Dispatch

'We Live and Die Here Like Animals'

The Central African Republic has suffered a horrific collapse. But is the worst violence between the country’s Muslims and Christians yet to come?

BOSSANGOA, Central African Republic — In the schoolrooms of the northern Central African Republic (CAR), the blackboards still show dates from late March -- when Seleka rebels seized power in the country and a nightmare began. Since then, the armed Seleka, whose collective name means "alliance" in Sango, the local language, have ruled through fear: burning down village after village, firing randomly at civilians from their pick-up trucks, executing farmers in their fields, and murdering women and children. Their brutality continues to spread like a deadly cancer.

Hundreds of thousands have been forced to flee their homes and hide deep in the bush, where countless have died from disease. The Ouham prefecture, where 170,000 people have been displaced, is the country's worst-affected area. Around Bossangoa, Ouham's capital, it is possible to drive for hours without seeing a single person in a village -- and the sound of a car engine is enough to stir terror among the displaced walking along rutted, rural dirt roads in search of safety.

In early November, as I traveled around the region with photographer Marcus Bleasdale to document the widespread violence, people often mistook our car for a Seleka military vehicle. One day, our passage was blocked by the meager bundles of belongings dropped by a family that had fled into the bush as they heard us approach. We found a toddler crying on the road: His parents had lost him as they ran away. When they emerged a few minutes later, after much coaxing, they explained that they had been walking all night to reach Bossangoa, where some 40,000 people are living in dismal, cramped conditions around a Catholic church. "There are so many children dying... from malaria and typhoid fever," the exhausted father told us. His family had fled their town after a Seleka attack in mid-October that killed dozens. "There is no food, but most of the people are still hiding in the bush because of the long distance to Bossangoa, and the insecurity on the roads."

Since its independence from France in 1960, almost every political transition in the CAR has been marred by violence, and those who commit it have rarely been brought to justice. Recent developments are no exception: The Seleka, a coalition of three rebel factions that had been independently fighting the central government for several years, formed in late 2012 over President François Bozizé's failure to bring promised development to the marginalized north, where security and social services were almost totally absent, and to implement power-sharing peace agreements. After a months-long offensive, the Seleka seized Bangui, the CAR's capital, and ousted Bozizé in March.

Almost all of the Seleka's leaders and fighters are Muslims, a small minority in the CAR that has suffered discrimination at the hands of leaders from the country's Christian majority. Many of the Seleka may not even be CAR citizens, but instead come from Sudan and Chad. CAR's self-declared president, Michel Djotodia, a former Seleka leader, has ordered the rebel forces to disband, but they continue to rule with the gun, particularly throughout the north.

Worsening the situation, fury with the Seleka is now spilling over into vicious armed resistance among Christians. One Muslim woman remembers a Christian militant saying to her during an anti-Muslim attack in Ouham that killed hundreds in September, "Muslims overthrew President Bozizé, and there will be no safety for Muslims until [the] Seleka [are] gone." At another massacre of Muslims the same month, a militia leader told captured villagers, "We will kill all the Muslims, and we will kill all of your livestock," before his fighters cut the throat of one man and opened fire on the others, killing four more.

If nothing is done, the CAR could descend into a deep, inter-communal religious conflict -- with much greater bloodshed than even what we've seen thus far. In early November, the United Nations went so far as to warn that the current conflict is at risk of escalating into genocide.

Already, the human toll, as recounted by those who have survived or witnessed violence, is shocking.

Nicole Faraganda, 34, gave birth to a little girl on Oct. 9 in the village of Wikamo in Ouham. The next day, four vehicles with Seleka fighters tore down the road in front of her hut, spraying gunfire at the fleeing population. Still recovering from giving birth, Nicole was a bit slower than her fellow villagers, and she was shot dead, as was a 12-year-old neighbor, Samuel Denamjora. The Seleka fighters then got out of their vehicles, looted the local school and hospital, and systematically burned down hundreds of thatched-roof homes.

The Seleka fighters proceeded to the market town of Ouham Bac, where they shot down another nine civilians. Three more died from drowning after jumping into a nearby, fast-flowing river to escape the gunmen. One of the victims, Gaston Sanbogai, 22, was a blind man left behind by his neighbors when they fled. He tried to hide in the bushes near his home, but the Seleka fighters found him, pulled him out, and shot him dead.

