Democracy Lab Democracy Lab Democracy Lab Democracy Lab Democracy Lab Democracy Lab

We Have No Idea if Africa Is Rising

Recent FP contributors have said that Africa is and is not rising. They're both wrong because they don't have the numbers to back it up.

BY MORTEN JERVEN | JANUARY 28, 2013

Some scholars have suggested looking at alternative measures. We could, for example, compile new estimates based on the ownership of goods such as television sets, fridges, and automobiles -- which imply that African economies have been growing three times faster than the official figures. We could even resort to proxy indicators, such as measuring growth from outer space. This entails using satellite imagery to capture changes in the intensity of artificial light over a country at night (measuring electricity consumption directly is not possible because of lack of data). The problem is that such corrections are inconclusive. Competing measures of the same phenomena yield contradictory results.

One of the most urgent challenges in African economic development is thus to devise a strategy for improving statistical capacity. The system currently causes more confusion than enlightenment, yet governments, international organizations, and independent analysts do need development statistics to track and monitor efforts at improving living conditions on the continent. It's unwise to proclaim that African economies are growing without better insight into the quality of the numbers.

In short, any evaluation of Africa's rise must begin and end with a careful evaluation of the growth and income evidence. Without such analysis, one runs the risk of reporting statistical fiction.

Photo by EMMANUEL AREWA/AFP/Getty Images

 

Morten Jerven is an economic historian who specializes in economic development in Africa and currently teaches at the School for International Studies at Simon Fraser University. He's the author of Poor Numbers: How We Are Misled by African Development Statistics and What to Do about It.