians.

The following night, I met with some medical professionals just outside the capital Manama as they received calls about injuries from different parts of Bahrain -- pleas for advice or treatment. Within a few hours, they received calls about three serious head injuries caused by police-fired tear gas canisters. "It's shoot to kill," observed one doctor glumly. People who are injured in protests still fear going to hospitals or clinics -- worried that they might be arrested, or worse. The main hospital, the Salmaniya Medical Complex, is under heavy security -- police and military checkpoints guard the gates, and security officials even enter operating areas. Treating the injured is a risky business for medical personnel, who face prosecution if caught at one of the underground network of first aid posts.

AFP/Getty Images

 

Brian Dooley is the director of Human Rights First's Human Rights Defender Program. He visited Bahrain last week.

DOOLEYDICK

10:02 PM ET

March 22, 2012

Dooley, you're biased

Dooley, Dooley,

What credibility have you? you were outed by wikileaks; you yourself have pledged allegiance to "local human rights activists" who have been proved multiple times as liars. Did you bother to verify the claims presented to you or were you happy to take single sourcing as your truth? Did you engage in fact finding or was your visit to legitimize the show trial of poor villagers telling you what you want to hear and you reporting it without verification? Your reporting is full of holes. I am amazed you can sleep at night you liar.

With sincere regards,
A Bahraini NGO activist

 

DOOLEYDICK

10:09 PM ET

March 22, 2012

you self-righteous idiot

You say: "The government justifies its use of tear gas by pointing to a fringe group of protestors who throw steel rods, petrol bombs, and other missiles at the police." I am a Shia who lives in a place where my people daily use weapons. Have you ever seen a petrol bomb? Have you seen someone burn alive? I have. A police officer. I don't care for them, but I have never seen so much hate. This is not my country. It needs to stop. Please stop.

 

DOOLEYDICK

10:10 PM ET

March 22, 2012

Salmaniya

You say: "The main hospital, the Salmaniya Medical Complex, is under heavy security -- police and military checkpoints guard the gates, and security officials even enter operating areas." Liar. Have you been to SMC? I don't think so. Your statement is complete lies.

 

DOOLEYDICK

10:14 PM ET

March 22, 2012

You ask why we hate?

Because people like you come in here and encourage our haters and liars to play to your rubbish need to be superior to us. You don't help. You think you help human rights??? Let me tell you. Your articles cause death. I hope you rot in the place you are going to you self-righteous fill in the blank.

 

MICHAELGERALDPDEALINO

12:35 AM ET

March 23, 2012

Whatever

Bahrain is just being used by Saudi Arabia and Iran in their rivalry for regional domination.

 

PULLER58

12:57 AM ET

March 23, 2012

 

DARKCLOUD4

9:24 AM ET

March 23, 2012

Thank you :) don't listen to

Thank you :)
don't listen to people like him , just search for the truth then say it , bad or good , what's matter is the truth , remember that life is not easy , just imagin what the people of Bahrain feel , it's unbelievable , what happened to them is not like others , they treated worst then animals , like if they dont have any right to speak , kill/torture/hunger/silenced..etc

it's like slow death , or fast deahh without anyone know or care , well thats what i lived here , dont take one side , all sides then see the turth and support it but dont ignore the others...

 

SIDROCK23

11:49 AM ET

March 23, 2012

americans accepting saudi blood money

bahrain is just another example of how the U.S will accept saudi blood money. they accpeted billions of dollars in blood money after 9/11 when saudi princes were putting money into failed banks like Citi bank and the $60 billion arms deal. and this will continue to happen. people complain about the israeli lobby having the U.S on a leash, but we should not forget about the saudi, UAE funded wahabbi lobby. they are worse than the israeli lobby because they do things quietly and out of the spotlight.

 

CECILYHD

12:16 PM ET

March 23, 2012

Bahrain

We at the Middle East Voices website set up a poll this week asking Bahrainis whether the issue of democracy in Bahrain has been put to rest or not, in the wake of King Hamad's pledges for reform. As of this writing, the majority (92%) of respondents (from within Bahrain) have replied NO. See: http://www.middleeastvoices.com/2012/03/poll-does-bahrain-kings-pledge-for-reform-put-democracy-issues-to-rest-91817/

 

MAIGARI

4:55 PM ET

March 23, 2012

American Policy and Democracy in the GCC

With the US Fifth Fleet based in Bahrain and the Saudis frimly behind theri fellow King, it is improable that the US would do anything on Human Rights and Democracy in Bahrain, not after annoying the Sauds by supporting the ouster of Mubarak by the military hijached Arab Spring in Egypt. Moreover the agitating Arabs in Bahrain are common Shiites figting to unthrone a Sunni Heriditary King!

 

MIDEASTUDAY

2:44 AM ET

March 25, 2012

Dooley's Vision and the Reality on the Ground

I'm glad Brian Dooley came to Bahrain. He got to experience for himself what life is like here.

But I'm confused how he could leave the country and write a piece like this. It is not reflective of the Bahrain that I know. The country that I live in. The nation I love.

Mistakes were made last year- everyone, from the top on down, has admitted that. But in such a short period of time, a lot of progress has been made towards reform. I don't disagree with the points that Dooley's making here- about police reforms and accountability especially.

What I disagree with is the perception that Bahrain is unable to make these changes. That somehow we're not moving fast enough. That somehow everything is going to be different overnight. OR that progress and reform can come without the buy-in of ALL parties.

The government will continue to make progress but all parties need to come to the table and be willing to negotiate a political reconciliation. And that can't happen when police officers are attacked with molotovs on a nightly basis.

The situation here is complex. This article doesn't explain all sides.

 

LUPE IGLEHART

8:20 PM ET

April 20, 2012

Bahrain

I think that, Bahrain officially the Kingdom of Bahrain About this sound Mamlakat al-Ba?rayn), is a small island state near the western shores of the Persian Gulf. It is ruled by the Al Khalifa royal family. The population in 2010 stood at 1,234,571, including 666,172 non-nationals. Formerly an emirate, Bahrain was declared a kingdom in 2002.
Bahrain is an archipelago of 33 islands, the largest being Bahrain Island, at 55 km (34 mi) long by 18 km (11 mi) wide. Saudi Arabia lies to the west and is connected to Bahrain by the King Fahd Causeway. Qatar is to the southeast across the Gulf of Bahrain. The planned Qatar Bahrain Causeway will link Bahrain and Qatar and become the world's longest marine causeway.