As they gear up for a major fight in Waziristan, Pakistan's leaders had better learn from their mistakes -- or things could get ugly in a hurry.
TARIQ MAHMOOD/AFP/Getty Images
Policy wreckage: The Pakistani state is a victim of its own poor planning.
As
the summer solstice draws near, it seems as if all the evil spirits are coming
out to haunt the body politic of Pakistan. The country faces an escalation in hostilities
on many fronts. And unlike in the past, when sweet deals and concessions could
woo militants and protesters into silence, this time no amount of amulets will
drive them away.
On
the battlefield, the portents exist for a major new clash between the Army and the
country's homegrown militants. There are reports of forthcoming military action
against fighters in South Waziristan, on top of the Army's ongoing assault against
the Taliban in Swat and Malakand. The fighting in Swat has displaced nearly 3
million people in just over a month -- a number likely to swell as the Army
moves into Waziristan. One might expect protests against the government and even
perhaps the military to erupt if these internally displaced persons (IDPs)
cannot swiftly and safely return home.
Pakistan
indeed finds itself in quite a mess, and cleaning it up requires some review of
how exactly the country became so disheveled. Before the assault on Swat began
last month, the Army had been confined to its bases, apparently having rousted (but
not routed) the Taliban. With the local and federal governments absent from the
region in name and in services, the militants crept back and established a
bloody regime. Violence escalated, and the Army was reticent to step in absent
a long-term plan for controlling the area. So, the government agreed to a peace
deal with Taliban-sympathizers. The truce was intended to subdue the militants,
but instead, it gave them more time to organize.
Rather
than melting away, the Taliban began snatching up territory closer and closer
to the Pakistani heartland, and outrage among locals and the larger Pakistani
population pushed the administration and the Army to react. Their tactic of
choice was a full-fledged assault. The Army now has
close to 150,000 troops in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA), Swat,
and Malakand. In Swat alone, there are at least two full divisions from the eastern
frontier and an additional four brigades cobbled together from divisions
usually stationed near the Indian border. In addition, there is a full brigade
of commandos in the Peochar Valley, and nine wings of the Frontier Corps. The
total troop commitment in Swat is about 52,000. The military is taking losses
daily. The militants, meanwhile, have taken the battle to the center of
Pakistan, attacking offices of the Inter-Services Intelligence in Lahore in May
and other softer targets, such as the Pearl Continental Hotel in Peshawar last
week.
Pakistan
needs to regain territory and reestablish the writ of the provincial and
federal governments in Swat and Malakand. The bad news is that taking territory,
as the military is doing now, is not enough. There is no effective civil or
judicial system in place to speedily see to the needs of the population, nor is
there an effective local police force to protect civilians from Taliban
reprisals. We are still waiting to see any semblance of a government plan for
dealing with the IDPs' return home. The Army is neither trained nor equipped
for that task and cannot be expected to hold the areas that it clears. Locals
told U.S. Ambassador Richard Holbrooke, special envoy to Pakistan, that the
civilian leadership was still missing in action when he arrived to assess the situation
in IDP camps. Little has really changed.
Now,
the Army may be preparing for action in the Bannu and Dera Ismail Khan areas
into South Waziristan, with the goal of flushing out or even eliminating Baitullah
Mehsud and his fellow leaders of the Pakistani Taliban. In its effort, the Army
may well resort to its old tactic of leveraging tribal rivalries. The target of
their affections this time might be Mullah Nazir of the Ahmedzai Wazir tribe -- traditional enemies of the Mehsuds. If
so, it's a dangerous strategy. If the situation devolves into tribal war,
Pakistan risks losing the support of those Mehsuds that may not yet be fully
aligned with Baitullah. And the Taliban leadership might simply melt into the
countryside as the Army battles in populated areas.
Which
brings us back to Pakistan's 3 million displaced, only 200,000 of whom have
been accommodated in official camps. The rest are fending for themselves and are
anxious to return to their homes and orchards. Before they can do so, however, those
areas must be safe and secure -- and there remains only a narrow window for the
government to prepare for rehabilitation and reconstruction before winter. With
the exception of the United States, very few countries have come forward to
assist in this effort. The Muslim world has been notably silent, as have the
Europeans. A number of potential donors had already pledged more than $5
billion to help Pakistan's economy at the Tokyo meeting this spring, but donor
fatigue might be setting in now.
Aside
from foreshadowing future turmoil, the Swat operation and the flood of IDPs indicate
a lack of strategic planning on the part of Pakistan. A coherent strategy was nowhere
to be found in both cases, nor was there any meeting of the minds between
civilian and military thinkers and between federal and local officials on how
to tackle the militants.
Another
seemingly obvious but important lesson is that military attacks address only
the symptoms of discontent, while doing little to tackle the root causes of
militancy. No steps have been taken by the government as yet to integrate FATA
into Pakistan's economy and polity, to regularize the region's legal system, or
to allow Pakistan's political parties to operate inside FATA's boundaries. Nor
have any plans been made to employ FATA's bulging youth population, an
estimated 300,000 potential Taliban recruits. The government could rapidly
create employment by launching heavy infrastructure projects such as east-west
roads linking FATA to Pakistan, construction of embankments, small dams, and
tube wells.
Washington
is doing its best to provide Pakistan the wherewithal to tackle these issues. Now
it's time for Pakistan to step up and formulate its implementation plans,
before it loses the trust of its people and the summer boils over into political
chaos.