At the large but deserted market town of Ndjo, we asked the few local villagers we could find to take us to their hiding places in the bush. Over four kilometers, we had to wade through a waist-deep river and follow narrow tracks. At the first lean-to shelter, we found the dignified village chief of Ndjo, 55-year-old Rafael Newane, whose face was lined with sadness. He showed us the graves of two of his grandchildren, Frediane Mobene, 9 months, and Oreli Newane, 6 months, who had died just a week before, three days apart, from untreated malaria.

At the next shelter, we found Placide Yamini, Ndjo's medical officer, who had buried his sister, dead from malaria 48 hours before. He told us that, every week, there are four or five deaths among the displaced villagers. Despite his medical training, he is unable to help most of them: Seleka fighters looted Ndjo's hospital and its pharmacy on Sept. 16, leaving Yamini without medications. He showed us his tiny medical kit, which held just a single bandage and a few surgical tools, and said he had been living like this since the Seleka came to power. "We live and die here like animals," he added, barely able to contain his anger.

Those who have made it to Bossangoa live in desperate conditions: Every structure and inch of space around the town's Catholic church -- its seminary, guest house, school, library, storage rooms, soccer pitch, and the surrounding fields -- have been taken over by displaced people, all Christians. The camp is so crowded, and filled with noise and the smoke of cooking fires, that it is difficult to walk among the tiny tents, hardly large enough for two people but sheltering entire families. We had to use local guides to avoid getting lost.

Just down the road, hundreds of displaced Muslims have sought safety at the town's school. This separation, and the presence of Seleka fighters in Bossangoa under the command of a man who calls himself General "Yaya" and only converses in Arabic, is a reminder that, even while serving as something of a safe haven for villagers who have nowhere else to go, Bossangoa is not entirely secure.

As we were walking in the church camp one day, a Christian boy came running to the local priest to say his uncle had just been shot dead by Seleka fighters at a nearby checkpoint. When we went to investigate, we found the uncle still alive but badly beaten. He had crossed into the Muslim quarter of town to look for his straying livestock. A displaced Muslim woman started yelling at him, and then told the Seleka fighters to kill him, accusing his parents of fighting against Seleka. The Seleka fighters beat the uncle with the back of their guns, and then brought a knife to cut his throat. He struggled and managed to run away. The Seleka fighters fired at him but missed.

Farming has also become a dangerous occupation for Bossangoa's besieged civilians. Almost every day, Seleka fighters and armed cattle herders shoot farmers dead, but many still take extraordinary risks to go to their fields to find food. On Oct. 24, Thierry Demokossai, 40 and the father of five, was working in his manioc field together with several neighbors when four Seleka fighters approached on foot. Without any provocation, they shot him in the head and then killed two of his neighbors, according to his grieving wife.

After months of suffering such abuses at the hands of Seleka fighters, the mostly Christian communities of the northern CAR have begun to organize an armed response. Bozizé, the deposed president, organized village self-defense forces years ago to fight an epidemic of criminal gangs known as coupeurs du route ("road bandits"). Today, these militias, called anti-balaka (balaka means "machete" in Sango), are fighting the Seleka. They are armed with homemade hunting weapons, knives, and swords, and adorned with colorful fetishes that they believe protect them from bullets.

A leader of the anti-balaka forces whom we met in Ouham said, "The anti-Balaka are exclusively Christian, and our aim is to liberate the Christian population from the yoke of the Muslims. We are not a rebel group, our fight is only against the Seleka and to protect the population from them. We are the youth, organized by ourselves in self-defense." But worryingly, the anti-balaka do not just target Seleka: On a number of occasions, they have devastated Muslim communities.

In the early morning of Sept. 6, anti-balaka forces working with military elements loyal to Bozizé carried out a series of brutal surprise and near-simultaneous attacks on Seleka bases and Muslim communities in several villages around Bossangoa, killing dozens. Muslim males, regardless of age, faced death. Tala Astita, 55, was in the town of Zere when its Muslim quarter was attacked at 5 a.m. Fighters carrying AK-47s came to her house and ordered her husband, Bouba Gai, and her 13-year-old son, Halidou Bouba, to lay down before hacking them to death with machetes. The attackers then set the house on fire and tossed the two corpses into the flames. Other Muslims were similarly murdered.

