FP Logo Your portal to global politics, economics, and ideas
FP Logo
Article Index
Search Site
FP Archive article
free registration required
back issue only
Home
Free FP e-Alert
Submit Free FP e-Alert
More Info
Worldwide Links
FP Forum
FP in the News
FP e-Alert Archives
Surprises of Globlization
Press Room

Current Article
Tsunami Truths
By Moisés Naím
Page 1 of 1
Posted January 2005

The cataclysmic earthquake near Sumatra, Indonesia, and the tsunamis it unleashed provided seismologists and oceanographers with important and sobering data about nature’s behavior. They also yielded some important lessons about how today’s world works.

The first lesson is that sovereignty kills. The maps and satellite pictures tracing the path of the huge ocean swells are a powerful reminder of the enormity of nature and the smallness of humans. They also testify to how irrelevant national borders can be. For the tsunamis, borders meant nothing.

But those same lines on maps proved deadly for many survivors, as they obstructed rescue efforts. Each government, even down to local and municipal councils, sought control over the rescue operations. Survivors were still hanging from trees as the United States and the United Nations quarreled about where money would go and who should lead the rescue operations. The Indian authorities refused to release information or let any foreign help into India’s Andabar and Nicobar Islands, which the tsunami hit hard. The Indian government, you see, wanted to preserve the security of its large military air base at Car Nicobar. In Sri Lanka, the Tamil Tiger guerilla movement and the government entered into complex and time-consuming deliberations on how to coordinate their rescue efforts. Burma, of course, remained the closed, despotic, and murderous regime that it is.

The second surprising lesson is that 3,000 deaths in New York and Washington had a much greater impact than 175,000 people killed in 12 poor nations. The human-made tragedy of September 11 changed the world; the natural disaster of December 26 did not. If the world’s attention to this catastrophe follows the trajectory of other natural disasters, the tsunami will have disappeared from our TV screens and from our daily conversations in just a few months. September 11 was a suicidal terrorist attack to the heart of a global power deeply connected to the rest of the world. It carried the message that it had a purpose and that it would not be the last. The tragedy in South Asia, by contrast, was a freak of nature that touched poor communities largely isolated from the rich world and with little capacity to influence it.

The tsunami’s impact—or lack thereof—tells us something about the links between countries and regions. The insurance industry, which was on its knees after the losses of September 11, does not expect the destruction wrought by the tsunamis to have major global financial repercussions. The afflicted areas are so poor and underdeveloped that international insurers had almost nothing to do with them. A strong hurricane season in the Caribbean—with a death toll usually under 1,000—can actually produce more financial damage than the devastation in South Asia.

But globalization has also made remote places in the Indian Ocean—from Phuket to the Maldives—more accessible to tourists than ever before. As a result, northern Europe appears to be the region most affected by the tsunamis after Southeast Asia itself. Norway’s foreign minister said that the tsunami may become one of the worst modern disasters for his Nordic nation.

If the tsunamis connected distant regions in grief, they also showed that the bonds of human solidarity may be stronger than ever. Although governments quibbled about aid strategies and about who was being more generous than whom, a flood of individual donations overwhelmed private relief organizations. The level of private resources available to the relief effort is unprecedented. Like the tsunamis, the goodwill of individuals was not deterred by governments, national borders, or political differences. Human solidarity, too, can be a force of nature.


Moisés Naím is editor in chief of FOREIGN POLICY.

FOREIGN POLICY welcomes letters to the editor.
Readers should address their comments to Letters@ForeignPolicy.com.

Related Stories
Shop at FP
Subscribe to FP
Login
Username
Password


| Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Contact Us | Site Map | Subscribe |

 
FP Logo
1899 L Street NW, Suite 550 | Washington, DC 20036 | Phone: 202-728-7300 | Fax: 202-728-7342
FOREIGN POLICY is published by the Slate Group, a division of Washingtonpost.Newsweek Interactive, LLC
All contents ©2009 Washingtonpost.Newsweek Interactive, LLC. All rights reserved.
Site design by bevia.com; Programming by Enovational Design