Astita escaped by convincing the killers she was a Christian. She then hid for several weeks in the bush and disguised her 3-year-old son as a girl with earrings to save his life. Her 14-year-old daughter, Kande Bouba, as well as her husband's other wife and 4-year-old daughter, were taken away alive by the anti-balaka during the attack on Zere and remain missing.

At the same time as the attacks, anti-balaka forces raided dozens of Muslim-owned cattle camps, killing people and stealing thousands of cattle. Particular brutality was reserved for the nomadic Mbororo Muslims, despised by Christian farmers long before the current conflict because they often herd cattle into farmers' fields and destroy crops. The tensions between sedentary Christians and nomadic Muslims show that claims to the land are yet another dimension of the CAR's violence -- much like they have been in Darfur. 

Aishatu Isa, an Mbororo woman in her forties, was in a cattle camp near the town of Ber Zembe when fighters attacked around mid-day. Surrounding the nomads, they took Isa's 3-year-old boy, Khalidou Ngadjo, from her arms while gathering all of the male members in the camp. The attackers slit the young boy's throat, then the throats of Bouba Keriyo, 10, and Tahirou, 14. They also slit the throat of the one adult male in the camp, named Yaya Douka. The women were allowed to leave after witnessing the killings, but as they ran, they heard the fighters arguing as to whether the women should live or die.

The anti-balaka's attacks have triggered brutal reprisals by Seleka fighters against Christian communities. This heinous cycle of inter-religious violence only continues to intensify, threatening to explode into an all-out war between Christians and Muslims.

Up to now, the response of the international community has been minuscule. A small African military force, called FOMAC, rarely leaves its bases and often yields to the authority of the Seleka. It thus does little to help the civilian population -- aside from running a brisk trade in beer from their compound in Bossangoa. A more robust peacekeeping force, like the United Nations force now deployed in the neighboring Democratic Republic of Congo, is needed.

Because the Seleka have targeted humanitarian organizations, enhanced security is particularly necessary to permit the unfettered provision of aid. To date, very little of what food, water, and medical assistance have been sent has reached the displaced; in many of the villages we visited, we were the first foreigners anyone had seen since Seleka took power.

As we returned from our drives through Ouham, we were greeted not by the panic we had seen initially, but by villagers emerging from the bush, waving and yelling "Merci." The people of the CAR deserve better than the glimmer of hope that seeing a car carrying people who do not wish to harm or kill them brings. They deserve immediate relief, as well as eventual justice, served to those who have committed crimes -- and breaking the CAR's longstanding cycle of violence and impunity.

MARCUS BLEASDALE/VII

Dispatch

Crooked in Caracas

President Nicolas Maduro is promising to knock out graft and corruption. But as election ploys go, this one looks extremely cynical.

CARACAS — Facing flagging popularity and increased discontent over his government's economic policies, Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro is turning to a tried-and-true formula to reverse his political fortunes: He's launching a full-scale attack on corruption. And he's looking to use it to cudgel his opposition ahead of the must-win local elections on Dec. 8, which are being cast as a referendum on his first months in office.

"The era of institutional corruption should come to an end in Venezuela," boomed Maduro in a three-hour address before the country's National Assembly, broadcast live across all television and radio stations on Oct. 8. Promising to show "zero tolerance" for corruption, Maduro, who succeeded Hugo Chávez in March, is seeking special powers from the National Assembly to allow him to govern by decree to root out the country's endemic corruption. Although Maduro pledged to arrest any violators regardless of party affiliation, he made it clear that he considers the problem to be more prevalent among his political opponents and the country's business elite.

If he can muster 60 percent support from the deputies in the National Assembly, Maduro would be allowed to govern by decree for one year, bypassing the need for legislative approval for the laws he would enact.

But for many Venezuelans, Maduro's posturing on clean government and an end to corruption rings hollow.

"If he wants to clean up corruption, he needs to start with his own cabinet, and his people in the National Assembly," said Roberto Diaz, a 33-year-old teacher in Caracas. "This is just a circus to keep our minds off the economy and crime."

The timing of Maduro's campaign has raised eyebrows, especially given the proximity of elections and past boasting that corruption had been greatly reduced under the Chávez presidency. In March, Maduro proclaimed in a newspaper interview that the top echelons of his government were free of graft, thanks to his late predecessor's determination to root it out as part of his socialist revolution.

"Corruption is tied to capitalist values," Maduro said. "The values that Chávez promoted are fighting absolutely against those who desire quick riches, personal wealth, theft, embezzlement. Anyone who participates in anything for personal enrichment, anyone who put his hands on public money is betraying Chávez's legacy."

Speaking of his ministerial team, Maduro said that "I can guarantee that there is no corruption for the first time in the history of Venezuela."

Maduro has taken a few symbolic steps against a few lower-level members of his party. The mayor of Venezuela's third-largest city, Valencia, and his son, were arrested for allegedly stealing millions. A former state governor was also arrested. Probes have also been launched into alleged graft at the state iron ore company, Ferrominera, where up to $1.2 billion may have been stolen, as well as at the Bandes development bank and a Chinese-Venezuelan investment fund, where the losses are pegged at $84 million.

However, the corruption campaign has avoided big names in the government, instead concentrating the attack on the opposition.

"The anti-corruption drive is targeting opposition leaders, such as Miranda state Gov. Henrique Capriles Radonski, and Lara state Gov. Henri Falcon, as well as various opposition deputies in the National Assembly," says Caracas-based historian Margarita López Maya.

Maduro's anti-corruption drive comes as Venezuela's economy shows signs of falling apart after 14 years of Chávismo. Inflation is expected to end the year at above 50 percent, the highest in the hemisphere. Oil production continues to fall, even though the country has the world's largest crude reserves.

Shortages of basic foodstuffs -- such as corn meal, wheat flour, meat, and milk -- abound. And the bolivar continues its freefall: Although officially pegged at 6.3 to the dollar, the black market rate has fallen to almost five times that as Venezuelans bet that the government will have no choice but to devalue in January.

And if the economy isn't bad enough, most people here agree that corruption has gotten worse under Maduro and his team.

According to a poll undertaken by the polling firm Keller y Asociados, 70 percent of those polled in a nationally representative sample said that corruption has gotten worse in the last 12 months. Only 10 percent of respondents said that government efforts in rooting out corruption, including the arrests of mid-level officials, had produced positive results.

Capriles, who Maduro defeated in April, has been one of the most vocal critics of Maduro's initiative. "A true fight against corruption would lead to the end of the government," Capriles tweeted. "The big shots aren't going to fall."

Capriles and other opposition figures have repeatedly said that Maduro's close colleague, Diosdado Cabello, the National Assembly president, is one of the more corrupt members in the president's entourage. Cabello, who preceded Capriles as governor of Miranda state, is the subject of more than a dozen complaints alleging that he stole government funds during his term. The government's chief prosecutor, who has opened similar investigations into allegations about opposition figures, has taken no action.

Capriles, on the other hand, has made a show of being clean. He immediately sacked one of his close colleagues from his presidential campaign this year after allegations were leveled that the aide had engaged in influence peddling.

"Maduro's anti-corruption fight is an electoral and political strategy," says Tarek Yorde, a Caracas-based political consultant. "He's trying to shore up his position before the vote."

Maduro has reason to worry. According to the latest poll from Datanalisis, a Caracas-based polling firm, only 41 percent of Venezuelans say he is doing a good job, compared with 55 percent who give him negative marks. Publicity fiascos, like his claim that the late Chávez once visited him in the guise of a bird, have let the opposition ridicule Maduro as an inept buffoon.

Still, corruption is a real problem.

State funds have been stolen, diverted, or misused by those in power for decades. "Corruption is a perennial problem in Venezuela,'' says historian López Maya. "Venezuelans are willing to ignore it when times are good. But when there are periods of fiscal problems like now, then there's always an outcry against it. This is a cycle that has been repeated for years."

The opportunities for corruption are myriad given Venezuela's centralized economy and rich oil reserves, which are the largest in the world. And relatively high oil prices have only increased incentives to steal as there are more funds to pilfer. Oil didn't create the recent problem, though. Sweeping state controls over the disbursement of dollars for imports, travel, and remittances has created an intractable state bureaucracy, in constant need of greasing to get requests for dollars processed and approved.

Chávez, when he was still in power, laid the groundwork for this pervasive corruption. In an attempt to stem capital flight during a 2002-2003 nationwide strike to force him from office, the former president created increasing demand for foreign currency by tightening access to dollars, all while eliminating key checks on spending . In efforts to alleviate the plight of the country's poor, Chávez often tried to expedite solutions by throwing money at problems outside established administrative channels. A score of "missions," or social programs, that dot the countryside operate with almost no oversight, encouraging graft. And while Chávez imposed stricter controls over prices and currency, he left crucial loopholes, allowing for enterprising Venezuelans to take advantage of the system. He also curtailed the autonomy of the state comptroller general and attorney general, making them appendages of his administration. Not surprisingly, investigations into Chavez's closest colleagues have gone nowhere.

Billions of dollars have been stolen. Last year, the Comisión de Administración de Divisas (CADVI), which controls access to dollars, authorized imports of $59 billion. Up to a third may have been handed over to fake corporations, created specifically to siphon off dollars, according to statements from Planning Minister Jorge Giordani and the former Central Bank Governor Edmee Betancourt. Other scammers pad import invoices to qualify for more dollars.

Some of the worst abuses have been perpetrated by Chávistas, according to an audio tape that was made public by opposition deputy Ismael Garcia in May. Mario Silva, a moderator on state television and a close confidant of Chavez, told a Cuban agent in a recorded telephone call that corruption and dollar scams were rampant in the highest echelons of the government, including by Cabello. The charges were never investigated by the state prosecutor. Silva lost his job and has since disappeared amid rumors that he may have been sent packing to Cuba. Cabello said the tape was a fake and has accused opposition lawmakers of corruption.

And yet, on the street, corruption impacts everyone. In a recent poll, one out of every five Venezuelans admitted to paying a bribe to a government official in the last 12 months. According to Berlin-based Transparency International, Venezuela is the 10th most corrupt country in the world. In the Western Hemisphere, only Haiti ranks lower.

Ironically, the flagging poll numbers that have led Maduro to this populist fight against corruption might also be fueling the problem, encouraging his supporters to be more rapacious, says David Smilde, a senior fellow at the Washington Center on Latin America."There is a perception of some in the government that they are in the end game, and they are grabbing what they can, while they can,'' he says. "And with Venezuela's currency problems, the temptations are great."

Maduro is desperate for his United Socialist Party of Venezuela (PSUV) party to win the Dec. 8 vote, though he isn't on the ballot himself. Recent polls show that support for Maduro and the PSUV is falling, and if current trends hold, the country's opposition could make big gains.

"Of the 33 largest cities, the opposition should win easily in 20 to 25 of them," says Yorde. Currently, the opposition holds 14 of these 33. And the opposition is in a good position to win the overall popular vote, says Yorde, which would be a setback for Maduro and usher in a new period of increased political tensions and instability, encouraging the opposition to ratchet up their pressure on the government by taking to the streets to press for change.

But Maduro also needs the Special Powers Act, or ley habilitante, to shore up his own political position, says Smilde.

Venezuela is in talks with China for billions of dollars of loans to cover its burgeoning budget deficit, made worse by off-the-books spending on the December election and government social programs, which target the poor. The Chinese may have second thoughts about advancing Maduro fresh credit if his party does poorly in the vote and doubts about his long-term survival continue to mount.

"The ley habilitante is a way for Maduro to consolidate his power in the government, while showing the Chinese that he has the power, that he is in control," says Smilde.

Like previous presidents and their anti-corruption crusades, few expect Maduro to continue his battle once the elections are over and the holidays arrive. It's probably just as well that his promised new laws are likely to remain that: promises.

"The last thing we need to combat corruption is more laws,'' said Alberto Barrera Tyszka, a columnist for El Nacional newspaper. "What we need is for those laws already on the books to be enforced." That campaign, it seems, is one that Maduro doesn't have much use for.

JUAN BARRETO/AFP/Getty Images